Loading...
TR-2014-62b OFFICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT � CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE•CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 C U P E RT�N O (408) 777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333• planning�a cupertino.orA January 7, 2015 joe Nama Commercial Tree Care P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara, CA 95052 SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2014-62 T'his letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on January 7, 2015, approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of 1 protected tree at Case Bank, located at 10250 Stevens Creek Blvd. The application is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROjECT This approval is based on a report prepared by a certified arborist, Joe Nama (WE 3238A), dated September 10, 2014, consisting of 8 pages and a peer review report prepared by a certified arborist, Michael Bench (WE 1897A), dated September 18, 2014 consisting of two pages tree and a removal and a tree replacement site plan, except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The applicant is required to plant two (2) 24-inch box trees or one (1) 36-inch box tree in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance and approved tree replacement plan. ModificaHons to the tree species and location may be made to the approved replacement plan pending staff approval. 3. NOTICE OF FEES DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Govemment Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exaction, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section 14.18.180 of the Protected Trees Ordinance. Also, please note that an appeal of this decision can be made within 14 calendar days from the date of this letter. If this happens, you will be notified of a public hearing, which will be scheduled before the Planning Commission. Sincerely, G �' Kaitie Groeneweg Assistant Planner (408) 777-3257 Kaitieg@cupertino.org Enclosure: Arborist reports and the removal and replacement plans CC:JP Morgan Chase,Attn:Dawn Jungemann,111 Polaris Pkwy,Columbus OH 43240 �'�''`� � `,/,- Michael L.Bench � / Consulting Arborist r�- ' ' C (831) 594-5151 ° ��I�•�''�G��h� ��-. �"�``.1„� �,�,� 7327 Langley Canyon Road � �7 � l5 Prunedale,California 93907 ..�.�-�...� �� ,�--�Z Review of One Tree Chase Bank Property 20250 S. De Anza Boulevard Cupertino, California Assignment I was asked by Katie Groeneweg, Planner, to provide a peer review of the request to remove one tree at the Chase Bank Property, 20250 S. De Anza Boulevard, Cupertino, California. Observations I inspected the tree on September 18, 2014. The description of the tree prepared by Mr. Joseph Naha, Certified Arborist#WE- 3238A, is accurate and thorough. The tree is a Chinese elm (Ulmus parvifolia). This tree has a major cavity on the northwest side of the trunk, making the structural integrity of this tree highly suspect. The cavity extends vertically on the trunk, approximately 18 inches above grade to approximately 4 feet above grade. The lean of the tree, which would not normally pose a serious problem, may contribute to the risk of the trunk breaking in the area weakened by the cavity. Mr. Naha suggests to replace this tree with another Chinese elm, but using the cultivar Ulmus parvifolia `Drake'. The Chinese elm species is a moderate water consumer. It must be watered every week to two weeks (thoroughly and deeply) to thrive. The irrigation must be consistent and regular. The Drake cultivar is much less susceptible to the disease Elm anthracknose. The majority of the trees on this property are Chinese elin (Ulmus parvifolia), including two additional leaning specimens in the same planter bed as this specimen tree but closer to S. DeAnza Boulevard. Recommendations The request to remove and to replace this tree is warranted. The replacement with another Chinese elm (`Drake' cultivar) would be consistent with the other trees at this site. However, the use of this replacement would not recognize the Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Site Observations: 1 Consulting Arborist September 18, 2014 20250 S. De Anza Blvd. Cupertino, California fact that we are currently in a serious drought and that experts predict that water consumption must be reduced, not only for this current drought cycle but because demand will continue to out-pace supply, unless radical conservation changes are made. Should this replacement tree be a Drake Chinese elm, as recommended, it is likely that this tree and other trees on this site may require replacement again in a few years, due to water shortages for landscapes. Respectfully submitted, .-� .--------�. e�,L____ Michael L. Bench, Consulting Arborist International Society of Arboriculture Certification#WE 1897A American Society of Consulting Arborists Member Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Site Observations: 2 Consulting Arborist September 18, 2014 "� Commercial Tree Care ,� � 1 � � ��� A Rhino Enterprises Company . 1 � September 10, 2014 � -� 7-�s �_ ._ � , _ _ Re: Chase Bank �C� � Z-- �-�_� 10250 De Anza Blvd. Cupertino, CA This report is to obtain permission from the City of Cupertino to remove one Chinese Elm. All inspections were visual and there were no soil or tissue samples taken. The following are our findings and recommendations: Findings: Tree Number: 1 Common name: Chinese Elm Botanical name: Ulmus parvifolia Circumference: 65" '� Height: 35' Canopy/Spread: 40' �,.. �, r-. - ;, � � '� � � . � � � �� y �-� �.s' rr hJ � �t� ;t �,� ,°' � v�� �� �L „y,7t, � � a . ,b z at , a. f . . � '�'� '�. �$� - �,� ,+ �,.,� `�.'F$ t �: `�zo-i :,4 ,�, �; �.� "p � r������� �,, �"C^. - ht _ .n y c f �... ,�1�... ` xx �;. ,�3�� } �� ��� '���t � F` �k. . y.- .� � � ...*�,. �.r.C-vS.2 r"` 9�ii�i .y Fr a• +�wp�y{.�j �� �� .;�. .�,. e���'� L 1. ��'�'p� � T�i�' �I.� d�''�4' �2'��f' �"t�'':, 8 ,{� � ^$�. -+n.; � � �� ' :�„ ,f`.. '1.\ � -� �r< rl' ,r ee �°. �ni>' a " 's �,�:_ * `� " �+L�, --¢+�+� ` Rt�� � ���l�.y��t 't" t�� �f',� � ..,�^y; �x} 1-fy��' _ �' ^. � �f' n�' o.��9�; ;, �� ~'" r+f.�`,3 dr.�° L c„� �r ��`�' _-r-�„ �_3�{��' J.��"'� .A` ,�*,'• ;�- i� -� � s4 � t.� E i��"� q � � r= -�� �;' FN �� �z"°�� �t ��Y��`�`� -�"�� � .'4���` '`� ��� f t: r..� �?t �,.. ��- �Src � �t."`' ��s�'Y,• :� ,r ...;��W�CC��� r��� }tf� � ,���� � .�� ������ . , � { � ,; , � _� y� i -: A� � ' ,,y ! � -e+T.l� � ��x"i. /3�,:��i �oi i,'�-�".�'�`� ` ^. ..� � �@ "'�a.�� . ,,.t,.f 1�. �Y`i � . �.. i t `� 4_ �. � r � pti _ : r.a �� ��`3� .. , � `t � �t }+' , � � y3 .i �` ^� �.T # ?1�A'�`" tr a� � ��� x �t �J � a����€ �� -. +� �� +���y•��� � ` _ �. , � Su`. Zr d$�� �+ " � �If �� ^I j(^V,A�- � ��� � ,� g `r r c '-� . _ ', �� m II,►..� �'7l��I� � _f.��_ -�1 G- � �.��.f M� �g�'"�'1: .f,T,y�:�$ � t.d' -_._ s � _ . � �'. i . . `a . . " w� �. �� �,��, ��F ri --£ '�� >--'�-•}�x���., g.o-_ _ `.� wr� ,�,� �-�y�''�e:,: sb �.. w., s�, _ _ ..:;y , .1= �I I . K� ,f r� II :..�. � .�nr, .�„,F.' � � . e .. �..Y ' � _ r '�i' �� �.Q.'� " ���3�L'nrt l,{y, �, � ,�.����+� p .. . `a'F,3:-�c - �' :`T r.,��� ,Y �..;..°k... � it`�/:x$ a�,. ,� 4 x" 4� t �` ro�' �+ �,_ � �"�° �T,^ "�y`��' I' �(1'�..`_ lf� a. �`�i.�;� -a � ,. ii . �.: , .. , ....-. . •" ' - -t°_�--� ` '� - .., . . V ... . . .�. -°..�. -�..rs�-�_.. __' � ... .�a'`r._,. .....�-�. e _ .a � .-.. �e, '_ .s' ' ' . ' . " � 4 ,� �. . : Y _ __ .—,..._ .., ��'_.. � '.� . . r v �.�RG-:- .:,..� C��YV� -+c �'-., � . Y- ' ''c+„qpF �•'�_�_ "�'°----- � �.�E' � .m. .- . �... � , . .. . :: ., .:x . -.: >�` „ - : . � . .�.y �>;, . �-�a., �-� . *.-_ . � . . . , ` " �--:.`¢",-- ` �.:+ c - -.- - �..- _ . _ .._ . n" .-sc� _ ,_� . . . � �� � ,,� ,�� � ���"'=__ - _ .__ � � �. . -e. ' r . . . °�. .. .. . .�; . . .- .. . nt� , � :-a=� � . .. �---� ., � ,.. �. ,�y'- -'� , �-.. , . . _: :�.,.--'TMn---�- � >. �� _ - . _ _ _ � „n�„ _... � :.. __ . . . ' _ ' -v.- -.s-... -� .. -...... �-:you,�„ �„_. _ _ - .� , , . . . ' . . . _.. „,s. . . . ,....�-� -,�.:-..._:� , .�. . . . .y'i . �, . . ... -ap.. �,�_. � _ - ' ' . w.;�._ .....'"'''a°' �.. �:..,_ � .. - �:�' �� �'� -:� .:, � '` ...-,..� _ , -. r_ � � . . ,.,... ,.._ � - �. : *�„� _ ' �r' �, � - � :. "�°} � ; � � i�� } �,, '� ��� a' �. .4 � �� ,c �a -�'p9 '`b '�.r � � � �� � .:�. � �`.�:G . .�, _l- y.'"�w� �`:� �� �`+�...� `h. Z0�` , � s} 'r '+s. ati 3^ i 'w:,�e:. �. �.c� �, s.,;,"' _ ''°�s ^5 Overview of the substantial lean towards the parking P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara, CA. 95052 Off�ice: (408) 985-TREE (8733) Fax: (408) 985-6536 www.cornmercialtree.com info @commercialtree.com � . . . . . . • ' • - . • .. .�, t .� ,,�n..-... a.if,�,x � ,�h.AaF9r5�:����- ...h ... �1 � � ��n" ,,..r�a .� *'�.'r''°q '��- ' :`3" + �� ��'�` ���{�,, ,`�. 4��� ,�� '������� �•`�` ti"���i�( �.�' E��r� `k �*„ '��! ''3�'w�. Y ` !'.� �yt�r�''��7 tr i, rrx�r"�`• a "t '. I* �(r , ,,, � +IT '`-�'i�� j,1�.� � s� `l�° "�'► �,�a� t��f t�h�f��,`�I„,fA a . �. �'w��� .,�,k�,,• r'd.�C� ���' � -�y v� ��/� ,.z�s�a�i ` �aF y. � ' '+ 55 � .a� W' �r M7ISf" ��'� .r �� � � 1_ 1 , •�4.{+e. �; y... K ' ��i�' aj'�O�' ��iL^ � .y' �y..a f� O aa� rr �.�rr . .. �j� .ti+� rj • �. � � �, 3.4� �' r `��w� � �� r i ,r `�a..� � � � � ,�l� � >� �.��+ � �<� ,��� �� � ' �y r' ,f o`�� ,� � ,•, y�� i �y�' i' ��,. � '` �!�"1,: . wk �_•.r�. [n tx. v� ' �.'�M. �: . r,a i� { �;$ � �+t ���.;�r. _��� ``r ���s�' r�;����p����^�,�, ..t ��,'t'R.{�"��`u � �� ��a.1�_:r'tt�n �'. a� `� �� ° , � . c' � .,'y, '�� ,r,r �. rz, '' �:. 's t. �#,.: � , "` �'��.�" �.�. y:: �' a• �' _ •^ ��� ` ... '�`� " �„ s.,.� ��� ,�'`� _� �; • ��• •• . � . �`� �;�� :,.. .�t�' ,� s, �� i ��� � h��Y* �,,�. � �' � • � • t ,, .,i .Fi ���t 4 ' � ��� �,s � �� Yo�b R � A�1I; ay,y' ,�..✓ .:��"�.dC`.� ...V1�e.�"a''���iJ1C� •'Mk y, -+�. « �„�s.'�'.'�Y'�k^'` .r3-"��'4w..�.rj�, g'�i t• ,�., �,r j'.v�..,'' 4n�S '�� �M ';�.. ;;�F �< ..� �.i ir y. �; i " �'�; `I.� '� �.4i ' J,;� ,. .S "� � � �' r�,,�'� ,:f,� � �. F� * j, .;3'�' f. i .n�. y; �'�;� r. �' ...i.., ��,>;�.' � �'�, . j 3r f. "(� ,s �1 . �4 � � '^�' x� �� y' ���� r ���`�� �..� �rt �`v�?,� � . . '4 ,•'1,�� (��� �� f`¢ '%i` �� s �. - E: �� �i i � � ;{ ��r, �,; - t � �� , .y�"-...w � � �` f�� ^F �` : � � f , ,� .. I 4` �,i}S���r i�����.�.t� 1 ��f �� 4� �'"�r 3 .> r��, i k'y �(' .,.�. Y . ijr�� "� � i�°_��.: �7 f�( !.�o• �,,.�.�` J,�[, . ��`i� �, E / f'4 � �.. :� �;,trn � ��,� � �'��� i �w ���� �Y-'�"� ��� ��, �"� � f �Y:' 74 � '':, � ��� f • _ , , 'y,;; �'�` `_ -.,�-�-�". .V� -.�� � � 1'1 I .�, • .: (, ��.#.�l17I�� F f�lx" ; .� r .� - ,. •5-* ,� �. _ ; . �J �i'w.:a }u u � .r� �.' r+A'v. ,y — f� ��ye��,'`ad .9 r` .. ,� . _ ,>,'._. -r i� � � � #�o �:+ �a w� ' j ,�s �`� � +�'IV-:' " �. � �, . a:. �"�'~'���3e"'�"�,4 `� �� '�' ��--4 z + �� �."`: �. y �E:�F � �� �t 'T. "FS'� .� Tu�+}� ..' �.,� . . tK t` -�.;.. �;�5 �. 3 �� .'�rt .. ;'��{�� `.., S . `:'.M �: .� n q n' � r^.Y:x" �^cK'4 ��4i' � ,+�w, � � :.��*a��. �a,i, e' ���•s�y tx 't•y,.'t�,4� ��.��t... v�h 4f � '� .....� . '' '�' �.�Li� ,r. hn��i .� '� �;,: .��.. � �r ��,, ,��:F� `� X i y�;�,_• ..� � ` ��. '"�� y� . ��.� �>����� :rt1�'�t'., ..� �"s�'�'"�.. �Pt���- .,� . �t, �'. _ �� s_�: ��"�r+ +��'*.d�' , ,�,�3� . �., - 1�,y llq .!°,°s e_ G v Se . e'� �.��� .eL k' � '.�i�,i. ' .lrL . , . •..A's: � -y. � k.i� . }�'Ari(�' �- .f.. ' � . �Y } � C � , .� �' , ...� I . = p -'; �i'�Y ��.. Yy : y � �'�4,� � .. . . ' � . �. . . .� � . �� . .. . _,. . � �1 � �?'. _ .. • . ` � •• � "~", ; � ' � io i�a„� ., . �.- ,+ - k. ,, .� , ., � � ��,�' �r: ' � i� �� . � ' � . �• •• � • ��' •' � � • • • � • � • • • � ;. � Commercial Tree Care �. �,,�,,, °�-•� A Rhino Enterprises Company Page 3 Chase Bank �� '��� 3��3 : ° ' � �� ���`�``� � Y � t � 7 i�' .�. �ii�.�} � �y,�,,,�.�}` y p"' �✓. 9lr �al September 10, 2014 ` r; ���� r ` , � � � { ',� ��* �' 4, �,� :;� �`��" l � _ � �� J�„ . . . .�I T 1,������C R��F ,�'t + +tv . .��1 Y Y,4���.+�.W��y- i/ � . �{',P'�J.::� FiS�'.��i��;�" :i3&� ;I z_A:..'i"j ..� �.�} �T�..... ���� ^�44��� . „w,p if�'�,� b�t`��. �_ �:.. x3 �.�� �x�-�:..�.���rb',J�y.�,`,•��Sl�`f ��� �� / ` � ,�,p_ '�# r�� F ''Y9 u fti��+y �tr � 9 ?4�ir p pfi ����� .t� � �M i� ? � y�}^���l��J�'�� �I, ' 'Ff +�t �, ia � � �'� f.��q �`��� �`s,�, ��sNC�y;t� �� �� ��`M � f`,. ��k:� ,,.;: j' ,.��„�p'�i�;T r C'��'�"�'i'� ��,. t r.;F��i 7�)�� �`��., y�.,� ..a�"� �- �. j,Y� �F.7 y�. .�� . '.'g r �[•�. � t;t .�� y p?�+�X_ �t��.r ,,�ti ,� 2 ��/_� ��„?�K j�� ��`��'���z ' �� t' '� ��;S s�' �" �° , ,���`�1� � �' � � � � « ' xat �` y. >m, `� 1 t >y +.'�. �� ��(� y j •�'��n �$'".. � ;� �'� � � �, ;y; 4��'¢-2�-.. .� , wLr� �,, �; �f,,:�+ "i�+ # r �,��i�t�*; .��t �;� µ f��.:� �J, ,�,���,�; '�' �L { ' ��u �tti F_. ..y� �r�� �� . •F� i i a � ..c � � ,gr; � }�`�.ec.�� �" y`'' 1v� �,: ��:,� � � tt� �E�, y�€�'" ��°v� ��% ,N, . ., r �r," �4 �., e1�t9'� � h �F..G"� s # � � � 1,. � ,k f .Y( ..,t��;������+- � . . �' '��',., `"3a.,� P��,{',r�'fii / ;��.�. 'y •tt � �,�,.py �� � '7��.� � � { P �.7^' �+— �i'�"° �'� ��," �" �. j� 3 ; �,t �,���� 4 �A: �11��. �d '�'. "�'._ - _ „ ����/t� � �';y' � ���. ��':�;� � i I�� �,.� ���_... Close up of the cavity from what � f,��� r �° �� � ; ��� �����''�"�' 1 ��k`����`�' - , �'°�� s'SF t appears to have been caused from an - �`' � ' � - ;�t`�-'""� ;;` ,h r� " °� `� � � , r� ; �� �� � � � ��5��\ � 5 � old mainstem failure g� ,� ��' � �� �� � �����.� '�`� ���►� ��'"—.. ' 1 n��' � .a,.�y�`�`�''� � �'� �1��'�"' ��-^�5e =f, '.�. c } y �� 4 y 7 ff K' i �, -; {�S � � L�� �. � } � r{�` .� c. �y� �• ,����3 � » ��. �.. i .. ti�' � � �� � ,,.�-,......j,_-��.----..,�._ S�t` F t��., y�'�,�MF� ��•... ��b y 1�`, _ °'tis,�'�'-- c �',y +k� „,r i y,i _ �"*--..+.�,�p_�. � � ` 4 t /�/,'�:�ty�R� "�'�q� �. �.{ 4w � 9i� '"5�w.`` '` [ x � �.JM1�,`�i �'!� 4 ��{`��`!� �,..q.�a �� . i.� F��,'}�r � i} �a� �Y -.��`�r ��, £ �`' 4�.q �`�1 ��' �r�=`� ;;�` ��� � +; .��r �^x `w'; �, '; `a�a'� ��� "��� � L'�•'- �o ..s�„r�ir.i7..���� �qjy`���' �� �� ���, s �'� � �� � } . . .. ��'�i'�' r,��`'�`` k i ,,:�t r�t ��� �, � {�i` 4 �� =n Z �_ �� A� ,�.�., � � v ' , a � �'oe � ��!' ,,� _ �.�' ry�y ;a, ,.-.. �::, � �,� -''.i F � "� � x;;ur� � �,.` �� +_ ._:..n, � � �7 F '`��..� � �� .'. �1 k e�� Q ��` r: ,� t�' 4��� a-�'Nl1�"`�'°-^. � ! yt�` s,.ww�T��,��°y,��'Ws> YY�t._-��*� ��l yi Rt'�'�,L�{}��.. `„ . ��+��(l���y .�w'� y� r'R t 11yy � � . � � � �rr. :� � � � �' � 1� l��.�-�"� �'�"Yr�7+_�,'��' �E'3. �si �"• `� ���'�1 r'1t �-�r w ���' q��—y`„"" ,�,, r a� '�t � `''�� � �'¢, . r� -�5+�+` r 5 �+ f" l��d � ` u'�t��.��;�� '�,'r y� � � 3"� � � , ��' �i`� �» s •� ,�7 � 4 � � � � A�i���� ,�t Y ♦ , � �f ..,_i.0 ��1� '6. : 1 i �"��c' ��� V � � #��i` ��N � + y� �� d a%� �� � �`��� �,�,p . ��} � ; - "<��' °� ,.ae�`��t�� .r, rr s � � p�. . �^*A e� H�'�-•t ti� � �' � 3�,�Ri..�"� �'�''����#�� �1�}' i� ��4,' � ��� tiw!' sa�. �«.y� �.. ��Z'4. � i� �,�, �' � � 9� �r��`�;�' ��u� �1 ��t � 'u..i 'w.a, Jy t d�.'� t t< Y i'1 C y�- ,�;�7' .y .�„'� � y. R�j .,� ,.e ' �"� _. J�.t ' _'t� �'{�t,7{'� �T� `�� �1'f � ��, i r . . � �•d• �r l�J}�' '..� �. �i �,� ;i ��.. S,� 01"'?�� � ."'� A_�s �4� � � � C9g ei� y� • �n-° �'� �x` .24 1 1.- � q �. s� �' p,�, i1', `, � y �� ���3" �t' � ��,��'� .i� t � �� � �� �� � ��� � � ���'� � t� hy 4?� .� 4- � ; ,�. ��� E t^ � �� � �r':�� ,.� � � a �� ..�° b �1 �" � � 4 c `'`# �r �R- x � �� � # � � � L �` � � r '�i.ir , n ,K, a '' � � i �t� ���..��� ���'�;, ^�x p��� tt 1 �:q; 4y, ��"t� '}4. 1 d` �. `� '�. ."� � � 1 it;t �i i �":a .7"k} .1 �r fq3o�`;y ' ?k. x.F�jx� �-,�i) 2 ����.�.. C ,b T� p ��� , � d, t '�`�'� d . ^ _��y,y,� �` �� �� �y. y�H�� v� �� �`��� C w� '� .I:� " P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara, CA. 95052 Office: (408) 985-TREE (8733) Fax: (408) 985-6536 www.commercialtree.com info @commercialtree.com a������ ���� � Commercial Tree Care � ° A Rhino Enterprises Company ��� Page 4 Chase Bank September 10, 2014 . .�� � ,��ar� .f 1 '� _'"' y�i '�.0 � ��- .� ��� .. � ..� ���..�� � ,� �a `4��"x�� '� � a ,� ���' �� � '�z.`� . '� � �O� � �,r � I� ' � �{� � A} �� ! ^� � -,� _.�-. ���� ,� y'��'1.� � r��� '* �,1- � �+y� ., "�,r ^�,.� �����„f *��� ��.j y3��#� _ I /'a':¢,J"f ��Jr � �V�'� � � �M�; M �.,j,�„���`- ��'+e`� t�k�� f' � #�j.�. ��FSTX/ ;`^�� •' �' �� +k}��i`�. ' ; �`i'�" {" ,,� f J � �- ��� 'Pl,l�'. � �� �.S„� .�'��� ��` �.,��_ ��..: * � �� �`�'�^ - '+ �� .�,�;�� '•y ,� J'?�.�ati� ��.'�.� , . ` �/''�� � y � • �� �� � ',�4�' . c� � �' �����.X . _� . � . , � �,a �f f�'� �t� ' . , •6 _ � ' rw, � ..�g'" . � ''":_- �"� � L� �=�;� � , ♦_ 1 �f �....�. .�: � .� , .4'.,. � � ���r� s• ✓��°� f�'Y.� r .., � a.�o.r,.�i.�s � . . r# _r ��� � � �.�� g��,� . * -0 . i .. /<�, � �.j1' .y,�i°.'°1�. '��a�.!'�C+ , ' _ " '`_`� '� . 5 . ''.t?� t. ;.� �3 L. �` _ „ � � f,�_ , E:�1� � L 4 O�- . � `�-�` "" �� - E"�'� *; �y``` ,�, ;'� '��� � .�' _ , � �,�,� t e � � E �,.,,..�, �' `� ' +' �� � r �� � �� � ��J ` �'� ,.� `'' °��� J�� s; _ °' -rt..' g ,'f, � `�'i-, ' �.' �^�y .,. �:,,.:w.. �' w��� ��� ��'' ��� `f_ .� � �r-� -,�� .a'• . � . � -r.- . �.. t . -��'7i." �"�. r"', ' - _ .�., .�, . � ' � ,. , t r� ��n�. ' . g +. ��$�„ ��`' - _ � r, . ,�,. � ��.�0. �* ��4. . The cavity extends 8.5 , inches towards the center „ � -� ' �� `� '`�-�. . r � ��_ �� ���_. of the tree. Debris has � ��� - .. ��.. �f �� ��e � '°�� � , � �, � ,..-..� . built up over the years � �`�" ¢ ''� p., . , , -� . � and now there is also - � -� � -r �-.< , . °��:' , ""`' ��. w� ,�. /�" �' � `�- fungal activity as �j � `�� ,�� � � � : �. � � � � �, :. indicated by the arrow � -� '� ` �" � � . • ��. � � -. - �4 �,r �. � > � � , (above) to the right is a � �� � � � � �- " � '���� � � �� �'� �� r� -� s-��:. , r°� �.`�ar�,,���.�� ;: � close-up �- � '` �'".. �f -`��„�� ��`� : ���. x - , �;�, r �� � �� ��, � ,� ��'� f ` ���c, ,�`��� ,;� � �,�� . ti� "- , c ��� �'� ��':�""�� ;� ��. � �R i�� ,°_ � .� a,. ,a a :F x'��; � � ', � . . � - .. � _ :- � ,,,� . ' ., .�� , ,� . -�� '_ �"` `._ #�� s, ,, � , . M ' a �� .....:: .;.. _„ . ,� " LYlk,t � , .� .^. . ,,,,� �� �r�'►�.�,,�.. . , ,ty�„�c�� "k�4�f'4t'T �..� � "�� ������ ���'���b ��,,: . J$ 's y.. ,x�, ,y:° t Y�4,#`- r4 �`:-.: �a�"" P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara, CA. 95052 Office: (408) 985-TREE (8733) Fax: (408) 985-6536 www.commercialtree.com info @ commercialtree.com 4��� �'� �� Commercial Tree Care ,�� �� Q � A Rhino Enterprises Company Page 5 Chase Bank � w: -� ' ' � ���' �� a `�` '.; ° ;r � � ;� �. '�' ° ,���p<�, � s �, �� j� � � �� � a �t �r�, ,�, ,�� c� September 10, 2014 ��'��° � ��t� 3�� �'"��' ���'� � �-�,����= ,. „��� �� ��1 I�h a� � .Y '.5'°y'�? �N,j Y -, a J ( a-� � � � ' •� ' ;�,A1 4� ^ 'y� Y �� � 7ti,�`� � l/i. x�-`�, �y.., T � � ' i i .aw'1�� ^r � . �„ :,�,� �,I ��yL.,y�ia� ����?.� �-.�"�� -}..;' �����' � r��11�� �y�� � Y � t � -�` / f t Y .�f - �� -�F ���. : � � c�'`7 F. ���`_, �� �, �� x�' _�c t - r _�;�� �` � � �� a � +'�,' 1" � rtx y .;t .k- � � ��A a����`���' �y�`'' i'i� � . � �.�, '.�� ,�,� ,.� �Wt� .�� a c 25�� "� .��'�`�o�' �Y��rf; y��'�ns✓ »�. ,�'�'��r �,,�rt�;. , � �a � � � � � ; . .�� �' s d� "O�a� �e� �c,'�` 4°� i �Iz� �� 'S^„>, � ��'� '�� yt,�Nk"`��'� i a�'�y�( `Y ��[ � 7 .� qit� „ �.. 4�. 1�` � ..(r � �•_l�ki.� t..., f y ;� �,' ��`� Numerous cankers are located �� �'����� ' '���� �;�� ��' ,�� " �� ��{�' 4�; ��� ` �a�� ',.s �.f1`.- �,�t�-...� „��' � ?� � A. ;,'�L 74. „X:,�, ar ° 'X�� #S'-� throughout the main scaffold `� ; ` � � �, ' �,�J � � '$'` `` .� �� �� "� .°i �'i. ,�1��:_ti: . �"1r �� 't� ��� � �� i� v�'. branching throughout the tree was �� � - �� � ; : �� � : , ,�� ,,,�� � �� � ` � r �"�' �,x' �:: � � g�' . wel l. � �, < < �,r � '� � ���� '���`�� '�� 3��- �� .. ,`-� ' 'Y ��3 ' "y ��;x � a �=� �'���y� �.,�\ µk�". �� ,,,. �� 1 "��;�„� , � `',� �s" � +:: �.,,' ' .. ' �.*, �.� � .� i `�. `�.�j ft� r�,�'�.`'' �.,�, -�- , � �,, �': 'F,� �f, ,r-:'�.� � ? -c ����. ' ����' � �- : � 'i =� 'k t 6 . ��4 �`.�.. � ,yr � \4l.� .�tn1 . .� � �`� � 'P �� Y'� ��i.� y� 'R �i�� 5 , `2 4� .� ''� . - r'g` -� �y'i i+'� ,.. xg Z �11� �` C s�'�¢� �—�-z., _ �,. ;,;•+ "� - rl ��• Y'��. c,i' �p J �3'�Y k �.M_ - � � l � "�.;.-.F 1:j,G+l:: , 'i � � �� ��� �'�"' ``'�� -�� �r �§„ f . �4 '{ , � �,. �� t; � -`c G r ' �`2{C���Y' -.1 M, � 1 ' �- ? _ i y./ t .. Y "a/�g A�- `S q' �' �j'�: �'Ll -'�:� f " e 2 �"� M '�y� � ,�. ��°,i..�4 j .�'�1 ..,�i � �� •'N'a� gl:�' f,��f.Y ,:�� � ` �`` � y t`�� ��s, ;.��� '.� �'�` ��`c• �� ��5 `�i- -. �t '1 c G7���s� k��'� .'R. �� "Y��' ���: �',� ~� . ��y�� � { .� �-[] .,§t .�. 4 -A��.� -�:-l. y,'aY y,b� �, ,/"� ��,�7 }���' ` t �...�r��'t�w�a� �t,^�� � ty��.<���4�S �t'� f� � :-f u � �� � a5 � ' :� �6. ��3 y{��t �� '"�4�.�r : e� �j� ' CZ. A �fi�t� Tf�j- ��t 7 ` 3� I '{g�s�" ���� �¢.� 5b- �M�� �,�`�pJ, * � + �t3°�`y+d Z'y .�.; �� S �. . -.��:�� a ¢ pt�'t.:� '�•• d' ,. . ',+, y tq . �. .. ,� y Y... �"F 7� � ._ � > d i;� } � , .a,,,r ,r �n k � ,r 2'.�:. .�: � k a�t. �V;��i'R ♦A', �r��! �R� . f'�� ���i`f� }���„r +' .4 ���� ��s �� d�� .;f� ��r�'�. r �.�{������ � 's �a � _ � �.._� �,�,^,. �`�� ,� ,9' �"� �k+,�.- '�'�' ° f d�'�: ��� n t1tr. �'x4, jr`,� a �,�`�,�`�' � �t�' � ` "'�� . s fS '!-:J �'f�k� �. is�� � �n ,� }:ect4•�,s r�`�}�k•. x ,� � 'w �������`'����Y��r 1`�fi'� _ �.,` _� i:�'` ��t�a�'rk tr.��� �.��qa 1.� `�-'+����,�"x;t�� �.� !�, �tp ' ` r'-'`� x- � ,*'P€� �r �' c- �+r'+�. '�,'`,z' � ^.,.,� X�+r.f"e��� :'.�� � � �p k�'s � ku, '`, � .� � , � � � � ���� -,,��t������ '� � L,r��. ; - i ".�� ��� � � ��.��"� ��,�re '�.� A,�� �'�,�f o x • �� ¢ � ` �. �� :� ����'"� �-F� .r;, �.�1 �. LL � .� 'y��."�:. t y{ A '��� .'i��y � 5y ��.f.. ,..i� t {'^k E .,y rr�a� - ,��3 }'{���>j`"Y 3 t�i:�� V� > >'J, aA*' 'g 'te.,, L 4-am��.�4�� � �i�" '.�'' a� � y�v : a �'� � �t'�`j'�" � ��� '� +�t r ��:, k +'° r� �. t��,"�� p�,�..� +r° �'..-�ri;Y31 . `/ '.'� � '`�� . �� y'� ..{ 7� i,� ._�.. E��� �a�y � t��. �. '���s�� ' .. �.. *.�,�' � .,���i��" '�'..� : � r�,�' �t" ���; � ,� , �,p����{�"�`# o�# � � ��,. �, ���v �s��, ��, l ; � r:� 3k �,k�'� +� 4�`�fj -.. d +.r d ,� ��,� �,�` � �3�, � '� - . t.t `�,� ""� ..�r z�,��+.� ' aa,�. x ;r .�'�o$ F i,�a�.w�y "�`"� ��.,.Y,� � ,,�^ 'r �y+! t .t.c. �\ �` ��� �i,� w n r � y u f.:�� �-. r', � � .� 9 y� c � � SGdE '�'t �'� .jf fl�,� t � � d . �'{ � t �� '�� t `� F'� ,k�. #k. � �4 s�'' y���" �P ��; ��� � °'�'� t� �'%,�` � �,�'i���� 1 1. ,��'.� r� :� ,."p �e,. f' x n � A �:� �m,-�t amr.s �.r `+- �K� -- � J�� � P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara, CA. 95052 Office: (408) 985-TREE (8733) Fax: (408) 985-6536 www.commercialtree.com info @ commercialtree.com 10/09/2014 13:53 4089856536 COMMERCIAL TREE C�RE PAGE 02/03 � i ; Com�nercial Tree C�ace � A Rhi.no Enterprises Company � . - � �—... .�.�_. Pagc 6 Chase IIan�c Se�cem.berl 10, 2014 Recomme�dat�oQS: Due to t�,e kocation and cui�xent condi.ti.ot�s we would like to rer�iove and repl.ace this trcc w.ith on. twenty-�'ou�inch box Gi.nk;o biloba `Au��umn Gold' Thank Xou, �,o.� ��,a� Joe Nama, �.S.A. Certi#ied Arboris�t #WE-3238A � � � i ; � ' � • i i ; � i � �....��..:��, .�.`�.�...�..,r� � , .. P.OI l3ox 549 Santa Cla.ra, Ct1.. 95052 Office: (4Q8)985-TRI;F(8733)F'ax: (408) 985-653C � www.cornmerci.altree.com znfo @com1x�,ercialtree.com , �� � �- , _ ���..� , , a�. 4 � ����� �� � �� '�"�.,• '� � _ ��-�_ - �������� Z1 l � _.a►-�'� �, .�..� .� � :� �-�-:� ,�,� . : � �.,.��,�,�;;,.��� _a,�...__.�� � �� � t , 9. � � . . ,,�. , ,a i �� _ .� � .�-• � .,. � � �'. � _ � �'. , ��,�'` A �. �" ,��" � ���� �*�a+�,�r�L.. ,;�. ��' � �� � ,;�,t ''�. a + � � �� '�' �Y r'. � _+� � `,�•� � � � `�;��'a f�����„ �, �° N � � 4 ���6� #� � .: d��a �. � ... x�� ..i�:.�" � . � � *� �L�.�. ��'� � �'��° , 6� � � � �� ���� ',S � � j � `� t � ,�4. � "^�; + "" � Y R , � � ��7 � � r� °"' . ; _ ..�—. — k �� � � F _ w��f` -..r.4 � � r{���f« '���'`t�"�`.,�'r"r.:� '� 4�� `� �' '�"'�',z� �,."'r� .:;, , � .'w',_ ar '� . �`�,�� a . � � .. ;�, �,� � ,.�, .,,,:. ������.,,. !. ti� ,� . •' �� ' `� . �. � � * "� � "�'�. � '�• ,, , ` � w �,�; �.� R�•' _ � ri* � ���4 � +, �'. r x ` ��t�^� p �, 'f� �'W � y e �i$'yAF ����$� `�� ��t�.S .. ,.���_�d .:�' ,/eA ��� `y! �i ,ti F ���k�� � F * c� �M � �1 M�. ��� a,4 ^'� � �a y� ' tY N�� �� '►�r� ` ��� ��,�� � �s � `; '� +���s� �•.� tl� � ��_._ ' ���� Fa'�, ������w. . .. � �� �� �� �r� � ',, %°�. '� �*� � � �� - � .� �� /t ��� ��: � HI �� �� �~ �� '� �' '.. �'� ��.� «:� ,, �x.K �.� f �,� A� a p`���Y4 i�.. pT �°" . . _ � ;;= , ,,��� ,,,.�:: ,-��_,,�x. ��mefl Y' � y�� *�,i �F. � ��s �r m:�:�x , _..,�� „�__ . Chase Bank ,�" �..�.� ?,,� i'_�°"- ��'!����,�i,�..� q , �� � _� t � q' ��� s .�p ySe.,:V�� M�' i ��g d �� , q' �'� s �&�i `7' � � � ;i , �'� 4� �`�,�( ' .� '�" °� '��'� � '� � ; �• _ � ri� Y � � j � 't. :� ,=1�'..� y F �: �;> 1 �250 S. De Anza Blvd. Cupertino �� � �a�� ��:��� � �� �� � �'v �• °'� .�, ., m �µY k o`�$:A ��"', '�. ���O $p �;"�`"..'4:��`'� � Remore and replace with 1-36" box Gin�o s` �. `�'.�1�—�v�1 .. j � 7— 5 __�_ ,� � , ��-