Director's Report OFFICE OF COMMUIJITY DEVELOPMENT
��.
CITY HALL
10300 TORRE AVENIJE • CUPERTINO, CA 95Q14-3255
C� P E R M N d (408) 777-3308 • FAX (408) 777-3333 • planning�cupertino.org
Subject: Report of the Community Devel��pment Director �C.K.
Planning Commission Agenda Date: Tues �ay, November 9, 2010
The City Council met on November 1, 20"LO and discussed the following item(s) of
interest to the Planning Commission:
1. A�peal of Wireless Facility @ Results V'I� - City Council continued the item and
directed staff to work with the applicarit to explore an additional alternate location for
the tower south of Results Way off of Bubb Road to be reviewed by the Planning
Commission ahead of returning to Council for a final decision between the two sites.
2. Modification to Shashi Hotel Approval - City Council approved the modification
consistent with Planning Commissiori :; recommendations with the following changes:
➢ Parking ratio of 0.75/ room with val et service which amounts to approximately 125
parking spaces for a 138-room hotel; and
➢ Provide Council with an update of :he parking situation after the hotel's first, and
second, years of operation.
Upcoming Dates:
Nov. 11 Veterari s Day holida��, City Hall closed
Enclosures:
News Articles
G: \ Planning � AartiS \ Director's Report � pd11-9-10.doc
��� ' ' � ����'�
Residents of Cupertino's Monta Vista neighborhood take issue with little-
known fence ordinance
By Matt Wilson
mwilson a�communitv-newsoaaers.com
Posted: 10/21/2010 08:02:59 PM PDT
More than 20 homes in the Monta Vista neighborhood of Cupertino have been hit with possible fence
violations over the past few months after a neigF bor reported their unlawful status to the city earlier
this year.
According to city staff, the neighbor received a n�tice in March stating that his driveway gate was in
violation of a city ordinance because it was higher than 3 feet. The neighbor questioned why he was
the only property owner in his neighborhood whc� was the subject of code enforcement action when
he had identified others with similar noncompliar t fences and gates in the Monta Vista
neighborhood.
Over the past few months, the city received sevE ral complaints about those fences and driveway
gates that currently do not meet the city's fence ordinance. The city is working through about 25
cases with residents, according to associate plan ier Piu Ghosh.
City staff has been meeting with the fence ownei�s to see if their fences were built legally. Many
fences in the Monta Vista neighborhood were cor�structed when the area was part of unincorporated
Santa Clara County. The neighborhood became F art of Cupertino in 2004.
The rules for the county and the city are virtually the same, but work needs to be done to determine
if the fences had a city- or county-issued exception, according to city staff.
For the fences and gates that have not been buil: legally, the city is working with the residents on a
solution that complies with the rules or grants ar� exception in cases where driveway gates meet the
necessary criteria, according to Ghosh.
The Monta Vista neighborhood is bounded by StEVens Creek Boulevard and McClellan Road.
Longji Su lives in one of the more than 20 home:; hit with a potential violation after the neighbor's
complaint. He bought his house in 1994 with his illegal 4-foot front yard fence already erected. He
said he was not aware of its noncompliant status, nor has he altered the fence. Until recently, Su
was unaware that his fence was not in compliance with city or county rules.
"This was a complete surprise to me. I thought everything was fine when I bought my house," he
said.
Su did his own neighborhood investigating and believes that more than 40 homes, including about
half the homes on Byrne Avenue, have front yarci fences not in compliance.
The status of Su's fence is still under investigatic n, but he said he will do whatever the city wants
him to do. He questioned the fairness of having ��nly some residents subject to the ordinance after
so many years of what he called neglect.
"Why should some residents have to go through this while others do not? It is not fair, and everyone
should be subject to the same rules. Either ever��one is in violation or nobody is," he said.
Alex Wykoff, senior code enforcement officer witl� the city, said that the city enforces the ordinance
on a complaint basis. Code enforcement does no': patrol looking for violations, and issues are usually
brought to light only when a neighbor or resideni: alerts city hall.
"There is no proactive enforcement done," he said.
The city's municipal code outlines the rationale b�hind the fence ordinance. As in most cities, the
ordinance promotes community goals, such as pr�eserving neighborhood identity and aesthetics,
ensuring neighborhood safety and social interact on and enhancing local Neighborhood Watch
programs. Fire officials also have concerns about noncompliant gates being a barrier to emergency
response.
Fences taller than 3 feet and driveway gates are not permitted in front yards. Taller fences are
allowed at side and rear property lines behind th�� front yard setback to maintain the privacy and
security of a property. Gates on single-family lot�� are allowed in certain cases by exception.
For more information about the city's fence ordinance and municipal code, visit www.cupertino.ora.
� � �
� : -z
Also covering the Stanford University community
PALO ALTO MAKING SUSTAIl1ABLE STRIDES
Environmental leaders find transportation and land use tiie major challenges in sustainable city planning.
By Maggie Beidelman � Email the author � October 26, 2010
"Did they install the waterless urinal? Is purple pipir, g in the ground?" These are the types of questions that
Sustainability Planner Kristin Parineh now asks when on site during the construction of a new commercial
property in Palo Alto, where more than one million square feet of green construction is taking place.
Parineh joined three sustainability leaders from Mol.ntain View, Sunnyvale and Cupertino Monday night in a
discussion hosted by Sustainovation at World Centri � in Palo Alto: Creating Sustainable Cities-4 Local Cities
Lead the Way. The four city employees discussed thE successes and challenges involved in making a city
more sustainable.
"Transportation is the hardest nut to crack," said Steve Attinger, the Environmental Sustainability
coordinator for the city of Mountain View. "You can't tell someone, though shalt only drive to work three
days a week."
Parineh also views transportation as a major issue ir� sustainability for Palo Alto. "It's the hardest thing to get
people to change their behavior on, trying to get the�n out of their cars," said Parineh, who works in the Palo
Alto Planning Department and Green Building Progr �m.
In an effort to understand commuter behavior, Palo .�lto has begun to use a new technology. "We are starting
to install counting stations throughout the city that, �:hrough microwave frequencies and infrared, track
bicyclists to count how many people are switching tlieir mode of transportation," said Parineh. The city's
planning department is also looking into creating gr��en-painted bike lanes, an idea that was first
implemented in Portland, OR, to increase bike safety among car traffic and, therefore, encourage more
people to bike to work.
"Greenhouse gas emissions aren't a motivator," said Erin Cooke, Environmental Affairs coordinator for the
city of Cupertino. Cooke has found that treating greenhouse gases as units of ineasurement in which to
quantify an expense to the city—and in turn quantifi� the monetary savings due to emission reduction—is an
effective way to make sustainability more attractive.
"We're writing a climate action plan as part of San Mateo County," she said. "All of those programs lead to
monetary savings."
Cooke expressed the need for more technological support in the realm of sustainability. She suggested the
need for an "energy dashboard, where everybody can go online and see what their environmental impact is
during the day." In Britain, a new track and trace technology scans barcodes of food items, allowing for "farm
to fork" transparency. Cities here in Sillicon Valley c��uld model those advancements in order to support
sustainability, said Cooke.
Palo Alto's other major challenge in becoming more sustainable is land use, according to Parineh. "We have
over 20,000 existing buildings in the city of Palo Altc�," said Parineh, who focuses on construction and
renovation of these buildings. "Working to measure �eductions with single family homeowners or
commercial properties is challenging."
The Green Building Program wors with utility comp�inies to build a relationship with the city, using
greenhouse gas reduction reports and green buildin;; reports like LEED to certify Palo Alto structures.
High-speed rail, the largest transportation issue on residents' and city workers' mind right now, could create
a significant impact on land use and transportation, :;aid Parineh. "It has enormous benefits for sustainability
and enormous drawbacks in other areas," she said. "How do we fit high-speed rail into our land use planning
for sustainability and also our public transportation:'"
These are the questions that Bay Area cities, leaders in sustainability commitment and innovation, have
begun to ask with each new construction project, transportation issue and environmental concern.
Though they work to increase sustainability on a cir�-wide level, the speakers said that it really starts with
individuals making an effort.
"We have a changing demographic that's going to ca�ise cities to rethink how they plan," said Dustin Clark,
Environmental Sustainability coordinator for Sunny��ale. "By engaging and educating people on what the
future holds for them, they can begin to make decisic,ns for themselves."
As one audience member put it, "You don't have to be perfect. Every little bit helps."
Cupertino uses high-tech program to reward stude:its who bike, walk to schools - San Jos... Page 1 of 2
�1����L'C'ttC�l� ��W�
MercuryNews.com
CU ertino uses hi �1— The zap beeps and the student's data is uploaded to
p g a computer database. Student tags can be read only
program to reward �a� a day and are programmed just for school
Y
students who bike, walk Each student has an account on the Boltage website,
t0 SC�lOOlS where they can see all their trips. Boltage also
provides reports and data that can be used to
measure the number of children walking to school
and to
By Matt Wilson
mwilson@community-newspapers.com help create an incentive program for students and
classrooms.
Posted: 10/28/2010 08:02:58 PM PDT
Updated: 10/28/2010 08:02:59 PM PDT ° This is yet another way to encourage kids and
parents to try biking and walking to school. We just
New high-tech programs at Lincoln Elementary and can't handle the cars. We need a multifaceted
Kennedy Middle schools are rewarding students for approach, and this one on the wheel that is
helping keep cars off the road. The schools going to get this going, said David Greenstein, a
Lincoln Elementary parent who is working with
launched their respective Leopard Trax and Cougar parents and the city on the Boltage program. "The
Trax programs, which use technology to reward ciry is trying to solve a problem, but they need the
students who bike and walk to school. parents at Lincoln and Kennedy to take an active
The technology, called Boltage, measures how many [role]."
students walk and bike to school in one of the most �en the students register, Boltage software
car-congested areas in the city. The city of calculates how far they live from school, how many
Cupertino's Public Safety Commission and parent miles they travel and total trips they make. At
volunteers spent this summer working out the Kennedy, about 450 of its 1,300 students have
logistics tof bring the Boltage program to the signed up, and between them they've racked up
Lincoln and Kennedy and tackle congestion. more than 7,500 miles since Oct. 6, according to
The schools near Monta Vista High School are in the Leslie Reid, a parent volunteer at Kennedy who is
notoriously car-heavy tri-school area near Bubb heading the Cougar Trax program.
and McClellan roads, which often resemble a Statistics from the Lincoln Boltage program show
parking lot before and after school. that registered students are biking or walking an
The Boltage system uses a machine called "the zap," average of .088 miles to get to school.
a solar-powered radio frequency identification Parent volunteers with the Leopard Trax program
reader. Students who walk and bike in the program Would like to visually display how many miles the
get an RFID tag that attaches to their backpacks, and student body has walked and pedaled over the
the zap reads their unique number when they go course of the school year, by mapping out how
past it near school entrances.
Advertisement
��
_"'�
� � � £�� ; _ �� �c���� �r� ��a���c��i�+� �c���ic�t�`� F�I�t�(�'
� �������
�� ; �
� �� �� ����e ! inv�i�� pr�����. �� t���r �ic�n'� ���� t�.
,�.
� _� �. W�� ,
: ,� :.
� � � : ���rr r��r� c�� ��a�E�u�i����,��r�
� �.
�� �
��c�y �`�r ���I �si��� ����J!�► ��
_.
Print Powered Hy � ���m���„��!r�ics `
http://www.mercurynews.com/san jose-neighborhoods/ci_16462593?nclick check=l 10/29/2010
Cupertino uses high-tech program to reward stude�its who bike, walk to schools - San Jos... Page 2 of 2
�1��,���C'l�l�l� ��V�
MercuryNews.com
many miles it is to certain destinations such as donated money for prizes.
Yosemite National Park, the East Coast, Australia and
even the moon. Periodic statistics and updates on the program will
be reviewed by the commission, which will also
"Hopefully, this demonstrates that walking and consider bringing the program to other schools if
biking that little bit each day adds up to a lot," said Boltage is a success, Nguyen said.
Susanne Millar, a parent volunteer helping head the
Lincoln program.
At Lincoln Elementary, approximately 15 percent of
the student population has already signed up for a
Boltage tag.
"My vision is to see 25 percent," Greenstein said.
"This is not going to solve the traffic problem but it
is going to make it better, and the kids will get
healthier, too."
Lincoln will focus on non- material rewards for its
frequent bikers and walkers. Ideas in the works
include winning a lunch with their teacher, classes
possibly getting extra recess time for a day or
getting a pass to the front of the lunch line.
Students are easily motivated once they've signed
up, Millar said. "At this point in time, they are just
stoked hearing the beep coming off the [zap]."
Reid is distributing passes to laser tag, coupons for
drinks at 7-Eleven and candy. She is working on
getting pedometers and bicycle odometers as prizes
for extremely dedicated bikers and walkers. Other
possible prizes include water bottles, keychains and
tickets to Stanford athletic events.
The city of Cupertino contributed $21,400 to pay
for the program at both schools for this year and an
additional two years, according to Daniel Nguyen,
chairman of the public safety commission. The
program is in effect for three years so that the
schools and commission can analyze any long-term
impact from the program. Reid said the Kennedy PTA
Advertisement
' � ��rv� C�'�r
�� N` � �''��� ��al - �a�r� ,J�se �15 f�r Individual � �
....
i ' � �" '!�' .. :' +��°ship i�lJp ts� �35 �falue) ar $�5 far Family
� , �� � �; � �`�r����hi� ���Q Value� to Mus�ums �rf Los �atos � ' �
� ���� �
��� s � �� ���������� ��� �
� ���� � �
�� ti&dH`.ky �fL.�� �,S i �j��g�, � .
: , :�e �'���r�,�� �3��A��as � � s
Get thi� ��r� r�#��� ���,������� ��;;. � 1� '� F F�� ��
��
: y ..,
��T�° r+�tu��um� �� ��� �atc�� �- -�
www,Prin��rc��° c�r�.±���r18�! �
�i:�:u kii n u+ I ex i:4m< �
Print Powered By � F�c�rr��tD r��mics .
http://www.mercurynews.com/san jose-neighborhoods/ci_16462593?nclick check=l 10/29/2010