104-C - Matrix.pdf
Protected Trees Ordinance: Matrix of Options
†Standard TR Permit (Fees, Noticing, Arborist Report, Covenant & Conditions Required)
‡Approved Development TR Permit (Fees, Noticing, Arborist Report, & Conditions Required – No Covenant Required)
^PC TR Permit (Fees, Noticing, Arborist Report, Reso & Conditions Required – No Covenant Required)
#Environmental Consultant to verify level of environmental review
Category Current Ordinance
(No Change) Proposed Ordinance Alternative 1 (Streamlined Process
for R1, R2, A1, A, & RHS)
Alternative 2 – No Restrictions on
R1 (No Specimen, No Privacy, No
Heritage)
Alternative 3 (No Specimen, No
Approved Development)
Alternative 4
(No Specimen) Alternative 5 (No Ordinance)
Specimen Tree Diameter Equal to or greater than 10” DBH Equal to or greater than 10” 12” DBH Equal to or greater than 10” 12” DBH Equal to or greater than 10” DBH Equal to or greater than 10” DBH Equal to or greater than 10” DBH Equal to or greater than 10” DBH
Species
1. Quercus (native oak tree species),
including but not limited to:
a. Quercus agrifolia (Coast Live
Oak);
b. Quercus lobata (Valley Oak);
c. Quercus kelloggii (Black Oak);
d. Quercus douglasii (Blue Oak);
e. Quercus wislizeni (Interior Live
Oak);
2. Aesculus californica (California
Buckeye);
3. Acer macrophyllum (Big Leaf
Maple);
4. Cedrus deodara (Deodar Cedar);
5. Cedrus atlantica 'Glauca' (Blue Atlas
Cedar);
6. Umbellularia californica (Bay Laurel
or California Bay); and
7. Platanus racemosa (Western
Sycamore)
1. Quercus (native oak tree species),
including but not limited to:
a. Quercus agrifolia (Coast Live
Oak);
b. Quercus lobata (Valley Oak);
c. Quercus kelloggii (Black Oak);
d. Quercus douglasii (Blue Oak);
e. Quercus wislizeni (Interior Live
Oak);
2. Aesculus californica (California
Buckeye);
3. Acer macrophyllum (Big Leaf
Maple);
4. Cedrus deodara (Deodar Cedar);
5. Cedrus atlantica 'Glauca' (Blue Atlas
Cedar);
6. Umbellularia californica (Bay Laurel
or California Bay); and
7. Platanus racemosa (Western
Sycamore)
1. Quercus (native oak tree species),
including but not limited to:
a. Quercus agrifolia (Coast Live
Oak);
b. Quercus lobata (Valley Oak);
c. Quercus kelloggii (Black Oak);
d. Quercus douglasii (Blue Oak);
e. Quercus wislizeni (Interior Live
Oak);
2. Aesculus californica (California
Buckeye);
3. Acer macrophyllum (Big Leaf
Maple);
4. Cedrus deodara (Deodar Cedar);
5. Cedrus atlantica 'Glauca' (Blue Atlas
Cedar);
6. Umbellularia californica (Bay Laurel
or California Bay); and
7. Platanus racemosa (Western
Sycamore)
1. Quercus (native oak tree species),
including but not limited to:
a. Quercus agrifolia (Coast Live
Oak);
b. Quercus lobata (Valley Oak);
c. Quercus kelloggii (Black Oak);
d. Quercus douglasii (Blue Oak);
e. Quercus wislizeni (Interior Live
Oak);
2. Aesculus californica (California
Buckeye);
3. Acer macrophyllum (Big Leaf
Maple);
4. Cedrus deodara (Deodar Cedar);
5. Cedrus atlantica 'Glauca' (Blue Atlas
Cedar);
6. Umbellularia californica (Bay Laurel
or California Bay); and
7. Platanus racemosa (Western
Sycamore)
1. Quercus (native oak tree species),
including but not limited to:
a. Quercus agrifolia (Coast Live
Oak);
b. Quercus lobata (Valley Oak);
c. Quercus kelloggii (Black Oak);
d. Quercus douglasii (Blue Oak);
e. Quercus wislizeni (Interior Live
Oak);
2. Aesculus californica (California
Buckeye);
3. Acer macrophyllum (Big Leaf
Maple);
4. Cedrus deodara (Deodar Cedar);
5. Cedrus atlantica 'Glauca' (Blue Atlas
Cedar);
6. Umbellularia californica (Bay Laurel
or California Bay); and
7. Platanus racemosa (Western
Sycamore)
1. Quercus (native oak tree species),
including but not limited to:
a. Quercus agrifolia (Coast Live
Oak);
b. Quercus lobata (Valley Oak);
c. Quercus kelloggii (Black Oak);
d. Quercus douglasii (Blue Oak);
e. Quercus wislizeni (Interior Live
Oak);
2. Aesculus californica (California
Buckeye);
3. Acer macrophyllum (Big Leaf
Maple);
4. Cedrus deodara (Deodar Cedar);
5. Cedrus atlantica 'Glauca' (Blue Atlas
Cedar);
6. Umbellularia californica (Bay Laurel
or California Bay); and
7. Platanus racemosa (Western
Sycamore)
1. Quercus (native oak tree species),
including but not limited to:
a. Quercus agrifolia (Coast Live
Oak);
b. Quercus lobata (Valley Oak);
c. Quercus kelloggii (Black Oak);
d. Quercus douglasii (Blue Oak);
e. Quercus wislizeni (Interior Live
Oak);
2. Aesculus californica (California
Buckeye);
3. Acer macrophyllum (Big Leaf
Maple);
4. Cedrus deodara (Deodar Cedar);
5. Cedrus atlantica 'Glauca' (Blue Atlas
Cedar);
6. Umbellularia californica (Bay Laurel
or California Bay); and
7. Platanus racemosa (Western
Sycamore)
Process for Removal of Specimen Trees
less than Specimen Tree Size: None TR Permit† None None None None None
Mitigation: None Replacement Trees None None None None None
Process for Removal of Specimen Trees
equal to or greater Specimen Tree Size: TR Permit† No Change TR Permit† X X X X
Mitigation: Replacement Trees No Change No Change X X X X
Other Protected Trees
Privacy Protection, Approved
Development Trees (excludes R1),
Heritage Trees
Privacy Protection, Approved
Development Trees (excludes R1 & R2,
A1, A, RHS), Heritage Trees
Privacy Protection, Approved
Development Trees (excludes R1 & R2,
A1, A, RHS), Heritage Trees
Privacy Protection, Approved
Development Trees (excludes R1),
Heritage Trees
Privacy Protection, Approved
Development Trees (excludes R1),
Heritage Trees
Privacy Protection, Approved
Development Trees (excludes R1 & R2,
A1, A, RHS), Heritage Trees
Privacy Protection, Approved
Development Trees (excludes R1),
Heritage Trees
Process for Removal of Privacy Trees TR Permit† No Change No Change X No Change No Change X
Mitigation: Replacement Trees No Change No Change X No Change No Change X
Process for Removal of Approved
Development Trees TR Permit‡ No Change No Change No Change X No Change X
Mitigation: Replacement Trees No Change No Change No Change X No Change X
Process for Removal of Heritage Trees PC - TR Permit^ No Change No Change X No Change No Change X
Mitigation: Replacement Trees No Change No Change X No change No Change X
Environmental
Review:
Ordinance Change No Project MND MND# EIR# EIR# EIR# EIR#
Individual Tree
Removals Categorical Exemption Not a Project per CEQA if New Findings
Are Met No Change If New Findings Are Met No Change If New Findings Are Met No Change If New Findings Are Met No Change If New Findings Are Met Not Required