Loading...
TR-2015-20b COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT � CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE• CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 C U P E RT I N Q (408)777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333•�IanninqCa�cupertino.org june 1, 2015 Terry Brown 10491 Scenic Blvd. Cupertino, CA 95014 SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2015-20 This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on May 28, 2015, approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of two (2) 14" diameter Coast Live Oak trees and one (1) 22" diameter Coast Live Oak tree, located at 10645, 10655, 10665 Cordova Road. Staff has made the finding that the Coast Live Oaks restrict the economic enjoyment of the property by limiting the use of the property in a manner not typically experienced by owners of similarly zoned and situated property. The current location of the trees is in the way of proposed development and grading. The finding is necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section 14.18.180 (A) (3). The application is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROjECT This approval is based on a site plan drawn by Giuliani & Kull Inc. titled " Tree Protection Plan", consisting of 1 sheet, except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The applicant is required to plant two (2) 24" box Coast Live Oak trees or one(1) 36"box Coast Live Oak tree for each of the three trees removed in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance. Modifications to the tree species and location may be made to the approved replacement plan pending staff approval. 3. NOTICE OF FEES DEDICATIONS. RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exaction, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Please note that an appeal of this decision may be made within 14 calendar days from the date of this letter. Do NOT REMOVE THE TREE until the end of the appeal period. If an appeal is filed, you will be notified of a public hearing, which will be scheduled before the Planning Commission. Sincerely, �� Kaitie Groeneweg Assistant Planner (408) 777-3257 kaitieg@cu�ertino.or� enclosed: tree removal and replacement plan CC:Brian O'Grady, 1150 W El Camino Real, Mountain View Ca 94040 Lynn Ooi or Jack Wu, 1457 Koch Ln,San Jose Ca 95125 Discoverer,LLC,4740 Snead Dr,Santa Clara Ca 95054 ;— _ _ , . ` .98'l! � , . _._ �.;, S40'S0'00"E - l �. - �+ : ',; \ -. __.., - " 173.84 — _, ._ 79.84" 49.89' -_ _ +1 526. 255 43' �" 1� ,�„ = '�'' \ - � '-_ _ a�' 46 46� � vc�.��_, �� - --_ _ F iIJ�N --`�' \ '�o � > �..� - , ' 1q<<.����, � � ' j _., + \ / . _ _ _ - '�' _ i. _ i � - - � ` - __ _ _ _. - - --, .1 d.1.- ,�� ,'' V- \ - i� /�[\ GU � - -t� _.r.,-_ ,.-. '+-- w rn ��, - .. -- �I�;�I'� \ ''� .� .. � ---�` �i - _ - .,.,�a, _ u� . �+ _ . � - - ''f . � - . _ - �� ��,� _ � '�, � �- -' _.. _._ . _ .- � � ���;� -�� ,. . � �} � \S�yG i\ .�t., . . _- _ . � a��' \� 1�� •�' `� \ =i� �. � - < "./ �_, , �, �\' \ ,�"�`+• .f.• �� �'�c� , .�-.:-.._.. ' - - - "� ' ,-, a �. _ , ; , _ � _ r� � `"` �= �� , ��� ��%�` �� '�� � � : _ � � � - ^� ��� � ---�--- - - -� y a � �� � >� '; 4. .> _. � . �4a�', _ - ' . 1 ,I _�� � -., - -----�-------- , < � � �% _ , m- � , cn�.. � / � ``' =''\ h'' cn � ° ' � _.n± `- t \/ � .�� , \J/� � - ." J`r-^ .. _ ++ C+'•+ N�. \ � �, �a - \ /J�\ �(" � .. . � %r_```�� J'.� \"�' . �� __ _ _ �.. �� _ G(�t� m � . .. 'AI: \ ��r , '. ��. . ' ,_' _ . . �� F .. r +��� �v 1V, �\� .. ��',..+ i', _ � -._ --'_ _' _ i " ���'I _ i ' � _ ' ' X +�/'. \ . ., . ��. . _ �'' _ �,I'�� \ �O , `j�j � , _ � __=h _��. #,��, o �� -_ - �� `� --- w�> _. . _ �� ��� � / `�,��� . oti� �, , „ , � �_. , , , ` � _ _ - .. . �� � _ �.~.� :�-�. ,, � , \ -. . �' - � _ _ � � , \ � �� ' �� � "�� ,.,' _ � � � __ , � , . , � � _ , ; - _ ___ - `::.: T �:+, r:..� .. � � _ - -- , �-�. � �� ,. _ , � � " \ �^ .. 1 A + , �� . __ .__ � _- - - -._ .;, .. __- ' , _ � ' ..„� � �G v f c� a / _- � � . +' _;* �� �\ \'1 � , c�,� . �. G�n.` , \ �.�� ^,s 7: ��(>.-c. ��" -.w.' _ � . . � ,. ����.'.� I � _ . . �-..,- �., � ��:� \. .r .�. _ _ ', , - ' -- _ ' " �'i . ,�`+ + + +� C. � � , • .� .i,..:n �7 i '�' ' Q - ' --"___' _ '_" O \ . i'. \ � + � � �, i '', .�.. .�. :��� �� y � ` •v + � ?� �� '� ' � :, I l ' > �.\.-'__. " ��,.^T i".O . - !1 _ J'� I � .-1 4 � � r +� k � 4 \ ` �. C _, 1.'� .-r:� O �.j � ��__ �1, J �� ,.`I� 1' G . ++ ' l : ; .. __ .��-�' J.� � � `�'l ,�� � \y,� I �\ VD + .�j� 4� k �<r G,� .. .. -- -_... ��.. � r < _ _ + n , ;<� r ��' ' .;` �'>� � F �' - tC�;T ..._ . - , . - - , _ ' . �:�: t�, ' � J _ -_. . � _ �" + + �. � G �r 2.�* r,l �?.e �'`?�' '� _ __. __ , ."� r _ ''� �',- .y�� .4`�, �' �.y _ �` :' \\' �;.� .. r - ,jc - - ---- -.-_. ._._ , _ � ., _ _ ; :rt + 1 � - ' � �.= +ci+a'` 'l'.,' � . . , +xl'✓ ��-� T , c p,:. I� --� _..... .b. �'�.•_ - , ..----------------�-_./ ..�, . � + .�. `� ..1__ \ . _ b' -- . ' \\t + +�? v a," r, ' `_ I _ I�;�,^ ��`( \'CV r�'. '�'` +� �: a' �_ —-..-_ � . - + - \ l' . - '�E�.i _ , ''..r��i _ si �u;' �v j .. ..... G�O � r. +--—--—-- -�� I.�J� . U � ��.i t ♦`• � , -�' PV' `_� `i�;rti� . � � _ � Q n� <,,, �.. ,..3-. , - � . .:i '. ..� '�> �YV, � � c` `v ' _. -- �:��' •Cv ' 4d .�_ ' ``�+_ + _ .N 2�4y. u•� { �K�i ��� . � \' ' �'L - __� � ' . ___. - , �,ry ���+�' .-___.../..- `.'. " \ + + � tG '•.�` l+Y � I �\ ^Q j U + ���>... �ti -(y`.Y w �.��� .^✓�„^,_.� . * \ _ +�, �� , �... _ � : , �i!G' � � C� � -• __'.__-. y.. ,+ , ,. . ;-� . ' '___.__' , `,r t t�� x.� ��. ; � .d' �`� �� O ._ -r.- +,- + �� � ��� \ � `�.. .Y - �. . ?i� ti �'�� �-�' -- .. ���, .� i.�� .:i� t ..:C ' �.` /.r ...._ `.ti� ��--+.. V :Cb �J�, ti�i ----------- - � / -.. + `�T++\� \' \�c�i"'t} � '. . _.�_ .1 �v vy �J�� '- ` �! .`r'�'F � '. + 4+ � \1� j�..r ;�!.r� ���.](/ y � � i .. _ i y ,1 ---- �+� + .. � �L��/\` ,� i ��'� .,� . �-LL� +z.;�, � `� " �} J - - . . _ �i�1n`,�` ,^\^�.1� \ .,y_, rZ ri�_� // i- .,,.y � :� , , F., ,T ,.� =, �+\ n\`"., '� `� ,� .°' "�" �c, + _ __ "-- - . a + a, � � ' �` �. _ .. � , � ,,. , � . � _ 1 < ; ' _ � � c_-_ + 1� c, , s .� 4. - ._- -_ - _ � _ +"+ +��, \. i ,�� _ _ -- - -- ---- � �` `��-"� � N �- _ � - '-� r i� - � . �'v ,}> '' , _" � + i „ v a' - �.�' � � ���\ � * � J�.: U` , , � - � � `� ��i° _ � + + +. C.�. Ci\n' 1�. ��.''' *1 � � �,�, ��_. � , �� --.... -------��v':=>` ,�� +� + -\ �c � � +. ` � ' Y G.' - � += + ' `O � ��t;ti� , � - _- ' "f �?, _ „' � c� _\ k ��z �� � . , . ^` 2�,;" , h + .� ����' - - � -1'� \ +- •' - +�_++� �- '�- � �� , _ Q >�. �� '� !?," aa + f ' ``u`� .`, � _.._-- �--- ._ + ���+ \ �, �� \ �`T�., v�.. �;, �, - . � - . �+%'��+�`y',� 3 � \� - O \ v3i ;� 1-yL�� Q��:. �.. ., ` .y7�/ _�• - -_.. \.+`+,f+�\ '� � ��,� . � \ (y tiq ^��/ `i�' 4;�: ��`�- _ +� +� �{ `��° � n�, � -'., U; • _. � ,� + + �, , � . `. .� \ _ ,�u �i \;. � . ;C,`? �J, + -�'� `I�r ,� ' \+ +'�'va � . �',.��:`� V,L ,�"� `C�:T . \' ;+ 4�+� `1� �` `�f^�� s'. ��\ ���� �l� <\'� _ ilO�� �� .. �/� � � _ a _ _ \ rJ � _ - � ° � -� ', �± ♦ Q +`�_.L� eC`'F' �c. �w . �/�tl - , _ �\+ +"z+ +, ,.�i, `� \ G<.; c> �' � ��.. , ,�, , �` ;`� � � , + _�� .., , , , �� , y; ,_. � _� � �� �� x�, r � �. _ � .�i�1'� � �� W � (� W � C� z � � X W � . � �,����i� � �.. _ .' "�^ w�wcrs.gr�-. . ._ . . . � .. _-_ .. / ' .. . `\ t4.. � , ... � + +, + ,. � , 5 �/�G ..?� .;� v y.. \ � + �. � A�^ .� D � � V _ , \ +>+�`+� � �' '� h �� � , J �� � � ` J�1 ,+�:"lF�a�t �->�'L• - � .�` .� � � a >� �� +� __ _ ��� /\_. _,+ + +=*'1 Y � :_-� � C> _ ---- '] �.,--- �/�, :.�Y' �i .3 +1��.," , \ _ � ; /�%�_. _ � / � !--'� �/ .S'� . , ;; r �� ,� ' �, , -- -- _ �QJ �' �/` _ e: ri�.., i 1;. . � <1f�•� �i_�,." -._ . ._-.__ �\ �:.1h + + + + i !�\ 1 �0 � . n� _.:_- . \�,+++++-�t+�v� � �` •.i't �\�.,,. - �.,; /�i ihl��/�')��� y _ / .-�l �{(/ ,..�::. n \ 'v+�� Qi �t7 °.0 � ` + � + + �+` � � ��` �, � � ��i` - l c �--ppJ �. ,. . +R e,.:� + + ro + �, � .r„ � � � �Ji � \ , , . � � �., ,. �. .n.� �. �. . � �r " ` a, ----�----� - -- + + + ��T + . ,* 1 a-., x _ tS � y'` �.�`J�� ���� � _ __ � � � � �� �� � ;+.,�, + +., : : +�,; \� : � _ + � :^ ' �,y, f_�-' � -—- - �I + -- Y= - \ 'j q��/ !�`1 _+'r'T +�_ . +*+, � ++�± t-��� 1 .a`,�^,��. �4.` ` � .. �: ��/ �K �' -v\+' �.��� r:'�� r - " { _ � , �}/�� /� � . + + 'w: a.+ �r � rrz \ � ` � : C \\,_ . ��.t' V ��/��� .`�1 � �4' . . .n_. � , �., ■`� . O� ' _.. + .+c.�,1 C_.� .f+��_.b.�-'>S��<�\. �� � \\ _ /.�f.• + � ��� 4-`��l V� _ ---�- ---�..__ OUi... . ----"-- . �-_ . .'n.. !'�i'�>^ x � .. /� !� ' ---/_��/ �/-�Iy^�:i� <y,`a' ti ;� + c�,• T __ -' .1� � �!J���^v �'�'���r�,'�� r ' ,�'✓ �� .�� V;��- �V \,�x i.�l f;� ��.! " Q�-' /.�ry --. ' �O � U.h� � �vti:7j\t, (� `i 'O o/ 1 y.- �� �I� �l + , J- '�i � �,, t�L�� � �` �°'� �"^ , -�. _ �°� _ � _ )`G �;�n . i2 '�. O� _,"af_"" � =`=-e�_3�..� \, .�< � �� - _ _ -rr .. �Q nti y" _ � , !v.�'y �' .:�1.,/J�.�,.�$' o,ti �G ' - ,rJ .F JV + f:, xh ^ .ct.�.. m�u c"t.,r � �� , .��,•"'V � ' - - ,V)Ji ,L.�2 � . � )�,`w �-ab \d� �c � �.�• v�'�-v �i' �,. - _ . ..� � ;i't . t7:tt .._ .. .�� ,�� � ` <�i . _ ; ;;.. r� „ \ ' V v `� �^� _ ___" � � _ T 41s� $ �'Fi '. �. • � .�i � r�` � - n� �F��i ;.� �, ' �, � � -\ �_, i' _�� --------- , � , . , � ., . . 'r . , + ` l_ `!' c,��' �,�o f c,� p 4 c�� �. r . T� .;- �;' � � .J _, _ �` I.,� <,� T� _ �'� , r. �`�� - — �� ,o Y _ �q_���11`��=- �;� � � �,�'• � � a . -� rh, � i LEGEND - ,t ;, ��.?1�ta� °' � L.: � Q a.' _�,,-{- - � ` w , , � �" V ..�'� �1. y,a�� ` � u, �i��,� �) l \� �C� .� �� \: T>,� �. -. Q-' � � .'� .� •� o �. ;y � -�'. �, � - ,�.' C:p �i � „0: ��� � G o�� \\ �, + ��� •`���,�� � _ � .� �,� + O EXIS7ING TREE TO REMAIN ,fr�", ; �y �'''�� o,`� �`���� � `,.;ti (/�� � K - (AND TO BE PROTEC7FD) �� �,_ '�2? �,; .w�" � �`t:� �' f�,'.,1�1 �1(� �.�" + `T ��; a � �� � � / J �J 1 � i �': !1 . .$)O•� �\ �' 'Q01�.J _ � r'�.�'` � "j - - , �4J ��' °' o � _ - -- -- _. ---- _- _ _ :� ,�. �_'t�'��.,� � �� 4 � TYPICAL�A R7C�OTECT:ON TYPLCAL TREEwROTECTIAN FQ�iCI1J6 Qi . N, .is , ''1, O• !\ /j_ sa,. - + . - 1.VriaW.ny wn�huetion openbao�wne�aclar shall wnarac[ard mummn.fa arh p�okstal vee on a cautrucaon aiiq a pro[eaive Pmnng � EXISTING TREE ,F' ,. . ����� _ .n�a,�;�ia��xat�unara�a;e�i�e�dcu�otm��m�e�nrro����n;�.a;�;ynbcrsz�.w�i.raaissca -.,� tlme ihe dlemas of tlu trwik�neewrcd in�ndw�a.5 feet ebove tfia n�unl TO BE REMOVED "`� �,<�i � °� :.nn �r�,a��ins�i«e �e�o�,���orn �de� p� �� \ . /� P^� e P P�^� y nm wrn#end rem.in�n piece unbl dl atma cmwuc[ion awriy sstlu C L ��� ''� �''� „"� ��h� /�. dtehu�beenoomplaed �f�� �p`,� ��-, ���,� .. � r��� \� - ' .�^ " 7.ProtectlwfmdngeE�IlbeMkM�ui�&a6iYh.cln�lYV�a610.mdslulth�watrce0fotactionsi��edNthe(meea'aYtwmty(20) ' .�. ,�' '�% �.. \ _ . \ � . feet iu�urL a�mnnc tobe clarlY wibk and leqibk m warkas m�he si�e et s d"utenm oPtwmb'9.e(23)hd.The�igM�)diil]md`i:,z \ �. ;•. . � � - _ , . • � .,}�•• haMimZonaKxyMa^. �I '� �i.i ��:L �, ti:.. �=:�. 1�..�'., ... ,.,-_�� . . I, w "�[ Z SO1 `�V � , �\� . / _ t \ �" \ , .o,� -, 1�g�• :.�. 5,p _ �_ y_ AS. { S)• � '> '�� \` �� ,, r. �� � � � - - -y'--`__` GRAPHIC SCALE � � - -- - `; `— _ w� r a , '�' ���63�6 � \ iO?-' p: � ' i',�.; .S .C\ _ t � �. !,� '^q y ,\ r. ,� `'\ ..,�- _C^: �8 �� :'`�;� � \ i `\� �, v io o s io 20 �o � �\ 1�"_" � � Ra�s 80' r'� �_ a �,Jz. � � � �--. �. < � . � , A - � � s ., •o �, ' r `, `�. . � J , , _ . ` .,\� �', n , ,� .S28 � , .�- � .,, . " ��.% � •'� c3 `*• `� 'u ,A �_-- :__ ..�__ - 3g 4p�',•''' <y, ?;'�'ry - (IN FEET - �J�. n;y ?�,�� ' ,�' - �-,_42 4 !:w.' ) � B ��, ,. �s ' ,.�� - , - � -- 1 inon lo rt --, - \ '`'.i�� ., .." u.. -•- `\. . - . m �o-- '� . / Oi� j. ' . �. �., h ti _ ��� /� \\ � ,_, ,� � � , -. ,,.� N �r" \ �J - W�' �r' ��� � �..k �'�..,, _ , .Q Y� `�' , � }-L� � �- �,_ f'�, 'v �2\ "- _ � ` _ 1 .r' r , -�y�_ a,_- _ r� __ �" -\ � c,'O `L�. . ��"l� � Y. •j��� �.;i+7� � 1 . � �' �� . '�.., ' � '_ •..� . 1 ._��.: �D n' c �'.�.1'�. ..,) - ' J�'`'___ r��'.•-� J\��"�...�' y , �'', NOTE TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY WAS �� � � ----.K_ �"" �r_ --� --�; " f �f�ti.`�.��"� ~ --" / � ' � �. m .J ��1.ic '. ti \ ;W, � J 'd ,a.' O�.. • %_,�' �. . ' ya .. '�. � �'� n' ` , VO. i -- a .,+.� '' `"--rr�.�\ _ �: .._,��-s ` .5;'.-._�,� t -�. PREPARED BY NORDIC ENGINEER/NG AND \ �';v � U �° � 1-�__ � (�.. ( ',� �.,�` ,�`_'_ ''- v�" ,_ ;�,ti' - - WAS SUPPLIED TO GIULIANI & KULL, INC. �� �"� BY THE OWNER. i� � �'� �° --- �- _ - _ -- �-- _ -� -1___ .;� � �� �� _ '- _ _ � - ` - -- - \� `_ - - �27.13, -_ - - „ = cz�•ro.,._.._--�--� - _ <.Tha owra sh�ll cawe We:equirad fmdng end fignege W be nutelled and m�inhined for Ih<duntian of d�e Canttudiat 5.in dfuWau w6ae a plwxted wc ranuro m be imnid[eee am o(LVenAed cuuwetioe and tAe ttee msy Le io denga of beng dnny�6y cmnwc�rn e�pipmmt ar Wia wrviry,�Ae ennuura or ubcontranor ah�il proeact Ne uea with 2^x1'lum6c enarekd wiN wire ar o�a meuu tlai do not dmn�ie dw vea.7La ntmf u m{mnoct Ihe trwik af ihe vm�amt madcnul conpn by lerge wnrtuctloe eqaipment 6 Me�c1�I 5tnnga No nnnye w plee�au of inewu4 vwmded ta we lo eanmuctlon a wua maOmsL acauwNted dae m unwim a Aeandiaw elull be pl�xd w+�fiin�u Ilmi�d the ainal ma ruoe of airy po�ed tree, 7.Fqu�pmmt QroninyLiquid Duyaid:No equipmmt Jull be clwxd a W�a liqwds.Inci Wmg,wnAout limnsrim,pkrt,dL mlvrnb,e�plw�4 canaaW monv m dmilsr mrm�G depnimd a ellarad ro flow inw ihe ermui mm mne af.potecfM trtc. e.Tme Amchmola.Ma dam,x��a a otl�a anaclvnenu,wlw tlun thoee of e p�ata.tiee nowrS ohell be nhched m ury proteeled irce. 9.V d�iwlu Tn16c Vo whimlu and�or camuuchon cquipmmt L ific ar�wkin�e WII rol�a place wifhin Ne virinl raot moe of wry pMCdcd troe d!c�hs�on«utm`etraet�ewnrnc 10.Na 6nvy equqanml�I dinp 6ut va Iwned�o truAn,trncbn.rtuila�,butldazm�,aea��mn,s4W.tar rmam,nenehen,oompm,o�; and Adsb•dull be allovW rtw�de�he dnPllne of any prdected Vice an eoY cooswdwn uw ii.e'.a�a.�im:raD,a�m,� ss,nne�w�aammmeu��uoe��,n�i,��,��cv,�prom,«�uro,�i�,a�.��«�w� 000ttruwmme�l�oe6ueqw+r ed WwnwinwriGnebync�cih• � 12 Impevbus P�vm�:No ptvin8 wifi uplult�h«m o1Lu�mpunav mslcuL d�sli be pleceJ within the Lmib oC Na Critiul tvot zme of �w������,.�a��r ama�ma ny ux�,brc wo�n� t 3.Rewt Prwng All raon nvo,ucM rc I.r�er u�dumens wluch w apwed a.•`ault ofvmchinp a o'Ln esavnrn ihdl be wt off cqwre �m..e�meti��a,,...�w�w�a w�m�.nw reQn��w w�m���wo eow+ar��nw�pa� t{.All pudic tiekw�lks'h+ll rtom�o opm�,Cm md der Cm 9ublm eaas.u�lwn�laure�s pamiUedbY�Puhlic Wak�Depertc�rnt TREE PRUiECTI�+I STANOpRD3 REVISED 5/13 CI1'Y UF CUPERTINO�AppROVED BY�DATE:]�� I 6� STANDARD DETAIIS City g�neer > �m m Z 0 0= m N.II 3�W U� U� � v, w p w� _ • m Vy � iM Q' Q N ~ U O � � ' � � O D ° � ° � � � �� � � O �.�.. O � •ry � X � � � .b • N � � �1 � p � D m ,� � � • r� � I y v �n � � � > � ��� N O 7 � o � Q � �� � Q LL O Z 0 U v � � O � Z � � � _ � V r i� ,VA W � r Q V W Z � � � J a a W r SHEE� C-11 �F 11 oA� 6/25/14 JOB NO. 14174 � �