Loading...
TR-2013-47b OFFICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE•CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 C U P E RT 1 N 4 (408)777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333•planning�cupertino.org April 29, 2014 Keith Koppes Pei Tsau 21976 McClellan Rd Cupertino, Ca. 95014 SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PEIZMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2013-47 This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on April 23, 2014, approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of a protected tree located in the front yard of a single family residence located at 21976 McClellan Road. The application is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROTECT This approval is based on the arborist report prepared by Sam Oakley (#WE-9474A), dated October 14, 2013, consisting of 8 pages including a replacement plan, except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The applicant is required to plant one (1) 36" box replacement Little Gem (Magnolia grandiflora) measuring at least 6' tall in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance. The replacement trees shall be planted within 30 days of the effective approval date of this tree removal permit. 3. NOTICE OF FEES, DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The Conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby further notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exactions, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90- day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section 14.18.200 of the Protected Trees Ordinance. Sincerely, tephen Rose anner City of Cupertino ��rbo'r��vell Memorandum To: Keith Koppes From: Sam Oakley 21976 McClellan Road Certified Arborist,WE-9474A Cupertino, CA 95014 925.518.2028 samoakley @ arborwell.com Subject: One(1)Mexican Fan Palm at 21976 McClellan Road,Cupertino,CA Date: October 14,2013 This memorandum is official documentation of the condition of one (1) Washingtonia robusta (Mexican fan palm) that is growing in the front yard of the residential property of 21976 McClellan Road in Cupertino, CA. The site was visited by Neil Woolner on October 14, 2013. During the site visit,Mr.Woolner performed a visual inspection of the aboveground parts of the tree. No aerial inspection was performed. He acquired images and took notes of the health and condition of the tree. Please review Figure 1 of Exhibit 1 for a site map of the property with the relative location of the palm in discussion. The fan palm is approximately twenty-four inches (24") in diameter at fifty-four inches (54") above gade(see Figure 2)and sixty feet(60')in height(see Figure 3). The tree is in good health. It has moderate structure due to excessive dead fronds. The palm is growing in the front landscaped area of the property directly adjacent to the driveway and house, discussed below. First, it is important to note that palms typically do not lift sidewalks nor damage foundations due to their shallow root structure. However, there is a limit to this statement. Because the palm has been planted inches away from the driveway, it is causing the driveway to lift. The palm will continue to lift the driveway and cause damage so long as both the palm and driveway aze positioned next to each other. The recommended minimum distance of a palm tree from a structure is twenty feet(20')to reduce the risk of windblown fronds damaging a roof or windows. Palm trees, specifically, shed fronds during extreme wind events. Your palm also can often regenerate fronds in a few months, well before the next scheduled maintenance. This rapid growth cycle creates a repeated hazard. We think the palm tree is inappropriately located and recommend that the palm be removed. The palm tree should be cut as close to the ground as practical and the stump ground and removed. r�•.: . . . _,::-.::�-,,,.;.,�,.,�..�,.,s�-;, ,, . ...,��r��-.�a�,�. � �.. e � _.. _ Please call me with any question�; a���?�yAl j � -"��n��.-�'Z .� � ._...._ t �j�f�c.�tiGn F�;urib�r 21976 McClellan Road � /-¢'������ Cupertino, CA � '"'""''�'"""` , j: ��:_ ��Pa9e � �:�:��,����,�:.�, �:, .,_,�.��� ' �,. .. . . ��...__. � ... .�_a: . .. . .. . . .-.s��` �,� �rbor�vell Exhibit 1 �, � . - . , . . s ; . - , , � . .� ,�����, - . � �, � � , � ..,: �� �- . .� .. ; , �a„ , � _ _� - � �, , ,��„ � � ,,.�:. , _ . „ . a, . .- .. . � � ir,M�. . � . ,;: , , - . ��' _ ._ „Z„ ,. . �; , ��. , .. ..; � .. .� , ��"'�.Y`�'�.�--+�.' �. ...,, � „rn�,xtrr�^TMyrn�:.�•rrti�r?r±a.-`t" . '�L . -y. �` . �. :� . . r � - . ,�, } �.,,. � t .. . u� . , �, _. .T ':�r... •....� �" : .., —.. �. n.:.. y�' � . , =i , � r� �•-"��+-� •�,: ,4 � �; � .s �" � ..>.> � ��, . . �� . ., . � .. ;,. �x�c ��., } ' _'. �'� 1 . j_ � t. " �. �� . j .'�, ,e,.. -' � �,�' ��i v��� s„ ,• . , � ° a#�: ..'��.���5%.�s �!"d�`'' � �... r, �`, •'� j—�k� .y�.`� k;, .l` ��. _ t � rf ' � � .._ �� � �Y '�} -`� _v'II�� .� �' �.� . �'� � ��` '�.�'_..__ .- � �-4"y 4 �� , �� . i � y��: � �,� ',$ ��k��f���. �. ��I �� ' . ' ' .. M1�,. 'p _ . 1 n���" ' �� .b A ��� . � •�� _._.�..-. �► `�- { ,�►�' � ! �_ �~ � � '. � ;� �,,,. � � �r ' � ° �,A���.�IAI�.n°� �� `��" � � ' '����!p��' � _ "- ' a +��,��. . - r��'� � .� ,,�,,,. j „ . —_ _ *. � �� . s .�, - v�� . ��'�'r'-°` . ' . , � . � _� ' ' �i ��4. .� �w ��, : � . . .��,� `�r � � : . ^ , ^�^ ! �"'—� f x � l n� ' �' ry� � ` ai�'� '�... �! � ���. �P� .. _ . _ ,. �1. ��� ,�'f'M1��,���: ��.•+ +�� ���� ' t �� k ��• ' _^ ^_....�..._ y�Y� � `x ����a" \ .. . „x . °'i�"`..'`'3: �1/1r , ...�.._ . g}^ . ; � �a ��. E �' *���f� �� �� "��r �. '� I t �... ��i �(,,� .. •._�y�e.^� q"M`M f� �' F � � ��� •��' _ . � ... .. ..._...._. . ,�r. . `,. f . � . . .. , . � ! ( �^,� �._ � � � .� . �� �� � �""�• .���• .�_.. .. C ` ,. . , _ � � . .+ �. :r . � _ _ _ _ _ �4A ♦ , � ,i��+"�.�y, � .:}',4 h � �.,4F� w- � r_ .__�a�. 1�'1 r� " . .. *� !d► y�f.o:�� �:, � d�.�7 i�...- � r_�; �f_ L,+k ,'W� .y.b�. 1� �— f ��'� �\���- ^1�� .1 7" - .._Sr ' � ...- � . .e. ... ... ,. ' J' . I .�.»..♦ -. Figure 1:the location of the subject palm is shown at t�e arrow location. The tree is located in the front yard of the 21976 McClellan Road property. North is towards the top of the image. 21976 McClellan Road Cupertino, CA 2�Page �,� ��rbo'r�v�ll �.J~�. . RT: . �, , � +. JY��.. ��' . � � r ',�.� �'� �µ��. �\ �,��e }Yi�� r P�` �� ���� +�, r� �i���a�"�- �_ � _ <,�,�: • I� ,'r�' �� ��� �,����+..�1. � �.�- .t, '��^ ',�6-,' 1. Y k„ ; �,', 4�,,� , � ; 1 s �, ��t t` � y �� 1• t ^ 5�),�.. � i .� ♦ ; Tr / /I,''- . u��� 3 j r.,� ... -fr� J�� /.4� f e t ` '. .. � �r+��.�.. � � '�t�s . 1 .��+�' '� ~fsst�`�f�"i�, • {, ""' ��� x..-a cz. � X _L s a�. i�-.�.r�,1�Y 17. v.a�,�_'fr�,.5�..� - " ,� t a��•�� �'� 9 ��, . � �� : � . . ' F .'�t(,' . . �*t��f k` ...�,_�-r ��f . � +��� � j: �� 1 �a. `� ,6,>� �Y r �fi a` +a� ' _ �a "^y. �* f b�± ,�� .. �� .f AI 'z`' � ��'� I l! � �` F�� . �: ' r ~ �� . I�II f� � � ��, �. �. T. i nM '` . . . •..� � . :: . Ai.�� ..., , .. ,;, . - . _ �n, A� , .... . ��� ...—. . .__� ._._,..__.. tr.'.. ..., , :... .... -� . - - � . A „4..:,�: ..�� '..:. . ,e ,. . ' ,m: _ .._-,� . ,�.. e. . r� P4�� ' �� K, �"; . !� ``,� � � 3 3�'�.'k . . . � .tS�.S 4',."� tr3',°�....�;.. � A}� �e w���- A � ��1 � W��'{n' 4 � m �, �*6.�„ . {•ty �_y N��, c k�.��.v'�y .�1 �+ � 1^G` . '� '-,��, . . � � �: � �� f,. � �rt� � � v :4M.�� +� �� i�, � � ,� �, t � i � � � � , �., a � � �;`.ca4 . �y � r�;,+v . �,1� �s"� ie g ,� .��' j� �'� 1 .� � �� ��' �, �"y� �µv�d y, i ,� ' � �' �"'.�"� k� �x. .! �.'k A.^ ).� � t'�., ryw ,�i. fi 7 ?�^J"'ht,f,kA�rv •! �.�•il. F�;� �' �.' 'w!� ,� MI1�.. �d � �� � � � � �; ' � �i �x , a E�'1 ' � � . : . ,. , "� � ��� °�'•} `� f. . , � ,. .. . . `°`" .., �r(�"y�}rPF ;_� ! � � L.,� � � �. ' ��' � �" � t� ' ,z:;, � , �'�,w y i ,.y �'�: �l,� ,{ .... :r,;, , . �,�, .A".�a�t ,;. � ..;�1�1#' �� . � ; . I� . �t+e� ', �..'�'��� 3'. t � ,�:f�'���'`��,� {�, � � '�r„. ��` ` �� .� k .� �' •� .a �rw�y; '�+,�o � x . , . . ..� ,. ..,, �. .. . . r j `' . ` q� � i .:'E � �t� �. � �v � F � ,.�.,, _,, ...� �:' . •"a�. n � � V f. . � .•�-yk'fe �,� ���'I�#I S IE,��' �',� . '�' ��j�'��`�.�.�. ���m:.. �,��'�p�"'; ���,(��..� {`k�^ I�V ��I, ��� �^°�� r ���, "^�, p> 4'+t ^�; d`. �!.��,'i�E ��� .. . Z�� ���x6+ '"�, " # ,s ��'t�;�� `� �� ��x �� � M� . I� �l. � ,.�� f ,,. � +� �� #jp ,�� � 3� � � 4.�.�1^�N,�="t � � �:b�y ^',�k,�� r � M�� a 1�,,• � _ .r.; y} a� � ,� '?a�.� '�i. �Yy �!'�. j � � �}tW x � . II. ,�c . ' ':: �' � �'� �� ' M1�� , . . k ^ �;,� . �.�.' t � x e` a„q¢ � � �� �,o � �. r,�� �5 .,�, �t"�'�� ���;, a��. } o-. �'pfi k '�a. �w; . �'„�,r i;f.y�,..t w '� + �; � ,, �• . �I y �, • . °.� x,� i t.w ,. . , � , '• " � � �i� , , � � +i ,y y� Y j,�-: ��x ndr� '��$ � .. ��� ,"�.� '7 � . 'yq... k A �.J W � Y - .,. 4 „ ���`r +'J. Y. w� �w,',� ': ,,. ' � •`�t 3� �i .,1��� 1 � w��;, , , . K .,�. � ., �n R ,'t i - � a E�� �� T�, ( � tS�, .. �,7 .. ^., \ ,. � �t .�ti +_ r + � .. oi�' �.ruh �ri���i r Y� ` M ,� * 9nt,°,` ,..°,�' x �. � fi1�' � �i h a me �,:..� ��t , ti aN��Y'.��}` �� �� .�1 t+t, y,,` '�.�1 �A �! .7C � Z � '�' � n ti�>�.� �.� ��.=�r} i�1`�� # ��i��, ���������' ��.Y-f:'�l ��Y� :�,-`j' ! '��. ..=c _.�u' ��d-y����? x,' �.:. �h��. X 'S� '' ..-G �j�..— 1 t�� r\t�� �`��\� � �. . 'i, � `.�er�(���Y,' `,ry-t,r .�y��'f'!, �y`/ j� � `4it.�:�i��t� . . . .r� � .. 3 9 ` ..? ���`:`�fh i� 'A r \k`. yy' ' �� ..',;.�F � ����wn��v:k 'y� ��y<`�.��,�' ..� AINC t,'��� `�, 1`i � ,��1�\.���.�'� �'�, ��*��y u� •' ° "„v� -z„, ' �� �y� t,k� n�,.�r:t�'�'''�Ce��`F�Y_rr'.t�?,}� t,*'�, ��!�ti � �i dV�t!,� � F. �r �l1���y�'L.�'1�, r �1 V�..+�R.' �4� �F'i"e t4 R1 r'��MC� �'•�S i t��q ^T�f.y+� �'��+ ��' [�&i,�. 1. G�.y h�1�41'� �i( `- t t T e , ,..•� ��". � ` � ;' � . `',� � �r ,��r �. �1 y� �j.J.1�`� ,k.,1j� �w5f �. G 4\�y�� '' ��1 s . _- � ,. ....�.�,ssq f�*y�� '�4 .'Y R� 4�jir 21k��J�'U �,�J#�`f�+N�i'v F _1 �; .� .- �t•���r.:; ^r.�� �4`��' t�n.� ,;f?4 4., �� �5� ,�d.t�.s,•`.21�C�6 a + 1>� �,,:� R 4t� ' '�7M'�' y� fih e Yr "� ,� .��a.� �! `u�����' � � � �>,�x�}.,� yr `"' ' �'� +.` �p ���1�� �f rY �.�k',��� �,q t: ,• . t �- '. s 1•� ,� '�"�' k�,� 4 � i-r ,-- '`'�z*�r° �? i"�+.,, w''. t"*' ...�,k . 4 `. � �w .�: aS�.,, i r ,4 �, i ,�',. 't �. s; Figure 2: an image of the 24" Mexican fan palm growing adjacent to the driveway. The palm is in good health with moderate structure. Our first concern is that the tree is growing too close to the driveway and will continually cause damage to the hardscape. 21976 McClellan Road Cupertino, CA 3�Page -�' �..'� ,� � 4 \ � '1� 8 4� _ �:'+:,�'+$1.. 1 'E ,.y�...n. �� i.+�,. �{. *Ix kz t ' r� : I+;' t S';� t � y . �� �11��'t _ �Yp� E� {i �� � m .�. � '� '�� r � # .�_.��`��. � � �� � � , . ,- ��! . .. , � . � . .__ __. � ;.� "� �. _ � � `°' �*R s - �`�✓. �;- � �� jf �' �F� ,. ����t.t i & "`; . i:� `�f % �rye-'l''� �t`��. - a .�r.:. � ? SiY'} r' a{-��� - � �' fJ� � L�`� �'�\+( ' � �,� ,� � + �, � �,r�'r ,� ,��T�,. t t- r s_y��� � . � �kyi�.�,��� . ' .. �,.. 4����'��#�� 3 ^ als o t ..t !r{is�f y�'� �.' , .j, ,i �i� i.N, i--: I �� ��.a. -�_ '- , � ...�ll z � r'� ' _.- F _ ...� ' ... , � '�N. M � . ,� .'�:. .. _..`�.. . ' +�.. -�=1 � , .... . • . ;. ��'� '1--' . .,: . . . .... . .... � ,_ `i�_-. �. �. _... -`�� n��' �"� t��pi`r��`�'�t � ' -' . -_ _,k�� r ' a t�. . + :�i Y..� .,,� t r� � r r; ,��/1�� � ' ;�i,�i�..� _�`t-�..����ar`'} '� . ��r�(�4� - '��. }'.� *�`�,�, .-+CrP. ','�'�_ ' � !!�!��. �`'� _ •{�� � � � �e.�C+�i,� �,.r. ��s- .t4 . - '- . � " ' r.�.�' ': �� '4�; �-;'•y ����•��-�� '�..1�� � -I�%`' � �C � �,,.�'., T � '° ��: :'� :_ '�Jn�K ' 't . .�. � , .,a_-. �g..� � �, ;--� �. �"'.'j,� '.� �pu�. e�� �.y�`t.,, �. �.� ♦ � �ti�'� �iu`�i y�� iPy �.� t:..r��� '�f y''v����:: � \, _ ��� ��L ti ��""+"lir.� � �:''P...' � ,i;. _ . ...q,. �. ��..`,}'�Z�°¢��rar, � � x c , .. �� � _ e�.. �'�. (Above) House with existing Palm; (Below) House pictured with suggested tree at). �° �� � u� � � ,�`� ��� ,�' �r i � �s �r . ,� °o ',,f�',`t �= k f -`r'....2►` ..++�` d+�y�� . .'��t��'.r�� �..= f� r{ � '�j,'"� . �� Y�•� � �x���� �"'�a ...}� '4�^�' '�,�"` •. ���� r ,, �, . ��. :�; . . 0 r � � �w�s r � � , . _ , , �"� ,�. 2-�a'' � ' � ��?1��: ,�'�,� � k� ��4 - , � " + � ' ` _�.,}; '^ . -.y �,. �,. „� �,: j 3,y�..�,".i..'`'• i : �„ t ,��"' ,�s� � �v, r� } +° ���� ���� �� �� � ,� �',� , r�>��' "A' � �'.t ��,A�^�+. a �1'r'' , � �} :, r' - ,+."� ��„y y � 5�ti� .+ r`. � ,_ . t� �„ /�-rr �< y�� •�_.yr.,..': _ ... �,.., � !.� . �T�aa� n��"._ .F"���' �.`fi �'�:.-T+�,..� �. d°� - _ . ,. ,N .,w1 .., '..'' _ � , `� � 'h ,.. . _ � . � : , y , ..- � � ,, � .. , . ��,;,...�- . j s� p� , v.�, w;a` � a�r- -. a �� -,: ;• ,�, _� �,� . p� �� �� �:,rst. �'.y�.-fr�„�ii�-F �� :�.As' t` � , .., �1 � 'p. . � �? . . _ _ ��°�q'�.k - - `.:_.. �. ' �' Y ,..s.,�, �� v; �.p ��` II,4�,,r�.. �Lu;' -..+,:`� .�I:l� . ti ��'S�� M .f#r +� . z ..:�y�_a r_ . .: � , r � �� � ���� .�. � ��. ` ��� .r ��11�+ -_.. � . ,�,� w,,�, `. +. 'u i ✓� ��_'�"' c�„�r �' , y '� f ;� d •��'"� � �.. .S .� •�.. "�. ^���. '� .. � ... �Yry 4.. �� ; .. ..�.y ��y 4 ,+� f JIraA 1. ��1 G q. 'F�4r .� ..�w . a'' '-..... r�* "" � ,� � � j. -���`,.�;.:{,,.��-�° r��;,,�� �xp� �-� �° a�Y , M b� j���`t ��}, , � t , � -� � .. ` '� ��,i�^ ' `� ��-.. � . . .- ; . .�. ��, �� .�� ,•�. i � + ' a��.' ._.'' __. �. ; �.. �. - - _�,�_ . � �' P _ . � F. � 1. i ���I' � y �e'� �M a. - } t # � .„t�� `���. �� , 'IP M *l r e �� J .,;,.P � � . ,�. � ;; .: • '� . - ,�► :� �*�,, _���ir 'A�j � ��� ,�`� � ��" �4 *t' ^ _ �_. "�"" �, +� tt�. .r ��^�+����,'i.F� } �:�7��� �..� . ,At�;.�,�,,� �� . . • ��.r�.,, "a,:` � - . . . . ,�� .��.„ :. ' y 1 r. . . _.."�'jy , 4�'_ � �� ��'� Y.' r � �� i� '� � �� ��1 . " ��� . . °�'�r .s; �`' ���� , r'k� , -,,;�� • �""° - �� ? .+� ��}� � �*" C�' '�r �' �w 4 "�� � � ��-,���ta� ,�. �a"*;ycu�... _ . . N �.; � � � ;� �,.. � �� _�, ;e:. � � ,-��s. :,;..�::a� . � ''}� �_ � �:� Washingtonia �':; ��� �� � To be �T Removecl ��� � � �, � "" � a � � '�xs�xil�... a,:, . P� � ,� Y ....i . ,j�j � �'g" . '� .�� � :>1 � . . ....,...au:r���:�.�:: - o.�11A1�...,....: . _. ' �„ 4 ��� Location of new tree ��� = � (Little Gem Magnolia) .�� �r�, 1 _ � � � ..�.._�,..�ar�.. - ..et ..�����r.. � �� u"'� ,'"� � �� �; � �jt �" �a t � ���-'�"�:�.�-�'; � � ��� s, � s��., t. � �} �y � # ,9 $ e � � � .� � t h. f e �.. : ~tr � ..,�y.... � � � $ i� � ,fi 'i-.. �a�a� y� .,.. , � �� .... .. �'��. �:`�-� � £ � � '���� �>. : �,�,, �,,3 � �Y. . 4 :"X. �.��. �P.��:. ��� x`�. r� � Y � ,� � J' ri ,.�� � � �' , .�r A � t;.�. _.�� -t - ��p ;raffic z r- ;�; � , �; ��' Y1 � � ;.��� � �� This tree is gone ���� � ��: ,,; ��,,i �''�� � �!����! , � . � � ;. �.t ��� � � � ��� � , m i - �,�-�+.,_�„ � � �`�.�����,� ���� ��;>- � aap! s � � ,.,..., ... �' �.� �q.. � �' Y� G e - ....> - �y# �:� — �� ' y a � I�i .. , -� n- � � � i I � f . �� Ima��ry b 2u:3�vogle,Map data�s��1I3 G�ogle- cvf��r,Goog�e Map Iu�aker tteport a problem .._ � : - . , i� ��� u� � ��- �-*���>�� { � (��' � . . � � �y� `�x . t '" . - �E'Y;g; �° V���'.. .. . . �k* � ��'M� �. .p�� � � � .:'"� -'�,.:., �-.:. . I I �'� � �a � '� �� I � k, � , ' - I r' .„�, v.:.A .,w,_.. � . x . }` � . . --.,-. ,._�. , �+ 1 . � �. _ �'::�+. :..�, I . . � g t . � `'l• K�..�� ��#: .. f' . 4 ° � � �' � ._ R, � � - - � . :�x��.t, �> '. --. _ � x� � . _ Washingtonia Palm �`�'y : .� . ..'�..,.. � ���� e.�o� •4..�. �_ A�R To be removed ��}��--- -��� ' Location of new tree � .��'�, _ �."�xN_..:_:.�,., ; , . � � (Little Gem Magnolia) � � ;, � . � � , . , � �: ��- : �- �� s� ��� ��y� � . � �• �# �.- 1`� W"��..�R'"',�E �c' �`��' .,:..4 Y . ,.,�g.. t�'.:. � . . _ . . �,. &l..��y -'&°��` r'�� +�. � � ,:�R� . , #� � . �.L L .�+�.. . .'� . � �• �' '-.�� g . � ... �' � .� �.:' �y s ; '� .. . �� � . . $• ,. }k" � � ! 4`7 �� �. ��. �,'� ',:-..,c"a." �I�,�:. '� i . . � . �� � -t�� k' r�e c+.:�.. � � ���� ' �.. . . _�� � � ' ' . .., •' �g � , � �{ -,. ., ,... �. 3,� ', �;man.rl���:�a�w:.:,.c �,' '�:�� ,�� ,�- �`��'*+� � ?�.F �•i!x� �. ; 'xr 4 "�' u,a..� l .`i�.a, a *,,::- <t_ "`� . , . . +qr'.�-���� ��` �: _ ;.` � � - :4� A �� Sc fi;R �"� ,� `.� � .�" � � ' � ��• � :Ec ,'�t . ����° , s, ,.�t , 3-_' � �a �# * ' �?:., k ` t��,� . �,.;� ..�� ,�~ �a.,,�� ,. �:�., �.�r� �;�� � � � �, ' � 9�- ��,.- � � t � �... _ ..._,> � * � �,� � �� � � . " . y� ., ..?�, "" � i. �F` � � C � F. �'{ _� * ��;�.; �� .. ,.1`jy.. �.. � . �� ,a=' , �'. �. . �� ..,.,� _ . ,. . ., ':-�. ,. � y z � u . L ` �:: :, . � ... ` _ . W:� . . � C, t � . � . '9V.. P � ��. . � T:�� � . . .. . . . .. � .#� , sR .w'�'� . . . � � � d r y` s�� � � � ».- : � � �i �, " ` ! � . ,. y. �:. �,_� '�..:� ... ti � � � � q� � � � � .. �� Yutli� * .d �.... � �� '�� , � � + � l,s i +,,;7;�; � �. � � _ , .T ,. ::,. .... y��," ....�. �P � . . . _. . _ ..M.a�5�i�,1� a � i _ . �.. q: � . - �}� { � .. � . . �' ..� F� �. . z.�� ��.�. d � � . ._ � � . �f�L`i�. ..4 .. . . . { ... � . . .�'�l� . ... . � .. k �� � l � .!� � �3"qb � �A' .1, �� V �_ � � J �