Loading...
Ordinance 1599 ORDINANCE NO. 1599 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CUPERTINO AMENDING ITS ORDINANCE CODE BY ADDING A NEW CHAPTER 3.36 TO ESTABLISH A STORM DRAINAGE SERVICE CHARGE AND DECLARING THE URGENCY THEREOF The City Council of the City of Cupertino does ordain as follows: WHEREAS, pursuant to the 1987 amendments to the Federal Clean Water Act, the United States Environmental Protection Agency has promulgated final regulation re- quiring cities to obtain a National Pollutant Discharge System (NPDES) permit to discharge storm sewers to re- ceiving waters; and WHEREAS, said final EPA regulations have set forth an extensive and exhaustive course of action in which demands have been placed on cities to properly maintain and monitor their storm sewer systems, and in the future, could contain requirements for significant reconstruction; and WHEREAS, the City of Cupertino, along with twelve other cities, the County of Santa Clara, and the Santa Clara Valley Water District, have obtained NPDES permits on June 20, 1990, which allows and requires the cities to regulate and manage their respective storm sewer sys- tems in accordance with requirements developed by the Santa Clara Valley Non-point Source Control and Storm Water Management Program; and [CC.2/OS] 1 WHEREAS, in order to conserve and protect the City's storm sewer system, and to implement various requirements of the Clean Water Act, EPA regulations, and the City's NPDES permit, the City is required to establish a reasonable storm drainage service charge computed based upon the need for, and the services provided by, the storm drainage management program of the City; and WHEREAS, the purpose of said charge is to provide a method for payment of all or any part of the cost and expense of improving the quality of storm and surface water runoff, the cost and expense of maintaining and operating the storm drainage management program of the City, all or any part of the cost and expense of plan- ning, designing, establishing, acquiring, developing, constructing and improving the storm drainage management system of the City, or to pay or secure the payment of all or any portion of any indebtedness incurred for such purpose, WHEREAS, California 8ealth and Safety Code SS 5471 and 5473 provides specific legal authority for the imposition of a storm drainage service charge by the City, and for the collection of said charge on the tax roll; and WHEREAS, a written report concerning the method of assessment of said fee was prepared containing a [CC.2/OS] 2 s • description of each parcel of real property receiving storm drain services and the amount of the charge for each parcel for the 1992-93 fiscal year= and WHEREAS, the City Clerk caused notice of the fil- ing a said report and of a time and place of a public hearing on sai~~ report and this ordinance to be publish- ed pursuant to Section 6066 of the Government Code as provided in California Health and Safety Code Section 5473.1= and WHEREAS, the Clerk also, pursuant to California Health and Safety Code Section 5473.1, caused a written notice of the filing of said report described above pro- posing to have such charges for the 1992-1993 fiscal year collected on the tax roll and of the time and place of hearing thereon, to be mailed to each person to whom any parcel or parcels of real property described in said report is assessed in the last equalized assessment roll available on the date said report is prepared, at the address shown on said assessment roll or as known to the Clerk] and WHEREAS, the report described above was available for public inspection and review ten (10) days prior to the public hearing; and WHEREAS, the time and place for said hearing was set by the Clerk to be conducted on July 20, 1992 at [CC.2/OS] 3 6:45 p.m. at the Cupertino City Hall Council Chambers, 10300 Torre Avenue, Cupertino, California; and WHEREAS, the Council at said time and place heard all evidence, protests and comments regarding: a) Whether the storm drainage charge should be imposed b) The amount of said charge and c) Whether said charge should be collected on the tax roll; and WHEREAS, with respect to whether said charge should be collected on the tax roll, that any protest made by property owners to be charged did not constitute a majority of the separate parcels of property described in the report; and WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Cupertino determines that the proposed storm drainage charge should be imposed at the amount described in the report, and that said charge should be collected on the tax roll in the same manner, by the same persons, and at the same time as, together wii:h and not separately from, its general taxes; and WHEREAS, the City Council also finds that the report described above provides an appropriate method of assessment establishing the relationship between the storm drainage charge and the cost of the storm drain [CC.2/OS] 4 management program conducted by the City and that there is a reasonable relationship between the need for the charge and the impacts for which the charge shall be used, as well as the existence of a reasonable relation- ship between the charges use and the properties which are to be chargeds and WHSRSAS, the charge described is based upon run- off co-efficienta established in the City's Master Storm Drain Study, which the City Council has approved and incorporates herein, NOW, THBRBFORS, BS IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Cupertino: Section i Chapter 3.36 of the Cupertino Municipal Code, en- titled Storm Drainage Service charge is hereby enacted to be numbered and entitled and to read as follows: Section 3.36.010 - Purpose of the Chara_e - Limitation of Use The purpose of the charge is to conserve and pro- tect the City's storm drainage system from the burden placed on it by the increasing flow of non-point source runoff and to otherwise meet the requirements developed by the Santa Clara Valley Non-Point Source Control and Storm Water Management Program established to comply ~CC.2/OSj 5 with the Clean Water Act, EPA regulations and the cities' NPDES permits. The specific purpose of the storm drainage service charges established pursuant to this Chapter is to derive revenue which shall only be used for the acquisi- tion, construction, re-construction, maintenance, and operation of the storm drainage system of the City of Cupertino to repay principal and interest on any bonds which may hereafter be issued for said purposes, to re- pay loans or advances which may hereafter be made for said purposes and for any other purpose set forth in Section 3.36.160. However, said revenue shall not be used for the acquisition or construction of new local s;:reet storm sewers or storm laterals as distinguished from main trunk, interceptor and outfall storm sewers. Section 3.36.020 - Definitions Except where the context otherwise requires, the following definitions in this section shall govern the construction of this Chapter: A. "Apartment Premises" means premises improved or used for a residence for three (3) ar more families living independently of each other and doing their own cooking and which is not separately assessed by the county tax assessor for each such family dwelling. [CC.2/OS] 6 B. "City" means and includes all territory lying within the municipal boundaries of the City of Cupertino as presently existing plus all territory which may be added thereto during the effect term of the ordinance codified herein. C. "Commercial/Industrial Premises" - means premises improved or used for any purpose or purposes other than as a residence for one or more families living separately in separate dwelling units, or which is improved or used as a residence for one or more families living separately in separate dwelling units and for one or more other purposes. D. "Director of Public Works" means the Director of Public Works and his/her duly authorized agents and representatives. 8. "Finance Director" means the Director of Finance of the City of Cupertino and his/her duly authorized agents and representatives. F. "Lot" means a unit of land which may lawfully be sold as a separate area of land in conformity with the City's subdivision ordinance. G. "Maintenance and Operation" means the admini- stration, operation, maintenance and repair of any facil- ity in the City's storm drain system, including, but not limited to: [CC.2/OS] 7 i 1) Items ordinarily recognized as capital items (eg. interests in land) when reasonably necessary to maintain the capacity of the storm drain system when new. 2) Street sweeping and catch basin cleaning. 3) Replacement of portions of existing facili- ties damaged or destroyed as a result of acci- dent or natural disasters. 4) Damages or settlements paid in the course of, or because of, threatened or actual legal actions to the City's storm drain system or non-point source program. 5) Regional monitoring, permit fees, public education and awareness programs regarding the City's storm drain system and the City's non- point source program. 6) Management of the City's non-point source program including, but not limited to, BMP manuals, public outreach, printed materials, City staff and legal coats related thereto. H. "Parcel" means a unit of land which is deaig- Hated by the tax assessor of Santa Clara County for property tax purposes. I. "Premises" means a separate area of land im- proved or unimproved, which is connected to or benefited from, directly or indirectly, the storm drainage system (CC.2/OS] 8 or any portion thereof, or from which any water runoff is discharged; directly or indirectly, into said storm drainage system. J. "Residential Premises" means premises, other than apartment premises, improved or used solely as a residence foc one or more families living separately in separate dwelling units. K. "storm Drainage System" means any pipe, con- duit, or sewer of the City designed or used for the disposal of storm and surface waters and drainage in- cluding unpolluted cooling water and unpolluted indus- trial process water, but excluding any community sani- tary sewer system. L. "Vacant Premises" means an area of land con- sisting of a single lot or a lot which is part of a sub- division recorded in the office of the county recorder, or a lot or area of land described by meter and bounds which has been recorded, without any structure existing upon it. Section 3.36.030 - Determination and im osition of C e For purposes specified in section 3.36.010, the storm drainage service charge established pursuant to this Chapter are hereby prescribed and imposed, and [CC.2/OS] 9 __ i shall be paid to and collected by the City, for services and facilities furnished by the City in connection with its storm drainage system to or, for each premises which is benefited directly or indirectly by said storm drain- age system or any part thereof, or from which any storm water is conveyed or discharged directly or indirectly into the storm drainage system. Said charge imposed annually and will be assessed and collected as follows: Residential premises $ 12.00 /parcel Apartment premises $ 144.00 /acre Commercial/Industrial premises $ 144.00 /acre Vacant premises $ 36.00 /acre Section 3.36.040 - Exemptions All government or public premises are exempt from the provisions of this Chapter. As used herein the term "governmental or public premises" means and includes premises which are owned bys a) The City of Cupertino b) The Central Fire District of Santa Clara County (CC.2/OS~ 10 • c) The Cupertino Union School District d) The Poothill Community College District e) The Fremont Union School District -"' - __ ._ _ -Q} The Midpeninsula Regional Park District g) Santa Clara County I h) Santa Clara County Valley Water District i) Cupertino Sanitary District j) Southern Pacific Railroad Company k) State of California 1) United States of America Section 3.36.050 - Annual Review of Charges On or about the beginning of each fiscal year, the City Council shall ceview the amount of revenue produced by the storm drainage service charge, the estimated cost of the City's Non-Point Source Control and Storm Water Management Program and may modify the amount of such charges. Section 3.36.060 - Methods of Measurement and Analysis Prior to establishing or reviewing the storm drain- age service charge, the City Council shall be provided with a written report prepared by the Director of Public Works who, on the basis of standard methods, standard engineering practices and applicable provisions of this Chapter, shall render his written opinion as to the adequacy and appropriateness of methods employed to [CC.2/OS] 11 ~• measure land area of premises served by the storm drainage system for the purpose of computing the storm drainage service charges as set forth in this ordinance. The Director of Public Works, on the basis of standard methods, standard engineering practices, ap- plicable provisions of this Chapter, and applicable state and federal regulations and guidelines, if any, shall also render his written opinion at to the benefit received by each premises from the storm drainage sys- tem. Section 3.36.070 - Effective Date of Charges The storm drainage service charges shall become effective on the effective date of this ordinance. Section 3.36.080 - Charges Collected with General Taxes A. Subject to the exceptions hereinafter set forth, the City elects, as an alternative procedure for the collection of storm drainage service charges pre- scribed or imposed by the provisions of this Chapter, to have all such storm drainage service charges for each fiscal year collected on the tax roll in the same man- ner, by the same persons and at the same time as, and together with and not separately from, its general taxes. B. The Director of Public Works is hereby direct- ed to prepare and file with the City Clerk, on or before [CC.2/OS] 12 ~~ the 15th day of June of each year, or such other date or dates as the City Council may specify by Resolution, a written report containing a description of each and every parcel of real property receiving the benefit of the storm drainage system mentioned in this Chapter, except for those premises the charges for which are not to be collected on the tax roll, and the amount of the storm drainage service charges for each premises for the forthcoming fiscal year, computed in conformity with the charges prescribed by the provisions of this Chapter. C. The City Clerk shall cause notice of the fil- ing of said report and of a time and place of hearing thereon to be published, prior to the date for hearing, in a newspaper of general circulation printed and pub- lished within the City of Cupertino. The publication of said notice shall be once a week for two consecutive weeks. Two publications in a newspaper published once a week or more often, with at least five days intervening between the respective publication dates, not counting such publication dates, are sufficient. The period of notice commences upon the first day publication and terminates at the end of the fourteenth day. D. At the time stated in the above-mentioned notice, the City Council shall hear and consider all objections or protests, if any, to the report referred [CC.2/OS] 13 ,~ • to in said notice, and may continue the hearing from time to time. If the Council finds that protest is made by owners of a majority of separate parcels of property described in the report, then the report shall not be adopted and charges shall be collected separately from the tax roll and shall not constitute a lien against any parcel or parcels of land. 8. Upon the conclusion of the hearing, the City Council may adopt, revise, change, reduce, or modify any charge or overrule any or all objections and shall make its determination upon each charge as described in said report, which determination shall be final. F. On or before the 1st day of August of each year following such final determination, the City Clerk shall file with the Finance Director a copy of said re- port with a statement endorsed thereon over the City Clerk's signature that it has been finally adopted by the City Council. The Finance Director shall thereupon cause said charges to be placed on the property tax roll and col- lected by the County of Santa Clara for the City of Cupertino, as hereinafter provided. The County's tax collector shall enter the amounts of the charges against the respective premises or lots or parcels of land as they appear on the current assessment roll. If the [CC.2/oS] 14 • property is not described on the roll, the County's tax collector may enter the description thereon, together with the amounts of the charges as shown in the report. G. The amount of the charges shall constitute a lien against the lot or parcel of land against which the charge has been imposed as of noon on the first Monday in March immediately preceding the date of the 1•-•+•y. 9. The tax collector shall include the amount of the charges on bills for taxes levied against the re- spective lots and parcels of land. Thereafter the amount of the cY.arges shall be collected at the same time and in the same manner and by the same persona as, together with and not separately from, the general taxes for the City, and shall be delinquent at the same time and thereafter be subject to the same delinquency penal- ties. I. All laws applicable to the levy, collection and enforcement of general taxes of the City including, but not limited to, those pertaining to matters of delinquency, collection, cancellation, refund and re- demption, are applicable to such charges. J. The tax collector may, at the tax collector's discretion, issue separate bills for such charges and separate receipts for collection on account of such charges. [CC.2/OS] 15 ~~ • K. If any premises receiving benefit from the storm drainage system are omitted from the above- mentioned report or said tax roll, either because the charge therefor shall not have yet been ascertained by the City as of the date of said report, or for any other reason, the storm drainage service charge for such premises shall be collected in the manner provided else- where in this Chapter. If the charge for any premises, as shown on said report for the forthcoming fiscal year, should be less than what should be the charge therefor under the provisions of this Chapter, the balance of such charge shall be collected in the manner provided elsewhere in this Chapter. If, however, the charge for any premises shown in the report and collected on the tax roll should exceed the correct charge for such prem- ises for the fiscal year, the Finance Director shall refund the excess amount so collected. Section 3.36.090 - Payment of Balance of Charge A. If the charge for any premises placed on the tax roll, or for any premises collected based upon bil- ling, was less than what should be the charge therefor under the provisions of this Chapter due to error, the balance of said charge shall be collected by a bill or invoice based on a detailed statement showing the basis [CC.2/OSj 16 • of the calculations, the location of the premises and other relevant information, and prepared on or after January tat For the preceding six months from July to December during which a discrepancy between the amount collected and the correct charge is discovered, and on or after July tat for the preceding six months from January to June during which such a discrepancy is dis- covered. The Finance Director shall mail said bill or invoice to the person or persons listed as the owners of the premises on the last equalized assessment roll of the County of Santa Clara at the address shown on such assessment roll or to the successor in interest of such owner if the name and address of such successor in in- terest is known to the Finance Director. Failure to mail any such bill or invoice, or failure of any owner to receive any such bill or invoice shall not excuse the owner of any premises from the obligation of paying the balance of any storm drainage service charge for any premises owned by him or her. B. The interested owner may, at any reasonable time, review the detailed statement prepared by the Finance Director. C. The balance of the storm drainage service charge for such premises shall be due and payable on the date the bill or invoice referred to in this section is mailed. [CC.2/OSJ 17 Section 3.36.100 - Collection of Charges Omitted From Tax Roll - B 11 ng A. The Finance Director shall semi-annually, on or after July 1st, prepare or cause to be prepared a .detailed statement containing the basis of the calcula- tions, the location of the premises and other relevant information, showing the total monthly charge for the preceding six months from January to June and on or after January 1st, for the preceding six months from July to December for any premises the charge for which should be collected on the tax roll pursuant to Section 3.36.080A but was omitted from the report referred to in Section 3.36.0808, or premises the charge for which is collected pursuant billing. B. An invoice may be rendered for a period of less than six months if the commencement date of charges is other than July 1st or January 1st, as may be the case with new accounts. C. On the basis of the statement, the Finance Director shall prepare a bill or invoice showing the total charge for such six months or less, and shall mail said bill or invoice to the person or persons listed as the owners of the premises on the last equalized assess- ment roll of the County of Santa Clara at the address shown on such assessment roll, or to the successor in [CC.2/OSJ 18 • interest of such owner if the name and address of such successor in interest is known to *h- Director. Failure to mail any such bill or invoice, or failure of any own- er to receive any such bill or invoice shall not excuse-"h>C~~,..,.,.r~~ the owner of any premises from the obligation of paying any storm drainage charge for any premises owned by him or her. D. The interested owner may, at any reasonable time, review the detailed statement prepared by the Finance Director. E. The storm drainage service charge for such premises shall be due and payable immediately upon re- ceipt of the bill or invoice referred to in this section. Section 3.36.110 - Pa ent of Char es - Owner Rea onsi- b ty The owner of any premises is and shall be respon- sible for payment of any and all storm drainage service charges applicable to premises owned by him or her. It shall be and is hereby made the duty of each such owner to provide to the Finance Director information suf- ficient to calculate the land area of the premises with- in thirty (30? days after request of the Finance Director and ascertain from the Finance Director the amount and due date of any such charge applicable to [CC.2/OS] 19 • premises owned by such owner and to pay such charge when due and payable. It also shall be and is hereby made the duty of all owners of all premises to inform the Finance Director immediately of all circumstances, and of any change oc changes in any circumstances, which will in any way affect the applicabilty of any charge. In particular, but not by way of limitation, an owner of any premises shall immediately inform the Finance Director of any sale or transfer of such premises by or to such owner. Section 3.36.120 - Payment of Charges - Location Except as otherwise provided elsewhere in this Chapter, all storm drainage service charges shall be payable at the office of the Finance Director in the City Hall of the City of Cupertino. Section 3.36.130 - Payment of Charges - Delinquency Date 8xcept as otherwise provided elsewhere in this Chap*.er, each storm drainage service charge shall be delinquent if not paid on or before the fortieth day immediately following the date upon which such storm drainage service charge became due and payable. Section 3.36.140 - Penalty for Delinquency Sxcept as otherwise provided elsewhere in this Chapter, whenever any storm drainage service charge be- [CC.2/OS] 20 • co~aes delinquent, there shall be imposed a penalty equal to 1008 of the amount as set forth under Section 3.36.030. Section 3.36.150 - Disputed Charges If any owner disputes the amount of the charge in any bill or invoice, the owner shall, within thirty days from and after the date such bill or invoice is mailed, and no later, file a claim with the Finance Director accompanied by detailed supporting factual data in sup- port of the claim. It shall be the duty of each such owner to prove to the Finance Director, that such charge is in error and the correct amount thereof. If the Finance Director determines that the bill or invoice was in error, the Finance Director shall correct said bill. Pailure to dispute the amount of the charge in accord- ance with this Section shall be deemed acceptance of the correctness of the charge. Section 3.36.160 - Adjustments in Charges It is the intent of the provisions of this Chap- ter, in establishing different storm drainage service charges for different classes of premises, to establish higher charges for those classes of premises which derive greater benefit from, or impose greater burdens upon, the storm drainage system, or other benefits re- ceived by the storm drainage system, giving full consid- [CC.2/OSJ 21 • eration to other fees or taxes which may be paid by owners of said premises for the operation, maintenance, expansion, extension or development of the storm drain- age system. 7', with respect to any of said premises, the City Council should find that the charge applicable thereto is unfair or inequitable, then in that event the Council may by resolution, agreement or otherwise, eatab- liah a special storm drainage service charge for such premises, different from those above provided, and hav- ing a closer relationship to the benefit received, or burden placed, by such premises from or upon said storm drainage system, giving due consideration to other fees or taxes paid by such premises for said storm drainage system. However, any agreement or any such special storm drainage service charge may at any time be revoked or changed by resolution of the Council upon a finding that continuation of same would be unfair or inequitable under the circumstances. Section 3.36.170 - S ecial Fund Created - Restricted Ose o Revenues A. All revenues collected pursuant to the provi- sions of this Chapter shall be placed into a special fund which is hereby created for such purpose and which shall be known as the "storm drainage service charge [CC.2/OS) 22 fund." Such revenues may be used for the purpose speci- fied in Section 3.36.010, and for no other purpose] pr~- vided, however, that moneys deposited in said fund may be used for direct and administrative costs of the City in collecting the storm drainage charges imposed by this part and for direct and indirect overhead coats of the City in performing any tasks, including, but not limited to, calculation of the benefits received by properties from the storm drainage system. B. Aa used in this section, "direct costs" means wages and salaries and costs of employee fringe benefits incurred by the City, and mileage reimbursement attribut- able to said collection activities. As used in this section, "administrative costs" includes, but is not limited to all coats for computer service, materials, postage, supplies and equipment. C. Notwithstanding subsections A and B, interest on revenues in the storm drainage service charge fund may be credited to the general fund of the City of Cupertino or to any other fund in the discretion of the City Council. Section 3.36.180 - Refunds Whenever any ref ands should become owing by virtue of any relief granted by the City Council pursuant to the provisions of Section 3.36.150 or by virtue of any [CC.2/OS] 23 error made in ascertaining the charge applicable to any premises, the Finance Director is authorized to make such refunds and to expend for such purpose the moneys in the storm drainage service charge fund. Notwithstand- ing the provisions of Section 3.36.150, any claim for refund for charges collected under Section 3.36.080 must be made within one year after the date bills for taxes are received by the owner. The City shall not be liable for interest or any amount determined to be refundable. Section 3.36.190 - Inspection of Premises Authorized The Director of Public Works, the Finance Director and their authorized representatives are hereby given power and authority to enter upon and within any premi- ses to ascertain the nature of such premiaesf to in- spect, observe, and review the benefit received from the storm drain system as may be allowed by law. Section 3.36.200 - Payment of Delinquent Charges - City Enforcement Powers A. Notwithstanding other remedies, in the event of the failure of any owner to pay when due any storm drainage service charges applicable to premises owned by such owner, the City may enforce payment of such delin- quent charges by instituting action in any court of competent jurisdiction to collect any charges which may [CC.2/OS] 24 be due and payable in the same manner as any other debts owing to the City may be collected. B. Any and all delinquent payments may be placed on the tax roll, and collected with property taxes, as provided in Section 3.36.080. C. Such other action may be taken as may be autho- rized by law and by the City Council. D. Remedies under this section are in addition to and do not supersede or limit any and all other reme- dies, civil and criminal. Section 3.36.210 - Severability If any section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, or phras~3 of this Chapter for any reason held to be unconstitutional or otherwise void or invalid, by any court of competent jurisdiction, the validity of the remaining portion of this Chapter shall not be affected thereby. Section II Judicial Action to Challenge This Ordinance Any judicial action or proceeding to challenge, review, set aside, void or annul this ordinance shall be brought within 90 days from the date of its adoption. Section III Effective Date - Statement of Urgency The City Council, by unanimous vote, finds and [CC.2/OS] 25 determines that, for the immediate preservation of pub- lic peace, health and safety, this ordinance shall be- come effective immediately without further reading. The facts which support this determination are as follows: 1) The 1987 Amendments to the Federal Clean Water program together with related regulations, including conditions imposed upon the cities NPDES permit consti- tute both a Federal and State mandated program for the protection of the environment and to prcv.'.de clean water to residents of the Santa Clara Valley. 2) The estimated cost of meeting these require- ments for the 1992-93 fiscal year is over $340,000 to be paid by the City of Cupertino. 3) The City of Cupertino has insufficient funds from its general fund to meet these requirements. 4) In order to collect the storm drainage service charge imposed by this Chapter on the tax roll for the 1992/93 fiscal year, it is necessary that this Chapter become effective prior to August 8, 1992. 5) Without this ordinance becoming effective be- fore August 8, 1992, the City of Cupertino will be finan- cially unable to meet its Federal and State mandates and therefore protect the health of the public as it relates to the control of storm waters within and without the City. (cc.2/os] 2s ..~ Section IV Publication The City Clerk shall cause this ordinance to be published at least once in a newspaper of general circu- lation published and circulated in the Cit~f ~aithin fif- __ ~~`r.. teen (15) days after its passage, in accordance with Section 36933 of the Government Code; shall certify to the adoption of this ordinance and shall cause this ordinance and her certification, together with proof of publication, to be entered in the Book of Ordinances of the Council of this City. INTRODOCED at a regular meeting of the City Council this 20th day of July , 1992, and ENACTED at a regular meeting of the City Council this 20th daY of July , 1992, by the following votes Vote: Members of the City Councils Ayes: Dean. Goldman, Koppel. Szabo, Sorensen Noes: None Absent: Nose Abstains None ATTE APPROVED: ~.~ a.e~- ~ ~,- C yor, C ty o Cupert no _ [CC.2/OS] 27