Loading...
TR-2013-17b OFFICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE • CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 C U P E RT 1 N t� (408) 777-3308• FAX (408)777-3333•planning�a�cuqertino.orq May 2, 2013 joel Smith Valley Crest Tree Service 530 Aldo Avenue Santa Clara, CA 95054 SUBJECT: RETROACTIVE TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2013-17 This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on May 2, 2013, approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of a felled Eucalyptus tree at an apartment complex (The Verandas at Cupertino), located at 20200 Lucille Avenue. The application is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROTECT This approval is based on the arborist report prepared by Joel Smith (WE-8889A), dated April 15, 2013, consisting of 1 page, and a tree removal and replacement site plan, except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The applicant is required to plant two (2) 24-inch box Red Oak and Southern Magnolia replacement trees in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance and approved tree replacement plan. Modifications to the tree species and location may be made to the approved replacement plan pending staff approval. The replacement trees shall be planted within 30 days of the effective approval date of this tree removal permit. 3. NOTICE OF FEES,DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The Conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby further notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exactions, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section 14.18.120 of the Protected Trees Ordinance. Sincerely, r George Schroeder Assistant Planner (408) 777-7601 georges@cupertino.org Enclosure: Tree removal and replacement Site Plan CC:Andrew Morris,Demmon Partners,702 Marshall St.#306,Redwood City,CA 94063 825 Mabury Road San Jose,CA 95133 Tel: 408.453.5904 Far:408.437.1817 Val IeyCrest www.valleycrest.com Tree Care Services April 15, 2013 City of Cupertino Regarding 20200 Lucille Ave—Tree Removal Justification 5tatement The Silver pollar Eucalyptus, Eucalyptus polyantherr�os, fell over due to insufficient root strength for the weather conditions. The tree completely uprooted and fell into the street. The tree was removed on an emergency basis to clear the road. If you have any questions please give me a call at (408) 833-5749 or email me at j asmith@valleycrest.com Sincerely, Joel A. Smith I.S.A. Certified Arborist WE-8889A Certified Tree Risk Assessor CTRA-1194 Qualified Applicator License 127599 fi:� " _ .�:°� '%���c13/'� 5��-i� 6, � . .;..:: ... "'--._ i "'r-- �JC� � �� I � ��ie C e���z� �� AT CUPERTINO �� �- ^ �� > T-- r-- -- � � T I I I � � � �� I �� � � i i k � � 1 I1 I i i I � I , t d,�i ,�4�s`,',�,'.'7. I ! � '�: � � t � v���� , �,.' ' ��� f'� . #Se�av;4. ,p +�`� � � . . . �... � ,.o- �.�^, ` 66 68 70 72 � �<�f�' 65 67 69 71 �aundry �'�"��� °�;��� � - 1 14 - �� ��' *������; 76 �$ — 112 , �� 113 ��� 75 77 ___ �___ 111 _ � s� �� � $0 -` ^_ 110 116 74 79 - --- 109 115 _ 73 118 � 64 62 60 58 - �--- �08 1 17 ," 63 61 59 57 -- — 106 120 �t��� �� � 88 86 84 82 119 � �� � 87 85 83 $1 105 t _�. 5 6 �-�----�z_J(��� _-_ . 55 U� l 54 �?� � '� �� � b , l r yT�y' T ia ���1✓ ` - — -- c 53 ' Leasing ^_ _ , — . ; ; C)ffice ` i � +�� 52 __, � '� S 1 � � � -� 90 92 94 96 �'' � �� �-���� � '��� ----___ ..�= 50 89 91 93 95 � `�''�� � t--- �'� �; c Pool '"` � 49 � 48 � 98 00 02 0 �" M �� ��`����� 47 � � �g 97 99 O 1 103 � � � �� . . -- �_.�, . � __� 46 ����: 17 -- 2 - -- - 45 �.,,, 20 1 19 --._ -�.� 16 -- 2 2 - - - - �5 4 _. 21 � � 14 3 _ 38 40 42 44 6 -:-�- --- 4 13 5 __ 37 39 41 43 23 �� _ �� $ _.,��'� ___ _____ 26 __ __ 25 � 1 i;, .� --- 28 - 9 � � 36 34 32 30 �� 27 _ ,._---'' a __ 35 33 31 29 ,�- -___ _ _ __ _ _- �� - .�,� � ' Vilia de Anzo _ � a�� ,�' ��,�,� r_ __ .� \� _ - -_._ -- .- - �-.,, �" y, �-.,r 'T - � �� — 41��-�. � � � �y.S�. �i ��� "1 . � � ;ILI�1 ��. �,��f� w y..� :�'4: 7.,�.� s�7S•'� ayN ��w � �`i` � ___ , _ _ _- - - � 20200 Lucille Avenue � Cupertino, California 95014 phone 408.257.9941 � fax 408.257.4558 �-- � �,� www.Verandas-Apts.c�'��VAL �� '���� �-� � . _ . -� � � 1 �' �:�:�, .. :� :�4 ,s ,�: � � _ �.�g, ..�. �_ . /3.. .. ..._._u�_. S�gn�#�ar� ----- �w.�.,.v ._���._._..... ..... . ... k,:��......... i+:'�.e i..`�i:� -�� ��, 1�� 1�.��� 2�1"� � x �Tlze � � . �� �� e����� �� AT CUPERTINO } A� .,��..,a..����.x.,.�._ �—<'�i'� ^� ��� . ,�„ � n�� �. I ° ;� y � 1 � �� 'p��.�,,,r�' �N'�y�}., �'�`tl���.'�"``��` ..d W.'�:. �m_�' � ';J k � ,�, Yr' ' / }.' .. � '�>i.��"�,1.4^*"��t. �r� k�$�i�k.�s»�*�*r h°���. �s� s+C�*r, �,�i��� — � . �4 s . 1 4 ��'.%�'H 2.r 41'�'��'� t aY,��,d���.'- , �� � � � � �� � ��t� *� 66 68 70 72 �_ {� � ` ,,,�� �� �:� � x � �� �� �u..<: 65 67 69 71 �;3undry � � � a'°b � "�� � �; 78 __ __ 112 � 1 14 ���'�-�" �����¢�.' 76 -� ___ � >_ � � ; �� .�� 75 77 -___ ___ 1 11 1 13 ��'r� ���fi�'� � � - �,�«h-� k F ��i ___. .�.. "4' �.Y�' "t� ? pr. 80 __ _ 1 10 1 16 ,.��$x ���� � 74 __ _ _ 1 1 S ---- � ���� �� ��. 79 -- -- 1�9 � ��' �`{h� :t�: �� 118 64 62 60 58 -- --- 108 117 `' "=` ` 63 61 59 57 __ ___ --- -� 120 88 86 84 82 106 119 .�� 87 85 83 81 105 — w�, 56 .�� .. �,� _, :.._ -- 55 ; ,,-__ �1--- )H� 1 , I � � I � 54 -`��� �-'��� �c_,�"� � ,--_. n 53 Leas�ng — � :�� 52 (�ffice ' rv � S 1 ,, D 90 92 94 96 � __ � ' .;.�,�� � I ���� 50 89 91 93 95 "�.,,.: �, ��,�� � � 49 Pool �°� � � .�;. ° 48 �°, 98 00 02 0 ;: �::-r�..� ..: _ . �.> t �. �#n.z.. : 4� �>,. . . . ���� 18 97 99 O1 103 .. �� , _ 46 � 17 2 �. ��, �`; 45 ���°� 20 ---- �6 � -- 19 - �5 4 22 ____ 3 — _ ---- . ' 38 40 42 44 2� ___ __._ 14 . 4 13 5 37 39 41 43 -- 23 12 . �_ _ __ 26 >> 8 i 25 � � ,. ���., -- _ 9 ,,. r. ---� � � � 28 �--- — ..-- --�� 36 34 32 30 ��� 2 7 __---''���� � _ 35 33 31 29 _ __. ` - _ _.._— , �� __ , _ , , — �� Villa de AnzQ —� a( �, " � ,�,� 0 ________.. .Y _ . � . .— — �3� J _ . / <--y�-. �,-� ���� � ;� � � k� � � � � `, � �-�_ : > �,�.� ��.,,� ��,���. . J 20200 Lucille Avenue � Cupertino, California 95014 phone 408.257.9941 ( fax 408.257.4558 www.Verandas-Apts.c�,����f�� �,.����� 7 ��.� ���x ., . N. . --��. � g.a � ':,''1' .�� nn ����r� � iC��� �U /"lal v�� ��� � .. r ._ .. �� , _ �� � , _ .. � ,> �. . ,R•jR•�, � a^• '3- ':� ,. .�' v ,r�s' � ` t� •t'« ; _ 1 •r. *, j�', ,�.,. a �:, •t..� . .. �� � �' Y tj x j�,•..� •#4�4 .'�, ���, �� '<t�r i � ��, '' � . .� �4 #� •,.�. �ti i. . �, `. ` �' ';��+�� � . ' � '� r r' i ``'31�' �': � v �����y '� r , � ;�*. , . ., r, '� `y ,. ."A 'i �a� 4�♦, l+ �• �' ;�,. t ` �� i� M� ,��1 � ` . � .� ,, . .'�` . !. t. %.�� 1.. � � • Mf��,�a .1 1 �y� � r ..�� �4! � �� ("7 . ' �}'�� .a •�. � T"�.�#' ��4! �y,. r . _ .r-� •y f� •* �* � Y� '� '�� � ��4 � � .a` � •s' `►"°4�� ''' i )•" "��� '�' t • ''•. • f` . �. . < < . . , + r` 't , � �• /`�.�� „E � �» ��4 `�, ` � .'�� �, ' w.i,., .�_ .* . . rY � . " ' . , � ' � ` -''tt � '. �.� , . , i1t r . .� _ _ '� r � 1•a i . - � . . .a' 4 �y •k -� ! ��y,,.�� V ..`� s ' ..:.M��' , :.y"�A-" �- ���;�. � +��,���`<�+�"'.�I 1�� ������:'� � � � -r� .��� R; �,;- _ ''��'- �� 1C:°i•'�' �' -i 1 �` :�` , , . �''�� 1 � . ' �' 'a r r ;, tM_�. t!y?�w,R}i. ; • �.�. ' ,, • ;t � t� : .. � •�Ii� � ,� : •��� �� #. '�!,_ •�' 4�� 1 �;� t � }�a`. Y `�, '.��, i �. ` � i . -� � � i� . ... . '"fi-' � � F ' r: '. . t__� ;:. •� " .a- r ,� �;s •. k1' � , a Ys� ��( e i� , . . .. / t ' �'.' . � � . ` � • ' ,�,� . ' , s t - ; P�.,,# �, t` ''t� a E r ,t '��r_� � � � , ��-' : '�s i ��r.°''���A � � � �-� . � • a ; . ,. � _ . �♦ ' t � . '° "" w..��.. �i , . r� t ^... ` ,..,k�- .�''. .�,}� .• �"\• �'�r�''-' 1 � � T' � ! �' ����� • i���"� � .. ��" � ! _ ...�� I �iz� ` ... ..`: �� 'S' �`. . � . . _ ` � • . . . .� . , • ` � � . "�.7� � �'�� y� �•�.� t¢ �. . ., . � x . .. . .,.r � � , - .,. - , -a , r r . . . �� ., ,� �zk .; � �� ,;��' ,� � � . . ... ... , . ..� . , . .� .,� ��., � , � . e .� w . w , � -�.,�• = ` y�� '� K 1 �. �. F- ... ' } c �'1t� , � '�' ` � y. 'k . '��i1� � . -P. ''£ .. '� � �. � �_ ��� . � t ti . . -... •����-�`-� ,�" `" �'1 :e%�` •� � � , " « ��`' . . + , � '•'!� ' �' ye*� : �a� � _ . r - : � + . b - � ' 1 R � ,r >.: �Y cS .f _ � . , t. },� ! M,: . ..� �: .�;:� . �-.. . "` a:\. � -�"� "� -. . -^��` �. .. �, . . -`#", � .. ` 's k ft'�".'+'� ��*� �. � , ! . .... . � ,.s . 3 `.-` Y _,.�,.z . �r� , . �' ��,. . �;.:,. :r'-' :.„_ Y•,•�-.. ..,, . . �... _- r . � _ ,_� . .�.. a � : . - . , y <. y�.:`-� �,■' A_`-.. ��..�..F�, � . . 7,� � � :�, ' . _ , , . -. A k �� .'_. ,, r..:�. , 4 ` . .y r s ,_ ..� 1 y„ . t `-F ,. i i: . _ ..�• . . � �k..,� Y' .. 5!` t % _�■I -....i . y .. , j `i, . ,. ♦. ' .�.t 'i. `� � �� ���� \ :f ,p ... . � y�� ��. t} ` �. . . s.F ��,,�,�}� .d ... .. .. .� , I I , �� YL ` �Q-� €�' 9 � ' � _.......__. .. � �+'�� �k � + _ � ,r y , .. . . -y.,�.. .,... __. _ .f � . �yj� � � '+.t . •" -�..�,, .xL ' ,�.+..�b 7'� s ..... �S �,� .., � .a� . � , , ,� . ��. r. � ' '� �I L I V�: ���V �� t '.' � ../".'"""�. .�'_` �: Y' . " .f.'.�4'uw. ��....^+.`5,.+►yir RV�q'� . �. �� � �� .a w!I' .. I�I�l��.. �tiI f . ;.� . - . �.,.. ,.. �r..7fi, tT.', ,.',�' ,�,-.. -'4 . � +.. . „ �:. . -.,� .�:..� _/. + _f . . - `.� . � ,'�`'� I�M� . , . . , - �#� - .� . - - , ; �� � � _ .. ; . : ;- - . ,«�. : ;�.�. . � . ,:. �. .,�_ � _ � a ��--. �- :.� �w ,��'� , � � . , , , ��� �- y. �,. _ _ _ ��`,�......4 , � . / � . .�� � 3 '. � �, ,;: �. 4'' " '� ��,, I��� ��^� ��n: _... , � ' r . ` � � _• < ,.. �� �: , . .. , :. . .. .,�....rX �,: �.�r. .� _.!�'$�'�,��''''+_�:.�s�'f f�:+ '...^ w+`�..� - ./� ' �3 . ..,�, ;�, ,�.•�� �i._.;: �� ,.f�t - �, ...,„ i ... .. :. . . . - • y �� i�, _ • .. 4...�.' j� ;..'.� "�7F,w ,._ .,..p�� +� s::�,_ t:m. 4'��. g-. .., . � . ' -_���. ".�.e',. ..�':,�` ¢ � ��`. ���k , ::. ' '.f� ,. � �� �� fi .a�- ,�� {�a � �., i � k,. .1 - r , � , - r_ ,..•, .. - . . �;- ., ��.. ;''�.t > , . . .3 AM� � ��, � _.� ��#-. ,, i � ,`�. - .�.,�,.� ,. �_- , � . �o �,� �'`"' ��9 ..rt _ � ,;:� �e _ _._. ._ . . ,__ . , . m n- '�'-. :: < � ..{�.� :���:: y _..::�se,- a�` �c. �'' ti t�� «.. �� . . , . � ' .. + , � '. - ' , ''/"'"�'`�It u' . ` - .� - _, . .�.� y�: - ..: � . � �-- � ,.F� � -� = '=- - �� - ; _ „ �,.�,r..��,_z,,, a ., ��:�.: - .- .. .y. . , d. _ . :r , �'�. _ t . � . : a . ,� .� � .. „ _ �--_• .+� �,*� #.� � ..�.. _ �� .a�e:, r,+".� .. '� ,. . � ' i �.p-�'"` _. `,t' - �x;:. �` r� a� , s� � � ���i' '�`sE.. s�.. r -:.,.,±"' . -=`- ���' -� - 't- - _ -'`F !�� �^'°-_-.�� .. -. - - . . _ _ 7 "`�'=--- . : , . . . - ., • � < ° _ _ .....� -.�.-- '-- -+F�-�. . �..� - _... '�.- �" i-..�"� ' �� > � ;. ' ,r�° �!F`- .� ...�r �- � . � � ` . LL a n- .y - , . _. , , - - -� � � f.: � � v°- n_ �. . ��;,. =� .,6.� . � �� r . ` . � . a: . � � , '�: : , _ ' �— „�. : , �,a� _ ��;-�" �_,..� _ .. � ,:- ,� , 3 �.. „� _�7, , �. �. �� �' ��. � _� �.t� �k.i ���� , ` � r , � . , ti . � � , ,: ��r v a ,� � » {• ,w _�'.`+`«. ��` _�-"`,�. k w '� . �� w �� , t. _ � F ,K' ' µ • � -- „ ' � � :, , ,. , , -�� ._, � �� i� � . ; �. �°�.. °,�,�, • .x , � . s , � ,. . _.. _ . .. , . .vc . .. . , � i� _ . , �:'# . ., . '!►#.. ,� .. ..., ..� ... . -� - - " - %. "'-.r�.. .a._. . .. . -r-..�� w ,ni;,�_ � _,� _ ,� ee`,�' ...� -- '. "�z .,. _ '' . .. � . .._ -. . � . ._ . � R, � 'a. .., s� �:s ! . r . � ,�� 4� .._� "�'� �,r ° . " ���_� . -... . . +�.=., .... - ��� .F« . . ' _ . . i . . . -� �7� �.., '°"� 2,�. . � .. ,.a€.� .. -� -,. � �; . . .. . ;. .,..� _ � � �.y.r-.e _ - �« •.,. �% ; . �� � . _ _ . �.:�;, .;� ;..,,- .-. ,..,.. �.. . �.'� .. . , . . . � , ,. ., ,�. �.�....� ;...._.-�, � : ;:' � dt>:�..,. „ . :�� . �i , a�`,... tt` . � . � �- t a" -�� °�-� .,, .n.��, .�t,�.: . q _, ,. ...�.,�. . . �. .. J ' i _ . . .a ��� et's�A°� �a �'� , ?�, .�,.. � ��.. .,� :: �.` ,.. . �� . ... . . , 1 -'� '�"r,�F� y� ��.�.. ��. '.�' : „� , "... .y��� ... U@ ..r . 1 Y-� t. . -. . � '� ' � '� . . S . . - ` ' • �� . . , �_ _ . . � _:��� . . � ,� . '� �,- a� � . - - - - . . ,.. ; � �� .�,�� , � , - � � , , � � .#� � � . __ � .: .a_.. �_ � � ., .. . �r.�„�R�� ; . . � . �. ' �_ . , . . .. T � � r . � , Y � e . < .= . _� . : ,�,, , ; .. � .,. ,.. w ... _. � �....- � .- ._ . -'�"�^�;, ai-. �i' . . . . - . . -� � . ... .� . .. � .,� .- . ,: .: . _ .+u,- !iff� - �3 � s ....y, °�tt � �t. _.e . . _ ��„„ � .: -,. -' " , - �=� ° - -.r ,.x. - � - + - . . , .�, . � �: � .. �� '-- ., _ � - - '"�r _. ..__ ,�,�• _,_, :...�. ,.,:.�• ..:.� ..>.�.sa...,,. �-_:- --`-�-'_.. -�� . . # ; .,°-'...� �' -�':. . -..,n.. �" �- vc _ _ s ,�. .� .. ,,.- _ �� � . „ . .r��. ��--� - �.., ;�., . .....,. -� � � .. . .. :...,.. , .:;,,,._. . .._..._. ......._ .;.. . ._..:.. .. . ...i,:-..,. _;,+�w!. nk�:';Y::T�a 3;L�:,i g '4. , "... ��... - ...... jg..3,r: ,�.r � ..� .. _ �,.x- 'y�, .. ,_ "' '�'�._'?s� ,k,. " :� .�E:�'��R` - ' � �., ; -- .�' �'-. �se;�i-�`�s. .. � .r �' ;�, .; ..,� � N �"p,� ,< .g, ,'. �., � ' • .`. ��� ,,�: _ e�� C�a� � ` �` ` ��' „ *h.4 • `.L_ .,, ..., ..s%. � ' . en .�r� .::�3,'. .-� #:.. -.r�.3'�b����: `'�':. . . � ..- :.�. '... . . _ . ,. . �� '�� .��- �a .�.,�. ,_. it'? re�� �,'- �s�V . `,r4�:.. ,, , _. � . „ ..< : :3��S- ar,.�s• r�;:s , a $.": a, , .. .�. . . "...,. . q'4,:;. -`�„'°- ���. ��V'�� � � =.x. ��� �� X�'�+ � ' �. �' •� < a. .,�.;�- � ,e.., ��,>.:.,j. ., . .,.. "�r p,����k�',� �.x �F�.; .�r. : a� ., •,i , , � ��::., . .�. �.�t t,.�. _ ,. � •. �.,. �4" �, a�', t ( y .i.,c<.. t,Y,:�a:.�.<�.�.:-,.. >.4�r._. ��.5 �: .. � ...... . ._...�.. . ..� ...:.na�.ra�.C.tM°..PV-.�,a:Jw _..s..anrw.se�n.... r� xa..u"......._..�1.. ... �M�. ea .e._ d ..P:. Jbk_Akiee�u>'a.b �. .� "i ...w,+.... '�r`tse':v1c ,n#.:. '"".:..n.e=,_.� a".�.e-`y�°.. . ...�.. .. ., . 'K'� ".'.�.:r,� :� .'�at �k. ..- . .. ...a'r.. ,...,. .... . .... ..... ...... . . ...... .. .... . . . . .. .. . .. .... . .. .�. . .. . .. . ...... .. ... , v ... .,.�..-e�.,.....P.... .. ... . ...... .... _.,... � .,..m,..�.-..... .. , .. .. .. , . ..... . ..... ..._ ..... ..:..........-.,....... r:�a .�#�`"� .''� - �__ �w X R �S `� y�� ��������?��ti� 5 tt �+ r . 4.'s.�'t.,ik!..�sy�4'.'1+.:�l Y .