Loading...
TR-2013-24b OFFICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE•CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 C U P E RT 1 N Q (408)777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333•planninq(a�cupertino.org October 29, 2013 Arborwell Resources Attn: Neil Woolner 2337 American Ave Hayward,Ca 94545 SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—TR-2013-24: This letter confums the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on October 29, 2013, approving a tree removal permit to allow the removal and replacement of 67 trees in a Planned Development Zone, located at 10201 N De Anza Drive. This removal is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROJECT This approval is based on the arborist report prepared by Samuel Oakley (Certified Arborist #WE- 9474A), dated July 10, 2013, consisting of thirty pages including tree removal site plans, replacement plans. Approval also considered the arborist report prepared by Michael Bench (Certified Arborist #WE-1897A), received September 13, 2013, consisting of three pages and an email dated September 19, 2013, except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The applicant is required to plant sixty-seven replacement trees in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance and approved tree replacement plan. Modifications to the tree species and location may be made to the approved replacement plan pending staff approval. The replacement trees shall be planted within 90 days of the effective approval date of this tree removal permit. 3. NOTICE OF FEES DEDICATIONS. RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The Conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby further norified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exactions, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section 14.18.180 of the Protected Trees Ordinance. Please note, however, that an appeal of this decision can be made within 14 calendar days from the date of this decision. If this happens, you will be notified of a public hearing, which will be scheduled before the Planning Commission and the tree cannot be removed until a final decision on the appeal has been made. If no appeal is made within the appeal period, the tree(s) may be removed after Monday,November 13,2013. Sincerely, � � �"�, Dian Pancholi Assistant Planner (408) 777-3319 dianap@cu�ertino.or� CC:Bob Granum,Nmsbpcsldhb/NMSB,P.O.Box 245,Saratoga CA,95070 RECE��ED =,� Jul 10, 2013 AUG �fi 2��� � ��'t'ee - �a y �PPEi�a�ion ��3ur���r City of Cupertino Simon Vuong gY• ��� l Q �sq.,.�l�� 10300 Torre Avenue `�'� � Cupertino, California 95014 ��������� � �,. .,_.. , Re: Sucty-Seven (67) Removals at 10201 De Anza Boulevard, Cupertino, CA Dear Mr. Vuong, This letter intends to propose the removal of sixty-seven(67) trees located on the 10201 De Anza Boulevard property (DA2) in Cupertino, California. It is a response to the report submitted to the City of Cupertino by Michael L. Bench on February 13th, 2013. The report submitted by Mr. Bench was a review of our Tree Removal Permit application to remove three (3)Pinus canariensis (Canary Island pine) located on the south-side of the building at 10201 De Anza Boulevard in Cupertino, California. Mr. Bench supported the proposed removals and recommended the removal of an additional five (5) Eucalyptus sideroxylon (red ironbark trees). Since presenting this information to Apple's arborists, a number of incidents involving plummeting Pine Cones have occurred onsite and employees have incurred serious damage to their vehicles as a result. Apple has since much more closely re-evaluated each tree's health and hazardous condition/pre-disposition and propose the removal of an additional sixty-four (64) trees onsite primarily for hazard mitigation and the opportunity to provide significantly higher value trees in their place for a total of sixty-five (67) trees. Images of all sixty-seven (67) trees are attached in Exhibit 1 for reference. Discussion Descriptions of the proposed removals can be found in Exhibit 2. The trees listed in Exhibit 2 are recommended for removal for the following reasons: The Canary Island pines are recommended for removal because they are a large liability. They are directly overhanging parking stalls in a high traffic parking lot which means there is a wide target range. These trees have a history of limb failure onsite and have been dropping large pinecones recently which have damaged numerous vehicles parked underneath them,shattering sun roofs and cracking windshields. The cones are large,heavy, and plummeting from a substantial height, also canying the risk of a cone falling onto someone's head, which could cause serious personal injury or worse. Additionally, several of the pine individuals exhibit poor structure with co-dominant leaders and multiple weak branch attachinents converging at single locations on the trunk. 2337 AMERICAN AVE, NAYWARD, CA 94545 OFFiCE: (888)969-8733 80 GLENN WAY, l.1NIT#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MA�tv FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA,CA 95742 HR FAX(510)670-0275 560 i EASTGATE DP.IVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WVVW.ARBOP.WELL.CO�� i �' — '_� �rbo'r ell. July 10, 2013 prafessionai;ree management The sweetgums and magnolias are in declining health, exhibited by low canopy density, crown dieback, and chlorosis. Both species are very water-needy, shallow-rooted trees. The sweetgums, specifically, shed seed pods that becoine a serious slip-hazard. Many Apple- employees have reported slipping on them. Any slip-hazard could potentially lead to a sprained ankle or worse. The privets are showing symptoms of chlorosis and exhibit crown dieback. Each of the seven (7) privets have multiple branch attachments converging in a single location. Moreover, they are overcrowding the adjacent redwoods. There simply isn't sufficient space available for both the redwoods and privets in this location so we are proposing to remove the much smaller,low-value privets in favor of providing the mature healthy redwoods inore space to mature. Since the privets across Bandley Drive are also proposed and approved for removal for similar reasons as part of the Alves Restaurant Project, these seven (7) privets, in addition to being low value-trees already, will also appear out of place and offer even lower value than currently once the Privets across the street are removed and replaced. The red ironbark eucalyptus are recommended for removal for the following reasons. They are a non-native and very invasive tree species. Moreover,they exhibit poor structure and have a history of limb failure, the subject trees overhang the parking areas and building, and many of these trees had their roots severed during excavation for the neighboring hotel and thus the structural integrity of said trees is further compromised beyond the species' natural pre-disposition for failure. The ornamental pear species are recoinmended for removal in that they exhibit significantly poor structure and are beginning to exhibit symptoms of blight. Each of the two (2) pears have multiple branch attachments converging in a single location and are overhanging the paxking areas and building. Having a history of liinb failure, these overly- mat�ire individuals have an elevated limb failure risk beyond the species' natural pre- disposition for failure. The two (2) red��voods proposed for removal are stunted specimens that exhibit low canopy density and tip dieback. Because of the stand of redwood's water-needs and tight grouping, it ma.kes sense to reinove the two (2) specimens to allow the remaining redwoods adequate space and resources for maturity. Replacements We propose to replace with five (5) 36-inch box Sequoia se�azpei-virens (coast redwood) in the Northeast corner to hydrozone with the existing redwoods to remain. This will provide a quick establishment of dense perimeter screening as conditions are conducive to extremely vigorous and successful long-term growth, including the existing bet7n condition. We also propose sixteen (16) 36-inch box Acet� buergerianum (trident maple), and fourteen (14) 36- 2337 AMERICAN AVE, HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFICE: (888)969-8733 8�GLENN WAY, UNIT�8 SAN CARL05, CA 94070 MAiN Fax: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAX(510)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO,CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.CO�A �i A�ba'r ell. July 10, 2013 r�afessi�Rat tree ma�a�ement inch box Acer palmatum (Japanese maple) for a total of thirty-five (35) 36-inch box trees. One hundred and twenty (120) 24-inch box Cup�•essus sempervirens are proposed to be installed along the south wall for a dense perimeter screen. The total amount of replacements are one hundred and fifty-five(155) trees. New trees will be selected by an Apple arborist to ensure optimal structure, health, and no girdling roots, and then trained from an early age as needed to optimize branching structure which will extend the aesthetically and structurally sound lifespan of the trees. In addition to the replanting material, a full soil renovation will be performed throughout the entirety of the building planters where tree reinovals are performed, including rototilling all soil to a depth of eighteen (18) inches and soil amendments into the root zone, encouraging deeper rooting and less potential for infrastructure damage. Irrigation upgrades will be installed. Overall, sixty-seven(67)trees are proposed for removal and one hundred and fifty-five(155) trees are proposed to be installed, a 231%increase in trees onsite, the majority of which will be installed between the neighboring Loft Hotel and 10201 North De Anza Boulevard as a dense evergreen visual buffer between the two properties. Dense spacing will also promote the trees to grow faster vertically than if spaced further apart, and provide a higher more desirable screen quicker. Please review this information and contact me with any questions or concerns regarding the information provided in this letter at (925) 518-2028. Sincerely, � Samuel Oakley Certified Arborist, VVE-9474A Enclosures (2) 2337 AMERicaN AvE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFICE: (888)969-8733 8�GLENN WAY, UNIT m$SAN .�•ARLOS,CA 94070 MAiN Fwc: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 VWVW,AP.BORWELLCOP�1 '"�►� "`. r �� � July 10, 2013 Exhibit 1 — Site Map and Images of Proposed Removals and Replacements s�: . • . I�. it� �i y "�*`�"`•;;";;, -� - �� .r� � °_ �,. a. .�.,.� . „�.. � ,,. �� �' � '� ' � �. ,�� ^' ` -�� - =�... y :,:,,..� �,�, ._,�. '��., -3'��;=ii����"'y�r�_..��� .� .. " 3 .�9 �1� y, j.,y � `-•I �,�� t,'_ ���, � ; � „_ ;:*•�. � � R � 4� +� ` r � r�f� '� ',. ; . .. " � •� ;�. �: • � �_ ,� 4,:•� ,._��,y . ���, � ,' i -��` :: ,,� � �,:.�� T � �� � - , � _ 'x��� � �.,� ; � }; ;;, n.� � � ,. � .t � � r , .,,�� ;� '� i, �t;� . ;, r : _�;b. �:, :i , i �� �-�" "i"� J i . ��- " r , rR t:� �,�:_;;7 4 � �'� * ' , j ,�� *,� .`� �.�_� .. � .�{` � �.,,� `�' � - . '�- `, �� • . 'l'�'°�� ` . I _' ' - �;�..., � � I a:i-'�N k �,:-�. �- ....J� +�:,n;�.w �i :;�:� ' � �'�" � L: " rr� "`�i°M�,:'�?� � �`:� y � .t.. , w�� FR°�' � � •IAjrd�.�r�,+.�g,��` .� � � �,a ` � .Y r � ' r �F`�"�i��' i �i.il � ( �',�"S'f`. r» ����� ' sr; � � , � � ��_� �- -�,..,. ` � 1. ��:-`�� 1.��� � r ,; -, �� _ :`° � ° ,� �,,.. .»�n.aa• �;. ��.�,r„ ._ • l�`� e �" t.^' ' �r �'1� r.`�t -. ,�'�: t�� . , �� � �� t_" �� • t�, ' "h, �1 �ti.'+�`'�•> �. �;'� � �°�+ '"„r `s°ao/ "• Y:f ��.i . ���� n '?� � ��., �� j� �'`�.�h. • . • - • u.� ;� r , ! + C-'.� "''Y ��' ' ."'. .�� 1 3, �e� ;�• j � � ''ri „ .! '. � ��( ;�, . � �4 � r � ��_ r «.�. �1 � p�fi� �`. , � Y '}'i �f' ♦ � s �1: ' � S y �. {' .•'�' • 4„ � '� ;,a'"`'�. '�', -j�+� �..t r"'n t � . ,�`�''�'"y'jr"�'.*w." '.�...,n•�ee �h �'",,..r".!� '�+�,ei �,,.�. � ��`+ '�su � ��' $���M s�� �y. .. �g�l � ������.e � "`'�`.�* � �;�'� ,��r �'� y��At,' !r���,� �`»- �'�:ir�'��.,t�;"`e'�.,y + *. -c+ � Fi � ,��"' f5'r�E &.. „�i4.." Nt��i�°y;�,w.��:T° � 1� � �fSG^...:.:��fa.�y„ r'rt���,.. +,,.,v.��� t�`�q.7.i �„d'y,�°�. «s�„ ,........._.... .. .. �� k a�;i°;,..`� .�__ .. r � ��� � ����� '.� ':�{,}�..:,,.� ` �. c... i,, rx.- �,�+ av_ � ` � .Sr^ i� i i �-��•^ a , ,. , �� K __'� ,...� "t.:n%,.,� �'„r_y� '� � �� ""��. 'r;L, - '"�"+ �� „ � ��� ' ;s_ A � � ..�, ?�- �:J�..�i� �.��—�...7�'�n��.� ! -� i.t ��.j-. �s—�' �' � "_r �a:� Q , �- . _ _ ,j r k -� • 1 r ''! ^ � f :.A yr' , _ L� �` "° �.t''e��, ��e., .�t� ./IIf��� ��' �'�.' '�� { x"6� ���� ��"'..+n'�c 2M �. � � � s ;,� .• tf . ' f s� � � � a" �.��� ' i% 'if �1•�• j �`�� � ., r" ...4i y�� � "r �,. -,� '`"'"`�� 1 :i . , �� -� w � ���t�y .� � �'' t �- � ��t ? .y.,1 � "� �^.. � �� �, � .���a '�i �`t:,Y{- f � t° .�`;T: �,� ����.� ., .y � ih�± i 1� b a�,� . ��s;., y�� .A. •..: Y° ��` � 't ��t� � su�y. �'i`t .. '� '"�&. .�:�, ��`S L.. �. � S � ..� „ ` _ �+� {'�" 1�..w+x" "�+�.;��zc�.. � � �`j �y� � �w'�1�°�� � 1 ��� ��w���'�+a� .,F". S Y,� �``�Y` , �'�4 .�'S�_ . . r � . .a ' �"� t��y-� � '/� f�,..�.,..;.m,� � ��t ..,-. : _. . '. 1 . '. f �.��.�`b��'"' , . a� L .. .r, - ..-.. � ; . . . , ���..."� .. � � .'.�., :*. �-r�- ��� � ��. . ` ,� �.�>. "a�j„�•`�`S�. , r , I , r ,a�.,a �e�?t �-3°3 - .' �_ . '+,o s",��.,�' � r y .. �^ 1 j�1 f--^"-x �� �y � ri` ��� . :� 'v,y AJ� � �'' - �, ` Y.fr K,f��,, 'I � �'`^�..�' `<r�-.. �`. H y ��"k" s524�. f 'T�±�� , :�� . � '-?�:. 7-l�,�,.+i,� 1 r �', . ' �� r��. �"�'y'�1 � �z ,R, r , ::l � .'._. �� �-J �.r.� a ,� J'°_ A�� � - ��,i..y►�.• �� �� ., ��� .. � Fw.`...ri �� � I 0. -'S. t � ��, � �c�»�',P'� � . .� �'i.� . . � .. t�,�� ,.,rs�. F � °�•�y" �- e i �`�@ "� ' -�` fG *t'.:� '} �x *A � t . I. � ' ,� ,�',!� � �� � � r�.:, ,� �. t«-t .� +�'f`�'�`�;' ,�tr".r...."�. rAM. 2�.�"'i. ~"',.;....�'���� �.t,c„�„' 51,� `� ,`"�r tC « �'F,, ....~M k.i� �.`:-.'ti`i tu� �4w "r s�` � �` ���,�g � �af ib�t�� ���xw�, F,�; ea'`-���°� �.. , �Z,� _ �'��e�: '�` � �:t 'w^G�� e y M . ,�"b �� �!T ,� a ft,j'j��q l� f O �tt � „ � 9,. � �'O 6 d�t � ,� .t"«�� ��r��*gy, � b�.�t,�,..�. st'`.l����� �."�S7�����3�� �. 5` ���y� ,..'.� �y��.?��j4n�...:ee a �,: .�� -�.. .�, � �r�s ,. .`�ac h,: �� ��t'as' "'�:�.�,t��"`.. �,.. �r a�-., d �ii:� `�y1 •.� } �e °.�"�h�J1f,�'+�p • ,*�.:� Ya. t..�e"�,,.. � . . . '�, e :e t t� w!. 'a� '_.�'l� r 2 ,.a„ .x x � r_`b tiV,r ,�^ ..qM,gF,�t M_+.+,. w „��.� '��a�,.,... w.;�p*�+.'�E';^�,. ,�yk� p��' .r t '�'',4�� ..r ' t���t?` ''". _ �i.�L'«. *» � T.;y. jy,�y' . -'�. "�a k"��� ......�*..�.w. , '- ��';,� ... t�.` . s r .1. ✓ r'� ,�1, �_ �.a .. ,� ... :,,�.. t.� Figure 1:aerial images of the subject trees'#1 through#37(top image)and#38 through#62(bottom image) locations on the 10201 De Anza Boulevard property(top image). 2337 Arr���icar��Av�, HAY��vAR�, CA��+5�� OFF�C�; (888)969-8733 H�GLENN WAY, UNIT�8 SAN CARL�S,CA 94U70 MA►N FAx: (510)881-5208 32�7 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANGH��ORDOVA,CA 95742 NR FRx(51�}670-0275 �CO'I EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGQ, CA 92121 WWW.ARBQRWE�L.COM ,""�.� "�. r or e July 10, 2013 ��"*�"�~",,;�';� �--� -. ��i ,""--"+�' . :'�.�`y'��"` rl�- �, y''" � P 1 ,t t j.. ...y�y R ;y;w r, :�. . � .. .. e. 1 . .r � r a� .. Kr. . . o, 'C+.. §rf.� ^Y M'�. � �.. ' Z , ./ z n y.. ��++-�� � �.._.1.�. �Ki� y \ (Z �� J� .� .I ,�e r �f� � � ' �`'y 5�t<�•1.�,�s n'�J•._ 1�^� �•� � r �j ;� L ; t �. ^�E.�-���l� 4._..�"�'�` .� � � :-� ' '� � '�' ,,.'. .. -�_.,^ . , � . - �`. ; x..g. � "..�' � � , �':° ,�: . ' 'r j j � ;µ � r, • ��.' � i �ry » . �� `'� �'��'�. � �� � . - t� -+.a1� � � � ..71 �`_ � � ��-�''7.. +' '� F` ,. :f !�`�,, I 4,� s : �,� - ,�-� �:�� . � . .. , . . ; � 'y ' FJ . ` t.. -:_,� �,�� � �,5��q,�►�4 . J '�. �..� ,ti.. � 1F `.� '°���' j . �4 t� �"._...—s-- ' � k ! +tt4♦ � +w� �� r�. i � 1 3^.v r. "� Y�j'��.1 r:; . ��` *�d" 4 �w. r . •ti � iM!' � • �C� �:-' ; „0Y, y°'��4 � ' � �`�£�'v, � ,� j�a .. ,� �,7���`��it ,�"'�i4. � �,s�� ; ']"'i ` . . N" �� . � � �y►.� �r^ � �'�I •�" t ��� ( t .� •,r�" R�r,�+N �. " �/' � "��:� � I �; � f�^�}r,. � �: � � I ' I �tY +� ..����»�.. t'e6 . � �;� }�'� #�' ��� � '� "�N��� � G , G., t -c r • 1. .. .�v� � � �� r� ,. � • . �"�•,� '�:� �-`��i r`•:: •� ` .a,��° �����yV � ' , � Y R� �+ . i �• 1��y��� � <��s.�� ti ,..�, � t . I .�� '�'� ��_ ';• , ,� ,.- �o- :o _ � ;.r � ,,.- �, ,� � � �� �� iT��� ; ! ' - �� i �� �. .� w/", �� r 4 r i �, `iA{ ,_. . i ' �8'��°'(? OOC' '. { A `�� I r�, i ��.JL�y1�-, 1'! � • t{ �� . f .• �,` ♦ R�,�,� � �g. •� ��1.� * : y �, . 'k � � � �..v. -. w. .��,� �...� � Y'. ��.i,;: _ ,� x w.e'�. L y�`� �rn.. � r^��A�..: - <" "'�� �,,_ A.3. �:. ' '�a � ��� ��� e,��� ����.�� ,r,�.,,'�'��r,r.����'� . . ..� •.,r ,...��w .. t•�"�` � . . � {. �. . �� ;, ' . �-,3Yx'R-Yp�4 �° �'� ,�w 4�r}�r . � , ^ "�r.. `�_�� �,�����'$�'�,a.w . .. x . ... .. . .. M, „ . < _' � ..y, " .'� ' , - , +r -+��. .. '� ti. «. --_ +� t �, r --, .,,.. .�9.«^g��, s�„ .b�.� a+"'�.�.r-. �A., . °�' �t ti�..,„,,. .k". •M^e.>�.:,,..... �����.- �:�+u. Figure 2: an aerial image of the one hundred and fifty-five(155)proposed replacement individuals. Note that the row of Italian cypress is shown as an orange line 2337 Ar��E�icatv Av�, HaYwa�«, �'A 9���5 O���c�: (888)969-8733 80�LENN WAY, UNIT#$SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MAIN FAX: (51�)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 NR FAx(510)670-4275 5601 EASr�A�r�DR�v�, SAN DIEGO,CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM ,�.� "�u. - r ar e July 10, Zo 13 :� ���� �1� � �, ���� 'w i � m �„ ,�.,�, , ��� � �� ��'°� � � °� ��� ���� �w� �,"' ;� � y A��� ���� *��r �� 'd��'" � yi..:: ..�A . �� �. w �� � ��a�s��� _ � �* '. ��. � � i��� .5� 9M�,� S � II�I III 9 s � e « f . ,- � ,` . . � � .ve �. � «�X�"�5 3fi, I K '� . ,a� y,. �� r .y,� ��r}t � e +a, xk � ..,��'.� 9x, X. s�.' ,�,''��d ��.: :P° .'� "�,�,. • � �.� 3. .� ::�,v�, rA � Sa -t, vr�. .�;: ' - • ?�.>, :. ,�,�� f'�;.'; _ .�; ��sg� �.m M1'�.� � .� ���� �' �. ~� ��: ¢� �t�,.. �\� �w � .�� � 4`tR *.. M, .f . . '� �+v.. � � ...�fi �. � �,� p 7�p'� '.`,1r:��� . � . � ., �� . � �. ,� ,. .« .�- � r ������� �.,. . .F; � . ^ .':. . .. �.m . . a �"� � � . . : �, �. ,.. . � '. �� - .¢ �.,����.� �, �.' r� �tf�:, � �, "'��- � � �� � >��� `�'�+ , � �� ,�� F- ��➢: .,�R.,. �. �,,.�.. . � ,, . . , • ,� � a � �..-. � ,�: w . c q*� '';� ,�"�' °�'� �'.� �. , - . �� .✓ '� , '�. . ,M.�- - .�;� .� 0 qa � ���`g-� �N �. � �,!� a ,�,;. .�.eiC9X ^� ;.I �? Rin a`8 ^�� �'I I; �or4 � q.r� ]+` .. � 3 F .� 7�P —v "�_ � ��"_; ���I ? �� "+�t� � 91.3 ii »i'N� � ..,, - , �.. ` ,,,��.� ,, .< , , � .. �� , ,,.. � ��,,,. �� Figure 3: an image of Trees#1 though#4 on the northeast corner of the property. Note the large gap in Tree#1,due to a history of limb failure. 2337 AM�R�cAN Av�, HAYWARD,CA 94545 UF��CE: (888)969-8733 $��LENN 1/VAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLQS, CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 32U7 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CC�RDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx{510)670-0275 5641 EAST�ar�DRiv�, SAN D���o, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL,conn �� 1 r , or � July 10, 2013 �"i�. � d..�5�,a���� �����.; k A �c., s s a„`�a^� °`'�V,yi�, {�6A .. \ �p��� ��" K�$re. ��'; >,P� a' �3a��' a .ka? �� .:�, �. �f'� �. ,,� ."����' .. M1 � � �'.. '�� �2�,a �� a . .��. ��w�,,�� . `�n'@a ' . R ��s,��',..: .aC��..�. �,�> ��:a�, at°�� ,,�'��., 'a;��,� �� � ., R'd-ay " �'d�� F�„ ,.- .a�. �. .._� �$ � � � �9� ' �q . . �� . �l �� v��. `1MC`'�x .y�`, '^ph: ��,y��".. _ . k ,k,�?,,,. , . .. 4 � .�l� , ��, ��B�.;� �� �J i � �'��^�. . � ,��: �,����YW�. ��. � . 3 6 �� , 9 � ?° .`y l�, '� N�;.. � �d,e�m q �$Y' �p Ax,o�� �r $ 4 � � �„���� _§� �� �� ��y"#�f �x "`fi�:' � �'b"';� " �dp�' `s .d� f � x 43� �v- ° s���'`%� s,, A">�K,; k � � �;# �., fi:;x��n i 4.d ,�rruw' .:aa ������ � � �.c� ..��� �. �� �� Ya� .� 6 gg s, '1° ,[^ ;� �n��A �#ir.�k .v✓'r�$G°"'v��"a�� ''"'* ^a,4y �.�.1• �@� ^r-y» 4�. KA�w�'�', �" p ��.kA�`�T'���t";^ f�� r�A'.° � •'�'�'W��� ^M �.:�. '� �}:: ��e. Veqa �,� r��A :.�3y� '4�' "� ��,. �.���Y� � � w�w � c w;y � '�� �& j'` � �,, � ��� ��A � p " � a� s °� _ r+�r���i ' ..r��'�``x.., �xr sw, � � � k �� o- ` x � N �., x � �� � ,� ��� .x� �k. w " ,,� � ��, . , . .% �`� �, . „��� sa �:,.�,. � , �� � � :€ � �^' ��t� ���� ��`�`. ��� r..� � s�u� � �z: � :, x a s�l �„„'i _�_� �; ���� �� 1,� , ' W��,s� ,�q �` ° � ,��,�, . , � � �. , �t P � < a ,,, . t.,��� � :;. ,, �C i ��{t1l� , .t � k` ° A. �a �� ,� �� � . f e , I � � �, . .,: � . , ' •; . ry,� �� Ii.�W u,�. � � a y „°: _ � ,.. ,, m�<: ,�, . , �,�.,. � ._ -.v.,,,,,�^ , �, � � � � . . .' A �.."" � �a t) � c Y; ��� ."'""^�.., .. „• �+r`"� �, . ��+ � � ,� 'E a y.�, � � � . e � 8:� . y d"� . ..� .. .`'�'� ,�,,. w4...: �sw, ,�"'+w » . '�, ',.�„ . ;: M� ��. �'G',�, � „'� ► d�. . . , .•.. i:�. , s � . - �s..a $� ' �- . � � � � �� �«�x�r� �� � � � �� e� �'4� � �.�'�f r����: x�*mL�,, -°%. Y �'.� ""��s.a � ��. ` �� . � .. , 'S' �. 8 r $ ""� . �w yf .a� ��,. p;{ �, ' .i �e;., x .' ro � .� .s �1�I . i � �� gz � � ,�.?: � a�� � r ` :§k �e �"` 's. ,. ..: F�- y i s . , � : .. , , . , ��,... , .A�� `�� r ,l � �� +�,,us„d'�W.��.4,. .�.. _.._ -�-- � ; ��� , �,,,� �". ;,ey t, ��"�, . . . .. *�ta . � � � . . . � �I 3 \�A\\`��� .� � s ��" {y_.i Sa., �... �� �y . . 1 r H� ; �'� �; f� � \�\ . ���,' � ���� ��� V 1�;. ry�,,� , rw.�;� „' . . j , ' � �� � � ,.: _..:.. � 4� y�F �".. N. ' , °�'�y � =�� . �`� �r"` �" � � ,,� �x, � 'r j6 i�� , . ,. �,� y.,,. '� �. �������� �3 w�L- m ��° MM �� ,�' �! . . . �4 ,k �` Figure 4: an image of the poor structure exhibited by the Canary Island pines(top left) and the drop-hazard from cones (left; cone marked with yellow arrow). The bottom images are a shattered sunroof(bottom left) and windshield (bottom right)caused by recent cone drops. 2337 AM�Ric,�N A'v�, HaYVV,��o, CA 9A�545 fJF�iCE: (888)969-8733 80 GLENN WAY, UN17#8 SAN CARLCJS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA,CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EASr�AT�pRiv�, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM .``� '"`► l _ �� � July 10, 2013 � �, � �� � � ����'� W��q; •,y , K � �. �E } (,.. 1 p��n.�� „ . .� �p * ��T,��WF gtl ,,,��N „?�' .��.i r ro.�.' Y �^•��0 .,�t!� � t�` �. ! M s` �,:' "�" ° � "�`' �� �� ` ��� � , ����� 'S� °, � ,* � ,� r� ��„�. -�r� �" ��" � '� �'� � ���" � � ,... w,�" s�� q�.- � e�r , �,q �, �€��� � " � ��,��"�� y�" ��'""��yr'. �,�� g�� .�,. ''�° �� �„� �� �� �..,:�,wd+`,�:#"" �� "YF'..'""�b�, � " y���,.*�'+� w�"���a*��. '1 t'�p,d':: +b^'" � �a�a� � , � . . 4 ,;� ���'" �i � ���d`�w .� �.tr, �',�'� , .� * ,.g, �,,� �r #-� 3 �a. .wro ��- � �,��` ^�k«�� ;���,� -. ��'�` � "�,�.,,� �''�, �"^ „�� +°�� ,�^�'` �� +�`+ ��� i d ,��Ay, "E"�'�", +� '�+"d �, 4 y"y k�, � < � . w «, r� � � ^`"�� � � .� � �t�. 3..„r� . �W.� ,�'fl't,v.� -.. $., ,�.� 3f .. d� � 4 �„ e ��, � �� �' 'g 9: � ��.�• '� � '*��^ �",�' � +� a � ""b�4� ',� +w � �„ _ `c�ti � °Om �G w�t y„ �'�1 �����. ' �y. ^^ ' . g, . "'� 1 'a f�. , � �' .�'�<,,�,g�� re,���v �a,�? kw� AC ,� _..� �'y P t m .� s°' 4 � {�,,,,.; .,;� �w� a�- �"� 9�'t.c� A .:,�� a .`x�a�' .. '\ y } . ..,�;"�, x� ��.d- . � ��" ,�, y , .- . + aR. � "� �" � ;!""t*4��' , � , i ��,°'' � �, �1r ��. . h�a � Y :�a;�"'.� ,�. ..'. � , y. 1i �;+.. ���� �����N� � �k4�� '"a����I�� � ��l� '^.'�f d b �•,'���r�� \ �::� �� � ��. ��.�� ,�A£ �.. ° ,��� �. ro�°'.4 � '.'�"➢y,y'*f� � ��"�. � 98` ft �� .. ��,'.� SY� �'��' °"y � .J�:a�x &�qq�'"` � �"_ ,�M1 s�� ,�,, �a � �Y°.`,� � m�'�th �. �°�� � ,� ^°s�{ "°`�',��»a 9�� .�°.�°+A�� '� �4"X n g . , .; ., , e . pp � � R�'"' .�^Y�v .�,.�'� `� �P}���e ��.�� 4�. .� kk D y y A°� �'�`J � e v: "K°,, 7' Pa ,.'� ,, e ; J y„g �� � �....iK �, ed r�' � ?.m: A.�,�h.� ��;±��+ '�tl� �,s �� ...p3� ar r' �r 6 �� ...F� ��'��^A.3r,•ti� ,� �q��� �,. � }� "� ,��' " �� � t�'Y � ,�... ; ^ . �. *��..�° �,..,2 �,�,, y �" ?cf. -�s �`�¢+«�',�"����' - . , , � "�.�. � , � �.,� � ,� .r� ,i � ti ., � "q ..a Y � "° i x�c�. „ �,: �c'�� � 'ro '�,'. �"� w� ".:8�,�ac',' �h r��°�,..6:,� F :ee. ,4� . .u� � �,a*b �tk..��� u � � '�`��„"`"�`�„+'�i�,.«,�, �'_• «s �`" ' *� �-��''`r,�� ����'�«,� .�•=�',.v �°�" '�`"��'�� ����� e s � . , �� � .. ,�` � . . +�, ,.�., �4 � > � �,. � ,a>� �� a�.Ty��^ ,�,�,�.: y� :� �„ •�`. �� g �� z . �'� '� .. ,�„ �• g •6�� �."�'y.`� . yMlf � � �'. titl � N ` .e.�„ Nr . �� � ,� 3' M � k�. �9�� ..� Dy,� ���a.'� f , �}� •5� - � ' +�W �v.'9! . 3 �� ,�" '�. '�.. �aW,."+ '� � r'wu � �'. 7� . . ��'r � �f '��1* '1 yI . °F6� .i1 � h '� . � � �& " .9 d�".,o-""$� �,k � � �'� d & },,.l�� � �.�y��,., �?'�w � B�t �`�,`. `�,.,r �`µ .�µ � .:��_,.� - �'"' `��#b�.. � � 3,�. �„� � l; � s."# �,.+A'A� ,�.# .d ��`�� 3�j' ;� ��"t � p t,i,� �1y":�{ :,�..� ���a��� . r ~' -.Y '�`�$, ' '7�[l� :�C' ;�`ma�•,� ^� � '..� - yA�+�� .. .;.� Y ;�� ��, �� �(° ��:r �`, ... � � �y� -p, '�� t ,q'e� M '� E dr� � � � . '�� �` , 4 1 �$r,,,� ���;p,�`�gy �<t,�a`� ys��'�.-�"� i'x �ti�,�°.- Ar'S �� `.�``y� .'� iV" ��� � �'"`�A'#-€q'�r , �,. 4a f�... d i . � t.. •# y" � � c�v s,r ��,�� ` a,y4 •F. - �+��x��` . -�-"#"'}�q� '..w+``" 2 gu .,��,: .+�.�. a,�� �5��'..+,. . .,��� , __.... � � " .. � � r, u� � .r � �, �Jrw^J. . . �"�.:.. . .._._ , .,- . .,, ., , . �.. ,,: , , ��" �"5; - . # , . .. g ^p .$�,� (�' ���-� s r-�k:: . ' ,. .. .., � . � •.q' �`t�i�. " � �a£'�� 'm'"`.,'.�` ..ffi, "` °� . s, s r q � : °� c �� g �,j�� > F .. -3: ,t' . « 6 � P�. ���'�aa r 3° � k�. � �.� _ � �y ` ���, � �C i�Y f�`l ��'A 7' '�y b �T3.`����'.�q .Yr x T ry� ��V y � z�°`�`' -�t �' ,���l,r�� � � :�; �, ti p �` � �.• � � � � � g y � i.. `�y �'" S;� � xa � . .. . . < , , :. �, .. � �.,.} . ��., ., . • .���"°� � . � �g-. - . .: , -� �. . ° � I�� ��'�r'"�;, 4�-�� r� �,�,. z � �` �,� ��,�.� «� � —� 'it".: .. . � � ' x..� ,���. �, ,. � � , � b�� ��� "ry��►"� �'� ��'�'�. >�: o:.. � > ��,'� . _ .v,� ���� , . ;� � . . :x;�°: ��d +r:�w� �,.k ��, � �r �•+ 4 � � ' .4 .vT ���� � �,,�� � .�: , y r,2�� <q s . ,N ��. �".".. . .. . � Figure 5: an image of Trees#5 through#8 along the northwest edge of the building. These trees are in decline and exhibit poor structure. Tree#9, not shown, is to the right of the image. Note that this species sheds seed pods,which has been reported by Apple employees as a continual,serious slip-hazard. 2337 AM�R�caN Av�, HAYWARD, CA 94545 OFF�CE: (888)969-8733 HO GLENN WAY, UNIT#S SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 32{�7 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHD CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(51�)674-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO,CA 92121 WWW.RRBORWELL.COM ,�.� ,` r o� � July 10, 2013 t� "�°��`��""�"��" � � '" � �� �'� ,�� '�'' e�� '+� {�p� " +� ��;�;�"� � "� ",��� .� � pR � ,��;�+�,����d�"��- � �� � � .�'�'� °� �,� � {,�:A,, � i�; z�,'., � ��, ���` �r qe�. f $�' �:�. '�,�'���.i� �°r � �, �} �,a � ��� � ��� � '�'A �� �� ,�'"�.. 5��� `� a � ��������� a �� �� � '+ � "`�} ,''�� »": �; }�{� �� � �� � � �� � ��� �t �; �: � �,, ��,�� »° � �� � ' � .�r� r � � � s y,�� � � � �,P �� �( � �'� � � � �s �� � c �,� a . "v.d�.�. t� .�s a �" '� �. J'° g� % a�' ^' ` ' K � �' „� 4F �y'd ^�, ��$� e a .y _�' . A �,.�. B , . M�p q,5 u�y"� �. � 'C'x°` � �' g � n e �, � s �� �kr� + �°� � � � , ,�� � Y� �� +f il� ' �",�R�'"� , �``' " .� � � � . � � .a �a ���;� �,. �'�' � . �� �� a �F k �, "` ,� ��:� ..� . � V ,a+� . �5 � �p� e�,.�}\�k �: � � y���. � � x � �r „�Y ��a�� 3�`.� ��m� ;Z �" � ' �'� "�o.o p �� �t. '° l�,a � , . , , . � - w . �� , ;. .• . .µ . t „ � � ,' "� „� �� `,�c. �'�„ � � y � . �d �� '"9 v� r�.. �v� � £`. � . � � � ,. � . � �� �h yy� �"��M "�� j w a� � � <� �� �� � µ �;,,� � � a > . .�� �'�".�""' � '< >,. � � 1 ,. a� �, u � , �y �, », ' `?�,, g�,; •�� 'S;r. �•, i� �. �+,�� �4� ' ..'�F. � M� �' 4-�"a'� '��t o � �� � �� A� �'� �. 8�" ����„ � � �, t��Y'.� . _ ,:� s � 3 �. u3e'�.�. �' �rt, iy . � MdW� � �� i� � _ .. ;y•� +. �� �•,. ¢ .:. � ' 4 �K � q � �� �, Y dq- ,F�"^.�t r ,.'. C,P�s6 �y wdpr ��� �.i r ', �_� ,�g'p�' � �p #� � � � �� � � ,�� �^ ',. �'`��. `� :i .. > , .� ",�p;'��`�=��� � � ,-� A - . �X��.. a P4... .R. � �Q r p .�s J A � _.. � `:.RI ` ��- -, . .` !. � � ,l,�` .� � }e-�°�y�,s �F� � �� � �i ��� �� ..�'� ,�4 r � ,�.,. ¢ � �� �� ��� � Y a r ; t y �._ S A Y�- � i i . �. o � � a� � R,.� fi. a . � a ,a.. . - Y ' i ' i ,w^� y�,�� >..p. .��'� �-' t'�� _ �� $g= . � �/� �� ° - ,�E ,�. ' � F ° :� � ��� � �_ � .. > � .. , � ,� �� � �:, .� � �� � � 3� 4,� �6��� �t�.�.,`'�. '. �. ,,- � �, � � '� b �4�. �,..«..; �ap� ,"" f . �.''��: ;� ��k. . , 6 " � ` x �# r �j 4." - �� �" 7 f.. ":�'.�'a k� v� P � . R± � t �`- _.. �YIM}� 1�� ��Y.� °p � �11. � ,� �. �R r'`�'"'��"�`� a�.. _,.__,._-�� �,.�,�.,-,,�,�-„�.,�„�,„.,.�,.,.� a;i, P '�" � ..� , .,�;�.�,�, ��.. ,�, • . � , � � � � , ., , . ., � a�:�" L,�. �yr� n£� '� k� t � �s.� a -�s� � ,r.y k ., t ' � . r � .� �fr{y��� k��4�� � A ���`,�`3�` , , : s ���. �� .:^Y� ' :�B"t �r � �, s1 � � � �"� x.k 6-'.y,� � ���.�� L � � � � �#�i�". ��� ` �, ��= ,� � ��, #� _,� ;i 4�'„�� , �;�"�°�� '� :r� t t. � � ; � :a ��� ,��� �€v k 5 � a�,�..��t=��`� 4 �,:� � �� � '�c�s :'s� 3�'�' . j -. �: $ ��� .._i +yR,� ul«ii.�'�;`�.r_rw"::-� aifnt.�. ��_a.____.._..__ ..s. YI. . « . ....��'e�, Figure 6: an image of Trees#10,#11,and#12. These trees exhibit poor structure, are overhanging the building, and continuaily drop cones onto vehicles. 2337 AMERICAN AVE, HAYVVARD, CA 94545 �FFICE: (888��6J-8733 80 GLENN WAY, UNIT#$SAN CARLOS, CA 94070 MAiN FAx: (510)881-5248 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 NR FAX(510}670-0275 5601 EASl'GATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO,CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWEL�.C4M '�►� "�► r or e July 10, 2013 �>; r� �,�����.���E � � � �. '� ]•3• 9 � ''`ff�ie Y M xF � S. J�` ��. 8�� �£� � � �` X� �����r �� �. ��� r� ��. $� k� Y�''�? t* �'.� 1 �•'?�` �` �P .`���� �,�'°+'�� �''.. �€ a���_ � � � f x �� � .� � �� ��� $i. � '�" �F ��3 " �. �� 3�e �`. �.�"��.� �f% �� / P �,y .sm'.�rs i s� ���� f�� ,��` .f.. ''s ,� 3�`'�' �;53fi �' �. � . - �4�. ��� f� � � z�,� �� � {. �,$ � � �' z � �' � � . � •y� � � �-�► £`� ,�g�,'� ;,�,� '' '�`�1 � a� � �a�_ , r °. �,,, � � �'•'* �:��'�� •. e . �/ ,�ib,� j #a �,�y �`�{�aA ` �rd'.Y �:s°� *l. .. �� a,A�•V ..:' dM...,�.�,.d� �'7"'�^�ar, d. . � �r k }'# .!'r go'v �` �� . .i. , '.J`��. �y�q.�, ,t �-`�'.� �",r ,76�`., � " . x t,� v S�"' �'`'� f � r �a� �� ` �;� �� �� t� �'� 'a�' � y � tt� .,�`� �. '; .. '�x ��i�g�.ti�� �"�' �„������ �'�'M��a���y������"i� ��*4,�f°^�� �'i',,y}�.. � �#F ;x`;� t�. . R���,��' ,t 4 'a"e ��� �� � 4�t�`� ��V � �8?�. �� �4 % {� � �i „y ! ��� t .��y . ..�' $ �yf$ •fy��- #�y ��y(�$��¢�ry.�� ��,5' �`„�h�v.����'$' Y r'�. _�..*�IM� ..n� ui4#�N� �� ���` �; ��'°'AF!.� "�S'a��E ".:rt����Y � 4� t �, gg 6� +� �t�+�,!���{(� � +�,a�n� � *� ��'� *-� a.�`• k �.t ,� � S;'3 j ;�i+"'�'!�@�� � �, #�r��"}�y "�`' �.�.` '... .. "�. n �y� �: �M :�:+, ^`�� �¢A� A. ¢ v S��k. r �,;� `�„{Y', � ,��_�� '1R t �+ �' � .� �i��..c> ;:��,• �`t'.. ,� � .� �#""X�� '� �_M�.�Y� � �7 �� .r ` � . -` a b°k p �,§ � ��� � d ;'� ��. a,�,�g8 a � ��.s rw � $r.��,�; . r > � �� ,.y� ''ak 3�f t'.. x 7 t y � .�("'6 "X'_ .'� � �A�„,` • ,:J' � p `fa,�.. I� �'"v *�.:°€ ��{a: "W�� r. ��. . � � s`�p � ' '� ���n � ...�� Y � l��'�, . � ��.rt,y ,�4 t ,� .� n .� ,,.`�A',� ,��..'R i �yp�s+�ki�� .,R?k'.g—' F .,R .: r S?. ;� r � .r� a .?�o' `�. ,�� , } x r$+. S1i`"` ' "T+ ° s ..�.� }" .�a°t � .���„...� 3'� -� �I~ �� ��i►� "xY���iryF'� ' :�vr S\�sa�y�, �, `k.� �.�-> 'y,`.... !�§ ,o ' , ��i � .�� �ik,- ",� �r"°�:+��R�7c�£ ��@ .,,� :e w'z �,� � �` � �.� � �/� �� r'� � �� "'t9� } �� ✓t�:*� �,� ��� ��°i�,�� m°�'.i'a' ..,.:�'� �.�G,J"t'�"'•a'` "; . s, , y .:�3�' s �:y�. „d" ��;R�� ���`£�'��'''#`�� �� x.r'�. �!r'��,s.� �. , . 4 � a ` y �< #' « . ... ......... e .�� �, f` �" 'tq�'" �i°'��"� ����.1. a ` •°� �� l���;~. " ;l ,P�x '�' ,w, " `���; {k � `� �3° 's� i �..`; .rt� � ""ti' '«""`' ,. �`� ����r" 3 r, ��,,,,..,;,....,v t<..,,,�•...�.,'`•� � � '�0� � . . l � `� �'d . 3? :��� '�2r" `�� ���4.�''J.�� 3�'�y�'�4C � - v� � ��j . , E �.y'3�r'�' '��'"�t � �'� -. � 1 �' Y+y� � .-�,. ��` �u') d; � �1 � w� �"'.-�y. ��- �� f ,. � �A..�- ��� k � _f�r� : 'f , y �S� � � " ��R.��..," �. � 's.i' ' .��� �, �- .. + : • . Yn . :.. �.q � '. � _, �. :. � .., _ , i .. : � :. d.r .. +W,. . F�'� � S<�. . �. � Y ' � .. � �T ..�."� �. "^\, � w �;` I � �� � S � f. �3� rr .�"� �, "`. A"+��' �'" r� - ��.*s.: '''r� �-� ,. �-a' �. .x;�^ . r -. '' �"�. i � ,� �� ��' � ,�f �- �.. a�. � ° �. h � ,� � ���,�, '� �:� � � � �r �, � ,���� � 4. p. > y^ p ;� � � � �� �� � �i 9 �� . 1 n � , y,.. �.. �.�"fl � .� � .a 4<,` .�t. � �y,��, r�'A. r�"`��i. ;�. �� . M,. r _ . �� �, �� '�_�� � � ,� r r p rF, � � � ..._ . . :. � . . � r , �,,�;�; .<� ,� �.�~ � �� ._ _ , 0 . � j q yry :i ' ,�,a " � � rt . r q �s .7r ...... . . . . . . , � � � � � � x.< � � & � Y ._ � � .. " ' ' , ' ..... � .. . : . ,;� .. " ��� . � e`9 a�.'� Y ;;� �_ .. .RG,..... �, �� ` A: . � .,"�� ♦. �s� ,> n�rt�'# .. .., :�- �.�,.'...�..�,,. . ,.,z�-,:., � � ,g : ; ��.x�,�° y =sp �., �n�• �, ., .• , , , _ ,. � ,� y„�. . � � . � „ „ � �, '"m •, ��'�'- �t�x,,. , �a:: � . , a�,,. ^ .. �,n a.w.•ww�, ........ Figure 7:an image of Trees#13,#14,and#15. These trees are in decline and are not suitable for a drought-tolerant landscape. 2337 AM�Ri�AN Av�, HAYWARD, CA 94545 ����c�: (888)969-8733 $Q GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLUS,CA 94074 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHC?CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM '�� ''��r. r a�- e July 10, 2013 � � � � r��� � � , � .� ��� ... �� W � ��4:��:. h�,�T,\ �, � ��� ��S �l.. y, 5; �� t�`� � . ���'.^� ,; r F S • � � � � � � � . : � .��� . �,,. •����..�,� r . �� ���r ,� � �"�"� ` � � �\�� r�,�� �,� W „ g a' �, ` �� �� ° � � .;�:.. ��4� ;°�5"y.,���t��, ��'a` �ll��` �° � �,� ��*�t�,+" ��. ,:;� .�� ...�„dr."�°yx�r �-a � . ro�. � � "'4� ��� *�� � ' w� � � �� M.,�,�,�y,� �� "�' a � � � �� �� ���� �t" k��� , � ���t� � �°� ��� � � ?� � yi�� �����:""� ,�w � '"� ��`�,,a re., �.�� �"� �'�"�� �� r k�. M � ?,'� •���d �� � -�,"��a��,'�5 � �`�^°. *�. t� � c ���� �. �� P .� " ' ,`.�� �y ,a "", � ��` �y��,���� +���Y �� � � � ,.� �',����a�'�� 'i a,,at � �� �.°:�-��' ..�r� �w� �����"X k � r "„� 3r' °"�" k�'' ��� � "���. �� �a ��"a� � �° .., a * � 3G��" � � � '� ,��a � �� "�i�� "' �` ��'m� ��d � s e d� ',. .� �te'`�} t , t �S`A� '��" �'�n. ? . �YY ,,y��� ' r'�; �,��;, �`� ��.� "� � ��+. ���, ���� _� ��� &'R.1p.�a"' •� � r�, .�'�. $"►a" °;a.�;'�a �:� , �,�"�"' '" �1� �1��" ���' �� �'� .e. tt n �^ �� x. ..� � � .'�«; �'�"�k���` � ,.�.-s� $*�� a . '������"�� " � \ � ,�a,,, s �`,�"" i w a i e t 1 s'r „q+ e. 3 4,� '�+!.; gr tR m ��^^" �g.�„ �'b a.`'x,"�.�„ .�`o-.�,�,.,,�� ��,,, "�,� � ..eY�,' c� s.�. �t ' � ���a"� �, . . . ' � .. fJ .� �°t�� '4 •"a, �`' ,,+�'' '�, , �,�,� � ���� `���� ���.� � �,; � �.�„ �ir. � � n� � � �r,;° ; ��``�'`°:`�,�E`��:y;' �x����+ �.° �,�. � � , .�,."' , �-� "'� "�"�,. "�r� �� �Y ,� �a �� �.� ��, �� � �� �� �r�,` '� ,�t,; � � �" � � ��z� "* �. .'a�`� a� �k � -� �^* �' „�';'''� �,x .w�" �a � .r� ��" � �"",a `� �'� � '�" s `a ��fi r �'k &""� a,. :�,�� ��,�,��9. .� u��.�, �»t a, ,� ��� e � ��° �" �� .r� „rx�w� � �� .*��e�4 �� � �p.,. �,��a xRy� �,�gy �!"' � � �-- ����,�.i .� ".y,� '� �+ `�� � t .�w�`tl ° $ � � ,, �,! a 9 � � B ,� '��`. �� aV .;Z � ���� ..�.t� ��.:�s"��w`a '�r P� � �'� �q'���°�a?� ���`�`�"�w ��, �� � �`�& ,.� '�''�'w�,�°" �^ � � ,� � " '���� �` s� t ���°'� ,�v ���'�, • � � r � „y� S ���. �� �A,<� � � `� � ,�� �. � ��^ �,�>� °,.�:,,�,,'�` � ����t ������ �� � �,��''�"�`d� � � � � �; ' ,�� �x���"` ,�,� '� � •� "� '"� �'����°"" .r� � e � � � '��. � ` � y� � '���'` r" "�:,-� s z' ,6. i , r. . � � �'�re:xy ' , ��•-�3 y�,.�� 4M +?x, �." � ,:..� � ' .& e' � ✓ � �"v_. . r�., , . � , n .. � : . �...� � a,z 7' ,.r 'Y',�. '�A�Y' � ,: . -.. ..�� �'� �' br ��L �� y �^''��� $� .� i��¢#3ggs� c�€ ,��'c.�.,� . �{ �r s,a's,x � � w�.. , r- �, � � ,� � x: �., � w , � �� � � = em a � �° �. ��$;`, , � � , , �� �' �'� �°'r � ���� � �: � �, o � a�: , 5 ���a�t"�`€ s a c r� � �ed, �....� . _°' , t ,� � - <d ,; � ��� ";� a� y y ��' ��`'.e .... '-:'. ,"�� ` ,*��.�� c.� � � 1. ;�y,� I � . F w�';., � s� �"" �� p . � ,�� ., f ,� � .:� , rP x � � & b+, : . 'ana �. ' "c�' t�� �3 ��:W. '.d � � �', av;."�"u�"�' . l�y, �5 � �';' , �a " � ��„d'a.�jP:+&k � +��� 9' .:. n y 3 � t�"^� 4..ya 4 1? E �� ,d'4�°, f,' ��� e s � � t p � y, °,W�\� \ \F � P ,;p� c , r �`°"� , � �s R�� a �������+u;; � � ��� �� ,� �� w.�, � ,�� �. ; � � � �v � �„ `a� � � ,��`. e.�`� ��� � ���w� ���,,�� � � �-� �. �� � � � t�``' ��. ' ��a '�� �,�� �� �` �,� ����`��"�`�' - �' >� .��.� G �.� �� � � {��� �, �� ,` � � � ` � -' , , rv � � '. h x� S'. �t�f R y . S . �. r� �� � .�`.� ��` .� �� s�,.* . . �. .:, �� �� „ � � � � .: � " ��� ����� �`� :� . �..��:;^ °,,�+m�°'- �.�' � `t� �'r�%��x. �" ��'�-���.�Y..��� � � ���` ,,� „ w � , , , � � � � ��. � =�� _ � � - " ' ���` � �� � . , _� ` f �'�s � �T� , :'�k . ��i � � �;, ��' �.. �;�y�� � ' �..�s�` •�`�� � y � . � �1, 4 F i .. .r"n{ �I�t�.� M �yb. t.e b ` �{E�'+� ��3 Y1� a� ^ .� � 7 s � .: � �.µ „ , , @•y pR' . .: � � � rW . '" ..�Y ' . ;, �.�M , � ...,� �M ��T �w � - �e r* r, r�x �nr° .,� „ .c: � ;, � � , t �oy •,� :y, � �,,,�—� �.,.^ � � w,.�.� ° � <�. N , . ,�� �� � .,.; w,, ,, � � �• � �� < +„ �u. ` " �� � � „���� ,�.��° � .,w ^�.„ �� ,.� . ,. .� �,. Figure 8: an image of Trees#16,#17, and#18. Again,these trees are in decline and are not suitable for a drought- tolerant landscape. 2337 AMER�cAN Av�, HAYWARD, CA 94545 4F��C�: (888)969-8733 8O GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 �207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510)67�-0275 5601 EAST�A�r�DRiv�, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.C4M 1� '�1�. �- r or � July 10, 2013 �� :� � ��� � ��"� ��°„ ,: � �� -�� � �.� � � � t�, � « �m . , � �; �• $ �. �� � � '� h.�� � � ,�; ``� �� " � � � � � ��, �� �f�' °� � �� � �� �` ?��� �� � "���� � y�haF �• � " � �a�. f� �o� µ� .#� . . b w� �°.,p� ��"�a" �� �� �,�, � �r`� M1�i M '��<��� �a� >x�`� ., � .� x y�� ,� '�{ �^w ,:<,� �., �;�� � p���"" , "��a�,�'":.°� p�"�°�� ,";��` %.�,�, �y' �• "M�� ..� �r � ..� :� � "�" � �"', ,�,,a , - �`� � �� � x � '�*�r � , ., ;'S«� � _ � � � -w� . ., °�, a� . R � �. e�� ,,�9@� a . � � � ,. , . . � �i , , m r �" . � x �.. Y � . � , , " . . .. a ��'��",,� �, " �;�� ° � ��� �� '` 's�V'� � : �� ��, ��.. ' , �-. � � � � �� v�, r �a�"' ...:� ���`�' d.. ,�, ""�. �,.• �^ � �!,�s ,���� „ ,� � ;� .,., . — �, ,_ � . , �- �. , �� �.�a -„ � � , . �_ � � ,� �. , -. �� -�,�. ' .. .. s � x .; r , � �. �=�*° � ����� ��� ��� �� �`�, � � �; , �. � � � a �g -"�'� . , �, � , � ,�^ ., ,- "'�`,t���� "��""�� Q �'�'.� '�" ��� ��'�.^� � � r . � � � � � �� . �� r. . ,, � � , , ,:�� � �.. °: ,� .. w . "�- ��;:�• �� �' „ °-`��.��� ,"�� ._ � � ,� C"»' ��"`� � � ��;w.��"'�. ''�° �,.n� � ".��qY 4�*.. �� ��� Fa�.° � r �`�� �. � ,.e. m ., r, °� �. �, x � ,� � . �� ' "�� �� � '� •r.�� ���' "�+,.'W"�°i` a �'"'�����' �S �.� �" �s"�' + `j'1� I .��,�'",r �� �,°� � ��' �,�"� �' � �r � y �- rN, ,�u�'x�� ,. i,��' � °',e��� � , j�'^�" ��F�� �7��� ,'/1�� x�y,y��a, �L�X � '��"� ;� m ��w ���..� ., ���F',��' -'� y m�µ„ >,y� ,'�: y�� �,s -�'� ..�,-� � . °r,ey t gpa p. "� .� �".��.' �'� . � x' ., �... '��, q�'$` r .. s ���' . �� ��`�x.,� f�>, ' . .�`" � » �,' , , a ;r�man �'.-°�... �3F�.�.�;��, ' . r � E �'�.' r � " .¢ y� '� . � . �� � . ��~.f�i �.~--_ ��f°�J.. 4,t� *.:: ` � - �� �9 . e� _,..a - �,. .�a � ., ,ry �.n� ,� z� a�.`ti '° ,�S �w� '4 ",7g�� � P"� �0"� { �. ��� Tx����KZ�': ��.y,� k��� ' ��� . � S�'��µ���?,y��• ,' 8',. � �� ' �* `y �y 1* ,J �s ��a ;�.°'� � `. � ' t . � ��„- @ ;t " �.' bf` 5 � ��' � � * �p?�,� �'�' ,,� �� z e♦ aWGr �tAaY� ���� �. � F: .�' �. !� g.. �i+i':�� � - . x .. rs� f �,� �� : ;� ,a � :�.� �• P� )� ' �`� � -sa �y �,�' �' � , ' ti 3 ' f �_��.� �� . �� , � �` �, �-. � � �, . ;� . �, . � �� � � � ' , ��. a, ,,. . , w�� �. � �� � � ���— � "� ��, ��������oa��.,�,�..a����,�. ��w �� , .�, � Y N $a� � y k..y cA ' y. �2 -x�;. � e �� 4 � ry.. . . 4 �?'".s� .�. 3 �� .�t , .�pY .,-i'�,-'.. �."�: . , . �� �� ��• ' .� �� , ... � � a. . ; :.- � � � � : ,� $ s 7� �r� �r�� .�r�.s r'�� j ��� 3.����r.�. �� .. , " .. .t�� "���.,. h *���% ' y _ . . �,:-; � .::.. ' . ;p' , �" 3 ' ,. :,.. R,.. � .�',ya a ; i.:.. .4 a.a�,s y � +," M. ..w �,�w- � - +� _ .� y._ _ �•+-� F. f°¢� a.��vm... ,., � . ".R. �.� 'y ...... ` �,a,.'. �� .�,-.�.�..� . _. . � :-v, � . , ' �,., ' . �.:". „' � i�^ ' . r„ �y � , . .,�. � ..,.W..-�---'_' .x..., .. - .�,�;p . ,--� .... � .e-. .w.�. :b°� .2.; , .:.a... ) , Figure 9: an image of Trees#19,#20, and#21. These trees exhibit poor structure, are overhanging the building, and continually drop cones onto vehicles. 2337 AM�R�cAN Av�, HAYWARD,CA 94545 (J���C�: (888}969-8733 H�GLENN WAY, UN17#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 9407� MAIN FAX: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CC?RDOVA, CA 95742 HR Fax(510)670-4275 560'I EASTGATE QRIVE, SAN DIEGO,CA 9212� WWW.ARBORWELL.COM �� "`. r �►�- e July 10, 2013 Ai �� � � r . , ...:.... ..... ... . . � ,�i,A''��iw,,��, �.,. .,�,. .. . . . - � �. � .�. xa �:' e ffa .�i�R;9�f/Mu'a i � � i � �� � � � � �,� � ��. �rt .. . . : "'"'"'"G:��� �.,..� _' �, w °� � , � � � �"�'t , ,;�, � � . • , r v � �, . . � � ,� , _ `��'` '`�; < e � � r a ,w �__._ �... ,„,„. � : �` e � ` � a, � . `."g.,��: �� P36• �r"@ .. � �t�-� , '� �u h��t . `�Y� ;'���r .xi.� ry . ��» �� . �� �.� F�. ,�� �_ .. _ .� � � i �� ����� x� ., '�J�.S34'�`: �,`�8� ��`���'. �` �, �� .,; '."� ,r..+w rw.w,rrrr`,iilr�lr� 's. �..� r z v�+ p i": tt x °4 , �. ` "�'�s w '' i«�� k ?�'p' `�` « t ra . s .F} ,�,yg-^°,�r"' �b,� j =?�i � �.i' � l.:-� �* .' ;b'�$.� ,ao,� � � �pn'. :&y � 4.;�p! .-u ��4 �+ �a ke¢�,�r�.! ���,� �� � '9s- ��,� °-�",^��+ �,.�„3.,ie� ,'} � �'- � ` p� �'4`��s �bi'Z�� f"�'?��r �.sF�`1 ._ �4ra ,�.r '�'}'ifv,�� �e'�,;;��'�.a.a ";i�s„�Y �.�" .�>° ��_,'"� b .,?.�;.. �� � y�w� y �v�t ""�� r�a„:.s~ .� �°-��.' .;�9w+M y B '.�;,� r; � .�.,;"o �,.- �ctti a �' .� *s�r� � '"�:�.r."�' s�.� ��c�� "'�„`�. � � '�'1�� � t� �` �� K¢ „ . x y, t �� ,,..,�, �° � �'� .. , W^'. '4 7 �y�p` �� � �'�pZl .�Y� �l.� . ' d'�Y ap i'R,9'� � r . y��,, ��,y�� A�.� .. 4�;�YY[yy��y 7iTx � "�� . sP�+RY. �`��.� .2�• +F�°" ,c� � I' r . � }�,.. �r . ;� .. �� ;: g,�b'�`�*�. . .:_� ,:�a'R. ^w,�+�� • �,''4$'S�-�+': .�;.$�`. '+F�A.:,,a-'. . . . . . r`+,��1��, � - ?e .r.` .. TM .�...� : E1 4�'e'�x�,,�;�� . � 'F`� 7['� ���a, r� . . . -. �'- �'n ���r ' e � � � ;.. � .., ..����.� � ::: '� -. �y :: �. ., �,.� '#i- : ` ss k�'+- �. ; s'✓.�� �S� �, -: q.... r _i, ,� ..'3,y �5`- . p,� .. ., .� : , . . �;� , .. .b, . , ... >t. ��, �� +4�3 � Ht � ^ K ...h.sr ., 1!4 ' �,,,.,:" ,. .- .,���� ..� „ ,.:�E t , �3� � . ` r .s - ,.:,, r.. . .�./"� .�.� � o,��i', � �� P� :� � � ti . .: ; .� ,.�. .. .� , � , , ,. ; .;�. �. ��' _ . ��. , �,, .....,�a.b v. .3a r � r � r � ,.. . . � , . ,_ -. ,.-.._.T-�.,-�—�--....�.-..� ...,.,..�.:m...-+u -' �"#i r _ . . a�e a��.;! � '' � �.. <� ��..} .,. � .r.r . . . �a �_� # ��,"p �� � �" � ,� >��� �� ' .' 7� z, ' ' t � ! r � �' `�; .� .� ; � �a�u. . T w, /,,,w+Y"'" �„..� .� w_�,> , � .. �� � �� � �� .,�+ � � � 3r� .i !, j . ', f .. , ;�` � ,,, a ,�,'�. ( . .. a,�.�arA 1.. _:t� �z�+:#�.a,S ki�� v� �� �. -- � ......-. �'..—. . 'F ��,�,�..: `.+�u F � �� � � <,�� � � _ ,P a��„,. . . ��r „,.�,A,,,.. ` �' �, „, . , ,�,,_ . � �w , _.�. � Figure 10:an image of Trees#22 through#26. These trees are in decline and exhibit poor structure. Again, note that this species sheds seed pods,which has been reported by Apple employees as a continual,serious slip-hazard. 2337 AM�R1�aN Av�, H,�YVVaRQ, CA 94�45 C3F��cE: (888}969-8733 8O GLENN WAY, UNIT#$SAN CAR�O5,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)88�-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510}6?0-0275 5601 EASTGA�r�DRiv�, SAN DlEGO,CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM ,�,r � � or e July 10, 2013 �" 5 �4 k�P tq i a °'"r � a � �� ' � � �ro '� - , �� � ..� b� Y ����•�' �n1 .���� ���5� ,�¢ . � . P��� . � M���1 e�� �"'R'4"E-,. . . .. . �� �,M�". ;; Y '� S,�.e ' . � . V #�' . 1 � ��� � / ,� . '� . ' � . �Q .t � �a�� �� � ;��x, .',� �, ea ,�"�j ��„�o a y�.,yAb �.��� �;�;�, �''��G. �s.�,... e��l, 't„q;� �B[,. ��.,. �� � �4q� �'.".a:.W�a +�4��" �""' y "M1 �'�'n°'� �.�� s r } . . 9',�''" � .e M �,. � ✓.: � +�c. '��"' "��p.N ,:, .A�rw'�y. 0 p"� ,Jry �{w..,�,��y�� � d �& �y�{, n� - Y' '(p ^j/"' $�"FM�:^�` ,} F���Y� �"Y§�,.p T � ,�� � �y�.� � ��..�.�.�O � �` �.� � ' "�- ,�'A �,,`",''�;��,;.k�, � � d � t ,�»� � ,.!�'�"� � c i. � a �`,� , � � 1a�� y r .a ,«� � ., : �. � �"" � m",,° »� � ��"+�I�� t,+� i"" .,".�P a�� ,� p°� .>+ ''k �%`"' `,�w^�p ��"$� k���'�`r k i�" � �v�`{ �" ""� � ��Y�'S��d�va,F�3,�,,.�W'�1�'� �� �� ,�� Y �ri ��a . y `� t� «'t`� A� �t`� � � a . a�a, ,,�q �r +�a„ �t� � �� •, r �. w,'� '�ro��'��..�. � ;�w�:1." '•` y#'� �.'"`TC,, .�.a r'F� � ' � �`' roa � ^!�".x�� w�4 �'.,�e`s. ��,,` ��6; , � �e, aw "' � �w J�' e �y � � �x' � y� w� " ^+'��" A,�,"!f. ° ., e�� �". }'.��, "� ��'�'r",� �I w .�"`"� �.�, � , �d L�'' `t m, .,r,.'c'�'.�` ._� � M� � �.. �� r� "t��#� � ��` � � � ( `�� �»G y,' � � Kt � 1�.� � V "Dj"'� ':$d �.� � � . , "'�� �: .7 �K:t iaF'� " s� " a � �„�� .�,.: �" � � � � � °� '�� � � � . � � �F °"� �;�` '�t�+ ��'` .. b � ,�« �p� � � �"°rt`a� ,�'��' , ,- �� ���Y �';a'��q, j��T���r� �`� y�"a "�,-�,. ��f�t.w�"'�''� � "fi �� ..� ��:v !°e ,�! '"� aa+� � � /�' �' � l� .� i'C.�'�i� � o +� �,Kr �+��°14�` 1� �/ '�.,�,�� .'i� /`��' qa a . .. � -�'a� . ^I°' �q„',� � +� j � � �. � e"�,�s ���� . q, :n� �" �. y� �� �� „P �>�.�1�' ° ��+��� � ,�"'��� '�,�" ��'n � *� �Y,�a' � �Q���" � � �K �` � �� ,� "� +�dm. ��y ��; a�^a b_ x . ,. .>w. ,+�r�,�5�, 4 p.»� e ,� ",��"��"� '���" �•�„ �� ,,�� � � � � �.�;� "�`� "�g ���� � , , . . � �►S ,. -,� �+ ; '�r �':T «� � � . �,� �'`a, �� ."� �%y�'.y � �,�' ^ .,.^ K y°�'� . �w �p y5�4'�LI�" � k��•. �� 1�'.{l' {, 1 ��� p� '��� l i . � " ��� ��w "'�' � �Yt N`� �z��'�:.; � '� ��°�,:�,nffi�'"� ' ,,'�'��w���s� rt, r.'Y'�' , � ; , �Y �'$ a ,� f��� / cW�F� �r '"�,�7 .. 4'a. ,� y», "„• � � . a� ra► ",�` �,�> �-,� � 7,, a ��� ty, �,��' ��d ��� � � . �. � � � � " � � �""""'r�,'�+ � . r� ` � °�°�' ,,.� � ���Ip'�� °:�° � "� ��.,ti�r .• '� �,�,�` ,�� � f�,,,.'�� .. ;' ,� "°:�:,��*e��*, �" . . �,« •�p »`�r"��s +.. ,. �`��. d�v,„''✓'4�i.�*��"�"�rt�� �:.r. ',r�"�`� � �N"��^"dK4'. ��""� a . � ,�t t . y � m..�"..�. . , < -.. ..��3 , �� � w „�, . :� , k,��,��4 .. . ,�'��"�,'�' �� . . . � , , �, ,, � . +g.- .p ,��yy �.s� d � � w_w � � ^ ' e�ra ,.,a�?�.��„',�r, "" .. . a ,� � � e,.�' . "��,'� .." . � . ..: �.,�.p.� .' � � t� ,,, � .� k` � wr'�"` '�` �� � � �.m{ . � . � '�'H �„ �,ii .�" '� a�. yY�yq �w w^ . ^ �`R s�� � • � �� 1+e � '� �M!. .v 3�.�"lY �o�+y4'�w , x'�+M+ � `g�" ' „ � �� �'�"� ..�w, , �... �°„ ��. y�x„� a�, ��`y,: ,. W 4 �, " � ..,.,, �Y x „ . , > � t . ...r� : . , .,.� �'� .. `. � � � i�! �� ' -�,�,` ,�v�:�r.t.,a�tr*��� .� ����. �„ °o�'" � ��� x� ,� . ��.., � � � �, `�*�""'�.. � . , � , �"� �, � A , �, �.. � ��" .��. ,���,� , . � ��, M� ,.. � a _-� �, � ;.. , .. � #, { ��R ,. ��g ,,,F .�� a�`� Y� � : .a � . , ,y�;iF a . ,; �� ��'� _�>w���� �� � +�" r`" `�R,,� �`�� ��' � µ �; ��'�",. .• ,M � ,� .1�. � �. �� , , �y., �y.8 ': .,�....p f Y �� +3`✓k.� A . +i�, �" x � ' � �,e -a� . � �� � ..wr � � � . '*��,�, 1�.��P,«. �e �x�� � ��yt.- . ,.c 7 ,,,-_, ., . A . , � � K ry� "'�� _ �� ��a�� � `�{�Ril � w. �,,:, �.�:. . . .. . -- � " �";y a , � w. �...�., �.�' � Y � �E , d , . r ��evna�� •• )._� �. w. � . .,. - .. . _ . .... s�. , $$$'� 95 z va.. Pb ' €� � ""�u� . 8����JY 1 Y"��d��i. � �C "V� < w, ���,w , . , � � , �(- � � `� � ;�—. . k , ;: '�wr 4� ��5'„�. . � � =. � , �, ^�•,� ,, ac , � .d4 �,. . �: .., � � �a .� � . a , ; . .,i.•. .,a � i4� � : � � N ���,r`f� 'n �r,� � �� ��� �,: �. , ..,m, � »��� x.?; � f ' ..<s . ,a .�;.-�,"�,�;. + . a,. . �s .:: . �s ,_,. .. . . ,.'. :.. - � �R'. .� �j9,, '��`, �,, � ` , ;: "�` .� �. ,�-, ` ��., � � � �,.: `.�. .� °e � � �� r_ �n � � .t �'r_ -° � . , �., , �; ,' ",�w � �3�^�`� '��?j+� t� , � �_ '•�r � � �� � i ..��r ,� `` .t�"a,'��� ��+� ,;; J,�;, '`� �'�` �t�' ���; A w ^�,.a�s�� ��� ,������� � '�, ��. n � �� s � ;.;�► °�x� �: � w�; ,� ;> �. ; ��� �=, �° �� �� �� > _. � � . . � , :M . > > _.. �'� . � d;3 ,.eti�� ; :���as...�s. .; ' ' :.w.-,. . . ' ,�� ;,���;��:, '�`a;,r�.� `..+... - .,.� , . - ,,,��.- ._ x � . _ � - - � .- , - , .� � ..., . �p .. ..... �� ,.. .:�� � _ ' . .t'°" 4.. �^' �� , %�.f.� � .. w" yx4. "� ,�i7�t.:� . ��YV.��'�' _ N .y� i. .�+�f".d r w. y �.� � m �, �. � '� � ������"`�;��+ _,,. �� ���� �,� , ,� , . �. � ,�;� . � � , a _.. �.�C�7r5'_ ,_ x� �. �� . fl r,� � .„°� � � �'� �\\�ouxa:.k. � „.. . ,„„�. .��...,.�m, --' ' .:, .. „,....��w.. �"�",�, Figure 11:an image of Trees#27 through#30. These trees are in decline and exhibit poor structure. 2337 AM�RicA►v Av�, HAYWARD,CA 94545 O���C�: (888)969-8733 SO GLENN WAY, UNIT#$SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MAiN FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD R(�AD, RANCH�CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM '`►� ""�. July 10. zol� r ar e � �sx �� � ��r � � -a��� 'z - ; �y�. �n�� ���.��# ��.< � �3��3v��� �� ��s�� ro , �#!� �. �'� ��%�` ��� �� �, � ,�, �,�� a r���- � � . �b , J p�� t� f� =�+�`� - .. � ""�"�.��`�g ��t;r�,��' ��a�� ��h : ` ;�r� +�':�' _ � , . . , , . � , °� ` .� r� � � � .� , , .( ',�o;f f- �.. � �,:�� ;�"A�°:,e• ' . . . 4 :� � ,r, , �¢ � � � ,� ; a �g�.,,:� r �i �: '� $k s �� k l ' ��: � `� z �' `� ,. �;�r���� #� (i �"°"' � : .. � � �� ��. ��' ��` ���� ��� >�- �� � �_�,, �, r � �� `#q� ��� -w*,�`�� '� "��� �,, � � � �� ���. �;�� �� a. � �° � : � �� �i�a bj~ � � , �. ��' � •� � �sg- ��t s�� �� `¢ '�� .��a" £�.� '�sa �i � � ��'��.( ��::���..`. .. u������ �' ��; �,'. �a,� ������` ��-�� �� � �*� "� �a d�c� � � i r s�r �'�e Yn"` �.a s�� � ��`& ��� p�i�� u � �� ���� ��f � ��� �����.���.z',e- �a� t�.*.��`�; ��r��YS � ���n ����` � h �x a" .. � f � �: :s- # �. �'� ,�� ,� � � f �y �����������, � `� �Y ��� l ��r���'�-�:ir ;�"'t..£'�� � '�# � �y.y�� ��� � ��' �< � � � � +� #* ..�. � �4.� 1# .:y . � i � ; ,,. . ,: ' � `�' = - 3 - � ��s , � w �F . � d j '� ��' +� � $� ��f ���� ,: , . l „ / ,� �� . ..� ��z,.. , , ' ��$3 . N� ..�M � �,.� � �,���, .F�:� f�g�'a'� . :�'w4 �� ` � ��•"a "� ,` W } �v f�� ,�a f`��'�l��) q�� �' �'� ",�.t�fie ¢ ���n'�w't p#^T� � �.'�',._1 ,�'�.ar~,&� �ro����.."' �.+'�,� � �... � �- . ...' f o : ; . §6 -- 'f ° � �. P,. , ,7�',� 4t,�,yg� �,,,�� �w . , � . . � ��.. .;,;� �°��. � � F,�:� � �y ��, �E � .. , , : , �r� � ,: �. ., d' , � , � �, _ �� ��J��+�r :i��. � �� "'"� � ,,� � � '� ; � . �. � . �y � ` � TM� ,. , , � '� E � ��� R'iF AF' -4 � �>'�w'Rb ��� .� �"k,. ��� � .. .,�� r.�� yv 5���. � �4� Y µ � .r � �� ��; � � � �k,.,, � � e � xbQ�� ��� �� � C �.. ��� ��� ���. sr .y� � f �� � �� � � �^ /' .' �.�`�..���.„m..� ..� v � �� .x .., � �� �� �r �m „�,M� ���.� a� p �: � ,�� , � �W �.`C"'w^�„ ,�. � �'' • +��'a '�` ���� � r" fpA�p.. �,� ��"B� �'^,,;^` �� .�*�. '��d ��'� '���� e ,��� �"1� � �" � �;.' � .�,. '-. o �.J ��.. � _ ' ' }�. �•;�.. � � , , _ �, , ,r� �, � ��, p� . �,.. �, ' ,� ,�. �i AM• � +.` w� �';� , �£, g .a�, r �� � � �,,;� o� � �,- 9����� �a$ � ° `�'�r4�� '� .�g';���k $+� '. . ` �, ,��'y°�'�� � �r �'*' �i� r�s e^ � � ��k� L.���;. . ' � r � 4 . �` � � `' � � � �� � �� ���� ��,��s ��,�� � s�^ ? ��9� � � �'�� s � , s` �k�'� ,s�� "� 'r �C:. � .�, �. � ��., f�,"'. ��d� ��.� ,L' ~ (s� i5 �` .. �.. ��•E� i �.� *4� ;: �6.� ��� � . ��'a�b, ,�t'�,,' K'„�� � dus� � �, ;�"��p� � ,�� �� , � �� � �� .. �� �^'..��\a" �dwt!"' �, AiN' ' .4 � 'Y`'�A+.. �.; � . ,.. :t� ,6� L�„''�..k " ' '� �;«4 ��"�� � A� � �������� + q < �.. �,@,,, � }.e x -r ,� s� y}�n",8 . Q a .-.,. "'s .., ��. � �MayR '�..� .� ��� ; ., M ��� �+ � � y .�� � �v�rv: "' ^ y. ..r'.: , ^ � rt�—,a....� . . '.°�r�"� .., �� � . " � '. � �� ..� «: .,ww�,.:.«..«m . n °w �d � ..,� , � � ., , sa a ,� '. �" ..��; �� ��. �-... ��� �� ����ws..saoM�..� .. :"t' ��.. :5'°x'� .� �. ; . ^ u#, �"�� , `� 1-a,rs� ��'� a* ' �� . F A, � 1, w '�+ � ,.tsy-'�S. '-�' F: _ a �k ":,,, •.. :• x ,..;.,`''� . � " . S P '� �b..�.: @ �� g `Qt .., i ��. �� . �. 'R+... -. 4 i��� _r, . �'._ �� r... , v,.. : � yi �� � { �� Y: , � dt+�." �.������a � �� I c w . � ��� v� � Fn .> ; � � .. , . . n m � - � � `° ���§� ��, # ��� � ��� ���� � � � �� o � � �-� .� t �� ' � � �' �� "i �� ;�, . > ' � �t .. , ����,� _ ; �� � � ��� „�, *�'a�.� 1 �. � � � �� �� � �� � £ �� } �$ ���s � � �'i ��� � � ?�, � �+�,' ,� ?'�;. . . ��� � �- � f _ '' � � �� � ;�'� � �� � � �:� �'�� �� z�� ��:� :� � �n ���t�- � ,. ���� ,�� �� ¢�- : � ��„� �.y,, ' �Y ��`�'������f�0�9�F -`��"43 P.� ��. �i� � �� � .. � .. �.' 'C � �� Ti'Xw k� '� "� `�� 2��'✓P' S� .., *Yl��� � }� !�a.£#'� kp "�, $t`%s 4k �� � � � � �° �y�X��i� '�r� ��.3�-��' ".`z y. ` "pa�. :�,�S` �iy� ;�� � +Aw � � �� �� � .�v ��•. ��. �• �� �a� ����- dM�, �6,���`Y�s h� ��. � � < -�.i3�t?��..:'�` �' � '�'r+�. ; L 4h..� �b+ 5"::£ . .L -'� - . . .. -r„_ _.vs..�,'`s _.., .._,. . ,s . . <.—�`qy. . � ,.. Figure 12: an image of Trees#31 through#34. These trees are exhibiting crown dieback and are overcrowding the adjacent redwoods 2337 Ann�RicAN A�v�, HaYwaRO, C,�9�545 O��iC�: (888)969-8733 80 .C`.�LENN WAY, UNIT#$SAN�ARLOS,�A�4�7� MAIN FAX: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 NR FAx(510)670-0275 560� EA5TGATE DRIVE, SAN D�E�o, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM ,;,i �,.. � � �� � July 10, 2013 "� ,� � � ,. ���'.�' " "x P '"°A„ '�` `.�" „�� ''�� w� .�,� .q °�^.� � ��, a�„-� ��f��:. �,F� w '� ° � ��t ,�, + � , -'�,� � �M� ...�'� � ��`l "^� W^• tf rp�q �csLti�J�a� �,'S� +R��T �. 9"�"�? "'r�a� "�`�'�... �y �� � k (!K' L � �qQ q� �i �p � � , '�YX.�A,$ `h����. x ��"`r# r`��� ° �w� �'�'�' �'� � r+r *�' ��� %:�'Rm. s3���3,.' � � ����a � * 'S `� y�, '"„�j � �`" x,.'�!r�� .��'�"°�q'�?,e�+ � »`'"�,#, I � '��� ��,"�� ,�"�: K `�'�`� W �"` � ��'� i�,.� „� �A �,..�'�.,ec��4-,#,. �-� �' ��I i il i� �l�i II �� �'�''a �;� ,„..� a 3'`�`l��,*����ba t�" ��.,w �w� ��.��.� ,�«�`��� �. ��a� M►��e. � 17i a �J� �z ����� v �4 u.����� � ��` �a �r �. r, �ob s,y, � .,�. e. � � . ° �.��.. ?a '��"��. " ����. . ;.. .'�'�`,,�`"���".a�''b" ,�;..$�.� �Sb.�:"a��� ��+��'�� �!.��"�����a'�°"�^ �:�f � ��.���,a N � ''�°,�,9,"'' " ;���'�'`,'��. "�' r r"=`�9��`�'~" �g ,�"" "+ . ,��r'- �., _ ���5..�. as'S ru�a`�r��; � � '�{t ;�..' .:: .: �"�*�-��.�� •p, �'y`y�,�"Cd�T s °s�.;�cR'� Ae t 4Y`m��.���',�«..�� .-�z�', �'�"1:. '� �: � �* ,'>.�f. ,�,�� �����[',+$� i��, � +5 ^y•"��S"��� .. ��"-�. �' ����`,°� � �K �, � ',j�.�U�nl '��� � �,� �+�r,"�; �:�a '��`r ''.� °� �` �;�. $"�"g u �s, �'�4 �a,¢ � C , ,.v� �- �.� ay� �` �y 5. r.�, .. �s�'�� ,� �� k�. 4� ��'._ �. K.� .�iq". �"'w �°?� � �$g .�� !��%� �f � �^*VN� .' �k����� a.,` � N...��� ��?`�� ��� 4��.���.�.�i.� x, .a;d'�f t a �.�'a'' ..� %3'a'�� "'��'.�� . �,i_ '� �.2,qt '�'° �� a;7�,�.a � °�.". N� , . � �;Y .t ��4�s� �� ,a' ; p <.* ..< � d ^�� ��,����� �; �5Y��,+" ,f�� �r'p} ��^ � -�. ���. �;' ��. ���r R � �'-�� _ �;�� �'����•��.,.� ,��;�- � ,a� �k�, �, �. � °' � � �- �-= a °�„ �, .�� �'. �, �`�_ • �� ,�� .,�.�"� �� �� � ,�.. `� � `�:� � . �y � ���� > �'` ` �� � � � ° � a ,ak f' ��, p 5�-ey>�" +R "��` Y. bp �,. ``3G�` �'��d �q'i4 ���ce i�:�£i _y�+ .� .:„ .a' '� 4 � 'I�. *s ,.�: .'� i'"Y �� �r Y ���c ..,�� .� �� . � � , x .,� s� �YF-� �' A� �..�� '� Y,g ��x�� �"�"'` ;.. _: "'p y��^"��s- • •� . :�>,� b,Fs. :., y� ; , �, �: , . �:: . � • �s�?�' s ;�� a�"�t£' : � ' . +�- �!.,, a �r.::� }�. - ��r � � �� �d �t•.. ;. � "r .�,,:s � 3� �' .� ,. * ,' ( w •,r"' .M1 .,. n� : �..:� ,,( ._.s.- � . . ;.. ��`r�'�.' �... '!� ��� �� '�,f�>'�y�.... ,i. M � As as . ` �� ce . , � , �,�e�c�` �� 4'- .�-1� � ���" � —�rtr;� ,�����-� �. ,.. *_ � - , �� �^-�. �� � ,`� t�"� }�' ` � � .,; � rt : r*"� �,, '��Y s . . _ �� 4, , � X � � ryr �.�,. � f �+ be \..' r y . ". �^ � 'r t� #�p�$�� �p�I r�. .�rv§4 e k.:L i�a�...�'1 y ^R4 n �; r. .yl�, �� I. �W� _} � ��~ �fI � � . '"��*°� '+.�a�m , ���' �` �i • " � *�'• ; ' ` �� � ��� �y�p 9 . ` ...� II 1 � �����: � .�. �aVww� �5-. � ��� �'Q.b eR ' > � r �s �a �� � �',�, /s <-.t P -.- �� y?. �``'• � � � �`��. � �,� � _, r. „ - , < § �, � . ;a � - ��.� r � � :�;. .. � . .: � ,.. .. � s ' � ,, ,� . . .. �. , . . . _ _...,;,,� m ,.,.,,, � ;.. 1� � '- � �', � "w _ � . �� + � �.- � r . ,. ��� , � ��� i p� ., . �.�1'�'_3 � . � » � � .;�' � .. ... ,..: v . .. ' .... � -�a., °-- ` � � ,'�.+�..w+ ,»�.,„„�, ..;:� .�` c . �• � � s i �$ i:, H,; e > � � ....... � _,, .. ,. .. ._.�.� � ,3; � � .. ?4 ;... ''�� �,, *-,�a._..��;� �'��� � r « , � � '�^M-l: i , a I �� `�� G�� � ��� � �� , � ��� �� ��. ' �.i .�,�:= � a �s�'" �,F� ,�" ,'< °-� r"�y , �': n N �' ��. � �, - �l . �� � . , � �����" � � � � .- �„ `s��:+�' ,:� �`�.r.w`» � . aw'M��-';"` r .. f R ��" _,-:. ��. '� �. .� . . `,�Oy�'.� . y:. "�Z'T R"�*� �`?� �s, ""`., �� . � � - � �. � � ��� , ' , . �� � .. � �� '���' r�"` '�� ' � • ��� � T,��- '�, � � �� `��. , � �, � � � � . , . .. °+� "'°";�,"" "" ;� "' , ' � .u ' � .a s � ( < -«.�>.�..5 _T's � . , . Figure 13:an image of Trees#35 through#37. These trees are exhibiting crown dieback and are overcrowding the adjacent redwoods. 2337 AM�R�cAtv Av�, HAYWARD,CA 94545 O�F�CE: (888)969-8733 $�GL.ENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLOS,�A 94�7� MAIN FAX: (510)881-5208 �207 FITZGERALD R4AD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510}670-0275 5641 EasT�AT�DR�v�, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM .;;i •... � �� � July 10, 2013 . . �� � ��� ��� .a�.� M ��7'+y � 3�� ,.��� ' +I�+��,6t'Ca��Y �y°� �" �� YVweRK ,q, �w+k� p I) � �My. .�! �P w* �'. ,� . a M�� � y _ e • � .� .�`. �. �.' a` � +��" a�`�"n � � ` d . .�.-��',. . ^r� }������ �� � 0� . . . > ��� ���:t:, � ' x� ��, �, ��� � �y�94�� y'� � r k '��� ��Y Y�� . �� d� �� � �q� �'., �.� � p��tl�` �. �'•... � ��tl �A .�Y k6� ��i` ��' M§�. y�i. � d�' ,�,er"� � ' �, y 1a` .{�d. � ,. <� . . ' , f ��.��� "��J � �Y "�"�� .. ��..1 B & �' " ��� a '`�� � �. �� .. C�i� �, � , ♦ �y �,' ��a � � .� a a, ���"�.� �'"�,� � � + S���. � ��.. � ��� � "�,a. +�a a> � �� �� . 4�� °�?��. �'w�w .�� �.'� �i3 ��� � . ?'�~� � (�� ,� S{� � ,,.i °o �.. ���y���r�"�'. v 9�� � P m MjJ x �a � {. � �� , }q,�. J' '�� �`� �ay �l•§ MyY,,, �FLt . �.°eT.��T���G��.. �„�'���°��, ��' ? "��� � � f��� �,.�"�" � ����r� -� '� p�L `�. t .� �..,� a ���' +,t �" `i x�'� - ;� °. . . �..�_ � a �� �� �,� �� '' `�' �,f r t� .x ,s � w �,. � �`H ��� �` ��` � �� � �"� �„� , ' c ��� � � N� ��r I ,'�� F^;_ 9�� �� �� �, a�� �P.� ,� �,H� � F� � �ry `� � � �� S � h a E�� �u 1 i e . ��t.� �tA. i.y '�" �Yr A. �"^ � .. W �, ! , x .-�� n. r. . , � i , > �,� , � Y� �.t.. �•.... 1 f .�' ..� ' �� ,±`?'� ' �., F 't �v fi`"` �'p � , � +' � F r � ��, � ��� ��� � . , . �s � . , ,, � ,, � s � � � � �� �, � . ; , � . , .. � ., '� ��, �. , � �� � . t ,y.�� , t,� �� ��"1 � � P�} I I I I I II I �: ���� ..,,r� . � ., .h,..w ..., - �'• I� j $; ,n-sow.�°,..rm,�s*. .. t. M I �� y" ��.. .�. . .. }� � �;�4.W ';d �`�,. � � .�+� �� �;�� . �`�. .:�."' � .. ���45 :��::. � + z�.�s � �� �v' �s�� { ° �a��: � ' F �j�. y % � � .. g'.�� ��i� . :� ��� �R'.. b � �` ' . %��# bA � :� . � ' � '�� '��-. �. 3? # .�� -.... , ^ ''e �Iw����Ilir�i��l�'� �Ii ���'E �t�„ .-°�. �� �.� ,�, . �� f ���� . , .A � ss�.. -� .;. �. � �' ,a�=P �;d K " r �; r�4_` .. +'pr�., � o Ag '„ ,.,. `x �' � S �< 3� 'A � <� ��� �k, g� � � �€s ,.4..,�,., ��� ��•' - � ' , � �-Y 3 x ���°_ ��j ��i.,� �� �; x � 0- f. iY- 'fi r F ��f 'ri s § 4 .;} /qE � '. t .,'i{� ''�' � ' : ;� ���� , ��- '� ` ��y �'� ,�� �W s;�?f?-'�'�`, � fYB. . . . „, �f'#�.; ;� R � if-g�.� �'� ". :� g,E#�`�y �: ��'�� .. .. ��i.,� � � y' zs � 3 �sl b _ s-�� $d.i ' ' � �p`� I � ��� �� z � ;'s�-���,��������'�� ��� 1 4.��`s->��'.;�� .: ? .M v: � p' �+��,. � � �� , Y 3 z��� � ���e ,r r�; �����,f �����;�3��i � c�'.�����rz� � � ,.`,� ,a�.`r_ 4� � �,, ����»�����������.�r�-kt J��cr+f �f�f��$���' �v. '� '� -. �¢ ! � �, ���t:f,�� v`.. '. ;.,ca J �"�s �. .���r�,����r�s�, '� .'i;: `^; .s i 3� �� � a;� ��r r� . 7 I} � !�� � Figure 14:an image of Trees#38 and#39 on the southwestern perimeter of the property. 2337 AtvtEr��cAN Av�., HAYWA�D, �A 94545 Q���CE: (888)969-8733 HO GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94�70 MA�►v FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 Eas�r�AT�DRiv�, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM �'� '�. � �� � July 10, 2013 w ��� ��. � �. ��_ � � � .� , � �. � ;�� .� � ��. wM�,� � �,. b p ��'�� t� .�' V � � i ? 1 p 6 �� ��.� Y � S� ' �� �1 � �l � ���"H����' a �# ��� M� � ' � ��➢ � i�'s+ ;�« �,� a� �: �s „ ., s . �. ; - ; ' P" �' ����� �" �`� ��` �� � � � ' a �f ��'� � � � a. �, � � ,A� �• �� � # tw �� � ."� �"r '�� � �,� �}� � _„� � �' � ; : � �. �� �� `� � K�� �;� Q, � ,� , ' 4,�. � 11"�' � ,�#a � � ,; . �� ; � �� �; ���,� ; . � ... ._ �. � � e � ��� r. � ��'�' � �"� � a� �' i.�y� k� '��t ���. �q� 'q i � �' �.� • p��. A" , �. � �� Q ,. .d .,v. � � �� � � k�' � �,� _�< � �� #�, �. ., „ . �, • .. ;� : � , n a � .,.,... c � , � �,,... �•- �, � M•�e, ��µ �` �� .�,_,...��e.m. , , � � " �,M , ^ r, : a n . �"II�"""MYY�...,� ...,... 4 .. S � ! � � F � �1. ; u�j;. � $ � � ' � Y' �" ,x � �`3 .,..�.. . ..�.... .. � . .w.T���', y ... . �- w. �..,., ., �_�.. . ...�". „ . � � � e. �....... . ,... . .�,.. .. —... � �ge � .. .._ r..yc�. , , � �� �� �� � ��. .�-. k r ��,. �� t^�i�* � " `M,.P M ; . .w. . m "� � w�^„,.4 � , � rl'.r�� . �'k.a t �,� �, ^� * t s �+e^ , a �.°Ya ��T�.'. _ q ����.��,Me„ar«'c"•�a��^�"��m �. �" �, .�r�� � �� �� . ��.. ._ _.... w...,�..� . . �, � «;� t �, �: �' ' ¢ �� �' b� . _, ���`4 �r..� .a�*�� �&, " `w . � ..�y��. .�. YPe�, ,. ,�,,�{;,..- .��:.r.y °'�4 „�' ,t � t' a i .��'�i ,���� ;,..'-,' '�1�. ,°�� �.�a�4' "�"ro�. �. '�� °� �;�� �� . � l�� " --- � ' fi ry �: �A` ^'� -q4y �;n.`+�.�.� .� ... sq' < . ` +,� � �e te�- �r`e . . . . � . ' �� g`� � � � ��� �+ .. � � �u ,�_� . �,� �« ��� ��.�;� ..�� ,'T.�DA �f� �� �� , �� ..,.� . � � � '. �� ti;':: , � w:, � . �.�q . ,. ..,�e a, ..�e ..�. , �t ,.... „. .._. . . . . .. � y.a �4:PN _r. o . � vn...�.. E,. ,L Figure 15:an image of Trees#40 and#41 on the southwestern perimeter of the property. 2337 AMERICAN AVE, HAYWARD, CA 94545 C��F�C�: (888}969-8733 80 GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CAR�QS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: {510)881-5248 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHt��QRDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 56�1 EASrGATE DRiv�, SAN C}IEGQ,CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM '`.� '`► r c�r � July 10, 2013 �. �,��, ,�� �� s� :� �. �� �� �>�� � i � � � :�� ���� �.,' ��� N�������� `� , ��`�,,� � ,� '�p��'�,���a� .Yi�� '� tl . �kb aa� `r'Y . . � . ' ` X ,�B k xr:'F ��`?t � �a� ��.. �3� . �A � 0.4 db"f . y��"�°..$ � # ^ y�. i g fl a`u� �w kb � r,� ��F R�� ;g� .�, . . ( ..,' �y� , � �c�� �„� �`.. i � .�� �@bg ,����.y �m "�� � ��t ) � �@ � � �� f � . i� .�,� d;.¢, i i` &�� .i� � ���a ��� �y`5�i �� �} � k RR, L* � �#;i•�y Z���+;':�� d� ,?�p��`�& �: � +N . . �. �. ����� f�� � ���e `�- �� ,�� �� ��.;,. � y4*�, �f'�� °��� �r} ��,�� � "�� ������ �� r'°�J 4� a,J�` w a%� � °� � " . � e ���j '��.��. �� , +t y E�< � dp a, 'q �+� ' ��y�� �'� c�e•� ..� �� � �"��*��.i i}� a�� � �� � �5� ��� ��' .. �"1>r� � .p�> .fa �� . fi�e�i'a�p����1 A; . � t � �� P � s"r n � • � �� , � �.� �a`"�C .� �f ��;� i.�, �,�„ �� �[ `Xa � t7��D , � �. ��' �,� � � �r }� � � "� "t F� � �k � ,���! j ,� �,;. )�� .a � , , ��� � ;a g��� � � �� �'� y�� d���� "��.�.# �� �` F ���`+" ' # �'" z � +. ��r+A1�;� , + �€� �c$�r�� �,� }: �3 d �� , � y �' f` , � � �,� N r� . . y � ,8.#�.; �� .;�,� � 4 . �e y�, . T��.` r� t. I� ��yy �� .��y p� '�� � @ . . "�+�""'4 w,,.,,� �j� �� •d ^e.».„ Y� .... , `��cJ � ._.„, ,.. .,�a �. , , ��'5- .. S�d 9 .. ;. ....� ��4���-. �, ....,�� .: c�, , � ..�r^... $ 't. .. ... , T ��-; } .,,.,,....w.; .. ,.....� - . ,.,...,.,,x:� ..,+e,.,yp. .�,.�w�.,.,^x ..... . . . . � n �«*.wmw.eww*rvs�, •. •. ��Mw�.q e., r�, r�.......... . ,,... . . �� .. � . '� � . �.. �.... .. .+'.... '�. ,. . w py � . ���. ..... -� .. . .. ....'`„�k.... ' z"` , 'r { ,�� ��� M q, � . � N � � �tl^...._ x�'"` ,� �,�_,; 4 J � ry�' ��. 'r � '� , "t, � �, �., �#�" , 7� "'� by � ,�.p.. � �.°`� �°� ,�i�, �x r e �. ".» N� 'a a, k' a "fm � . � ���r Y� � � d F ,s� *°a.�. � �� '9�` '�L.;,B�' ,..,.... �� "�� �a�� �`*�` '.;° �". �,. �r � �, , J� a� � , , � . , �� �� � � �� � .� "�� &�,�. '�x �� °M""' � ., � � .. � � k.r�� '�,a r= ,,�� �s,� � �Y� , :"'�'^� _ . fi Y $��Y �'�� �� _ � 7 �9i% , n` f� � S �c �,. >. "� �� ��� �v: �;��!4'�, �},�' �`�y;; i.. .r '��.`f f �'� �: � �ry 't„'t.qL. .�;� �`v�'�-� .. � �3 .�� �"A y� ,i�. a"e`; P�a,�- �. � y�qy�'��-� � � � � '£ �� � � � � � � ��J 4 ,���5 �; : ,� �g a��,� ,s t, �ur ���� � a� � 'M�f�� „b�'�`aw'� i1�, �.. . . ..�M� �P :$�'f�. R"'3��.: � i;��y�,w`lda��� P� •�^ , 'y[:. � � .. �Y�'da��`� n� � n� � � �� 15 ''"" `` A�g �� �g �<v�` �" � ,��.� 9 i � � s; �� ., � � , � :.: , , � �,.. �� �.. a �����,f . e � .-. �� . .:,._ � }F� - � �� t � � a p � � ,�,� , ,; >� �r > q � e � ,�� � <� � f � � ; : ���� ��� � � � � ��- � �. �. : k � � � r�� � �� v ^ „ ��� � a °`�:�� �� ;��, � � ,,, ;�', �.� �.� ����� , �,,,„ , „, - „���''��,,'^� �`� .<�`,*"" � �,. �. �: � „ > �� � „ ��,„„ . �n,y.,,�. • ` fi.,>n +'.� ° Figure 16: an image of Trees#42 and#43 on the southwestern perimeter of the property. 2337 AME.RICAN AVE, NAYWARD, CA 94545 U��ic�: {888)969-8733 80 C�.-,LENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94�70 MAIN FAX: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510}670-0275 56O'I EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEG(a, CA 92121 www.ARBORWELL.COM ,;,i ... r or e July 10, 2013 � � � ys�+� ,�°� �� f r ''!� �� �'�� � � , �� �, �a° „� ,�,�p� � roi rD r. � . � � ',.�`�r., r� �,.��� ��'�,{..�,'��- : .�h,^2't a �` !X�,�6��,�M. d �. � .d 3� �v .4 � �il � �„�. . ' �d 1� ..t . +j, J.�� / � V� � .a ��... ✓ ��y° �,�'.Y"i�� d ,p"'�f Y ,��. P { :�.y,LL6 �� +�S�.�' � Jb .r a'i� 5 +�x u p�w ��.. y�,p, ,µ,� � Y�`% G�d'o, `�1�� � � . 4 S � �Y„����� �E°d"° `T � AC A . �'.> "+�7 f ` 4� � °a'�"'� ,',�'yu ° o-d;s�c 'e°"� �:�+y;!;,�r�l �, f ��� .,'y- � � fi.���� '" '� �^� .y„� .. ��� � '�''!� `� .� �� �€ #; �`��4 r�.�q���� ��'q',, c°a�.° ��{°" M���^��•� ��..�� �( ���g R� � �s �# � �� �t� '�t � �°4,. c � ��, , '�/r� {� �r g; '"." �*' `. ��rc� e %� �;�+��,kR�,�a�.�W����d a, �` � ' # >. �'E`t�p' ��. � �F 11� � d„��•. ;A .a � � s'" 0. � r, d qp���AM� � �� Y.�3 �� �/ �� .� ,� t �� # ��� $ � p, f,�„'f:,Ai�d sY���'�fi{.�.a.F��, +�e�+1��` d y^,��;1��Rp � �R',� ��. ,' � + �._ �, .'; w �' ���* ��a�p� �, � �x �:��{,� � y �J��k 'f r� � ,% �� � L� �: � � ;�, � ,� r �� ��,WE '�� .��M Y� { w'��4M�� "F� ���Y� � + � � �.� � s � x.. �� \,�, � (��N`�� J+4 .. �. � �{ j�a' 'f� �� �N � �� � � � � � � r,� �.�r��,� � ��« � ' ,�,� a�:. �� � � ,� � �� � }�� � � .; .� , +^°�'���i ,v�� a w +y��" > -� � y°3 � { . 7 � ,� °m+' `P'K � 4 r � �� �' � t '�` # _ �, i �ka^�i�,��,����� 'a�" y"��� 1�� ���q �q� �� t-; ;�� � ' I .� � '� €. wz >'t�� R �,�,}'�.��� e ,,'�` �. 1,� # , �Y"' �" ,�. � i'�p� ,q�,§ `: '�t u;:� ��; � s . , ��'*' �, �"`°p' �•'►+��^ ' ' ;��, ,���" ��` .�pA � t•.�+ '� �I w.3�;� '���'3�� q ` �,„� k ..:, i. `'� ;��'�'� '��;/�w"iL,, � ''�,r' r ��i ,,.� �x�` } .&�, � �r�,� . c �'��� -�v ,� �,' ��� � '�°�"'� z�; '. 5 ,;�li� �'� a'��#� � � � ,� Xp��6 , �� 're�^�p° y� ��v F�rk#�� e.ro� ��a. �' :�,�£ .� ��� �-� 4s, ��;�" m,„�`"n ,� $' �� � .� § �. r� ,�� �� A .� x �� � � �� �` � r�. ,� �'��`'S"' A"Y��;�""�' 'p�p �"°�,,;P' � ��� ��''£���,y �.� f� + �� V.� '��� ; t�'"Wc '� �tl�. :':,9°�aW �`"Y ,�� �Y s � .x-• °� . � l-$ : ,�`':, � � �. r a tl 2 �r P '� �'��`'� �" �� �'�g ��.. � �'�`'"� � ���,� �*`�� . � y.p� a F � ,.�t � . �° w+3� '� a: : f �� ��b �.�. 'r� J*` �,��. ��, � �F ���+ ,.��� ���� ����¢�eh�;�{��X��� 4°� ���,r � � �3�, ,� ��� � v * 4t A�-� � i i � � �p -' �� �' � �" z� 9 .�[�� y: � � '".r .. �~�,�,� , tl��a w.�S�E, � �� ', ��`i�� �`"� ��'� �-. 7 �T��yy",� ��ai�`.. �y�. � �� �� ��. .'�•�� �A� �'� �� �,�i -'tr� � �f � �P�r°Y�,��° i�.g�.�� �-��:. t �_���t. r ;t y� �j �}F 9 a��an. �"� f� �- �� �Y Y# '�.�. N� ,�/ ��4` y,. ..� r:fi3 . `� 'S.y�> �y4i�.-� � �.- �� �' � ��.� ,��a� �� �' ' � �r. ���f �s� . ��'�� �1 �` fr ��'r.�.. � J � '��� i �■y� ; �r. � � �`�' k «^��`".�. � ^���µ �.����. � �f�� k .'��� " �r�� ' r ��-��;s � � `�r,i � � � � � �. `. � ,� ���:��� �� �� •",�*.�'. �a� ' '� �' a.,A,��t s� ,�� � , � ,� �E' �+ '-� uae, n n1i .��aa .. .��b� � ��§; � � +�c s � � s�a s,�y $ �� .. � c�_ �r�� � , � � ��' � ��� � � ' � ��' � � � ,� {�� '� ` �t�`��` '��:� �`�� �, �,, "',� ' • �,r��,*�� � � ` �' F. ���� � ,� ,������� , �,��',,(' � �` ��� .. t �� Y ,y t � F � � �a' , ; � *�. - <.*' r, '� � ��� # � � ��`''� � � �� ��� � ¢ � �'- �; �"`y,° t' x� � :�fr � � � � a„�� ; ^+ �� � f?''v z # � �;; �� �. ����je� =�i. N � � k �� �� k L. 6 � , � � 6� �- fa'�� j�� �'{ �% '��$6� �"�. 2° : �,�,,f � �, .� k ��.. " � �' � # Y.� ��� � � I i � $ �;„�.3"-,g:7���� '�„J�. �§"� 'I llf . `� i '�^�'�. � s'�' 4� ��o����3� � �� - , i ��,�£��' � m�. �' � ,� ��� � .,. x�' ,. , . : � � - � " � , : � , , � � `,� � � � �m i. � � kY L ry� � 6.r '�3 S .;. m.,y� � � � _, j 4 � �-'y..� 3f�A .,*�.. � : 6 .y ; �iF� ��- s`f� J�` � h . ,, ` �.-�l � *r"mr ; �,� �I� ' ' ' �?� �,.. f � '^. ., 4 y�ue � -.�� � e . , , ,_ r. . ,'.�. i' ' �� , r», y_ xL , 3,..8,�r�'. �' r� � . : .�.� •��,�£�. ��s+� : .� ' �� �a".d��- �� '.��.,. � ''y � , ` �_.:� .- � I � � �l : S � �,s. � � �,y .: � � . .% . t . Y .�k � ys,j��..�� �$�s��� $� y�t/ ' �. ` . � .��y£ �� ,� � �^*.L. �� 5 }�j����111 E{ �. �����'� L 1���.�,� �3'?�� ' � y�� y -Y � j r�s-� ���� :'�:'-� 6�"� u(��.�. ��`�"aa. � ��� �����F �� e�N�- _ .. � , . y � �: n��YY��'},. ... �" .�i�.";, _. Figure 17:an image of Trees#44 and#45 on the southern perimeter of the property. Z337 AMERICAN AVE, HAYWARD,CA 94545 OF��C�: (88$)969-8733 HO GLENN V1IAY, UNI7#S SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MAIN FAX: (510)881-5208 32O?FITZGERALD RC�AD, RANCHO�ORDOVA,CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5641 EAS�rGar�DRiv�, SaN D�E�o, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL,COM ''� '�. � �� � July 10, 2013 � �� � � ����, n. � � � � y. ��, ��� 5s � , � t� � � ,�-� �;'".'� ��, w�I" � � e� „.rf����yt,�f� t, �y♦.�. �. � :��, �.... � ..):? �.� .9 .,.�. � � 1 Il,...y . d`y.� t :-i a�� �� � . � f +`F, �`- " �� x,_ a? a , �� � � ������ ����� � ' �� z ��� . � � � ��� . �� � �� ��. � _"'���'�,� '�`�+� ���� �,�� �� �`� � ,� .-�k �e � �� � �, , �. ; �, '� �i' ��ft, $ .�✓fi �� �a �."r �.>. �' . a �' :���P�.�, �' � g� "- � . y �� �"' ..� r?, Q� � � �+6 � � � $ ` �a ` ` ����. i4 9� .��, '� ,. � . �,�'� ,,{� � � �= 7� ����`�_�.,.., -� �a �`j� � �` r"� R � /F���� �: � f.�� �� � "°� �» � � '° � ����{ �� '� � ��r�� � � Y� '�— � � � � � �, �r ,� ' �� � 1 �� "' '� ��"�: ?�,� , � , f � ,��1 }'': � `� , � �_ {K. ,-} p �,� JF... 5 � .� W� � � +� t� � � _ k� $ C, � �` � '�F �� � �'��� �t��� '� �^F ��p x � � g�5� ������ �/ �� ��'. ! � ,Ir��f+, �� u`x ��� � � �. �, F � _ �� �', � �'"� �� � � �� � � � , , ��, 5 ,,� � t � ° � ,�,� � z a ti ,� � �`'��`���` ; � ����,�'�� � ;��� `�` �,� a. � � ,"��� �� *�"�g�H' � �� �� � � ��.�;������'��`�. $ t�...` y; ���,�,,� �w, b � � � �, �`�� �—��� '� ,�, �,,, � � �/� .. � • �t�; �rtg Lg.,�:e e , ... � ��'�, . rx��_; ��.,i��� a�� .�M � ,, r',d� �'�. '�° j - � '�j �n/ � 1.�� � �`E � � �� � � �5;� . � � , ��,� ; . ���. � ,,,�� p. � �,�;� � , .:� � ,. , ; � � �� # � �� � �, � �, 1, '� ' � �'��`"� �. � �""� ���- � .�. + .� ,� � �, �. ¢`, '` f �'n � � �".. � � � � ; � � � � �� � � � �� � > � ��_ , � ,. : �, > . , ' . �,,�,.�;„,�.� .,,��`��t�� +�� ,,, �».: s� '�"� ��' „ ��, ��,u _ . «� ��� '�: :� x w +� � ., h k � ��} t�� � .: , 3 �. �' � r .� � � � � P � i �Y C��p �p�� �4 �^A k �"�� ��`i��..�� ���� � t �Y ' � ,�.. � ". '� .. .��e � � _,; �w�� � � � fr '^',: .� . �U� i �r �E. ��r ����� ������ ' .. � ��, : r -�. ,�. -�',�.e�a�A%:�'° :. . '���� �`��..�.� ' ...... w, r � . _ . .� ,. � . , �¢ a �� ,. ; >. . � c� , s -�r� , ���� ; ,� �� m � � m. "�r , � � a -a ,�� �� : Y"� "- � .. «•�e. s�. , ..2n�2- _ � ����~Rt« , '� `�. c�� � +�� �� �f ���� 3 �w � *� �� � ., � � € � H ��'s �:F �"��.� �`��:a'�.�'`��'�: � . �€�',.. � � ����� �� �, �w A,, s��,# � !1 q .2` , .y..,� � � � gR � e ,.a �+ � N ' � :f . �� � ! 3` � "�" � �S,�' 4.s�, E � � ������� , t..' .. � . � � ��Ki`^r�'t"" ,�'� �'::���� +" I -c� � � 5' � � kY" .:.I. � � . ,.,;,. �. �'� . , � . � t; ,, . .P... ; . . , _ � .l , �,,` u T. . �� ., a r��. ', � - ° , . ,.� �• ,.a�t" '�. � ,. . ., .,, -�-�_ '� ,..-. -�-'- " , "�- . . ._ . , .�,u^ ^ . � a . } .� � ' �3, . �. ^+ � �Y . ��. �` r , .- . .: . ... �.. s. .�" � >s � 4�s. � n �, ` .z` s�� � _ ,� -..; �'���.±:. , ,.' ., . . . .b , i:. �< . ..,. ' � . ' . : . e�. �s�: ... �r� _ . . .. � , ��. � - � , . , f � m, � r � , t. ���«s;- '� r� "t- �, m� . .R. . ,. � . , s. �b;.. ' y s�. ��'3`����°s��+£�`t� "On+`�`rc � y � 4 � Nr � � .. .. ��� � � j �.� ' ��� � " R a3 S° '€��� ' �'5' -� .�"� � . . .. �$���,..w£ �CC�y'4�3��yeYY`. f : ' � ='�s���&�w-�"���.+�.,� �,����'F RR ��4� �": F - . :-; ��,, � , y '�.��`�+4�,'�"' �����8 t. ? .�� .- ' . '�c��y�� �e }[ ~f 4" �}�f .�, ,� �Y' �. - �,�«.�,.�x. ''�a;£� ,a,%��%-�A� ''Y°�,,?���+ �.;.,� � x .�,�.��$ ,�'�,��_ Figure 18:an image of Trees#46 and#47 on the southern perimeter of the property. 2�37 AMERICAN AVE, HAYINARD, CA 94�45 CJFF�CE: (888)969-8733 8O GLENN WAY, UNIT#H SAN CARLOS,CA 94�70 MAIN FAX: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO GC)RD�VA,CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 56(?1 EAS�Ga�r�DtzivE, SAN DIEGO,CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.CUM '�►� ''\Ir. r or e July 10, 2013 „�' M � + � �r� ,�� „�'�, . �� *���'` �`,�� i�„, "� "��.� �� �' ° � �� w ���r���� '� �'�' ��"a�,�� ����±„� �m.�, � 1 '�`. "b� � � ��w � e y.. a' a a ,� w..`�v �' � "��� ��'t �i,+",v,rM�pA y a° �n ��� �''. �,� ���' w f ^��4 + �,, a" .`d �r p d g,r+-.^°"�$r«t° �� ��p ���s� ��e "�"`5��r� ���4r �o Y" ^�•`` .'� v � �h� S � 8 �p"° w. �, a� ,r e a�`�, �3� � '�'y . ���� ti.§.er �i���s'y � . � ':Y� �tF �;�' �+y+�yg�;,� ..y+�'p',� O�ra.`.�p' �� t "`$�A �e�a �,. �6 9 �,�4 � j t�. }� ��`*�Y' a � ����� �+�� '��1 :;� .�r�� � „ �� "��' �x d � �> ;w ��� v�j • �� '�! � �� '"����.C•. ,'�� "r 2 � S�s .}'.�`, i �K i' .'1u�."Y�� d' �e i {,�� b � . ��m R ���� �iY-��.,.�{' � �V k 'dJ' A /I. ` �S � '�x ���` ^s���� •F'r � r'�r�` �.M�•F��µ �µ �'j��Y.��� 4 ����A�y°C�yr°�'�� �� ��.�� �y'r '�� .V.r � �i� ;^�*����^ M .i.{,,,��Y��+*�.� �r6�A� r��1}a�l�� ^ e ���.sa.'p �•�^'�`t$a'S`� � t�r�����`� i� a9� ;� �`Sr� �5� 'p. ,i � � y�.�v! '� .�� �P' "�,�""G*r� y Y r� '� � 'g :. � f, �`a t ��.: �a *��� ;���,� s � �! �`� �"���`� t�� � q ,�°�M` �4,i� d'��""' y� .t �:-�� 8 � ,��a� i �, � S sa��.' �d �' <g� ;.�,\1rj �,.,••--...^"'"' ,� �?r � .�w a� � � ����l������ 4�x���g��� ��t � ; ��, F �p^«�,.,+ ,. e, . y�� 4��5(�"¢3i r ' ' :�. r��g �`�'e�4'� .j���qoFy.yi°. ,��� R�,'�,+ � �.`s � �' `--a� ��^ ^�� ����j � k, .4��s {� F' b e �� \ '1 B� �r N�'pa'� i�•f a { °' ' . r ' °� P i��� ,� A 5,"� �'� �� � ��"�y � , .� �v``4 ,W +'. ' '�'s,�� �1 � 'ek`',�� .'' � '���� � �4`+ �`'�`�����:'�� t� ' �� ���yµ. �'""�,�#�'� r, `�e: . ��+, �' ~'� 1� t _, Jt ��' `� q. �x � #�.A'•��._.'�* � � �.T', �,?��.�'� ��q,rdy, � � j° b � � gfw �t: -X� � A . .$�M�� �' � . `� �y3� �7 � ����°� �s��. ` � � �. q� �e, ��� � ��. � �j'� �. � � �, . �i � a� � f�7� . � �� � �,�k �� �� & .d 3' y 7 7I..y,�p� ",K� 3Y�t. Z i ; � � � � .4 �' ',�' �'&Y' �. ��f c ��. e r , k $�,.�� }"� q, '�r�� t�e '� � '.q � Y R`� .., ��'X, ���'a � �r `/ �b ��T��}� ✓ �.' `'� � � � �f���:� � � 'b .tt � �� � ��, � a� y� q w`?� ., ., ��{�; � Q-���,{f j �, 3 3��tA• ♦�d5T'@ x�� ��,a'y�, j �l.t� � �',� � �a Y .a� ax'����q F�ra t$d� ��� s��y�t #a ' . � ��^�.,���{�;r,�, ��*'�,4.�6• 4 ��'��,.., `�8 ; �`�'s��°M«�"$ t N�+ � t � J"��4 � � ���,f� } � �- � "a4d ,.�a a';to �x � `� 3 3 �'�5� � ;1� .i �','�i�t >t �� `�+ !� � a�� '�' v � ��s, r $ � o- ,�� � ��; `'`�' *`�" �x � .� �, x a, iya S�,^f � �,� ��''q R �'a � f� e"����«�r�.n��" �:#�¢'a�''[ � `� �. ``'iy7,���(`�,� �J p� � �. ,�; �t°�_ 9,���.� ��4��� ,�. �1� .2'�F��!`s�" ���tj�, �t�y�, �#�Y}�� �� M1 t•S �b�,y��� �2 d6r s.�.v, '� � �t �.�� * ���'i t ♦ ��� 9.1i. py,�" ����;' ��. �"�a�.r q �� w��j ��9.a s �r,6� � � �,��� � �a,d�+r� � ���, ����r 9 � " �ry'� � Q ,,�."'�s 'A' ! '��.. �e,��,� �'� ��.. �a� '�x.,,�,� �� �`'`a� `�f`'�,��r+�t��r '� � �{; ; g°i:t#`����+ �� a � ����v���.4 k�� +� t 4���'�' �.� '% ` �`�f ' �l���T�.. .J � �f ;k� i�� ' �� ,� �� a3 � � ! f ; � ���' ��� W� � ., �,+�* �.� ,� z�� �.� � '1.r� ,� �}[� +' `` ��a,�. h g " jp ,.,� �� t. � .�`H�,p..��,..�+k R,��yj_ 1F ��g� "��� � 4a '^4,��� � ,� -s� � �q�� � a��� ��� � �� d�+ #�����'9:�":� ��`�. '� y,',J'k� P e . �� -.'F 5 �'# e��� �"� ' �✓� d e�ige� v .�,.,./ � � 5�,��� ,q b � �� lti, ���l�y� $ t,dy�. �� � '� �� b�N� AEt � S�' � � ' 4 ,yta (������.�g��y� � ��t,�`�.� �v�� �x ��e � '� t��� �_� �. '� ;; �� ,n. � 3� ,t. � �� % :sg �,�� ����a ��',�n �, � ,,a � x � ��' ,,�• �� `a �.«•� � t„ �yy`i`4+� �' k 5 e� 5�'' � �' � �� � t:'" � K1.����' �� 7f� �" � fi��� �� I�� '`��g��t ♦. ��'�L# �."'"�"1�� �'f� 4 y„�+�"`� w�''n, � , td> � j�� � ��or'�3y>=' ��_.'�iy � M'� #"f �.'� ��- �,3'...' � s�� a����R�������"`�: a - '�� `� � c��8' ,�t ,t� -�cp�y! a d^f k �e Sl�f. r� �� �`:� ��<1e�. �� ���+"�� .�}� 9�`.��"�;��r ;;� �� � � s, �` �' �y �� -� �#r;v �, 'y,` �� `'��� �¢ �$�%�. .,�k ... .�� k �'a '� � } • �� ,��-,�'�t '�ia�? � „'`a'�; `�•� �s�. �� £,��,��t �a ���{'�8. .°��.tr�q��d' �.���. n � � � ., , x . `9 � � � �h { t.� .S ,. ��� � �� , `�- ab�p, �y� � ��. -�' ����y��.�. � '� ' s;. � � 3 "q ..... ,, � � a �" � ti B. x- F . # '� � '� " � ��jF 4 F# . ... � . „� a �� �r3, r' ��1� 1 r A3 ?q��`f'� . ,j ����,� � a����'� �' , ,. : , , v .;� <. , �-�'`°°'"+e,.- `= , . , . , � �.�=s�,�"� .. e ;L`:s a�,� ¢ �� �,?�`S�`+E+' , ..., . . � . . - . . . � i � , :� . . .�. .. . , �g�- �" ; �� � ��� i � � ... i��� sr: . i � -�� � � � � '` '� ; `_ � � � �� ,� � � ��,�,�..: ` � � � � � �,��: �� � � . . , : ; ��� � � , ; ,� ,. � . „� � . , , . � ' . -Y- : � ; - .. o�.- ._ � �,. ; � .. ..'=µro'�'R1:C"' � ��„ �� ���.�''r i"!' �� � k� �` �4. '� � �b � � e�..�`� N � �� ��*. . u�^ , ��� ,"�, "r�� �� , ' , .,:� . «.«w�q :.,:. . . . :� �. '. _•� x�s. �. . ' ::�xi.'��v��.� '`"+` 't� ...� {y u� ^.`�w. "`�^'� �i� �' �„ �' '� �"� `� «^ �` 1p � � ��. �� �, �, j•a� �r��� �� �,.'#a��� U ^�� � uy,����'. 4 . .„% � ,�„ ,,,�y . "�'`�`` a�'�w' x�� �q ��v, ,���`�� ��l• ���`�«&, � � r .« ��:x<.. � � �. �, k � > . ,-. , . . � �� - . ,,., '`. ,� _ � �. �a �� .,,� e ° �� ;' ' '.s, Y� �,'f i ''y� ��e"^ �.....,��.�,*�.� �. "� .r � Figure 19:an image of Trees#48 through#51 on the southern perimeter of the property. 2337 AM�R�cAtv Av�, NAYWARD,CA 94545 ����C�: (888)969-8733 8�GLENN WAY, l,1NIT#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MA►N FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 F17ZGERALD ROAD, RANCM�CORDOVA,CA 95742 NR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EAST�A�r�DRiv�, SAN DiE�o, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM "'�r�. ''�. .... 1 �� � July 10, 2013 .J nK �� "k�. � e . � �r „�,n e a �. i � ��.,��M � �.. �"' ,,a;�; � ,z" +'` .c '1F� �"'�.� �,s��'n �:w ���� � � �a �� ; � � �i�" ��� ! �� k� � 1 +� � �{'�'�ra,�� S f�$�k*�a�' ''�� "' °� a � .�xr p�.A '�� 3 �p�G�. 8z�::�� '�$,� '�'�g � �`�"L'���� ''Y�'d ;r��:�'�� .K� r�� i q�,G��`'YP� � ,+�,,.k��,�� �W'�aw ��04"� .. � �° �.s� F +" � � � � � �,� s,�� �( �3� ��} � .,�f , rs �, ,�. }, � '� .�� r � � � ��' '�;�f; 0 d, v�;g7�' ' '%a����a .. ° .i'i�� +�, r � '� � �" �L :4':�� �M���� � �� �' w�� �� �r�^ ..�� � �� ^� ���. � "' � �! �� �„��a' �,l.�d' .,� �` �i� ,a�.�i�*�. t�� �� , �y�-. �'S . . � � � �. > < ' . :� �,,. , ��� .,p � y� � � . :4 < ; �,,. -. �, .:�;r � i. ,� , �- •'�xrer . , : � � a i �� � � " �P b 4 ti � y, ,�p "' � �� ''� � ` \« j :"r. ` �'a � � f', �p � � �, a.#A ;� �'hw� ���t�'�. � ,.�� -ar..., `"'�., t "� v'1 4e ."�� .d"' � +, �M ���' '�d 9, i 1 �j' �� . ... � �'. .. k� � � � , ' ��s. �� �, � � a, - �� p� � , .�kr� n,y '� Y� � ���� . ; � � �3� � �F_, ��,. � �ylZ� ���3:��y. �, '���� ��� j J � � �.: Ptr� �4 !�. } �., n }�'S �«������� 4s�4�<� ' ��. '€ � �,��s' � '�a ,d� .. � � . �w('�R4t'a �-� �''� C� ' � .� � .��tz�.` - [�� mr-��-,. �� � arj �. �y��r�� y+Aro �_�,�' q"��s �F� ''�'n�s- �" a Y,��'. , �,� . �..,; y �.. _r.w ,�,� y�. $ .kL ,� ��45 1�'S�ri �" � ��., Fr'�a1-��r. �y � �a. � . _ .� y�,. '� -$w." � � �: r' , t �%,-'w���t z�`� �%� :.. ,.�' . � �' '`� �� �°. �� �� - r � 'y� �t ,.� � �3*-< � ; t x , ��� a i�:� t ��;�-�-v �,. �� ,¥�t� �' d�� 3 � `� _ . � ���.n �� �� ���� ���� „� t " , ; "s� �� i"�..+.` �'� � � �"r`'�"�' .'¢��h��€�"�'�` �'¢i �` ,;;:. Figure 20:an image of Trees#52,#53, and#54 overhanging the parking area. ,,���< < ��� ���� :,�r ,� ���. � , � �,� � �, � m r� � ��, r � � � } � ,w '`=�� r , "'� ;�"w � � �`' ,¢:� �u r������ � ��rt �«� �'�'�� � ����� . ��` �� �. �' �� '�� m� � �. ,� » w . .�.��5,r��� ,��� ��° ���,�� . �g� ;¢°�,�t���,���,�'� ��� y , "�1� .it�t f Is ...5 9 P } „ 9�� 7") �y"�n' � �,p�A^+�'� . �T�' �., x� �)` ; f a� � +"� .. �r"°f� ' � � x. � $ ' �' .�+'� .�Y "�.. �"y�1Y�.�. k^ � ,�r M1 +'J` � "°�I � � �'�a,�'i+�� ,,t �r� f t ���1 '�" �°: ',�,'�r �i. �1' �,3,,,.A�� � ��°,t� ,��.��.+'��r�� �� �� y�f r �s�? `� t .� � � " p,.,�°°`� �r�'� '� ��5 �r�A j AJ N�d y� � sv P.... y �R 'Ko .v,�' +� js� (1 � � ��` , J^ &°� y � � ;� "nd ��" , �� L�`t �c+ �... ����� �* W a�� �� �i'' ��?� �* N ' , . �. � , ��� ��,��,. � � ;� ����, "� � ����,��` �I° { ���� �� �� M� ,. . � .�� � � �,` { .�; � � �w a: �� "�� °�*�r���,�� ,�� ����- �'� ,-�- � � , � �� '°��ro � 5 1� �a�� �� ���� � �ti�`"�s°� ���� ��:� � ^w�a4d��t a t-m��� ��F �a ,�`��� �" � � � � ,+�i� �,, � � . � � ._,d �� �r d��q ��.. .. ��' -�' �;� � � �; �; �� �Rry�,��y� .3""� `AX x y � � � +���i j� ��"� "m �� �.°Sj .. �- i?±� � �y�'� � ����,� . .. � ".F�y� � �ek � . �A�_ � 6 &` �u ��". �`.,�°�',� {� '� ��"Y���y�,����e ���£��l g� � �� �� �� �.. T' � � ;��+:r Y`f �,y�, -�"� 'N }� . } � ��,`" . .. �7i^n.s"=�F � �.i��.a� � �Y ��� �. "' -r{ '# r f�� �. �,-�'�1�+C � %`�'� t", � "r i � S �. ��' �� `� 1 � V �`.a`�d i� s �f ,� r... ��c�� :� • `£ �'����'�'",f .h` ��a��� &��.£%c ��.'f' �q� � <a a�� � `��f*�3E i y�,�'�" ,�,�z� � � 7 r`� �.. t,�'��?�'�� ��� ,�,��� � ,eA� s�. r��is �+€ € �f � ��?��. `���t f �.�p f 4 � � � ,^�:.. i' � $ . . r '+`�� . y ,v�`'���, �� . � .. ' � • � � «..'S:. .. � ,.•:. ,:'p°"^y.; , 1 t' -..,,. M _° 1 1`Ye �: ^a, .;�...,. _, � ,. ` �� :� d � "s.^f� P"Va'v� . . .,�, 4. � � 4 � . - . � '' � �i �;""` 4.. �. �-,z . , � � �� - . �• `. _ ,, .�,. ,. ��. � � Figure 21:an image of Trees#55 through#60 overhanging the parking area. 2337 An���R�cAN Av�, HAY4•'��ARD, CA 94545 OF��cE: {888)969-8733 SO GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLC?S,CA 94070 MAiN FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO G4RDOVA, CA 95742 NR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EtasTGATE DRiv�, SAN QIEGO, CA 9212� WWW.ARBORWELL.COM '�►� '�► r or e July 10, 2013 ` � . . -� ,,�<.� � — � �,� #'� � � � '�' �• �' ����+���,p�'��.�,�� ""��c � � �.�:e ��`:� ��, a�, ��. � � ''�� � ,� ,�` �., :� `�' �'� F����� � Y��'. ��`'.$9`�+4r .i�i �= �"°�.:���� . . . � fi,� i��:�$'�� �R 3q,�.,aki y.M`; .R^ '�^` ir4i..�". r�' . ����, � ��'#3,4.� �y.�x. t�a. �`��:�, � A a��,�e �� �'qt�,.�'�. t y.„ ..�� _ :a. ;•x ��� ����� � t., 4°�` �� +�� ➢Fy�� P• �A', '��. e� �.� '�,�{ Q� �-� ~�� r�'�' ^�te" a �" '.a�� A.. �,'a '� `^`� :'� �`�� ��,�-,'� e #" ri, d ,._ �f �'�"'�`��� s,y:�.' ��` '�c '�, .".�,.*1.-�,,,�. a� ;'.+'�`#�,t.-.���± ,. � ��#� , �ti � �� nvrx. .�e., ' ��p �� " . . �.'� r.- .. �� { � y�� r.Rc, P �,�. .� ,`: P':�'�' .�t�+- �f��°'�.�4 ��� k �� 4. � ,b a t,'�i t'At�,. � .�... `'z�''-K� 5� � - �.�, �� :� �,.� 'F�': � �� � *�'�' ■*ra�'�, .'��S� �t�. ,.. {� *$�.' .�-*`•� y,x x «" "Jix' � ,ay '�«,.„„_.. <;� ' �y' ��.. . �- .-�,. ;eF"� -. yy,..# 4- ��p ��'Y�°��• cY' ���6�9s �.- '�-'f"�yY (��'"�A� �:.. �4 k .y�.. n , , �r�� ��?�,� �`�'»4� �� �� �;% � z�n� ... M f�.�'��/ �. �-��e R. ���`4 �¢,3. } + �' w?w�, '�.i .. - . t f , � i`8�3� �" . ` ,�, �r � �.,, x .;" µ ..��,M.,..:,., d,y°�h r <�,. .P - �.,�p.t ��s= �A.. a Y"', wn r, 4'�, �.�.,, . a:�a....r, t k ,x '�+e'�'... � � ..i74,�� � ��� 't j' .4-. �abe'.�:� . , ��~ .,, y y;��k 'Yz�S¢ . a��,i�'�*s-",,� Y°'t Js 'r'�.. �'� , ..,:� r3-*. ° , ..o. > . ... �r � .. s �� �?�a 0 .�~ '^&,;,r-•�. :x �. 6 ��� ��R _ . ..._... � ... Ya%.:.. C 4�� ': . � "fG "' � * q�, � . �' ' . � � �,'� �.. � � � ,:� ,� _ � r � , a .z " iiSL+��x�, � �'x-� �l r�� ��^� a"'�. r .« �..� r ��„ ���'"- �,� ��"�,yi'i �` �� �'�� ,°�a � � 4s. �-,w �",��+a � s� < �4`"�;&s�' . ' � ,• : � _ ..��r�. -.�� y " �� ��'a ��4.�y v , � - "'�- a" �., s,. t�.. . X ��"� �°`$�, . r y.x.,'Y,� . `p� 1 ,y; . �& ' �`a�=� �,a. � . =}..: _ �W '�-� .' . : �. �� v �, . p y�, � b ^ „ti�� . ,�S'¢: f ;.. : �,�� y.S� Y�,�°"— --}. ; g: _ � � �� � `} i ��. �� q I .�„'S � �'� � .' : ,iy��.� � r;#.i ,, , �R s . }� �ij I�4����61'IMI� t % �� ��, �� �'r'� l• �, . ��"��- �t_- . � , �, F . � � ��� �� �� �� �� � � : ,� ���-� - �� �.: �. , �, � �- , � ��� �,.� �f � � # .� �� ; -°� '��,. "�- '. n 3 ,cr�.'.- � ���"' � f�� x�' . .,,y < < " . . �o � �r ; . � p> h ,, 1 . '�= .._�: � � ��� ` ,�,�5.�r��.`�»y�-. � �� �� 3 � �� .:_. �° u :-� . .,_ t i , �� � rS���' ,a, � � �� � a , ,+a� � ��'..:��:: „w� '� �.. � . � `'�„"�",-P'--, T�i �A . _ ri.."i�,�.,r.�� . _ .; - �� „ :� U . �—.,_ � ;�. �;. ,,v. �a. � � .,x .� y��,.,.e�gyw`� _ . � �� ` `�' .. ,-° �`�`,�� j��-+ , '� fl - ��;Y �',' � �"�a�:-b.. �� � ��,�'�y�r��g �� ��� � � �� �.: �'-----�,. �, � �� i ,i `�'° . . ��r—r,?*� $' � _; _;��`` _w. , , , , _ .,_�. ..,,_�.__.s. � .. �� t 3- �r` � � �,�;, �' , �, , .. _ :,,°. .� � �' a y'n 1 5 I �I X M�� p y�ek Y��i��. � Figure 22: an image of Tree#61 exhibiting poor structure and overhanging the parking area. 2337 AME��cAN Av�, HAYWARD, CA 94545 OF��CE: (888}969-8733 HO GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 NR FAx{510)670-0275 5601 EASTGaT�DRiv�, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM ��►� �. r . ar e July 10, 2013 � . �� �E ��?�w,� ���� Q• •��� �� �'��e`dprt As yc#r .?�� ���������;�� �����,, ����"���„. .� +eo--:. �gq,� � -,� `� ���y> �.�' '�,y�i, �r*"�..� ��_� �t " �#. �„. � � � <." ,�, .�, � �` " ` `,"' � �x � ' �� �. � � E F`�, ��� ��,. �, p;� °� , x�, � �;, �w� �:;�. � � '° � ;� � � ' '� ,� �- + �`k 4 t e .. `� �, , � �� � � ai�+. �. � ��,,,, ��, � * � �� � ��� �� � �����";��'��� ��� � '' +.,Msw� � •,��v +4 x'Y �* �� �� �:�7 e � �.,� �. . *°�'� � -'f; g��, �MMI�� ��',� � �{ , �1M"� '"� �..'p��fi. = X»�* ,$�2 ,Fts�-t�3'����' .,.;����. �.�: �,.., tw 1��a�. `$' 'a'" �, ' „ �, � . .... , . . � �~ �� �� ^ � rs,- �... . .m..,.., . . ' �^,E a�. �; a �,',, xy�,� �' § � ��`c ,.r��a � zy� " > ' � . �.� "�� sf a.a �,y*+G�" �,� , � "� r" ° � �s' y�.��`A . � � '� ' ��i,s,� a 6:` �, �''�" -s & r q�� ',ssT�' �+� �`b a�f4 �, a ���...^"t",'�' ,.y�.. :.��." �ir� ��y �k� �+�. �a�.� �$ Y� i �' k� � �� *ti�� �� � * � +� _.�j � ��:II�r (�� _ ^r� JK �,f;,� 3sS. �,.�. ..�m�i �" . � � �..t������ '� ���� .:� . -�ar � ;« y � �"� �s�. �"t i f � !. �ft"i .�. �, �' a ^� • a r�{ a�'� �t'i �f j ° =�� ,g� ��. "�"". q� �,�r"�.r�'t��.,Ai -_4,�Y..'q " q�,e.. �yr � . < w ` � ., _ 't ` ��� ��' �C�� `v '� � . az e �`# +�`,� �r�*';;, �� '����"�, . �' ,�:a ry _�,� � °'�:, t ���4�,` Kn,,.,�. . �� - _a , `�ir,h : ,�:° .. �, . ' �.r�4� �_ P✓,y '`A�, c � ,�� `;w.�� � ar :� - � . .. .. ��„�m � �zN r �;��s.� �vh ,�j�sr r�.;,�',,� . ti� .�:�.�, '���� ,�, �. g � £' ,y ��r��y�� ����*���„' ;� ., � s� J. �i � ,�s ��� t�°+�� , a+�a #�. -+c�.� >x -�x �, '�` , �, � �' �, ,�e�°` b��,,� ,� � �.x��. . � , ,� �, � �. � ���,, � :�� � " '�' '•�, � ,-� � �'"�+�..s �' -�`„��_. � -.�M�� �k`��� ,� � �'�g :�" ' ` ���'� :'w�'�'� . � .�� E . t "'� a�_ �""�'�*„`. � �� . > yi . r � v�'9P}AS `, ' � � � -„vk° s°h• � Y �+�' � � '�`�� f.y`.C� +�E. " •+'�" �'a� il �� � e `+�F lm- ..�= '�� � � ��j� d x �s Yi� t , � ..;��r .i.� �a' �..-��, l�.# . �:�� �a. }✓ !e �/' a�^' ;,4� �� �;' y, . ... . .. . � ,.�.,,^.^� �?"� d+ n � W` �v r�.r,� . a ��- ae ° , :�°3^ � +F,4,.�:�� "'� �4, s'r' ..>.� �'^e. �, -�^� .��� �,"}; ��, .F ,z �� l Y.� Lr' ��`� . �'�" ct€ � '?N p�j�� ' �_'�', �� � lIi ���"'"$+v � ,Wt-��^ ) T^R'y��, t� .✓�,��d+N X�� Y f hi� .�y �i € ' �p� �� ¢ :�� �_'(" �@ .� I -� �i. 6 ��� .�•�.• �, , v � .. • r' � ' .� , �` ���' � g�' .S+' y1r. ' '� .x ._�.��� �. ..� ' ;,� � '�, rt�� 1' ,»-. `e� " ��, �` � �t+ �¢'�d # � ." li� +.;�.�.� " ��:s i6 .f �;wk M�'t� �`� -,�s . �.� � �.>Y. C ,- . � � � _ �_ ,'�' �s �� �� «, ks, � . . � ° �I���Y{I�y� � Y�BY y � :..�. � :-,t . *t ' �4 � f"""1�..:` .r�� .. . . ..„. „ �a t� � a .,. wh�... � 'm � � V. � �� � �� � �� . ,- �"` �-�i� _,,� -`� �y � .� . a ,.,,,«,, : �.,� r� �. 1 .,,y*, . ., ..�....� � ..�.;. . ,� a..s+w.>,........��. , .. � � s,:at"t�r � ..,.,_...,�,,. �. ��a � /r ... ��� ...>,. �����a. iy� . � • �� �� � ��' �4� e�! � �, � �� � �� �����s� ����„� _ ��` �� ��� � '�j �w � II 'I' I j l 1�d1 �il�.i� � i � � . �,, Figure 23:an image of Tree#62 exhibiting poor structure and overhanging the parking area. 2337 At��ERICAN AVE, HA`fWARD, �A 94545 UFFICE: (�88)969-8733 8Q GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CAR�OS, CA 94070 MAw FAx: (510�881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM „�r.� "�. _ � �� � July 10, 2013 m � �� �—�� � ����� � ,.�� ��a � � ,��� . � a � � - ”" �'.�� &�. � a�`��c� ,,, � �.� � � A . °'� C,��... � � r�" � � �n �;, ,Y `' +�` a'i , . '*9 � C . �p�� C � • $�� f� �E ��a���^� ��., . �y k i k ��. � �� ��d��.4� � �. ��. �k� ��K �� ����� . '��'.ww,<...... ... �.5. ., a, �d� `��` � ...� � " �..� � "� �,A..�:���� �F r a, � d.. '. = .4�.`\�. r x., � � n � �; . d 1 a�+"S, . .. . ��R4 ����V`Y � �, F, �� .�. � 'A;. '� fr ..�, ��. „ y� .��.: .,�x„�� ..��.: ����:� v� AIB�` . � ��,�� . ��� " ig"'' �'�� �� �e � � g � 9 n "' M �' .. ,�,. �e c- • � ; . . .'�'� � �: . �Y���� �'� � A� � �:. �. . � °� `�rv �',� � '��' �.�a�� � . . � �a . '„�� � �y` `s" .•:'�. x�. � : ., �,,. ,�s W.„-*a^ , t r� � "�Rk w°�.,; ^ t'��. .�°" ` 1t,.. . , .., . &�" +R.� �,�a, •� �'�s,.� . ._ . ��,�u.�� � ����, � � K� " � + 'mawAP�'' � '.. 'n 3 . �� "� ��i� #�� FF� k `�' �4' .x � � .n� ' �n "+eR , ma,�e ... +z �. ;s �" � � ..,.. ".�, .. �,.,�x -' � �, �1 �^ �, . ;.' .r� �wml�v,..:�� � � w'��.. x " ', . . , � ,,�.. , .� - ,: �' � ''y,, .,.z � �� , � .. �:. . "'� q .� '_ � �� V� ,�.. , �.� . "a � : N �� '� �r �: `g. ��. .� �� 4� ^ �� � � � �� � j Y� aa� �,�a T �t �, , < ,. _,., �, � w. � ae*� r�� s` �+` . � � ;� " �,�� x � ,�� "' i�; ° N ro � � �� x � ,s�'y . .. � , . , � �_.. '� � � �` � �� � ,� �±,. �� '���'�`���% � x�' �. �4 " �" ��;����#��f���� ,. �,' �;'� ���A�����' � ���9�i��1'��P��ri+�;di�f����f�i��+P„Iw �� g�,^;. _ ��r ,� ��,. . �I �3' 3*R �'.�r �� • n�.�� S . $ �iL �' ,�:.. �y�_: b. ta� #� 3� �, �; ,� ,� ` r� ��° : �"� � � � �� � ����� � ��� � .��;� �..� . - �� � � � � � � � r= � � � '� , ���� ^��§ "'�jv�� ��'.. �E��*�� #$�'�� �������)���� ��Y i I �ri�. _� � '�' ��,��, �"�� y �,� '� '�� h �'� "�- °� � � ��� ��",�a�- � �`�; �.�� "���r�,- � �',, � �. � ______._ Figure 24:an image of Trees#63 through#65. 2337 AM�R�CA►v Av�, HAYWARD,CA 94545 C�FF�CE: (888)969-8733 8O GLENN WAY, UNIT�#8 SAN CAR�OS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD RUAD, RANCHO CC?RD�VA,CA 95742 NR Fax(510)670-02?5 5601 EasT�AT�DR�v�, SAN QIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.RRBORWELL.COM ,�. "�. r _ Qr e July 10, 2013 �. ;,� � .,��„ ,�,, „��, ,;,,,,,,,, �„ � „�,, �,,, ,,,� ,o: � �. , ;;� , ,,, , ,, ,, R � � . � . � � , ,,, ,,,,, ,, ,,,, , , n . .;. „ ,. , „ , . ti, � , .,,,, � .,, � � � ��� ��t,� � `"�� � r. �� a� � � � � }V� ° s� N�� ,,�a» �p e `1h� : „ �u y��� n � " W ak` , ""'• +��� .'*'M, �,J� d � �� S� ����� anN ,�.py,.:, � � � � � & � 4� �� ... � �, �����w� ��.4;+� 3 �� �41�.� . ��.q� ,� �b,y�S Dg' j,� ,�'^'� � � �� b �. � �. �� :�� ��"y���?� � �'�� � «, �� � � °,� `�, '�„� �� ��*� �� -t� ��� �, , ., � � , �� � � a � � ..�� �� x � „� � ,. ,_ ,� � '�,� a „ �, . t . ��„"w s��:., � s � �, � , ��, + '� �, � �� - � " „ �.��` � ����d� ;. w,��,��" . c o � a r �..kkyM�,"� '"�;i t+� � A Y� cgq r,,.� ' �.. � f. ;� �'� � ,�� �� .a j �� 4�,�,. y�4"�r.w x�R".�Z' . ..,�,_�� '� '�'a � 4��°..o R ee � ���'��'�"'�r#��; '"fl �''� w � ' " �� s.�^5' � � y. �� °�: ✓ "°�' �` �& ����.� � :�,�t „'�` ;� � ��� a�'� �'-��t' � '��', , , s , � ' � _ ,�,�'� ` "`.a;,> �� �• ' ��"�w= , �k'�'�* �". ..' �, a. � `�? s '��,�'����`> � ` x � �,. ��,��,„�x�'� ) ' �"�' � �� c °.�;, ',v�rv� ��' ��,g �„� � ,�y � T"E"o.3 3 %wa�. <�� �� r. �� �}�`� rtd 'ni1 �.. �� �$, M. 4�� ��'", �� ��.� ,� �. *�d"..:,�,.���. .' 8°'� �w' � '�F`"°'.. , # '�� .��n y... .. . r� �-�� + � .`�'`.y�`�.,,+�: � ��, <,�,.; � n . �� �°�� ���� � � � � �� � �� � � � � �"� :� .�"�:� � ���'' ������"��� � �'"�� �'g� ��;e' � „��°,��"��^� ��,��^„w�����. �. ��> � , � �, �. � � ` °�� � � , , , � °�� �" � ;r �^ ``�°� ��&�� � `. �r� � � � „^'� ""- �- , � }; "' ; � �'�f`�- � �� �`� s�` , � � � .. .._. .,.� - 4'� 3._ �� ��� ,, x �' � �. ,��",��� �, � �� � �� �..�g �:F '�, Y°�„ ��A��� � 4��� "c��i�',�F �� . � ��`„a `i , �bq �,fc �s� � ��' .,-_ �k�er� ���* "`�'�u�y._. e� �:�.��a � . r, a e ', � c , � � . � � � �� ` � . : . ��.,�,„.,�.. ... "�'"'�' �. a � �sa �t �:: ��.� � ~ �� � � t � �p 3 �� ��� � . ��..�, a,�..e.,„�a.�„a•. �� � ���� .:} ,� � � T�4 �.t�.. w..�t, � . .���I : s 6: '�: � � .y�' �" �'i�.,��.t�, �r� ��� r �r t . . M`�« � � �un° � � � �n$' . . j. � �'��y*�5 �� z � ��� � ������ ,« ..M-.�:... -��� �+�- a �,,,�` _,g,,;c,�.: � �{ � �,� , �� �i�: ��_ �� �.�<,_ „�, � r . ,s.+�'��:r a..„ i'M+"_a � � �I�m"� � e ��� �� ° " ' ':�e;: .. `.,�.�`�, ,a,>x�4�,,+� �.,�'",,� ',�. ; �. . . . � F� ��' ��'�. �,� ��Y $ � :t;. a�t��A� ��. . � � . �� :� .,-. � ^ � � . �"� " '"'^�+.sa..w.,� ' ' .�,� ,_ `�. .�, w � . ,�#. � �Y �. Figure 25:an image of Trees#66(second redwood from the left)and#67(right-most redwood). These two(2) redwoods exhibit 40%canopy density with tip dieback and 50%canopy density,respectively. The inset shows how much light penetrates through the what-should-be-dense canopy. 2337 AM����AN Av�, NAYWARD, CA 94545 C.�FF►CE: (&88)969-�3733 8O GLENN WAY, UNI�T'#8 SAN CAR�OS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)88�-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA,CA 95742 HR FAx(510)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN D��GO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM .,`.� "��r. -- 1. �� � July 10, 2013 � .J�, `# � �. ��..�.^ pR��W' � � �' N � .^���� ' � .. � a �M �'� '� •r ..�.. V4 �` ti�„ ��<;._��z' �. iP �k ^+qi4� . a � �� �` � .'#�`x � �� �� �� � ���.�`��,,;,` _ � � ���� �{ �A .a�' .�4� ���. c���. � .�5�},� ,rt �fi�� ,�'� �4, r� , , , ��� °�"�� _".R � ��°re� �'�r ,� `"�'M1�'A'� ,� ,.�'�At� �,��.�^:� �,�""�'�� ,y•g a. y� 9 q4�,i � Sux "ik ' Fi�t .��3 ��Y�����a"�S f'a �%.. �`;�9,�� " �r� S`��Y �' �*��` ��{L4 �`w 1 .� #'��T� � ���«e�s�,e; '.s: 1�� "�p � � '�C,"�� ' a„�!+ �$P��;.�-�: �,�, �fn,. ,� �w.-y��;' f. ., r � _ ����.��� �. �. .!, . sc„ ♦^6.,�� " r . a ' "�t. . � '�.�„-# �.� � �3 ��� �� x4a �a��P°�� �� � �r' » ., S, � ,py�, Y N� ��..��'$ �� � �R°�S-! �h�..�, '�• � �s , . ,� �R "!��� �$§�'lk�.v,+.�, A� $' � £Md! r* �'� � � y 8 r; �. �"m�f{ �� 'Y�R s� 4' ,�-��j� . " � 'S.»4` �w..� �; . �`�� .�� W,��.. . ��� ��,* �; ,.,� 1_ ��,��� �. A�..�L� � Ft�D^�,�.,'�P' .4 ti� ss ,�µ �� . � ��* �`x . x.�F� �"� ; ^�3 .: � x ,� i� w �.���� �; � r ��s.� ��: a� �':� a, b�� ���,E ���..r- � .. �0.",,� `x^;n�. , �... � � .�. ,5 ,x .�. . � . � �. a. ' � , ��.w` � "� � ,r`r.�^ P�'s'�'� � ��`.�� . � k �� .. c" � y�' a`sr'aa�& .�b .�.,r �q "� � �� �m � '"F; �" � ��" �*I� �� ��.. ���� '3. �.�r «d*��� , ,°'�'R' �� . # r r*._ � a �,� � �a��'. . �„ r�� �_ 0 s. _ '�°�' m .` . _ . " . ♦ '�� , n / � . .t + � �p � � � s� � , � 3�; �.d ��,eay� ��""�" " � z .r '� �� " g �?�. .# ` �. a� a � ��.��..' �"` "s". �� �� q�� -� °��,�� 4" '� �r��w t q �# �' ;� � . '�6` •„ NR" �r� ��� A '���� �� � � � �� �. � �, >;.�n ,: .�� �� ��;�' � �,� ¢ �'��� z�� „� �. � . � ' _ � �, ,�, `��� �:'� � �;�_, � �"'� �, -��� ��—�. ��`� ��� , � �...» , - � � � .� � � � ,�.w�„ �;� , �.. � ��.... ,,,,rrw.' 3S . .'�^,v��.,.... '�j, .. ..,.. .. , , ��: �� ., ... i:a�w.. �. a � ... , ..... /""e� .. :He:�.n9 , �,�. � , . �,« : ar ..rR � .: �. �"a .. , 1 , .. ..+Hr« �. � �� , ' ,yrrrw�.,, ��i ,,. ^ fk � �r �`�, — � � .... "� .� .. �1 .a,.<, $,p �,:.:, � �°�� ,. . � . _. �,.. , . ,. . : .� � .... .�� _ >�« ��� � . . � ,.,, �� ,.�, � r _ ° "� . � .. . �_ ,,,,. . _ � a �� �` < �.;:._.� �. �� � .�.:..._. ;�:. �,_..� _ .T.,�,b � � Figure 26:an image of the proposed replacement species,coast redwood. 2337 AM�R�cAN Av�, NAYWARD, CA 94545 O�FiCE: (888)969-8733 8�GLENN WAY, UNIT#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MAIN FAX: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CURDCJVA, CA 95742 HR FAx{51 Q}670-0275 5601 EAS�r�A�r�DRiv�, �AN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELI,..COM +_�� '"�Ir. r or e July lo, Zol� �—,�„`_'_ -s � � �.� ) � ' '��� �'°�;'� "'� " � � �� � �ds� � � "� �.�� � � �,�� a,�. � * a �. . „� ��"�" � � � ���T � �'�'`=�'" ��� � , � � � t` z �,,, t' ��� � ���,� ,y�j ' a'� � `t�`�w- � '�� � �ak� t'��,�sy g �.. �@:,, y� • _ . r° .b `` � \ � � �. �` � . �''.� r'�F . ��.ne ' r � i . � � ` . . 1 '� �;� �=i ._ �.. _ �� "� F ' ��»,� �� ���+ �!!� r xq�, 'r't+"'.�. i, u, rA ai � ��a;� t«•^ . ._ � .. . "'1.� , . .� °�,.., vf . , � ' ' �.'xa�. �t � �bps���t� ,c�"�� °"�,�'� , . ... � . Y"�'?"s�� .,.s,.a. =A �a�ry,.x.,;6�'�:. �.+.r�^A �„�`°,�'"�<+t � . � t� . #-+� . .. ., . ". ;. `��' � ..:a^� y�� .. %' .. r . a,�, ''-,g � . ' _ � . �. �- „ ;'. '�S`3 `. . , �.1 � � ; � ��.'� 3�, { ' � ,..:�., �� � .' -. ' � u �,�,,.�� ,�.,�.� ag:.� �.r.� T`r I �k�s� ... ��.� Lh . ,..,''�9' � ;^ „F°,'���' ?�"*Q� � ,:�.r� .�. �"' � tN' �� _ � .. . .��...�� �� �� ,f- � .. �e� x� � � , '� ..����Y ��� J,�v ., �*e s{�'�. fa� � P'. " � � g c, .+ t��';.:tl tY� � ���� �f AR�� � �� °�'� �� 1� "� ��� k >.xt � �. ' �� t y y�fr �� � � . r�.'��,`���'.� � � � �,� �»v,;��'"" s���a. : 'a 4���� .1%� 'p"" q+ :r ,�p°��`�.t�'"�` '�. .: � � � � � ;:, ,,,.r:�'` . ':,�f , �� . � �+��. �,y: ` , �. � , ,��e ' �°.✓ � .`x ir,, . ,�„ ,^ 'r 4�' *xi t�°�; ♦ e+'..-� �+ i L } � ° ,, ,�� ? � ' `1 ' � �;� % ♦� ( � � � y��N' i �' ,=5�� i i i ' 0 t'� '.s �6 �, ; {{i „x�� y j Y +�, }� ��"`> . �9'��i� e'� }Nr�. � .. �x'^`a. � �:• � ��� IO a 4��.✓.. . . ., M } tk .� i �i- 6 w�v„r kCv�e � � 4,`v y ^ � � �1 � , .� AT" 4 �S. � � .> .,^,,. �_ �„� � z � �� �^^�. � ���M �� 'J'� � �'` � � � Y� , r � . �w .. �, ��`�� ts� -" a,� � " ,�' �< ,� ,�� � - �_; ,.�� X� �au. �,` k s v ,. ' -7° �9 f'" � s� � . :.,�°�A` ,,� ' ''?�,�.,a�, „,'�n,�,,'°,��� �.�.,`� .� . +�.� � �� � � ��.. ._ �wd -. ^� "` �^^� . , �- . , �^ . , Y . .; '� , � ...+r *�. � ��^ . „� . ,�8-., � � .':�,��.��'"" fi� ,r�.s",� ,r � ; �, ,,.» �_. � w i , ' . 0 "" -.�. '�.' e w . . ' . „ . � ,'- r� �, :. . 3 .• 3 A ,,.. .. . .: . -� .YiN.�, „ , . ,... , .-.�.. �,�.���� ��.a '.Y � ;. 6. ,�.°n"F � :. �f�,� „ ��� ,a,_ .., �r. � 't� . _ �fi; µ m F � . �� ��:: - ,, �.. �., .. •. ! �, �-..�. �.. '�'«,t�4iy �� {a ��_ . � . �� .. , , �,. t''M- _ d �r" ��", ,. _ � . � �° � ,r.,' `"� �� �� 7 .V� �r�- `�#t r�' .�,. „�, : � :y �� � �'". � ` ,� ` � , r Y � � v�' ��'"i ,. � - _ . . �- � , , .. ;� � -' r � '� �s� €� � �S " �� '�, Y ���� � � � � � �. �� �'�_ � ?"'-� ", t��� .'}� �` "��' �� � ; � ^~�^� "y� �.,a y��.'" ?.�q��'���¢'My°'��5�Qµ� f �M1 � ,..�fl�g ( ��� � _.� A �*� ���� � -A g6F .j..'�' S��n.tiq 'SWr.. � rl` ' C1� "k ii�tl T+ti, . �,s . iF ' �^� t`t`r� �ai.i' +s�.` F, �� �: � �� ! 1 S �� �.. � 4 � �j+ t �v ?a i f fi� g't a � '3 � s�'� � 'f. i�$ ,��g�.G � A'^ �� �4 4 ...9 iH. .,. �� � w, � r ,� ��� �� . `�".z�.;� �, �i Y f^b }c �F � .. ,s$." P �� - yj . . < ��t _ } . $„ � i �' �'-+i �,�sx 4 ".i-� � �� � � � �f � � 2 e 5 a �: �w w �°'�'n.x �� �t�-:� �-'rm'w &'� �#'* �'. �s�� �"�� :� �p�{ �, ,. 4� �i� + `' ,.+��" � ..�. <�,� y�j`z.��� �'C`�. ���`r: ��.',� � z..�:'�� �,..��� � ��� i �"' ' t �'`��, ' ��',� �,.�s , , .�t'a � �� � y ��r"'�� �` � �� � � � �� � ,��-� - - �,=� ._ � � � � �..� :a � _ ` - -_ . . . ...,....: � �� . ,•..,.. ,� . ' ""' . �-. � —.;��.__, - �me���a _ �,,., Figure 27: an image of the proposed replacement species,trident maple. 2337 A�;t��z►c�N Av�, N,�Y�va�:�, C�i 9�54� O���C�: (�3�3�)�J-�9-373:3 8O GLENN WAY, UNIT$�8 SAN CARLOS,CA 9407Q MaiN Fax: (51�}881-5248 3207 F��rz��c���RoAO, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 HR Fax(510)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM "�.� "�r. r or e July 10, 2013 ,, , � � � y�;"/" " ,�„ W,� ���,��,�� e bi i.���� n .. � �5; � 4+uw.. �a�: .....—,w�. . .. ,�� A^� � � �r.'I�p, w a � � '�x� ,� �.� � �'���'�, � �� ���i �,t�«a �, "� � .. �/ i��,^r Ak 6.. �* ' . a, R.'°� �v,�, � � ��� �, ����., � . n� 4�: ,� . .: .. ��H ti w�^ �rx ' „ �� ,r^" s � . , . ` '�" _�" �"'.° .. w �„ �` s ,.»".. , . • ^ � a. . �,�,��..., , z � , �, ,,. a .� �• . , �. � $ ,� ' "��� a"<< * a�"�*'n ° " „�. ,.�' .r��, "" ,�. � r�°� �r'�'�."w �°°a'r � T �" '.,?' `,�, � � „��, �, ��: � ���° a'�a, „ a � <. n, ,r rt� '�> � � & ��� .+ �' � �� '"�'^��, � .v".L� e c n w'�w �� � �- " .. � '� � �r'` +`.„ ��"'�"� ." , * � �+a� ^c� �y�* �� �u� ' �,�' -��' � b ery . �n�' n k�,� r "°'��� �, �� '��, ak,,..,�#y�,�,�,� , . vb. , . �,P � .„,. � ti" �'°w`��r�,"� �.; �' .. .� � � � „b �� . y . :4� ff '�' .. �?*',�.. �,c'r „da�a .��� . n$ ax "`�, `,- , �'� , .�, , ma �p. '.�c �9 � . .'�►� �` ,� �� �4�. � �� � .�A 5,�. �]4.xS.Q�a" ".y� p Nw 4�N°�a'/'"WW�=%+.�,,, -y � �°�p�N..z �.�y Y Mi^'q'�a. ��tl "��t�� � � ����: �i �" �3 �d` . ��=tl�..��'*� � .. � . '� �^ #m �, . "�!'%' '� '� "'"` ,aU. ��., .. �, ..w. � � N . e �vu. �+'��`y� '� "�. � ��. �r ��. "cs�r`"" . °�� y °3�', �. ' �"�°�`� ,'�^�'""` "t?�, .+X� � d s � �. a . �a . � � ' as,�� � ' P"' �4�i .r �#sa , �`� �� '" � � ���www,,, w � � 3 �'�" � . � w, ,: � $, ,S� .. �' ` � �, � -. ,,� � 8 f� ��� � � '° k t��' � � �ro��f �`�i,..�.Y �'y � .'�'�' �� ��:,� ��i9j f- � „ rt���� � � yy�`� �n,,;"w�, „¢�?ax*�m�w��..s Ay�a?�� r� ���'� � ��t'li��Y� p�da.a�r'"�' h�,.�"�`�,. , �'.�w.��� ,y .., �.� ", .�. �r�. ��yl,� ��,�1., '�. `a� �'s°'" ♦ ° � � ,� ,,��,� '�;. ^� ' „�� �� �s � act' 6 '� :.�o-.�'' "�.�.±w;_z'���" ,Po. �➢ ,s '�h€° �� z . �a��� „� , .a � �'� � � ��� � ��'��^�„ �, � _ �;t � � �� �� �... �, � � � �` � �� ' � . . � � . . �� �-�.. �' y a �,�o a. _a. � �° �� ,� a��.,,,_,�' � ,� � , .. . w . nq go., - ,.s Q' . . . _.�.,,�.�. ...—d_,_�, t r,� %�:i ,°d '�' �q ,� ,�Vy"��� �.... � Figure 28: an image of the proposed replacement species,Japanese maple. 2337 AnnER�cAN AvE, HAYWARD, CA 94545 C��FiC�.: (888)96J-8733 8��LENN WAY, UNIT$�8 SAN�ARI�OS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCNO CORDOVA,GA 95742 MR Fa�c(514)670-Q275 5601 EASTGAT�DR�v�, SAN QIEGO,CA 9212� WWW.ARBORWELL.COM , . ,,�� 1 r or +� July 10, 2013 � w � �� .�; ��..: �� a � F. Y$��. � � �� •$ .- , # �"� r<. � �, ..���" .rr"'"" ��t y�� .' ��� � �" ��r„ �R � ."�� �x�: ��,r• ,,«�'"" R. A A��+ a r"" � �..'""�'' �.o. - a��°"r�� �'; � i,.� .. ;r�.� ..;� '�"ss" �`,� •�"!1��4, � A JL e�e ��evf . . ... .� 3 4��:. � y^ � E „�. � d . '� 'n'.�R'.., � '�a� : � `�� � � �o '�'� �� � �� �����' � �, �.� � ,� ' G �� �` , Y�� � � �� -.� � \ y`, ��" � � �' � � � � ��i �,��� � � ����� _� �, ��� ;���. �` � �.�`,��. � ��, + ������ �� ��'��a �`` �' �, '„ ^�'#`g� ��;.'�yb�,-,. �s. k \ �� �9 �...������f.¢��"�;fi . � � . � £. � " .� 'q{° �,? ' . � F-' �„h t Y t h , ��?;: .. . .. � �, � ���� �+�' . . � ���� � ° �+ ��p �� � � �� � �,,"�� � ,y� S�. l _^-*�„ � =tp� � �.. �, � ��� i . � �.'{�`t� ��� � y# �i'r: � � �� ��,*�;- �.::� �( � *� .} �� �.. ' �� « � �: 3n' . � Y � '�� ' t��,q.. `� 3r ���`,;'..� ,�"����� « ;�, U � . ` �,' �� s r, �� �, �� ,�� ` � „'ai_=,r�����{"��� . �'� �' ���?�c c,'��.� � g's�..-�.f t�� jY )".,F�� ,, . x � � � ..;� ..j ':ti:� �; � .. .n. 3,;t ', 't�° � i `�r y. � `, ���re'.�� y g� ��,�..�.. . ,�v, - �`� �, � `" �� , +„�'a. �i� s.� z ` '`��t ,�, -{, � � y i:�a ��.+q'., �w .. � ��*`� � � ��'� �e`' ¢Ew `"��„� � ; r a. � �-'� ��*L �+„�� ���� ��¢ i - a �� 3 _.. ..__..,...._.� Figure 29:an image of the proposed replacement species, Italian cypress. 23�7 AN��ricaN Av�, NAYVVA�zc�, G;���545 CJ�Fic�: (888)969-�3733 HO GLENN WAY, UNIT�#8 SAN CARLOS,CA 94070 MA�N FAx: (510)881-5208 3207 FITZGERALD ROAD, RANCHO CORDOVA, CA 95742 NR F�(51 Q)670-0275 5601 EASTGATE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM � ��rbo`r�vell Exhibit 2 - Proposed Removals 10201 De Anza Boulevard, Cupertino, CA Tag Common Name Species DBH (inches) Circumference Height Spread iinches feet feet 1 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 23 72.22 65 20 2 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 18.5 58.09 65 20 3 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 23 72.22 65 25 4 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 26 81.64 70 30 5 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 9 28.26 40 20 6 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 7 21.98 35 15 7 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 7.5 23.55 35 10 8 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 7 21.98 35 10 9 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 7.5 23.55 35 15 10 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 17 53.38 65 20 11 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 19 59.66 70 25 12 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 21 65.94 70 25 13 Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora 4.5 14.13 15 10 14 Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora 4 12.56 15 10 15 Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora 5.5 17.27 25 15 16 Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora 6 18.84 25 15 17 Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora 5 15.7 20 15 18 Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora 4.5 14.13 15 15 19 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 18 56.52 60 30 20 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 21 65.94 70 30 21 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 19 59.66 70 30 22 American Sweetgum Liquidambar styraciflua 8 25.12 40 15 23 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 3.5 10.99 25 10 24 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua S 15.7 30 10 � Arbo'r�vell Tag Common Name Species DBH (inches) Circumference Height Spread iinches feet feet 25 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 4 12.56 25 10 26 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 3.5 10.99 25 5 27 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 8 25.12 40 20 28 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 6 18.84 35 15 29 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 5.5 17.27 40 15 30 American Sweetgum Liquidambarstyraciflua 7 21.98 30 15 31 Glossy Privet Ligustrum lucidum 10 31.4 30 25 32 Glossy Privet Ligustrum lucidum 8 25.12 30 25 33 Glossy Privet Ligustrum lucidum 6 18.84 25 15 34 Glossy Privet Ligustrum lucidum 8 25.12 20 15 35 Glossy Privet Ligustrum lucidum 9 28.26 25 20 36 Glossy Privet Ligustrum lucidum 9 28.26 30 20 37 Glossy Privet Ligustrum lucidum 8 25.12 25 20 38 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 23 72.22 60 25 39 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 25 78.5 60 25 40 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 15 47.1 60 20 41 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 24 75.36 60 20 42 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 18 56.52 60 20 43 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 22 69.08 60 20 44 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 18 56.52 60 20 45 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 24 75.36 60 15 46 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 16 50.24 60 15 47 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 11 34.54 20 5 48 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 16.5 51.81 60 25 49 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 8 25.12 30 1 50 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 12.5 39.25 30 20 . � �rbo'r�vell Tag Common Name Species DBH(inches) Circumference Height Spread iinches feet feet 51 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 13 40.82 30 20 52 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 17 53.38 40 15 53 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 18 56.52 40 20 54 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 18 56.52 40 20 55 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 11 34.54 25 10 56 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 18 56.52 40 20 57 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 15 47.1 40 15 58 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 12.5 39.25 40 10 59 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 10 31.4 40 15 60 Red Ironbark Tree Eucalyptus sideroxylon 21 65.94 40 25 61 Ornamental Pear Pyrus calleryana 11 34.54 50 25 62 Ornamental Pear Pyrus calleryana 9 28.26 35 15 63 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 12 37.68 50 20 64 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 12 37.68 55 20 65 Canary Island Pine Pinus canariensis 18 56.52 60 20 66 Coast Redwood Sequoia sempervirens 10 31.4 30 10 67 Coast Redwood Sequoia sempervirens 12 37.68 35 12 _�.. �"'�••.�. � '�,,��-r Michael L. Bench � / Consulting Arborist � � (831) 594-5151 �''�'� �y� 7327 Langley Canyon Road s �� Prunedale,California 93907 �'����4;/.�� � --� G�C . ��.�, --..-- ��� �.�,� ��� ,��-� _ i7�' �13 � �'`'' �- ,.,: ,,�:� . �. ��� A Review of the Trees Requested for Replacement 1�-�������m��.��-. �.�� 10201 De Anza Boulevard �� ` �� Cupertino, California ��---- - � Assignment I was asked by Diana Pancholi, Assistant Planner, to review the trees for removal and replacement at 10201 De Anza Boulevard, Cupertino, California. Observations I inspected the trees on September 13, 2013. Trees # 1-4 Canary Island pine (Pinus canariensis) Trees # 1 and 2 have previously suffered the breaking of large limbs. There are large gaps in their canopies now as a result. Trees, which have suffered broken limbs, have a greater chance of incurring additional broken limbs in the future (Dr. Ed Gilman, Lecture, August 2006). The risk of additional limb failure warrants the replacement of these trees. Trees # 3 and 4 are very full and dense, but they both have long extended limbs. In my experience, extended limbs on this species, especially when the trees are mature, such as these, the risk of limb failure increases each year. � Although these are impossible to distinguish in �� ���. -� this photo, Tree# 3 is the center peak of the 3 on �m� ������a R � ��'�k the right. Tree#4 is the central peak in the �°�`- � ���, ,-f��� �10t0. � �..r ��`;a �� �� � .��.. p �� �, .,� ��,. 4� !. p'���� c%a¢, �� ��x g� � � -� �` .� �' `� The limbs of Tree #4 stretch across the � � ��.���,,� � 4�, � �� �,o��� ; �` .�� � ��.� driveway toward the left in this photo. The limbs , .�;; b,��. ' Q ��i ��, � of Tree# 3 are also well extended, but they �M � `�� ����'' ' a��. � �`� �� �� ., ..�� cannot be seen in this photo. �� ,� � .�`��v � ��� �o� , ��� ' � �� �``�,w ,.. � -� �� � � � � � � ' � � �'� �-� ���.��� These extended liinbs have a high propensity to �� �� � �` � � �-.��' �_� , _ ��._ � � break as the foliage is dense and very heavy. §�� � �� �'�'��.� �� �.,� �,, �� �:�`��,:;��"��� _ �� Y� s ! `' �' If we were to remove those extend limbs the tree � .,�,�,� _ � � � � A= . � �µ�' � � � .: �L�A would be top heavy, referred to in arboriculture ;� = P_°-� �:.� �� �"'� as a"Lion's Tail" which makes the tree more -�.�„_ t �� � _ � �� W�.` � prone to wind sail�and falling in a storm. �. ,�.�, � .� w _._. `�,;�,���' � � ��r��,.� � � The request to reinove and replace these trees is valid, because of the potential risks. I nonnally do not recommend to use Coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) as Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Consulting Arborist 1 replacement trees becau�., of their high water requirements, but ir� _.tis case, the Coast redwood would be an acceptable replacement species in order to maintain the continuity with the adjacent coast redwood specimens, which will be preserved. Trees # 5-9 and Trees # 22-30, American sweet gum (Liquidambar styraciflua) These trees have maxed the growing areas, in which they exist. That is, their root systems have filled the planter bed growing spaces and have no other open spaces to grow. The result is that the canopies are experiencing die-back and decline. It is the same process that occurs to trees planted in a pot or urn. Eventually they out grow the container, their roots become bound, and the tree starts to decline. Ultimately the tree requires replacement. These trees are in the early stages of this type of decline. If they would not be replaced, their decline would become accelerated in the near future. The request to replace these trees is valid. The replacements recommended are a good choice. Trees # 13-18 Southern magnolia (Magnolia g�andiflora) These six trees were planted in an area that would have been appropriate for only two. The result has been intense competition and poor performance. It is too late to attempt to salvage any of these. The suggested replacements are a smaller species requiring less space. Trees # 19-21 and # 63-65 Canary Island pine (Pinus canariensis) These have been forced to grow in close proxiinity and in competition with each other and with Red ironbark eucalyptus. These responded by growing tall and spindly with their foliage in the top 20% of their structure. These have the structure we refer to as a "Lion's tail". These are partially protected by the building and partially by the Red Ironbark trees. However, the adj acent Red ironbark trees are recommended to be removed and replaced for other reasons. Without the protection of the Red ironbark trees, these will become vulnerable to wind throw. I recommend that these Canary Island pine trees be removed and replaced. The recommended replacement selection is a good choice for this location. Trees # 31- 37 Japanese privet (Ligustrunz japonicum) ��,� ��t:A � ,.�. These specimens have out ' � ����� lived their growing spaces � � ���� �M�f �_ and are starting to decline. � �, ����,��� � �� �; k� � ; �,� They have die-back in � ��`��� �s�'����+ �� � � �-Y � �;�'��� portions of their canopies. ����>�r, ��. � � �;$✓ � � �x `� '�� This decline can be � � .�A.� ,�' ��. �,y .�. .��.4�� �.��:,�� `�R1, �� � ,t �`��,� , � � � � �� te . . �, . . _ '` _ �� ���� �,�, b ��.�;. �P � ��p'� expected to accelera . �,� " b °.� �, ������i��!�l ., M y ��* ��p; ' �,. . . ����1 : � � � � "'��s'� "�;;;> `.� -�; ��,�,� . �' � � �;, ���������.����`�� ���;� w, �� � �� The ro osed re lacements � � ���.�-. p p p ��� � � ``� ` ���`'`" �''�� � are well suited for the ,w ,t , , ,. � n,�� .#k'.f w d'�� .�` fi �� ,�wx:1,� s : -'�,y> �� i �; � �k�� � �`�"�����,�;+,�� � ��. � ,.*� �"'� �� ,'�� � � � '�- ,���� ;�, , �- ,����;� �� �-x� � •�. � �:�.,���,x � g-rowing spaces. ,, � ,� -�.� �., .�,�.. � �'�`�;�ys� �:����i� ��`�` �'�, �,�"' �,�; ���; �.� � � �. m � �`���� �����.A�� � ��<,� :k 4 ,� �__ l� ,�; �° ; ��` � 4 � � g�` �V &" �' " �x '�"� I recommend remove and �, _, s�° � $n. ����t .,h q ��y., +�Yi ,�+. .� �� �b y �w a� *������� '�G�_ „�" t ,.�w i .,,a t"�,'�i� � �� �. ,�,��' � �,���� �-�,��4�`��"� ' replacement. �.r p ,� .� �� �,r -� r`f. �.e x '�'" � ��w. �.a.+,'*."�'' �;..'��¢p,� ;�w,.,�"- � � i �)µ �° � �-;��� .::i � _ < ��� � 6� F�,-�} . �� .. . . z! � • .��. s r �,, ��•. �+�`y. Y", �q� _���'"{,-� ,q b t�,y w ".'� � � G ,T.�� �5.�'� ��i,.rn.�_s a �+{ *"��+� 4 ; � ��tQ..''�m n.}"�..8'�.��'��i���$!'.�} �� , ,� . �x.s��i'`.�.-.�?��3�y.�Y:4��r�•�--�r:.�i... .!.i�.i� Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Consulting Arborist 2 Trees # 38-60 Red ironbark(Eucalyptus sideroxylon) The red ironbark trees were originally planted (approximately 30 years ago) for their toughness and their tolerance to severe drought conditions. The grey foliage contrasts beautifully with the rusty red bark. However, no one predicted how prone to limb drop they were. This species is highly prone to breaking limbs or splitting apart, resulting in unpredictable and occasionally highly damaging failures. However, most of these had their roots severed on the south side of their trunks by the neighbor to construct a retaining wall. Now these trees are also considered unstable and at risk of falling over. I recommend removal and replacement. Italian cypress is recommended as the replacement species, which is a good choice because of the narrow space. 2 Trees # 61 and 6xOrnamental pear (Pyrus calleryana) These trees are in decline and are dying. Their replacement would certainly benefit the urban forest in this area. Trees # 66 and 67 Coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) It does not appear that these are poor specimens, because of poor maintenance practices or because of lack of irrigation. If that were the case, many other trees on this site would show decline. Instead the majority of the trees on this property are in good condition. It appears that Trees # 66 and 67 were likely root bound specimens at the time of planting. I recommend removal and replacement. Other Existing Trees , In addition to the trees requested for removal and replacement, I estimate that there are approximately 200 trees on this property. All of the growing spaces have been planted with trees. The majority of these other 200 trees (approximately) are in good condition. Respectfully submitted, �-.--.— e.�____. Michael L. Bench, Consulting Arborist International Society of Arboriculture Certification#WE 1897A American Society of Consulting Arborists Member Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Consulting Arborist 3