Loading...
TR-2014-68b COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE•CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 C U P E RT 1 N O (408)777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333•planninq�cupertino.org January 13, 2015 Tian Hua I Kuan Tao Attn: Frank Liu 7811 Orion Lane Cupertino, CA 95014 SUBJECT: HAZARDOUS TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2014-68 This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development; given on December 15, 2014 January 13, 2015, approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal of a felled, hazardous, and dead 30-inch diameter Coast Live Oak (quercus agrifolia) on a quasi-public/institutional parcel located at 7811 Orion Lane. The application is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROJECT The approval is based on the Statement of Justification and images provided by the applicant that show the tree uprooting and damaging the property. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The applicant is required to plant two (2) twenty-four (24) inch box Coast Live Oaks in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance and approved tree replacement plan. Modifications to the tree species and location may be made to the approved replacement plan pending staff approval. The replacement trees shall be planted within 30 days of the effective approval date of this tree removal permit. 3. NOTICE OF FEES, DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The Conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedicaHon requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby further notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exactions, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accardance with Section 14.18.150(B)(1)(2) of the Protected Trees Ordinance. 7811 Orion Lane TR-2014-68 Sincerely, .- � � � , � i � i rick Serrano Assistant Planner (408) 777-3205 ericks@cupertino.org Dated: 12-15-2014 Dear City Planner, Due to the heavy rain on December 02, 2014 the oak tree from our backyard fell down (as attached), damaging the fence, in order to protect ours and the neighbor's property we removed the oak tree on Dec. 13, 2014 and at the same time, there were a few dead juniper trees on the west side of our property, because they may have caused hazards, for safety reasons, we removed them. We are working on the city's requirement to replace the new trees. Should you have any questions, please contact Frank Liu at (408) 529-8618 . Thanks. Frank Liu � � ; � . .�.� ian Hua I kua ao 7811 Orion Ln. Cupertino, CA 95014 � A n°.�.-, �„a.,�. .l_}.--.-..�-,..�.��1/-.�.,,�.�.o,,,�,�.r��. .,.._:9 Jii�i'�3r ..�^I,��" �� . .._,.., ./_•• -- �- -� ..._,. .�...,.•...��.,.�.,.a., .�/-� .:.y., i L /���� ��" _�_.,......_ ,.yr '° �/ �t�� �Y ������;��.. �i,� � �` � � -�. � �� ,�t� ��s� �� �s �i` � � ,� ��r �-- � k= ' � � � �+� �� �� �`����" �� �5���. �,`: �. ��• ;,,f .�::�� � � .!r' i� '� �, ` FN j��: �w� �+ t $� �'.d'�'e . �:� . S��Y '*e. �... � �`S. -! +r� s_ � '`-.� �� � z �� � Tt � . �j<:��,i� �4� ,��v c`' � �1 L' ����� � �R' � ' ��y4*7cc r t}�,: .� '�i?.� �� ���� � ��'� �: � �, t��� � `���� -�; ��' APPROVAL '�� �j�� �� ���� ! ,:,�., �; �` r A�;r:;;._,t�,�;, :,� ;;,, __ ! �,; � •�, �r, � � ' '��°'� � ���� " �� a .` ��``` �t: 'r;: /��_. ,�` '� /�� � � �" �' �.t��t��i '��/. ;� /r ¢..li/,.?':' �t►'��a �:�`�� '�'�!���� ♦ 4�i�fi '`:-s .�,'��t�: ..,.��� � + 4 ��r. � �....�... .. ...a..,�..�r . /"�.-.,......... �'7f�^_'. ?,�±ar��a�"�{1��:� �,:i, e+;� :� � �4:� a} `'� �t . r[ � .,..,, � ^`j � .,�� . � w ` Ti��. ,, .` . y�Y : t^.'. i' .g. . '3 y� `�=��@�Ft: ��`+�! ��i��� �r .�� � . �t �'��` ���� i,-t,� �.- . ._� .... .... � � ,�a�':�'��'R < _,�r .� _ _ -� '.�� Y�'. .-�4 f . �,1 ',. --• "'`�� r tl- X�.,��',T.. rv�� 'frbdyi �°��*�,.y Ce. �t�.�.� .r '�p' � '� � j{ �. '8 • ''l� . . '�� 1 .i 'r%S ._� 67��� 8'r.� ,��.,n ��'' `.: : �. b� ,� ��' � �� • . p. ��;.P.� �W � � =!, r (,,s4•'*. ' � $��. `,� �;. }tit"jid r u� . � .. � il ,. ,{p ,-_.�� . . �: . r �.��. ��,��� # �� �: �'}� � ;(n _ _ .. ,,, �yy ,, .:. � t� • � ��. . �FP, '.F , �� :,. w y.r i �Y{h �Z.��Y ,;. �i�� Yt�.' �� > _ t . }���#�, � �, �x r ^.`� �� i r r.a. ''i�i y� m- ��r '�� `'-�� ,j �i�,�� ��y�� � � %#'�. ���� ` t1Y ..��# 1, I-�� l y�,.� �7' \r;�' $k�±�` 4�3}}r,� q�1.�� '� � .�.� 7�.� '''�'� y ;�. ,f � � .,� �� ,a � F �� , yy� a ' � l {`rr,� R ,,*� �y � , v 'i �.�1lw q..�� .�. L,. + t '�� �.�'t 3 ' .// •� _ .., � � `�,�, ra1l;. �r � ,.,'R ` .iS.�� y �}�` ��•4 + `F'i� • "t ��� ' � � ;� s} t� t� . �i ��� } it��.�� y�r'$K 4F� �~'�� Y « t� � `�" � 1��� „� "��. * , �.c ' '�- � � ��{{ e � '"" r '� � i ' ., J1 � � .f_ {�i ��� �P f�"� �y f A �.�,,,'f ��R7i _ . 's �I_.�4 :. � . � x 'f �,1 �� �Y� S A �'U�'�+T' '�t,+�R ` � �R � � Y � ,(. �� ` M 41 � 1 1 t,� "f �.�a� �(� .�t �a$a' �°4';��� '~ � ��"',� :ilv����k`�„ � .•� �S,'yr t� '�*`' i'.,4 � �•e^A�` _� _�,ya`. . . .-.X ,ti y+� �. `' � np� '.►n� ;t': 'Y lf�?f � F' "'=9t y.. /�-��J�I►� �K, s J Y ry TR .�?w }�..��:+�• �� •.� ��.. �.f r` -'$'4t; 9 J .''�` 'A' �� � i,�j� E � ;x�i* a .x.�� ' �X$� * ��' i 4 �`! �` ���`P ,� . �16 '� . v � a �' .. � -`. •3o„'Sr a ''.r'- i4t c -d"��: ,.,..� '� 1 +� �m- �a � � � � � `� Mw-.�''a.� t9' + �;�� I�� �,�� 8.., -- .. ��✓�►°•� .F ti � . ` v' ' "i�: "' 1. �� '� .i �. - � '"''_ ' : � ac.. +K-•., .� �! � �� t,�; ...{ ti,� �t �'�"a`r@�� , �+I.'!t+��� . � __ A ���,���� � .b`. -.,� ��f "�� ` . a �, " �� ���(�� ` t' . . e �A a • y . . . . y.-�. �.. >. e � . �.. '.., ,�� � � L .�.;..� 1 ; �, .•. ' 1 � % 1 ' � � , 4, 'I{� . j . �: _ � � > .�a � �... T . '€ , M a� � ' -.,. '� , _... ,., , � .� �' ° �' � , s. � ; , � F_" � f-..� ��. _ `Ew� .� .�" . . . ` . � 1 �`'.F% . r � °+A��.�� '�... � „ y j�,. '.i" �', i� �� .. . . ' \. ":�i. ' ! y� JJ . :� F�c. � � .>f � � .. F`" ,'��� - . '` `� � f , ' l��,�' � `� r��i , .. _ K � ' ;� �-�._ ti . .� .. . ,r „ . ^� " - - � �` . . "``"'°s �" `�:.,,,' . - ��' .r.� �t'� � �� .�. . ,r..� _. � �� .� � �! . _ _ . _ � _ , .. �F•t"gw' ' .y. ,- ^�... .. �� � ,' t . ty� * . �♦ , � �,� . . . T, � �f ��� ���•. ���f p f�jp� .,. y� � � . �v-'�_z Y� � � � 'C�f:�� _� �� ! � � �,1e � . � ,- �3� �r� . , tii J!^�, T. � `i� ..: 1 Fa° �. ... � . ? . . 2� _ . � >. � *y..:.�t' "�"�.'.p �,,,y ��` � J r .�� � d,!���? '����. � , `f '�: ��. �'�,.. . . �%�'x ''\ }� t��`..~ �45,,,' . , . ` ��.��'�i ,i � �.a�v .e, � ��r.; r ,rt,+' 7. �'7f'�S •,��,�.,,,� .`<Y.�'� 1 i I 5 � °i �`-��, � , . r +�, y�� �6. ;°.�fi _.�"d�"S . +� ,s � �' v. � 'a. "3,7t I�r 4� yi� � �"v �.f^ -c^.= §�'' � �, � . ` , . .� t ," 'm. F.'� �;4,r �e�u'... v` ��.,'� '\ � i� . : �o- '�' , k� � ��.. ,�i'.r�.i.�y.A�s , y� ,.,�� "�."7�.. { .�, � � .... -.�s .� ,i�:a K . � '7r��- .�... a * ` ' . . . . , �,, � � . .M'+Y. ^'t'YNa �'}+ �. �+C� "r . � �"�!k �� � 1. i ,. . � '�,€ V4 �; . ��T1Rwc!' .s- '"r JY"'�'°' �r �������� � . .. R�* �.`^� �, i,.�;,.` � f� . ' � �� �k ""'_ '���� Fr� �''`�r '�'�"'.�«�` �';�-� � t�"'��� � •,a`' �.v' '�5�� x ' �k, ,' � � ` ,„ , � . '"`ti_� �c�F' " ?P� + + ,`,,��, ,�''� � a,� �; � ,. , � �`°`� , .arrr��• fG���'r�� � . '�� � S'�� '3``..a , `:� t� � ' � , b. , , � , .. . ���y� .. , ( +n \�S�i'�� ��� � � �J ' \�� • � \ � .M.�� �, .' 1 J$ �.#� r` k' A-� 1 X �f ...Y[ � . F"F ' -� . a ./:k .� 8 M5 � iT �-r. r r:,71 � `�..:�. ;�^a+i '�I'1..�`�-,fi,..,,,.+.�,. . .�. ., � �' t , y p 4 4,� i�_ ,�,;� �,r, 7 .ti":�'`�}wc:,�'� i{'�� si+�� #'�'�'�_ ';S. �.�• ° '"w:•Y!'�y. �a '� 4���*�S,�r�l"� � '�' :�� § >i�,�' �, r�u: . . . � ��'��, e-:� �,;�-.i,:. • `�-" , ,.�Ah ..� . 44 ,�.,.. �, ..+,. ;;,���, .:��;. . : , q� . �.�,t'';-'���ve-.`':-' �.- _ „.';,--':.• .r=�r�';�`- .. fi'.e� �'> '`'�`y'�, °ic'r�,r F+:•o .� . -I �« r � "r . , ..�, ,� , *'s +�-`..y�1s�,.ic��, • � -c ..�.,,, � jtH " f'' 'L' - t . . t, a ,. { ...� t � { ..M,.y� , _.. � .� •- -'=�-{r �. r'� , r . �r �.48 e' . . . . � �v.. � �'"� � rr : ��'� .•�: . .x'":" a - •;�.� ' * ` ��� . ��. ,y� .. , - � �, ' ,� �� ��� ��� 'y� .. X j ? i �� .... �..T" ��' .Y._��' ..„y�t�' �.� ��,R yr-,� . .',�� ��� ' � � „�i.. � . \ ,�" ,„�• ��� ����� *�' � «�� . . .- 7� - ;3r a� � . r"- � " ��"'.i' '� � �a ��. ��=5' �y.'�M�h. :� :�" -�t . � - �` '!� 1 ,.�.� �� �� < ,. � . �g` , , �� � ,- .�` .��`r. • ,'i��� R �.xi.� �'ii� 1,� iw`..,.� b'.� y,� ... ♦a ru�p ,�. tl a, � �.,����� , .a.� .a ;�.�.i;�'���� .��_-{S��i �+..'��-,'.t itJaA'i�,�,�,'?, y� � - f'�.R`.. ,'•+� 'iSll+l{ � � .+r�.�.. . . . " . . � �c. � -�. � • , ,._ . S . . . { . � � �n :. . ca,� .� . . . . �"r �'t s ,A� r`'y{� c!?Y� �'A►S� e`vi , �a' ,��"�� s.c*"� V;: .� a��r � _ . �4 � � M;*N���+r� °',R �.. :, �, , � . . � . � ��,� � , `�'� , �'�:..� �'' �. - trf -^K�.sy urf r<4� ��' +'"'r�/��R i�y±�,,, �� -1�� i g� +� ++�� � ����`�1 �`'KK _.1 f; ,��!��'ykj '��G'i i'1 :`.�K � ..���i /'•��/ !A'� �1� . . �, 4 1 t��� ��L�' ,.✓. �l 'yi' ��'r � �*6 �$ � � � �5 `. �` 1 ti' � .9S�'..LY � � MLy r. f ♦.l ../� � � t� � �� `+ � ,4Y�+ ' � ♦ +l "w d t_'����,�r.! a � {e L.'�*`�ti',�,��{ :y;`t..:�i"'� J.:%��'°�'�..�r� ,�-' -,;� �T� -•, ti�.- �',���; � T �`'"� ��.. x�. s „", Js�tt r�'°'�w -,,`�..,,6> ir�"`°�w�" ;fs ��'"'.,.. .�i:°�i},f„91�1�1:,�`,fP'"V. ���,i+'�'��. �-�' �� ;"�{�+G�t�,�r...,���= .�!'~ `�*,�m� '�";,15�.'j�'� Y�„j r��.�y..<�...�',,'�y ,,�y_�_�f��'y�,��-�� . � .�. �'. '�...` �k .'.\ ':,�!��P'.>• 3 : �':"jI�"' ',��. .,j• ..l. , . , �r. , ��k�.���.�M'�� ��.�1. y�Y �'�.;v��` •� ..� � � , . � y . ' � �rs '�.1�X. � it G::...�� �:' �..c °t' '� � �.°���-a.:rY.��` � ��.� Q. rf•.�y.r�� ¢ ,.�'::t i:,� V~'�.�y..,�_. 1.y`� ..,�� as j�r`-� pg�� � .+��i�t`�. � 1?.d _ n� , d• '�T . ,.+� Gt . .'�, ��� �,i�. �../. w ' .�. • � j R� _T. � � . �`-�6jy ,�,�,d- '* '"� �. `t,.`�r.;t'",�o,�� � .�'^4+'`.--- :>.,:j�,:�',i, a�-: '�'""-� '�-� �i�' - - ;1, '`' �-'� t r�"'�•�'/•'�o, :�` 0.�� s '�`�,'�"�`�,��'.�-• � . : - ` iw:% .s�„j :, ,� •�^`�e..,� + -,.� i i: si� f�'��FO' r<:i � *'-,�►., �i.p � i. �'� �� /- �,'^- ' , v - tG�" .�,. "- ��' �. .+. ' �„ _,i� ,s r�.,.' �.i^ t :�� - :�� +� �,� :�;t �r t --: s,'"�` ��, < �' .� � � �,;_ � -,i _�.� �`t..�,s '' ,.������ �' 'A,i,^ �" 'y � .,'c'j �-: "� � "'� -,.r�! t,yrr' k ��Y'��i�"i.YY� '� �� ���. _ t.�*,� i� '�, r -r?-.� f' �`� ..��: . �" � _ . �"p ` a� -- ,i� � . . i.'�' � y ,�"',. ,"`,+- -r".'t e%iJ��� }"��.=.'I' - � �� .�i� r�l� ��' � ' � J k �" _ a�,4 "'���� -+�� ' �i`� ��: (� ( �t t _ � `Eb.� "�". (.�.f,< +'Y( ..,.=*, � -�!C �, .,� . � �l.sl�. ,�+� r`����:(l�;�i� ,tY°� �"M�n. "`�>'?� .'�.,4'`4 '; t� ♦,.:µ7�a *`*�'`a^ „'.Y"_� '^':'''+�,'�S-.. ,v- �. , :;,. �"� . r y� . �# ,.n�fS.a��. . . �.�� 7 `�t`' -;+'y� ., i�. -•s� y' !+Ii'�' -+rar= . -, �..�a,..i L..r.r.,R �.T� <, ,�,�.' ,.�,���M1Vt1' . .. , �.�,?'t\ . ' .�,.r ` "�! „ . . - � -. / '�} .� �° y (. __ , -�. � �:.��.;,� t�at'., :S-?�►. v��. •.r^��T=y .'L�.�.*��Y:G��. �-,��� � .:�� ,,, �,-.. i:, .i'��.. �� �.. 1�v4 ;� '"�� ' - , . , .. � . . . . �,+ ' . i:".`� - ,-,, iic ♦ .�. . ,`,�- ���. A ��� -t� _ ���,...+ �: , y �� � ...L, •�-�^ ,� a?T5�1="r_��% . ��'.. ,\ �� .�>„�. �" `'`,,��l.�:: ��T v���.--.• ,0.'d^"�> ��.�.a�.�, �.,�' .r:�..rr.-�T7�a- = , .�'� ��_ �': !' #,,.� � r_ � ,����� .1 �� ���'� �t ���R.7►+, r ♦�. ,'F:.S� ��^-� -',� � ,,�d' " ,.�. �.. Y � �< �-- si , y; -� �`� .:t ! � {r,� �.:;�y. +a.y¢i✓"��..-�.!.�..<.�.�'Y,^�6,i t,, � �c ,I� "�,..1 .+r� ,. 'M-�'_ '4 '.- �`. �►,�,,.,�:� �?' � ; t��� v` �'i�., i� :.r�lr's'7�, �-:� ,;. '���e�'q.�`-�''��.� '.���� _ ��r ���i�p_�.-I � " =��,.�,}-�'�,�-.j:� „���'�.•�,7,�ic�q1u„>+t _ b.�� y� ';�, 1 P"""'� '�►"/►•'��,��� k„� �1�'�.3..v�. ��..R.t,,� s �`'�3 ,�`,' �Cn,��,� � �rf' � ^� f �� � � �� .c i� t ,y�� +�' -1d�. ��,r�,a.� �'�. � ! t:� r � ,�� ;M� �� �� �-� �:.���'.ff .�. �� ���� �� �1F.^�S�F �����`�� � � ��4'°f��'�'+�� � �';;�`�� ���`� � � � "��r a�.li''Y"'!�� �.�I'I�� nm r P -�_�v ...+, '�^'' � ..��� ,���s:��� ';`�`� t''- -#°��"°�j*.�✓°- "+ ,��_ �`„r• �`�,.����.1 .�.�' .A��yl�j.-'�", ' �f 'l� ~ �.A i� � '`�`e�Q���� t�`�� :^"'79tT ._ , � �gp .- , r '��y,�.- +� �.�/ �i� 'Ta/ '�8vd�'���'��i.�...,I/Y✓. �� . ,'+ .'�'� '.��.......��'�'.. ,. :�J��.id:J .�:'t�� t- ..•i i �.'q 1'� sL��'t�^ i , �-'1 �°�� ib9� �:::i �'�". .+� r t' . _.... � .� ��`'�y � ...��� �'R`:..J.�,,•a�s'���a�'`�i .'