Press Alt + R to read the document text or Alt + P to download or print.
This document contains no pages.
TR-2014-69b COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
, �.
CITY HALL
10300 TORRE AVENUE•CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255
C U P E RT 1 N O (408)777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333•planninaCa�cuqertino.orq
January 13,2015
Leon Demar
21853 Gardenview Lane
Cupertino, CA 95014
SUBJECT: HAZARDOUS TREE REMOVAL PEIZMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2014-69
This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on December 12,
2014, approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal of a hazardous 11-inch Deodar Cedar
(Cedrus deodara) on a residential parcel located at 21853 Gardenview Lane. The application is approved
with the following conditions:
1. APPROVED PROJECT
The approval is based on the arborist report prepared by a Certified Arborist (Michel L. Bench #WE
1897A), dated December 8, 2014, consisting of two pages not including site photographs.
2. IN-LIEU TREE REPLACEMENT FEES
The Director of Community Development has determined that it is physically infeasible to plant the
required 24-inch box replacement tree. The cost to procure and install the replacement tree is
approximately $450.00, of which the applicant has paid on January 13, 2015, in accordance with the
Protected Tree Ordinance, Section 14.18.160 (B)(4).
3. NOTICE OF FEES DEDICATIONS RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS
The Conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication
requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section
66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and
a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby further notified
that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and
other exactions, pursuant to Govemment Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a
protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will
be legally barred from later challenging such exactions.
Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section
14.18.150(B) (1)(2) of the Protected Trees Ordinance.
21853 Gardenview Lane Page 2
TR-2014-69
Sincerel�,/ � �
/
�/� !J ` __ �,
- �;�;,�
ick Serrano
Assistant Planner
City of Cupertino
(408) 777-3205
���'`�
�
�,,,,,- Michael L.Bench ,� A t .-rjP �
.., _. -
�::._ .L � o� - �,�
} ,� Consulting Arborist ��.�. ---.-- .�- __._�..�,,.,�,,,�,
f � (831) 594-5151
♦r `,,,-�� ` l"�.�J' / ,
�� \ 7327 Langley Canyon Road �
�"� Prunedale,California 93907 � �
..�._.�...,,,�,,, --^ ��
A Review of A Deodar Cedar
21853 Gardenview Lane
Cupertino, California
Assignment �
I was asked by Mr. George Schroeder, Planner, City of Cupertino, to review the
photos of a deodar cedar tree and to provide an opinion concern.ing the tree's
stability, if possible.
Observations
I reviewed the photos sent to me via email of the subject deodar cedar(Cedrzc.s deodcrra)
located at 21853 Gardenview Lane, Cupertino. It appears that this tree is located in
the back yard or possibly a side yard. I estimate the trunk of this tree to be
approYimately 12 inches in diameter at 54 inches above �rade.
Typically it is not possible to gain sufticient information about a leaning tree in a
photo. However, in this case, the photos were excellent.
'I his tree has started to up-root. 'l he lifted roots combined with the leaning trunk,
are the obvious. These characteristics do not always indicate that a tree is starting
to up-root, because many trees lean and many trees have surface roots. In this
case, the most signiiicant clue is seen at the root tips in each of the photos.
In those photos, the bark has eroded from the root and the roots are stubs. This
means that at least a percentage of the roots have been destroyed by decay. The
most likely decay pathogen is Ar�nellaria rnellea, a common root decay pathogen.
For this pathogen to attack a tree, it is essential that the soil stay relatively moist
all of the time. I suspect the irrigation at this property or from the neighboring
property maintains a relatively high level of moisture.
When this occurs for a short period, it does not typically develop into root decay.
However, a locations where the soil stays relatively moist for most of the time,
especially during the summer months,Armellaria mellect will go to work, which
appears to have happened here. This disease daes not require a lot of water, but
some moisture - rather constantly over a period of time.
Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Report from Photo Observations: 1
Consulting Arborist December 8, 2014
21853 Gardenview Lane
Cupertino, California
I-�owever, the process is fairly slow and does not occur in a few weeks or months.
For the disease to have eaten through the roots seen in these photos, the process of
decay will have taken a fe�v years.
Conclusions
The subject deodar cedar tree has been rendered unstable by root disease.
Recommendation
I recommend that this tree be remove immediately. If a replacement tree would be
required,the location and the species would depend on the site,the space, and the site
conditions.
Respectfully submitted,
;,,..,,,..._
a.�..___..
Michael L. Bench, Consulting Arborist
International Society of Arboriculture Certification# WE 1897A
American Society of Consulting Arborists Member
Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Report from Photo Observations: 2
Consulting Arborist December 8, 2014
21853 Gardenview Lane
Cupertino
Deodar Cedar tree in side yard
a���ov,�� i�2 ��� �-6 9
Ap�si���ti�n I�d��nber
�� ��/��
�= . .,� �
i,, � s:
�� � �.� �
_ �
� � ������
g �
�-:T � i . � 9ri,:. Y,gi" I
`. � '���� .c� . `' �'
x .�
`� �:�
� .� �
� � � _ � w �� ��
,_ :� �
��
, ��,
� �` .�� ��
..� �
�,;�
��� �.�"'�
, �� . ,
¢ Y ,_ , : _
� � .. . ; ,. ,
�. ,�
� �� � �
�.
> ���.. ,;�.. �u �
K. ,
��.. � _ �, � � �� � I. "'--,
, . �„�..,
. _
� ,;: _ . , � ,
� � • � -:c< � ,,;� �-�_:
�: �,s��� ;; ��,
�� � ` �g'
' , � '. , �
�� ,�-� , . �., �,
��: ...� .. .
g_.:� ,<
� �, . � :
, �� >
„. ,, . . � .��
. _ ,:,: .
. >, . .�� � ,..
... 8„t., � �.-«; , ,
'. . . ' '�- �p, �� `� �: .
. �!e �a� ��i
� �
� I ;
����� 9,� �il ! �p�I` 1.
�� ��& - ��'
� � � .�. ���� �
� �� .
�"�� �m �.�
..
_
�.:.
;� , .., _
��� �
� _..
,
,
� �
; �i
. ,. �
��,
-� �� -��� ��
� � �
� � ��-:
� � �
�� � �t ���
_ . �. -�
: „ _. . , z
�m.
�
� k � '� �
, ,
�
�__� �:. —
�
� .
�� ���
�
�
.-a
�
�
�
. �
`
\
t��
�l
E _.
9`:, '�\
�
��
��
1�
�
! j
��.
~ V�
's
,� . - `�
�
`�� =� �, '' ��. .n. ,-��a;
� � , �'«� � ��� * x � ,� . _
� � a -�. :
s � g
i
_ ,[�.< � `�' e�� mtr i��e--
� �� �d'�� � ���4, ��'�.
� � ����- �� ��� 2 i� �
�;� � � ��� '
� � � � t � s,t�,,��,� � - , .:�,.-
� � v
.
�+.
.,?4 �� . ��Y� yt� ��4 �: � . .a� � .s
4 ��.` * a ' �c� �_
�� ._. A �4 �� ,w�r�
..s'tl .��,�`. t �k�� , � f�d�s�,
s: '
. ` J
��: e 4�i •
IF-^� �!�"`� � i ,�'
�
���. .�, �,���
*��w,- $' .,� �`
� � � � � ���� - � �
� � ; � � � ��
� 8�����=4, ba��, 1� `:
<��� ������ ;��/ � �a
x ����� ����� � ,
� � � �, �. ' � '
� �
� � . .
_ _ � .�,, r.^°
� �� a ,� � .,�
� ,u ..�
. , � ,
� �
� ��." �°���� ��� � � �, '
�� � �� a�� �
�.w ' • �� �.
, ,-. ; �
n �r� � ��.
�^ ¢� >. �j s � i ,. .
4
�� �
��
.� ; �
. ,�*�—�r
,a•,� , � �'
�
� �
�� � f��� ��� �.. �� y o ,
��� �� ���, �•.Y
�- .�'� `"�� � ;'
��. ���'r � a' ;s� °rv' +�: �r
► ,��' � �.*3, �,� . . � : ' �.,.�.�
„� �_ �� � � ' �.,
r. �d,�, a� • '��e� ,�.� „ , �r =;� � '�� ���. :,R,�.
a �v ,, � a ^�` �„„,s
��'� °" "k �� '�� ."� �"� �� C g.9 s �::
"�p ♦ �^ a �.�'�g,� .,��F'.,. ��✓ ' ���g� �� .
�a.2. t `�.� �,. �..��''�y,, �` F�` u g .. ,,., { �J!"
b � 6� .�`i�r � � ,s
.� �, t . � ��� R 1��.. A� � .. � �.�.
k `'�+�� .; � �?.��� -f „�„,
�,�� �.��w.�` '� ��,��'r���� »�a . �
.. �, _ . .
����� �� 3� ;�W'- � �sA ..�
�. � ` �, r� � � �, �.
� �= f' .w� � �
> �
� M�� � �, � .�a
a .� � _ - v�. '� �"�_. � _. Y z, �a:'�.
,=t�
�
i�
l� � !
� ��
� ��.
� � �
�`>,
�� ,,
h
��
/ 1�y�[, �w g ..y,� �r►,�,sl ,��,y . �Y . w4 � ' M
j„`�� '�k ,�j� � !f �"�y`I. '� f" �7' � �` k .. y�.� ��e- � '�x' f�°� ,�g
� j' �� V -� 4' t� i .! �` ~��� Y` ����^��� +���s �4 � t � ��i �t � .e"'y i
�
, r e
,
��. � � � �i tl a,,� ` .+�. 1 F ��+� �� �-�M„ �
r4A?�y. ���e'������,� ..��jt�t.�a.�^ � �4`�:.. .c�',�,''t'"° �'`��d,�j � ��`...� q.• r��G* r�,� � '.it �/y{�' ��� 'j�'t�.1�'i.^; ��.i. ��,,.��t�#V. �i
*�.Y� �. �P'ir+.':'*a � � �� �� � T'4� N�� ����m 'f ��' � ���1 4.. � �$ 4 . .�y/���R
' �x :♦ � x����t ���" � .�p �a � � �`# v t j:�A •�` (; �..- 'p �/ . -� /,"
c. R * � G i� j*�^ d� $// 1 t � f°
t�'. � 4�� "T'�„�' �J,. r ��� '
(� � p� � ny� 1�" �` �!►y�, y�,+�ci �
,
. , '� .> �� �+ a"'"�A.. r . r < . 4•
� {`�'
±E .�r `°���*,* �d!`,�{ ����,. � "f,�� �"�.�_A '� 4'��,'�y� y��� J . + r�X.' "*.?� ��1� )/ ���r''�'��a g.
MMA�� � 6 Y f�a�° , 11� . �� j -S ! k,� � �
.
� �Jr {;" �'t6'�y,�w ��,p�y�Y � � ����1�" �!p'"+�� ��'�" ��,�A..a y.,�r��f
� �.y ��R �.R K�" >.� '+� C.'...�yl, r��,� d� ` ��' k �t�.�„+. ��.� �� �' ��: �:"'��'����'� ��'$�� ..'`��✓
� �-
., ' r
w � y1y � y .�'�. �,�� !"�, ri 4 • � ds+ r� �, te" r� � �
� � ��
�� (�.'��e- �t I?.'s y�i4�� *�ws�d � w �& �: �,� -�,�.! ''dt� � ��'•�,,., ' f # }���a � ^yY,.
� i��, .(' i +e��X� •'�.4s ��"�'„�, .�f # r�.+T`s"`' �; � ��s+ ��+� �^.j A i�� ���
,.
M �� � e i �, �� .? ��� � 1 � tr��'►'Tt.. ��t�",�� ,.� ` P
� n
a� ei4.'.�"`� .,dr '� �,�,�• �e# ��r� � ��'r• �t wy..rw *'.�..`I,�,: �F, ``�' �.r
�..� k .� x.��. 4 •�� #q' �ar ��M� �' ai� ��� p�`� .. .�� $�� �� d�`���.�`� ��
� � ,F � � . � �g �r � ��,
�,, Y: . w ���. �� �, � �� ,�c�,��
. `
.
, ,.
� ��,. �- � -� � ,�� �' ��, , , ;�t" °�.�+��} , `�a � � �,.s�;,'�
« - x
M •
. , »
.w....;��t .�. �° � � ,. � w�+ , , . . . � .+t" �� �'.�' t ,
,r�) py �. �
�* R�� Y s�+�!!�`,� ( �.t' `ro'lr� � + x , "�! `� '.:'e af�d"'������h' -T •.'� �ef'° ��°��
,�Y' i �k gy1� x �L.�tV-�y
�aM������ + �� i +r�Y � 6 « N �_�4�� * �� � ��a� � An �� � i/��� T'� �1'. '^ -�
. \ . • {
� �+``w"� "" " � �"'������ �}.`��' ��� �V `�'} �"��"'��q�f���+��� i`ag�'.e�.` �i � �•�"'
�, "� �
� ,
�' � ��+�;,r r> .�� 5��r � ., .� �Jy � ��:,-�� �`� ,� � y�
� �`,j,.`p'��• ...�;a "t y'tJ'� �'�, r "' ! ��` ��,� i�' .� ��.:� f��, .I.«�,y/��;, �.�j'..`�`r M �} y'�,�rr a'a� �� �.,�....
�4�' �, .��, ��� � �• s� x�' a� ��� ' r� `�/ �
- _
e�
. • . +�
�.�� �� Z k ��� . �f� ^� a �i � .� ; t+ ��f �'�9„ )e+Y ^ '
�..: �`` '#- �Y�� �f, y M M i � � '� 1/� � � 1'
� ,.�.a'��., � `�� � �. �,� *o- '��a�� ti ,s p l .J�r .�'�► • �/p'�,i '�„Q ^�. .�
,,
�,`�' `:� *���+r'��' �" �'`� � �,� �'��� °". � ' ''� ''° x" �'`� � ►�.,"p�;
y � r
�
,
a
��� ,""r.. �E.dr:r"a ..��r►, `"' �. ,� _,� �y s" -• ;�. ,�`_� ' �:r �;,��� '�1 f� "'`r�'`�j.`-� .• , y ,�:
}.' V`y. �.>. �f "�t`y`r' �+! ...,*� M,r �^y�a i .M..� .. . ��
�
< " �r
y Y �i � # ,. . � . �! � . S�� �. ' l i
, . Y �� '
` .
���� ��' � `�"�+'�� � � '����y J� � :�,� �•"� , ��' w�1!�u'�a�'•'�,,,�``.'"� ,ia, �Aj .
. �„
�r�r � j � rr � �r �� r `,� �'�� . '. . ��R y-r��y,. "�r� �'rN �°� ��
. �°
,. � y�
e �
, y�,. ; _ <T
. . � • - �. �
�,�' 1 ; : '�. +�� - ���-- '� ,f"��''� ` �' . � �`' ��r ��' .,r„_ r�:-.,
�
�,�), �"� ,�r�; ' f� t�t�'` � ft"A;�.,�:��� i �. �aC' w `,a!�` �" � � �j� r�"�t�'? ,r`�'�`�!'T7'
,.. ♦ "� .. '� - A K!r!� � , "�` .v� s�' y � ,5» �1�y4,r"�7
. � `� � _ ' +k 9 /����j, ''�, t '� �r ,�r,-
fw... � ,j�+�'.Y y,;�r�•`r'*.,�'"� '� t �<f ,�,l,` ti'"a ��.�;"� �� "d1 ,�`�'""�j.�%`�s�� �`,�� �,� �,�� �� '�• ..
♦ ����° t . t � .1f� � y�� �tvR + ' � -��� f��� r,d►��""��R.. /'�
�
� %" y
�, �. � �'1, 11. � .y � 9'°Y�.•�„ywtia� ' �.- . ,��a�. -
� ,�,y+,�-�`Iyy��„ ,c,��,�-�'���" �°,�~ ��'x."�+ �i !�';"'�� :�,�' _ '�`.�j���s��`�ti p ``��� ' �+. "'
�:� � •� . ��r •'{ ��5 � ''��«.' �~� A" \ ����,, p� ��f.����y''r� i1 '" ��A��.[/..*� trY�o � ��, �
a a���'.., �+��'i•�. '�d�� .�::� �r � s�a"�� �. '�*�. ►•"�& �,:,�2� �r,. � � '�f``,' ��.���'
�.�,�. ���� a' r��:g�?��l° 'M. �` .+ '"L. �"r. " "i�t.�t:s«c �'`.€"k�°".r �-�t r' �� ,t �� � •v.::'�C ��,:1�"'�'T
*�'�!' .� � . 'AI a J�,' � s�4.,��.^�r� � �� . � � �r� �eL � ���� ��`��l''"k ��;���, �.. .
„ .
'�`y�'�,�► � � �`'+F; �"�.� ? '' .'- .`�y�y � p�„ `�� ` `r` „� �'��`�.._ y� "' , �a`;,�.�° a ��� '' '�
`�. .� a�„ �.. .4 r �, y ♦`�1�� I c: �-P �„"y, `��„�,g'v, . �•.4.
.
. ,
� ,f„ � � � �,�� ."d�.� �, � ��. ,:,r�'� ��µ �„� �.�� �7„�ti y�����` `'�►.
� 4 � � q �y( �� r�,y+ � � ,�f q�„'" -�"w "i"� �4y� �/ ��L��ad. � j
.'� . 4 �' � :�;4 p ;�,�{ �`�;� ��. �•�
, ,
. .�� . ,_ . �
, � y.. '�t .
•* � � �y � i.L�s �'��„t't °' i`""r �•!" ��;���ay ' ��. .•)�� �i��.. :.s�`'It.������' �� �� �
�"� .� : '. `t,,, '� �
� �� * .� � �w � � Y'1 � �^'*rt `� y 3,,,, X�, a
��yr� ,� ,� � y, �'..+ '' � *��`� "�..� .,��! ,j;'� .c�' �,f ,• ,�� ��,,/ ��`�' ��— ,
y,ve .
- R . �j f
,. `��
P� k�� I .��; t-�6� � T >x�>er _ ..'� � 9 � + ) 5 `f`r J �/�.. .(
!�
� � � � � ����L ��'� k ��r'�'�i. ,�'.•� �� y �r ,� � �'
� � � �` = i Z,.�� �� r ' � �� ,�
, < � ,,4�
�,, �'.k��''�„•, t"�� :'r.* ' v' '� .�Y`a� .+�, � �. .. �, .��--.. j +r++'� � w� ..k �..
w �,�. 7 � ��.' ,�'' �' '�r��, �� �1 � �,�'� �''�`°�-i �'�, ",y",a �'�'.'�}.�,����",1��. i-' ��.U ���� �� �������
t ��i°aa„'t� �' �a�� * . � �-.,���'%�, ',1 �;+* ���'yc� :w�.�'�,i"�ry�S4! �''' �����`�'....;.�,f �" .�_ '"��i
_ A�
, . � �,�a �
;r a�';}�'�" '+��� ..: �� �� r9, w.��S� �',�j�', / � 4�i°p'# � �gk '�.;f „"'- +y,, �I�'".'�,.s° a� ,''j1 '�!�`+1r..
�. s
,
� aii��_ � `'� " �'� S � t�' ��.` � � �k .F�r.� . �,�'�, .14���`:. :,�u f�ll ..i'�`�ys 3"�'
t ,
g�"� v: . � , �
�' � ��,�.��itn���.'�� JiM1� � ��. �i.� �,�.Ni �?^+:-;i �r� ..az. ''�'�{'�� ��.� ��1* ` ,A� �"�*+'? "�+t�� Y; ��l���j
� � - • '►�� �°�. ,. .w. ° .� �,, ,(�,,r �r r
�'�!. �.i�w �'" � 4 �t.+� ') 7 a . � ' • r`.;�R � � � r.�r � ��/L a.a�!'� �� '�a k��'1 a1f��r�"q �x ���:t
,'"� � . .'�i;:+"' r � "" ��','„'� � ���',! �Y.`� k i��',f tic� �. �t�`' �*,�a:t r 4r,� �,'.,�LT� �a, 'N.�'�` }���..+�r'y`�.";;�4,�' '�:ty,�..a
y
t� ,
� ;'� `�i � "� �;;i�M�< � �',. '%!� '�r-� v� t�. �"►�� � . �'�� , r. ?r s` �` � ���`°
,� �'1�i `����.�► J ��'t`4�►�Y,'" . '� p�" 7! '�c' gF l'rt,�+�� i`�"^"` '�`7 �,�k,. �fy.?�" e ��
� ��1► �', �<
t.���wd4 lw'' . �»�` *� �,r � �•,,�� 4� �i�x �t� � M�� �� ..� °°{���}i1�' .` �^. �'r ���4�' �#.
e
M.' � . ,..�y,k :,e�� � �_ � {► J'!r`� �;,-�,�!'..�� N t,�..� � , •^�`�� ,R � � �,���*�j, �fi'k'1
,
r � . i
t`°�I' �r' ;s T �+ r� �,+� �.� `�, �' ��:� � � ,. .�r f � -1�
,
�t ) ��s Y�F'ts �.. �`�" 5� ` t+ . A� r a,r(.'_
. �
� ,�' , � t',> :�`�Y'��! ! ., `/` � `� � �c�1�^� �`� �:� :�� 4�, " �`
� ` � • "� � , GI`!'
; � �� .� •� � � � � � » �� �.
� , .. * �� �� '�'
r � .�
, T
�'-A� ��A T, �,'� �*�A' • � �. � "*'.� �%' � �.�t�c���.�. � +.. L`t��'t�, .,.� lA�"..���a��� aµ
'��, �. t��. �_ '"f} ,���� � �� �� °��a� y ,y, p,�"f� �, �� �
. . .
r . , p ,_�„
µ
�.���!�. �'���, ` \ �� �,��"�+0° ,.�y �`�''''"� �� � "1.� �' �.� a,a ��� _ � !�a., � �s` >
�' � y�� ��. .l�d °� �}�� .�4�rs1��:•� Nrl� ���'�� � y r r ar�: ��X`� 4"' ��� �" .�1. *
r �� �. }�,, � ����
� .
� y,
iek �4 c����!� e ' � � � �y'�;� ! �+g�, d � �, f �� ' �&%''�t�, ��, �' `.� „'�tak��.
,, .
* a
�.w ' ��' . j � < �*� F. 1�"M4 �*�7 � �� '
_
� u
'�'" t e i� .�'`
��""; 't ^'�,� s� -� � +�' �"� �'�
,_ ,
. r � "��,
� ,.=�,��.�,� a � ,� i� ,� '��� �'�. � r � � ,�� ,;���
.
.
.
4 #R � ,. 'w i�', yj� �' /��° .l y* j , ' +`.•, ��°'" '�i+ Vr2„� ��°��1"'�. '� ,
�� �
.,•
,F �' "�` ' ��
��°�bq�',_���°. s r�� '��� � t r � �ut�. `�.�, � l�j�f "��
� �.. r �# `,*'�F� �'8. _j • ��� �'i ,1 f f:��W A � .
� '�r � , ��. �� � �""�� � ` � � �, � �` y ��
�. . � w � «, .�t- � ��. �' $"'� ,�
� 'y(`�",�'� ',.J. ��y'.� ..�Yr a��M�* . � .�* f",�`�. . f .' p.�p Y� "'ygy;�.� !"., q'
� 3} �(��r�f�'
.�y1� � ,�. '�l'.� �4,_ � � y�`� �. =y� �{1 Yre.I t!�* *� �q' .
q�!.;'! � ■aL J T�� y [?� ♦ . � . .� �
� 1` 5� 4���`�`�, r �,�"y� �t. 4rs �;�♦�'�s„�� al�'"
r*�y� 'M � tr � �� a , y„�.:� �p�' �y%� �J � T1, .�•(�, . .. ! .
:«� �<� a!�"j;r c,., �; � �a�`,�ti ,� °���;w` t e .�;�,+��t"f� . '`�°� r ;, r �
h� <
, ���
��.r�`a '� �i.� � �y '.� �3�'�� �`�'��tr'�� � � ��` yv h` :�} ti � � � � . �
�.*,r:
� �. y�. � � � '� � � � Ti� �c ����
�r ,, � _a. ��
� ��� �� f,y����* ' ��,,�r,r� ��.�( ��� k9a� 4�. �- ���R _ , .. ,_�r.�
•
.�
,
'• . ° . 3' T ilw . t � v�-.,-,--a...—�.--,:.
�.�..
� ;
.
, r
4�� { � a� � �i ' ( c � . `.^ k .. __� ..
.
.. � al
� .�, �, f�' . s��.,;�
� %
1 '� � "t 't' w� '!'.h �� "'► *' ��{tr . 7 ..
� � �
. i ��.� t p . i^ .. . . . _
4 .,. 4r�-�`�` �A t � t
�t ` ��� � � � �� ,M. I��`>� � �__
� ,��t,��6 �"� ,� ,� 4�;�,
� , �
• � �� c'"'' � ' "' � `M�'` � r � x
,��.°M� . `, �> �c. s�; . � �, �,
�����.' . . .A> � 3� s - f * ``- . � 5��� _ `'. "
7ia . • . .,_ .
% �°^" P ''� -
� �w��€,� y,x� ^ . ,. ��� � ,_ 1 1 a��-` .
,� � � <` �� �: �` �
F �
�4 "�
_;
; ' � . � ' �� _ { 7'
a ,
'4' I .� �,;, � t : r.� � q . �'�' ,
F }
^ .. � . . � � t . .� t s P�P� ��4�
; � ?� #. }� � ��� ,� ��'
� � � �
� . `
;
>,
• � � . �
_ _ � , � � i�
,. ;
� ; � �
_ �., � � �.
€ � � �` ° � � �� �� �
�� � :� _
s �� � , ' ,�. '
� � , ¢� '�
_ ,, . ;
( , _ . ,� .
\, `.,y. � s , � � . �,��-
, : ,�
� ,
�,. a . � F�,< �,� � �' ��` � ��
:
,�, , � ss,. . ":'�'� ` ��` �`'�-=,� 'c, �'�
.� _
� � � �� �
� ��
.{ ������ � . . 9 �i''. _., . „ �TM•. � ����� ,4� �,^'�"'" -;,a8'�'-�q,;.�i �,,.?.��;;' �.
,
� .,.: �� • ': �„,. , ,"��..
t =z,t�.,s+a. , . ..
< . ' < '
. . .'R y f}, . `i i 'i" ,n � ` ,-,. y� '� '�` �
�
.
� � T � t
�.` �_ .. �.e..; A , � r� ' .ar
r
�`€� �_ � ; '�� „� ��,;� �
„ ,, �,. �� _ : '� _ m
s « .,. � � �� • '►
. �a � , � ,�. y. `�� ,�, ,�z .
.�- . „ ,.,
. , ,
� + �* � �� �w '�� � � ° =v �ay� ?� +�i,°�,,,� �`� � «'�'`
.
`�
,, , . _ ��
; i,
� i.1 . . '� �@�p ' � . � ��>dF �' .'� ,xxti':
.i`'' . �� ���i:�� ' 'a.�` +� ��!_ �h� _.. q' 1 ..�*, �i.�'��; "'"�e...�� ., ...'' ��� �t + ,��.' �.. 3k��� �.� 6'�s,..
�. , °k
i . . � _ .... +
., # `
�
. .<
r�: y � ... . . y_ �� a� �� � � ��,�,,:"%` �� , �ir;D , � c°�y �,# ` �:� .
.,
�
�. s, -� x � . r�' ' � � *�` . a- . _ �. �"� u =. t � *� � °tF
= a. �p�
..
\ `,
�J � f .p.. ���<�'�`�� �'+.f � , _.��e;.c�y ° �V.7� r�} °�.;� ��....s "�s.,.,��....��
�J J , d r>,.. s ' ` '
. �„
:� ,�,� +�,� .�. S ♦ � i � .�#+a�a ��� ' i' .- 1 Y �� �,����'" � ,kp ��- ��/�I`a. . < #� R �q
x
j. � .aa� �, - ..� �� �.�:. ' �,�i _ _ ..� },�,.�,t ,'. ,�1'b�.., +. � e'- .t e �+ � � ,p ..
t;�`. . ._ ' � � ! . .
Y
„�. .,. _ , .s � �,� '� . ys� . .
..jiM-�#�„j•. ��r i�t'#�t• ,y_��-.l�. °Pa . lf ��r"�. i: i`..y� �ai°'y. ���`2"��r,��"�' + �.,�4�� �`�_`� ` �.�^� i�.e
w ,� �c � '"`
... , �+r°�.,!' {`;..,,< r� "°±?-." «Rt f't;�'y�`V �° � � r.`` •,�,4�'3s'�^ ���� ' 4 a: r� �:, .
# - . . ° - ,, ,�•r, _ y` #� �+'b� '�'�` �.ty.. �r�„ .,.�.,,,� ,�, `�"
6�;""„� ' .. � �� �'
�`` r
. h . . � � a'.� ,� . 7 3 !R ,�} "'' .�� �r' P �
.e+",. ..- . - { _ �1y�'. , yj- '. " .
'w .s-� �.,� .....i€a. �L s . ,�Y. <�mryy �i�. -1�,� �ta a e�' \+#�t """� IM wR',�,.-wl i�� �' ��a��, .
.�`r�"' y��ry
'� .. i � 8a 4`$�+" ¢° +� , '� d a`� �.� y`.:.
z.. .E
r':?P#+�s� a ` , � . ,, i`i• . • � � � �` , "'y , � a ►� ,�.*
.. � . � � ��?k .. �T .# . '� � tt -�
. -� , .. �_a �y�:s.
...
.1,,��„ •, �.. ,.r ., - . � . �... ,y r� `..h ir ,�.� ,. _ .A.g � � �i�. '`s i�e-^'
,ay.,;a„w : _ t� �, gk . ..�.. ,,;r► ,�!' - y� x'�ay'�y �:,.:�,� '3�. ....
__ . �. , � �
.�� �, . .. �, ... er1 -�.n+�` � .-�: �� r�e � ��.- .l�e,�� c.�, t�v.T '`-eA...y� . »« >
_ ,� � y� *�. � .� . ,..
.
�; _ "++. ; �,�. ,� . ,.• . �► s i .� ,r;.�,�� ° �r� r �6,��."!
,y ^*
i Y R,
#� �+�` '_�,�*\..�F��''��.:. ..�« -...,w�-'„. � � -;.�f �`�� �� � ,1 `'� ""'%t1 � a��# a".`"�'�[,�t,��� v�'►ln,*.�`e ±�.�.
�� y
,
. ,xi� i�h a� '- "*-'�+ ,� _ g � � s�o �».z �.r'•',��� �^ �,f«:. `4-� ! 'y,'f� �,,,�,<° �.°�_a,F,..�. . r �,Y��� ���.
. ,�.., „ .< ��lk��� �� .... . � *�r °� ~��c�'r..� ��".'1�`��,{F� • .. +.y�+�;�,' p t�"'r . �f is �s. ,., - �, f�,� '� °�� ���� ._�_� �
_ . .. . . . ...-�'d'
,�.�,• -�'�'•°^.t� ...'+�a � ..s �• _�y` ,��.�.•��� _-. ,.. '� � `�' . a��t. ,. � �� T{,� "�,- � �,..$ `�� .
.Y�"`"„y+.eA�y _."a�':*w/ :- ..' ... s t'+. ���A ,��'t°"a • ' �.f�v�i g y y ' "'`• ,.�,� �� ,� _ �" �r ya,�'g��" _'�. � ?sr�-'*.,.�
_ I( ,.,.
�,. ��.. . ,�.. . . , ..� ...� � � M. �fiR R T��'�" i ..Y �� � �
.,,� s-. �• ra .r._ wiY�, fl.l '� f- - - � ti � 4 �M �i ° "'�j'Y
�°w..v - • ,y� t � ' �1 � +e' s ' ..�'t i1� �< ` � �.r.v.M� �•• .y�' - � �A+1�. ,i �'1M�'�..y iJ-'
.
¢ �'`p � ..... , x '�. W+�� '� � },�Fe l b eT� ..:��,Y - ` E �„�*p '�i .
e
. ��
` t �
�
�t���'" ., , „� ` _y � `�..�
°:.d+' �-a�iS �..�,'�. y . ,,_ �.+tc. - Ty# s�Fr,P"' a '� ,�''s`*r #h., ';°°' , '��$ a �� •:�_ .,. H
�!b� '�. �.. ' ,.+��p1� �c. !, '�t+. �,J{,� {,p� s�!'d' .. �. {� j�p '°'.'� ^iw w'Ar.,a 'R" . A�f� .�•'_.� y� � �Y�
^ � a.�v r,� ¢.�� �9�s� ��' "` �'� `"' ' �r f b=�'��"S5'�;�°,S`T� �� g� �� ^� F ''°�e�.E'�.'��%��r 'i �j� �.s.._.
t ./'t.! �"w� +�
� � '. r � � ' �.:
. '` �i _ � � �F
,. � $t.�y...�« �Q�: ' � ��...d Y4 ; . f�t,` Y. •yl�+ .�s.e� Ye� ?��'?t � ,.. �` s�t.y 1+�1F ./� �.� « *�, }�';� �� � v° '�g!'� bl► ..r
fe . .».,• :.. �y
♦ar" ,,y_i'a. -. �:�. .. . . �aG , .,.. �� . ^a ��a�t 1�� p� i �.F�"L °�'r"`a.- -� �.w. `�t�n�,.
..
w . . .i .. o x t ., „ , _�\ . �.. . �y . . .
�f��.�� n
�
�y ,� ��� � , ° - �.,.
°�++'``••y� , <�pr . ��� ± •. +.� � ►r� !' � '"i / ` ��''* .,�.��� ;J "; «f����; s"'��fi�� ���� s �F> � �t*a� ° e
r
: �
v
- .� 't�"_ ` � ..,,
� �`�
� � 4�
. ,'
"*►..� -�' .,�v��$��.s�e► `1�f �. �� 1� �� i�, aC ���o l�� $ �a ,K` •i�y�'.v�� �� ` '`.«:+
��°.��.,�.��;J^ -�; �j�- � ,�<,� �� �` �,7 R'��"�'°:,� �7'�� s. � ��„'�,�f'� - �, -u. i..+i'�."!�,°� � � y°,�y�.
>
fi:t .�„1+^. .' : '"- t. _r. ^s . i e`a�a..*�„„ � �: .;.. 1:'+"�r.�c""-,�!� ..et `�..ae a a.� �_ �•s;�..
a
,�y � a
�r-. � )++.s�ld,� . ,.°" �e^�ii� X�� s, a4+;,� �r.l�r��^�' '",�� , , �-,.� ,t ,�g��,,.,y;'.��y`..K"��.,�_�r ,. a �+�'�,� - � d � ,.+. � , ., °
�'h *� H
a } .
Y � ��",�f ` , �_�4 ���,, � � ..t' � #s' 'T' r" °� '^ ��.' ,� � '�` .�A�" "K = .'t .. �."���a�r��
. -
�
,�r�a. ,�lb �. ' �„ �„ �,,._ ,,,,, r '.�%� � ,� f.`<. �i.��" _ "tr`� �e � 3. : ..,,, � ,Y�'$+1 �i a� �.�
*ti �� ' � �_ �,� �, �,,"'•> � .r "w,ea.,s.sa �#�� , t :.�t .�y, .� �,���
�� , > ,,�I+�� �*-� . � j� s�.:s� r, .. .* i` ��� `�,�iea� ..s_ '"'� ��� ,
�i ... . �C �„ ° ��w� � ' . .. , ,*�ir� ,� , ' � ' �t� �w�� t ��w"�a�� '.��'!+.`� �t`-'.��� +°`� ' ' �`v`".�'a..t, c�
��, .
_ ,'t a. ` a
� # �i4� � * � � .,.- . . � .. �,� '��;, � e,�
• � 3.. , . `� .. * � .:
'g ; : . i� � � `+�
.,�{�� ;;y.,�# . �+;�.. �'r�e � � .�l�'r�"t1'' �� ��� ��,��#'�' ��_ �'6 '�t���� ��.� '��'�'r�G,t��+.:'� �'' rtr� SS,+�•..� .� ���'��. � ��>
� „ a. � � , �� . � �„ .w",. �t �" �R �Y'/ at� `°� �`Q,�, ' a r��,p � ' ��a�' �: �" ���4�
" ° �ir "� �'s
b } 7 . � y��
�� � � �{��
� .. j y
.h i � � , � �. I `- ' �}4
r An y i
� t a #` 99 � I t R � f f �E ; � t;+� a�� 8 �Y
� �. .�� ,� �i ;��' '3 '� t�.g� � a � o�/.♦ �r�' �`� ��t � � . 4�`�°'�+e�,_�� . . �, �
.
a�j j . �
• • �k
�' ! 'ti.:�
� • ' L *'
.� � ` .. � '�T'�y, � 1�� . Q ..}�i . Y
�
..... � .. �� �. '4�...�.� `�"° .�4.J- �.� �g � . �1'��.
p� « � � ~ i
c:
?;ffiv # �`���� � �a�lr.. �c�. � s;1 yr` ei("_+'_, * ` }P ....1.,`.y°�( �; ::'++a� a.� ►��� P�� i„e, r v ���� � `,*,„FS,� . ,y�•', -Y �3 �
' �. � p �:.: 'a � .
5
. - �-�. ��' �.r, ,�.H�y�i '�.r� ,� .^r" � .� 's"'�.. -. ,.� �"�`,< �� �°` � „,s zk+..,�ac�
n
� �,� `
.
� � �p' ��
, '.: y�..„�
,.�. _ a�t_ � 3 i , ! - i.- 1 � f �-°� � �'�.°'4
. �r' *. �.R,.".,, . �� �� � 4 J�..,�1� �� �T,1R,}..� if�� � ,tit� ��t�����°�iv� �-a. ��� � �� ¢:�,�� �K
t ,`
. T �
� . 4"�: �. � �
w�j...� i�."�, ���� i�� .�� ��.t�;�`_-''.t1�9- '- � �.(r e ��p � �6,� !! ��AM_ ��t40. � .,,,��;°se�tMb!��`"��w'k
rj��� -. . .�' ' ���� . , °� ° t�•^��--t9�...` .{' � -,� � 1� •�f,•,,iY. .,s,. _°�' � �:it�- ,��,k'��� ' i'+..
'
� '
, .
,/ : t �y, y,,
��wl' .�.'�� , ,�„ ,�� !� � %, � =r, e�'� y �r., ��� ,� �,. �. � �°��
'.'-a .a.`T; ��y/ f ,. .,. ,s.a . ..�/ �E1. 4 �,� 1�+h" 3a� iM? r '� _ �`," .,'T� �`� #�,,,y,
, � ,
, ��+� � ,S ���3� � „�i*s` ��� � , � i . `�� ;���� .��� ; � .� �s �:��q�',��' �a..` ti•y,��° �'� i.+�
, ,
,,. ,
,�'���V, � , � ,�r ' ��.,a �i _ ,��� »t� �' �.r. i\ ...- �` .f. �#. -` -��' '�. �"i"� � -`�'
� �
. ,
`�`r •° � .A. R �� �...�� .� � ti y�1"� `1...` .
�.�,i�ii,,�,�.-�"��p►sr�er`� -� �� � 1 j � �j✓� ��+� �����.� ��.�.� ���+����'?��l� ��p �,�&���`����'^!� 2��V',,,.yt, .� �J ��# �6.
� , .
* . _ � � ',. �
a
�'�+" .,,�,_� ��, -, i t;� :
� s�
, � , . .fi►.�, t � ,, ,.r _. �.. "�► ` �> ,,,Y �'�„� �� .., �
��. i a ,�l
� �a .� ��
..
� a � .�_: , ,�rf � rrr, °F. x� .���tsY. � �'� � g (�-�''_ ��t` �r• �*�"±����,�°"��� . :���`" ���, �+,�
�
�' �E � �'�i. �°Y"``�.+...�v���il'.::'y�.5rr'+a�, f� �'.i� /��.r-,� 11 �Y,�- �°iw�►\ii�,.[j:� • "`r� .'�'a i�. *"�` ,i`t�` �: {w"•, °�°.,:� ' i�'��`„'+�`*'�
'y • �
,w��..F�,". .`L"�� ,y`}.,, _� ..:;'°�.- -'...;_��wt?t�"-� s.. :�� .p �i: � "I�� :�!¢ 1�,.. .�- :..s.�.>... � '. -H T�t Ye:� . - '..," a�' �.''el��'.
_ .31 ��d i�a "Sa.s...,,.� �..
�
���€ :
�.��"�.'�°,�
.��+ .�'a�'+�,�,'
� ��LL`
se
� � �
0
�
�� 1
� .' �
� �. �
: � y:
\ 1
� '
�:
t
4
6
a �
� , _
. ,�+r � �
't .. �. � „ ,
�
. � :g � ♦ ~ � �-�- .
. t�1 �.. r� L_
� p #
�� � � _ , ., �
� s .
, , ; ,�
�
�, ..g _ .. °�� .�, ��,'' ��,
, .
.
.
� 4' '�"" � �� `� -�°�� , � � �� ��� �� � �
� ,
� � �,� $ "�
� � � ' � �_�� ` �'� �. � � � �
� � �
�, ^" r�+" 7'F�." § _• `' £ _ �"
. � � � �� �
� � �>; ,� ,. �, ,�
. A. ` � �
� � � .�,� . � <
� �„ � � �
�� �, � �. �'. 'a�` . ,� # �n �� �� � ���
' '' ' ' w,r'. ,
�� ;� � #, , � � � � �r `,,� �., .- .,, �
,
� .,
� `� �
� �_.�.a--:
, " '.�,� � '�� ,,�. ��`'�r ` � �z.
�-a� � __ � - � ,���,�, .� ���¢,�_�, i�, ��,��,� `� � � - �,�,
- .
�� ` .,,� �- °.�� �r�,. < "�
� ;�� .� � �� _� �
, . ^ ,�
_.
� °� �` ��� � � � � � • ,�
`_ ; ' ��' ��� �� � . � � � � ,r..�° -
: , , -,��a• , ,,r,,�� + m � �
� , ,�y ..� 1 � � �'
�� � � � � �� � � �� �
� ���� � �,��_�:� � � �� �, -, �,�. ��,
� � � � � �, ' ,� p. � �� �` ��` $
� � � � �/�': j�� � �'�� �. � ���,�, �
� , � � (�h '`� � ..: � �
� ¢ �, {
� � ��� � � t � :�� �
� � ``�;��,..�� 1 +2��' � " 1
� � �"e � � �
� } , '� � �
..
z � , ��,� � � .���
� ;, �..,�s :. . . .c=� :, wa �. x�.,w- .. ,� �'..� t k� 4 � F :�'
. _ . � �° p Q a� .
. �
_�. .�.-._,.«+.,:�.----....._ _�,� ,�t, . � . -t .
� .>.� • �IRi'"`� , '� < ;� �p ���� f�
. _�t , ,
� � . .�� . �^'' .. ' r,.� � _��
� � : . ,��.�1 �`�� ' " �� �� ��. z `�
�"`�� �` ... . ���'� 3 . � �. '�
` �`s`-.w '�* �' l9, f� `.n�e. : � f��`� �� ���a
� ° �_` .`� �� V"e� � >�.s. '� ���(.� � � �
�. .� - �}-� : ;.; �i k �p ,ro� a �` .
.
r
` �Y
.. �,�,_,ry, •� � - ..' � ��' 9� �
.. -
a . � a.
.'
. c : t � . � �;+ t �.�; �� ", E� �-�.
.. � ° p; .. � _ �.
... �. .., . .r*° . , � ,
:,. �-. �� _. . �f �'..''E�<` x�y°" . .'.�b : �. . ..
$a`:
`. � _ �2 �TS_s �„ .P.. � .� .� a,y°! . 4_ •� '�. X w
r . 'S'...' ,it. � a��J� -_ ' . � s .
. _ . -s . "��''' � �� p .....-r ��-°
_.. -
. ` � , . � � r t x
°� v..
. ; .� � ��� ��
` � � �� �Yev +� +��Za��ry �`�eqr�i. �d.
. � y {
. . �
e � �
,<� .. , � y _ ��� � � ' . �. . .
`-" y.s '�` a-y`�"`'"4'a',A��.cT �f "''S'°�4"�7'!' ",.}e� x, y ,�,1."' z:
�. t
: t +
��'� -� � �` — � �
_ .�E. r .� � -�
_ � �`�''���'� ��
�.. ,�� sc �-,� ,�� :�, ,� =`�
, �,r :
_ � _ .
� y- �``'�`�'`��as -�,�y -�.,,�►�►"�� �°�,,,t�` � .
�
x��. .. ���' ; >°-�°��-�,,� • � ; .
: � ti � .�s� � �s s
�..� _, . _ � . F ,
,�
� w a �• < � ,-�':���� �w z:' :�� .�
_
� r
r ' 'i�`�.+ � •"?� -° : �,�
�. 4 . ���
�._ �.: r ; � �"� '' �.*� '��� * � ' �
�
., � �. �+s .
�
_ �.. ��^`r. „� �.°,:
�� r�
. � � � � � ��
,.,., ,�
.. .
° �� ,,,,,� ��,� -•., �., . � ,� -.""" �'�",�T
�
� , � ;�-.
:
, � - _ . ,
_� s . �'�{,a` .. ,Y� � � �. *je . �,,, z ° i
<
. ,,�� .
w. � � �.
�,w,...,:�./� t'� . , a
, � � e�
� � �..., 4�`'�,a�'f� >� ��':�.>���. �"�"+a,�.,"�- �"� °� =;�s� '�::�`�
.
��Y .: � �r^ �F,�`,�,_t�y� jr�, � .�� a- »xq� : "`*n
�r '=�;.� ' p��� sg�c r�. �f��"`� j�`�` .a�;� "� rt r� a�� � ,�:i.
, e'F�� ��� ^� »
, .
�. '� * ,t��X�`t�py:�� �4* � �. �� �� � y � . r�' m� �4
9k� .�:7>. �' �^' � � �� r � "� ,�'w�rt��,► ° ,�
�
",�u Y .f "t� ' i �f#,+��.,#`-t` ? � �� r.�� �,� ��� ti�"��,,;; '�
_ �It ���,��Ft .*¢r°����.�� '�T . �� '� .'° s Ms.p�1, '�'�'w >k � • � ^��
.+� �;. «:: `. ;• ��'` i� s"t,� ".r.}'�':� .•�,,, , �r -w' ' r�'",��. $ "�,��. <!�� �.
>� p a." �,Y ,� r. � ` � � ,w�• �� � «� "�-
< '�
- � :
�«.'�' z � � � :#r�`a�: .� ��!�„�j�'^ � ��a,.-� � :g �,�� � �"+`..:.3 � �.. �� �. . �_
«
.
. �
_» a ` t " ' ' .�,�^� �t '
.
.. .,, �'',;,. ... ..
s��,
. . : .,� �. rre s . • r
_.__. , _ .._._ .. . �. . L�o.��.. �, . '��+�.�.. �J"� , m