Loading...
TR-2014-56b OFFICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT � CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE•CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 �����-�-�N Q (408)777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333•planninqCa�cupertino.org November 13, 2014 Northern Trees Tree Service, Inc. Attn: Sione Misi 16192 Setting Sun Dr. Anderson, Ca. 96007 SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2014-56 This letter confums the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on November 13, 2014, approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of a 5 Redwood trees in a retail center (De Anza Plaza), located at 10525 De Anza Boulevard. The application is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROJECT This approval is based on arborist reports prepared by Sione Misi (#WE-7717A), dated May 28, 2014, consisting of 7 pages including photographs, a tree removal and a tree replacement site plan, except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The applicant is required to plant ten (10) 24-inch box Italian Cypresses in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance and approved tree replacement plan. Modifications to the tree species and location may be made to the approved replacement plan pending staff approval. The replacement trees shall be planted within 30 days of the effective approval date of this tree removal permit. 3. NOTICE OF FEES DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exaction, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section 14.18.180 of the Protected Trees Ordinance. Also, please note that an appeal of this decision can be made within 14 calendar days from the date of this letter. If this happens, you will be notified of a public hearing, which will be scheduled before the Planning Commission. Sincerely Gian Pa o Martire Assistant Planner (408) 777-3319 gianm@cupertino.org Enclosure: Arborist Report, removal and replacement plan CC:Hunter Properties,Attn:Suzan Linberg,10121 Miller Avenue#200,Cupertino,CA 95014 ARBORIST REPORT Prepared for Mrs.Melissa Cullinan Hunter Properties,Inc. 10121 Miller Avenue Cupertino,CA 95014 (408)255-4I00 Ph. (408)255-8704 Fax. Tree location DeAnza Plaza 10525 DeAnza Blvd. Cupertino,CA Prepared bv Sione F.Misi Certi�ed Arborist WE-7717A NORTHERN TREES TREE SERVICE,INC. P.O.Box 127 Anderson,CA 96007 (530)510-793.7 Ph.. (530)357-2540 Fax. �r .. ., � 'r`�—�c.>�L.� "�� , -- ,,.,s..« . _ . !`.__.. . _..t.��—_....� . . . .. � �... ..._1' l I-I3 - i�f- :�_ � .�., �._ _ _� �� � � .i - DeAnza Plaza OS/28/2014 ARBORIST REPORT 1'he following observations and recommendations are for(5)Coastal Redwood(sequoia sempervirens) located at the DeAnza Plaza on 1 Q525 DeAn�a Blv�Cupertino,Ca 95Q41. it is the iatention of this repart to exaanine the(5)Redwood trees to determine if they are causing structura} damage to the near by wall and concrete the concrete pads at the rear entry of various retailers that occupy t���.'Ft�e�c�r�ra�p�`orm�o���2�,2{#i4_'Ihe��}��u�t�.s are i�t6�e ba��f tfte two t�cu�d�gs at ff�'25�3e�Bfvd.'£hese�edwo�o�tree�s vvene p�ed to cfuse to tt�e wa�,nat allowing adequate space for the trunk to grow and expand.The small conidor that the Redwood trees are grrn�'iag is very Zi�ctited'm space abaut 1 U'vwicfe fvr such a}arge grawing�ee species.Ttre 1oc�ivn of the Ii��s a�v��e s�€�a�d��c�€�€�t X���'s�e.�R€�w��s� located behind the following unit,#105,#175,#106,#108 and#100. T���It�€r�d����er�iet�sj��ximat�y st�c 6�"�t�g�E a�ci wi#t�a��af 2Q„ to 26".The Rec3wood trees are the cause of thc damage to thc wall and concrete foundations.'The lower trunk and root crown is expanding and causing the wall to lean in the direction of the neighbors.There is visible damage to the wall lea�i�g and separativn Qf wall at the co�ect�g pc�ints.'1'here has also been a 1�a�g�ry afconcr�te an�imd�r ground Pip��ge and rep�irs c�used by the r+��od��r��_�he leaning wall is a potential hazard. ��t't�y�e��'R�wrtto��es��������I r�t��#e�ec� trees be removed due to the potential hazards and damage.The small confined space that the redwood trees are growing in cannot accommodate such a large growing species of tree with out some degree of damage �tt�e�rc�t�g Sbrot�tutces_ Northern Trees 1Yee Service,Inc. Sione Misi Certified Arborist WE-7717A F f).Box I27 �lnc�erstm,CA 9�}7 (530)510-7937 Phone. �53k�}357��S�Fax. �Torthern Trees Tree Service,I�zc. Page 1 '� � ��; � `�°' � �'� ..=�s� �' ���, . ��. � � �� �� r ` . �� �� ',h � �_ ��: �'. 4 �. � �� � �� �; � � � �s �^��` �;, , � �.. ,.._._ ... _ ��''s -� � . ; _ �: ���� f � # � ;;; '�� �y � � �, � � ��,: "il `� �' � �:� t � . - � :; s_, �t � � _ � :�ry �` � ;� ���, I I��� � �` � � � , � .� ,. � . �. �� � � � , _ - � �: _ . �.- , , ; � :�,. , ,� � r_ �- . , � � . � ,� �<<_. . , � �',. � _ ,� � . � �� �:. _� - , s� � � a; � '� �"� � � _ , : � , _ � � � � � , 5. �,�.> r a � Q' � � � '� �i � 5 _.., r r � . � � � � . �� -x �,,«.� s� �r .'�.,*,�'� �,r " � �s � . . �, �'.. '��. 'Y �Y �:�.°' -a��. ' �a, b �� L.`:� .:.,g �. ;.��s;. �.,. y ;y .� ,k � � � `y ; � �. , 3,'��,, :'S . f „nV � �`r. u� � � , _ z;, a � ,' � s , ,� ,�< � - - - ;r, �,. . , .. , �� .. �� :et-�� ' ' :. SG ,_.- .. . . ; .. .�� ,� ; . . , _, � , �w �. . ... �� .:., . �! ,.. � .. . . . . .. � -�.. � � � � .... ',„ -. ��.. .: _ `s'� .'� 4�.„w. � . : t� ' �,..� .�.-G - . . ' .. . �� .:; .., . � . . .�. . .. . .. _. . ....: , ., . . o: � 4�� ; .:_.. . . .. �:. .� . .. -'� _ j T �� ' � a » . L � t h� t . � � � ��� �.. 4 �+�', `,Y��., .. e g �. � +°�1F I1 •k �FNt '��" - S . : ; � . al� � V . �. y$ F � qF'� �v'�' � '�. , '€Y � � � '� =�v.. 4. . �.. 5 f '9z� , , a. � � 5 � , , - � ,:��' '.� '�S�S J�� , i ;L:. . ' � ". : ' �{ ._ �. � ,� ... -� .. . , n i _ ' _ �: . , = A' ' ,, rc�,,_ 'i %2.� c-. b y;; .. .. �. y.i-�.�p,� . � . _ ; . .z:'� .. '. .. � � . :R` g " �- .. . -� . � . � �4% " �. � §.(�' .ti� . �:��' � � s..r: �,. ;=�$-� � � . � .. � ::: ,�, �. � � 3; ,K_. ..- ���• �. �� �� �� � ,.� � ��;: ,: r - _ ,... r �� -�. � ,�, ' ' _ . , en.�. ' � - . , 4� ., ,.: �, . ... ..x .t . ..:� � � : [� , . � '..,Y o „ �9' � 'Tkabv �:�; ;. . �v .. �' �- � _ .,.,, .. , ,_ ' . ' . ' . + . .". , .�. �.. ' . . . „, . 1 . . ,.. � �. . _ , ,� -� � � � � � a�: � �i:., `;�. � � � �;s�, ,�: E ; � , ,_. , _; ., , � �� r �� �s , � ,�� } ,- � , � � ��. � ,,�, � �. �, ;; , . x �. , ;� � ,. �`�' � ,� > �� ,�; _ ��; , . ,�; ,. �' � .°� ��; �:::- ��, ��" �- � s� �` �- : , w. _ t �. ,. � � 1 r� -� � - - .',.., . . . .... . . . . . � . . :r �'�� . . . �� m .. 1. y�� .y . aT 9 ::��, i, ,.,�� ;, S"� �. ,��. f ,�V��I tU, I §..�f � +ya�.> �� . � W z'� � � �` �c ,� %' i� �x � �� � € � .� . � �..r � ..i �` �' , ��' . "�,. �� N� _� `', %-:4'�. ,.. ��,> b � .. � , �, ., , . . - ,..,,, � � � '�, � � �}��i � � k '�" .' � :aK�p "' . - a. � i, �: �R` .. . �. _ - _ _ ;r� , t�m �, � ", , a ` ., b . .:. ,,: � .. . , �., n• .�. x �y .... - . �.. t. . ��, . � � �`. � :-:: �: ; i: t; ., : � . �'• �i fi � <� � � � f J• V . .r . b. . . -a�`^. .. � �� '.�'. �. ::i,.� Cv:� . •� � , ,. ' ' . . �.�:�. e ° �'i=, � .. �� , �.i'.. -Fr.vs -.a�^. �� � Y Y V � �t.,�` _ .. . . y' � �, ` �`� �; � '� '� s ` }�; z. � �� , ��' `i, H �F'� �„e. r:,�. '" .. . r �� ' �� ;� � !Ca �� � ' � - � � .... �si } �. .. ��� . � . . �;�§ R��.:����-':,, 5 « , , ,. 9P ;:. .;. � . �. � . � -. .. .:.� .,. . �'. - uq. . ,.�. ;. ..� ., . S �.3. : ..i ,,.. . . � . ._. .- . ,o.. f:� '� . .�.''t;^ ";3 a�' gW ��` �' �_ r'e� ��F�� � _ . ,. '� ^�;� �. ' .. s.� 3' �; � . .� ;�; �,"�'. , � , � � � ; , � �:,,,E, : �' ,; • � . .,. _ � , : - . � � . c_� f������� �? "s�,� � � � - �'�. � r.��=' - , , _ , � � r- . . .,. h '. �.' . � . . �c. � �. � :e ,� Y ... � . �.. `�," -��, :.._„ r -"r ,� � . �� �^ ,�;� ��� t � � .., �j{ � � �' �� � r � �'�� �4���� � �� � �: � � a. �-�- .. - . •� � �� � $yF � ����5���, ��� � � ..... �.` � . �i � � . • r; ,'- -. . s.�' .,s Y � . . �., . . -- _ ._,. � .. . .� � . .� .' . _:. . . :, , '.. :: . r y �y �� �� m: '� �� � � :� `�e ��'. ,� � �.,�� � �� _ ��, �: � � � � � �, -`` '" 4 � � ��� � ._ .,�` '^,� � �-' � ��I� '�^� .. � �, �, a ,t . ., "�':- : ��. �, � � a � �. � s ,� � r �R �� � .. f. . : .... ,��' _.. . . ,� � �',�- � � ���.. *�'�• � � � � � �. � � ��� � ... � `i � � � � a, �: , � � �. �� ' �i;� :�• ,a, #' . : �,., � , . ��� .� � �� � � �� .r ' - - ��`t �` s: - "z'�„ : `�'�x". : � ,��,. . ��" ,w. ' ;-, ;:: , N � y��� � � ,.. � ` � £. ,- � ���� � �� :,� �` :�. - .� ; .. �:. , �� , � �r� ..y� . � s ,� .. . � �`� ., k� �,��$ �a��� ��.�{�C , '� \� � - "`:� _ ��� . a , � ' � . � . . . . - .. _ ., ��:. , «�:. �� � �,� ., ... : � „ - � s z,r : :.:.w. , � , �, .< . F �� ., � �,n � ,. � �. � , 'eFS�� �`- ,y. _ � k, . a , q�c, . . .. ,.�:.i"�` 'f ' :5� `� �..� � _ , ` } "s:-�. g � .. �" �� � , .. .'. . � � . ' :� „�. ,� �_� . .,.. � -` ,, � - . � . , � �.. ... � .. . ��. .,, _ _. y,�� ,. w :.. _. .�' ': ' �� `�� - . � - ,- � �. ' b � '�' ' :$ �^�� � .;� � l , . . '��" 'i5:.�. .. . �� � :...7 �� ..a.. �`$. .. � � 9 . ,r� �.Y . a°' ��..�_ � � ,-:x. � � .. �� �`p � �` „:; � . � b : � � , . � ... . � � ;r i � ' _ '. � _ � .: 3t"`. �.. `�,�-,�„ .. . ��. . . � ,�i . � ,. - . x . . . .. . �-:.... . . ..... .. _.... .Y. �, ., ,_-:tx- � 8��� ti� '�"r�� �n � '� � �' � � � 'i �� � ;� � � ;'�. � ' � � � .,.X ... ,y, .. . : '�'. �� . ��.. ..'*h �� $�� �"P �'� {-u' ;a�.� � . . . � - � � a' � � � „ �+ ;. � � �-� ��� � � ���� <..; � � �'�:=i { y �, _ � � � � � R ��� � . , � �, _ � � ��.� ,w` ��€- �`� �; � `�� �� �� � _ � , � � � �� . .�.;;:: . . , .. -a�'� _ �'�#. y r. �" " ^� � � r�"�s � �� � � � ��. � �� �:. X" �J � - �� .' . � :,� _ _ �:: ��v � `� � y � ��� —_ �f.� i ��� .... ��„ � . � �. F _ '� ...�. � :,� <g;� - .. - '�7_ .. . .. ..... q K�'.. � ' � - � � � � 3 � ,� .F �. , . �. �-' �,',; , , .,, r , ^' � #. , .:... ,.....,.. �' s 3�� �2 '� C 'y�' � �ry� & '.�fS,f.''� . �" ��� . �Y' �� : ,� ',: �, � -� > . � ��`�' +�, �: � � ' �_ _. ,,.,�+ _ ��< r., � b ':"�` - �',Ld nJ� �y � . _ .. � �' � �'�� j�;i� �� h . � �. 4 .. � � . �` �: � k �a, - .. � ,' �s • � , + � .�`�. . '��° . � ,��:�. . _ . `�� s �. � �� �� ��:� .. �. .:� � '� L� � . ._.. ' �'t.F � ` -+ � � .� . . ; } ;,. � � �r' . * .,�.. � V �. ';�'`� �`:' .. .. k� `F�� ... „L::'� ,�-.. � � � , .z ,. ..�..s.w. . ...,.'3 i.. , N . .:-_ , ..� .� : '. � i r -, . ,. . .; . , „ -- ., �-` . . ,• H�f;., �. ` _«. �. „ � •� photo.JPG � � ,, � � _� , i j•:. � y x 1 �/. � �' '� ' ... � � �; 4�.:�` x �P � t � � � �� � �" � �, �� �� �� '� � � b � , � ^^� ' � � �� , �r ��. � �Y , � � t �'. P ��� � ' � ���� � �� � � 'f'� r g ... . ,�. � ' 1 �i� � �� .� t S . .# '� 4 ��. � '� � ¥ � } � y 1 y�, `�� �- � €�: r , x I 'Sr � Z � az � h�[rt A,- ���w. . ''� f ' � x .�d y,�!y i i ��it� n' k�"Rf���� � � 3 �Y G `'f "]�� 0�1. � �� ��.A x.'. rn � /Q x ��4 � y Y�[ � �`j�� 'y �:�� y E `�' > . , . � . , �'�;., ,. ' . ,, � � �� . t .��C[��kW�� ��' oi�;. i �l�'-.Q��. � ,�, ;� � � r r' �"+" , a�. ti'� y e; �+;�,�y„��; �� , ��=' � .� �,�a : � t �r; s;<� f� �s'- � � � � � .r +�; „�> ��A�+�':�"�'�;:. , � ��: .��'" `"'� -�. � �� , {'`� 3`�a . �_ ��� J5 �� �`1 . . 'i` .'`�„ ,�q'+,�, J' � � s�s� ..�o'��y, .t Y �I �e � ' a`�'55��.�.� i .. . . t. . a �f $-. �fi� s�% �.. �;_,L-�;�.� ' �F p ,r i 4���'��� �" �� �, � f�,� ��� - � � , • � r '� � � ��y.� �� °',�.:a �, #�> :� ,�,�"� � A �" ��° !(p�,, �`S� � 3 �>.' r, . x ;�;�� °� °=� f b �t �' :.wa. �„"�^..�'.xx.`�.. R�'x���b��".`:��x�"'� !� �., �. � �,,R�_ � Page 1 of 1 {. � � � � �'. � '�.,; . '' https://mail.google.com/_/scs/mail-static/ /js/k=gmail.main.en.cwyogPXLdlw.O/m=m i,t,it... 8/8/2014 ��1n14 C3'D ...�.-�C.. �,�c�10 V,�,.��..' --, �A�--L- 1RA t�(�CZ�- A f�!� !�R��",,,. "i._f�U.t�l K..S �%4 C"� �� �--�------���-�--�- __.._.____..._...��._.__ ..____..._�.._.__.._._. �', ►��.�'�n�.r.�, 3�v�, �d�J►��iC�S2-- ���tz.l�S l l�l.�.. . �u?,�c•!t L.�aJ���.R�l C.�) ?..�S��IoU , 5 � �' l�.c, �t�� ��s �'cz� �/ c�, t ��� �� � �s�a� s�- 2�'� � v7� � � t a�a.5 � ���S S S ,�e.���zc�„ �tvci , _�, �. !µ-S� �,;_:,..� �_.�'J��L Ti��-� �.� ..,,,_. _ il—�3�� � �.: .. y �vG�. ^ , � � � _ � C � � rt� l� �`� �� � , � � � ��'Q `�g � ���� ���� , � � .��``°`J ,,�t,5 �� `� �ti� P � 1 � 1 . -- �� •�6� �, �ef�rTzC�, ��/�. �-1�1.�s1�-__ i�k?���-.�_i �.S , t�.l,.C. , u. `"aUZ.E�•l L.._t o,:��;tz..S:.� �L�S�i i�S���.��.U U t�lf�f�t`t i.�,►z� ���_�=�_, -.� t�.�"� S�X2...I11 c� L 1 ba.C, �`�a�, ti''t�s ` - � ��,__ 2�3'7 u ��� ��������� , . �. C�"�'"� � � 40C� C�► � � � C�A �4 tO�z� -- ����5 ����.�i,rd .. �.. . -�� �`�'.L i�-�i�-,5b�.,��...�. ,�,,,..� _ . _� _ � 11-1 3--�� - , l °�- L,�l�'..� � � _ c� � � � �-