Loading...
TR-2016-16b ����z����r�r o�co���r�t��x��v���r�E�rT x , CIT'Y HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE 0 CUPERT'INO,CA 95014-3255 ���'������ (408)777-3308 �FAX(408)777-3333 �nlanning@cupertino.or� May 12, 2016 Sam Oakley Arborwell, Inc. 2337 American Avenue Hayward, CA 94545 SUBJECT:TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—1�pplicatioa�'g'l[Z-2016-16 This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on May 12,2016 approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of twenty-four dead and hazardous protected development trees at an office complex located at 10431 North De Anza Boulevard.The removals of the trees include nine (9) Raywood Ash, seven(7) Evergreen Ash, one (1) Holly Oak, one (1)Japanese Maple, and five (5)White Birch.The trees are labeled as 1-24 in the arborist report. Staff has gnade the firad.i�g fhat the protected tree is dead and/or h.azardous and.cannot be co�fxollecl or re�.edYed. th�o�gh reasonable relocation or gnoclificatio�. �'he proposeci re�l�cexne�t plan gs consgsfent vvitla �he fl��ot�cted�'ree�rdinance s�mce the applicant is�eplaci�ag the trees on site,aa�d the number of replacernents is consistent wath the orsli�ance. 'g'he firaclang is neeessa�y fo grant the tree regrioval permit in accorda�ce wifh section 14.1�.180 (A) (1) and (3). The application is approved with the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROJECT The approval is based on the arborist report prepared by Sam Oakley (#WE-9474), dated March 18, 2016,consisting of 17 pages and a tree removal and replaceinent site plan,except as may be amended by conditions of this resolution. 1. TREE REPLACEMENT T`he applicant shall provide the Department of Community Development adequate documentation, includuzg but not limited to photographs, receipts or invoices, to verify that the replacement trees have been planted within 30 days of replanting. 4. PROTECTED TREES T11e applicant understands that replaceinent trees are protected trees and may not be removed without a Tree Removal Permit and that they shall be responsible for ensuring the proper maintenance and care of the trees. The applicant shall also di.sclose the location and species of all replacements trees on site upon sale of the property, 5. NOTICE OF FEES DEDICATIONS RESERVATIONS-OR OTHER EXACTIONS The conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication. requirements,reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1),these Conditions constitute writteri notice of a statement of the amount of such fees,and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exaction,pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a),has begun.If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020,you will be legally barred from later challenging such exactions. Sincerely, • � ic Serrano Associate Planner (408) 777-3205 ericks@cupertino.org , ��,;��,: �s�� �J�2 �-o%,� —/�, �'�:�� �'��,. �� _ �.__,_._ G.:_ 5 :` s t a�;J:..=____.._�� �. , �/�/ r_ _.- _ _ �,. �-=� v: : _ _ _.���b�� �11* r . � _.:::__.-... _„_.. ...._ March 18, 2016 _ , � � �r�,���a��,�z��.�z�,��,��,>��7��,� City of C�ipertino Community Development Department 10300 Torre Avenue Cupertino,California 95014 Re: Hazard Tree Removals at 10431 N. De Anza Boulevard, Cupertino To whom it may concern, Arborwell has been retained to prepare an arborist letter for the commercial property at 10431 N.De Anza Boulevard in C�pertino,CA. This letter documents the urgent necessity to remove thirty-five(35)hazardous trees in total as a site-wide attempt to swiftly reduce significant tree-related safety risks posed to Apple employees,especially in ad�ance of potentially strong winter storms. Their removal and replacement will also serve to vastly improve and extend the long term viability,robustness,and value provided to the property,the greater Apple Urban Forest,and the City of C�pertino. 35 total hazardous trees proposed for removal are: Nine(9)Fraxina�s ar:gustifolia(Raywood Ash) Seven(7)Fraxini�s u{idei(Evergreen Ash) One(1)Quercus ilex(Holly Oak) One(1)Acer palmata�m(Japanese Maple) One(1)Malus domestica(Apple) Seventeen(17)Betida per:dula(White Birch) The metric description of the subject trees are in the following table: � ,- �: •� �-.� �•. • � . 1 Fraxinusan ustifolia 10 20 20 i Hazardous 2 Fraxinus angustifolia 12 30 30 Hazardous 3 Fraxinus angustifolia 9 20 20 Hazardous 4 Fraxinusangustifolia 8 20 15 Hazardous 5 Fraxinusangusfiiolia 10 15 10 Hazardous 6 Fraxinus angusfifolia 12 30 30 Hazardous 7 Fraxinusangusfifolia 4 10 5 Hazardous 8 Fraxinusangustifolia 13 25 20 Hazardous g Fraxinus angusfifolia 12 25 20 Hazardous 10 Fraxinus uhdei � 9 20 10 Hazardous 11 Fraxinus uhdei 6 25 . 10 Hazardous 12 Fraxinusuhdei 8 � 20 ��v 10 Hazardous 13 Fraxinusuhdei 8 � 15 � 10 � _Hazardous ' 14 Fraxinus uhdei 10 15 10 Hazardous 15 Fraxinusuhdei 9� 30 10 Hazardous _ 16 Fraxinus uhdei � � 9 20 � � 10 Hazardous _� �7 � Quercus iex � 11 25 ��5 azar ous 18 Ace�almatum____ 4,3,3,1 10 ___ 5 _ Dead _ —J 19 Malus domesfica 7 20 10 Dead ___ —`�2p Betula pendula � 4 20 � 10 _ Dead 21 Betu/a pendula 4 � 15 5 Dead � �J22 Befula pendula 4 20 10�� Dead __ �23� Befula pendufa 5 20 � 10 _ Dead � �24 Betula pendula 3 15 5 �_ Dead 25 Betula pendula 2 10 5i �_____ Dead 26�� Betula pendula 9 �25� 10 � �bead � _ 27 _ Betul�ndula 7 25 10 -- Dead� , 28 Betula ndula 11 25 10 ^ _ Jbead 29 ��� Betula ndula 9 20 10 Dead 30 —� ----� Betula pendula 12 25 10 -- —�-�— Dead �31 � � Betula ndula 8 25 10 � �_� Dead 32 Betula pendula 6 20 10� � Dead 33__..�. _______..___.___�tula pendula 4 20 10 --_- ._Dead 34 Betula pendula S 25_� 1� �-� Dead 35 .�_.._ .�Be ula pendua 9 25 10��. Dead 36 � �� Betula pendula 12 25 10 Dead 2337 AMERICAN AVE,NAYWARD,CA 94545 QFFICE: ($88}9�i9-8733 1993 EAST�AYSNORE ROAD,REDVVOOD CITY,CA 94063 CELL: ��2�J��`��-�0�� WWW.ARBORWELL.GUM �1 Arbo'r ell. March 18, 2016 ���+��y5,:r,�,�t��E:�,,�,�,<{�,r::„t.��,r Fraxinus angustifolia & Fraxinus uhdei The l�azardous Ash are located street-side along Bandley Drive (Trees 1 through 7),within the parking lot (Trees 8 and 9),and along the north property line(Trees 10 through 16). The Ash onsite were planted 30-40 years ago and are now at the end of their viable lifespan,especially considering the harsh urban environmerrt they were placed in originally and have been struggling in ever since,including narrow parking lot island planters surrounded by heat radiating asphalt. Additionally, Ash is not appropriate for the regional climate, nor is it a species that is sustainable throughout prolonged periods of drought. Ash is also a failure prone species and many of the on-site Ash have declined,warranting immediate removal of the trees. The onsite ash are infected with a terminal disease called Ash Dieback for which there is no treatment or cure so pruning would be an insufficient and ineffective solution. There is an abundance of dead 1 imbs and deadwood in their canopies warranting immediate removal. These hazardous Ash are recommended for immediate removal. Along Bandley Drive,we want to preserve one(1)of the existing Ash(between Trees 6 and 7). We identified this tree as suitable for short term preservation as it is the largest,healthiest specimen on Bandley Drive; however,since it is starting to outgrow its planter,and already lifting the sidewalk,we will eventually need to remove and replace it. Quercus ilex Zhis individual (Tree 17)is located along the northproperty line. It has a defective root system,evidenced by girdling roots,is severely leaning into the parking lot,and has a high probability of failure as a result. This tree is recommended for immediate removal. Acer palmatum 'Ihis individual (Tree 18)is located at the front of the property in the courtyard.It is dead, determined due to its extensive loss of foliage,severely desiccated limbs, 100%lack of green growth and extensive firebligtrt. 'Ihis tree is recommended for immediate removal. Malus domestica This individual (Tree 19)is located at the front of the property next to the sidewalk along De Anza Boulevard. It is dead with severe trunk decay, determined due to its extensive loss of foliage,severely desiccated limbs, and 100%lack of green growth. This tree is recommended for immediate removal. Betula pendula The dead Birch trees are located along the south property line in a grove of vai-ious trees(Trees 20 through 24),and on the 10355 N.De Anza Boulevard property(Trees 25 through 36). 'Ihis parcel was included in the original lease of 10431 N.De Anza Boulevard and is shown on Exhibit 1.2 for reference. All of the Birch identified for removal in both groves are an immediate hazard and should be removed right away. 'Ihe Birchwere determinedto be dead due to its extensivebrown foliage. The exactcause ofdeath is suspected to be due to an Agrilus anxius(bronze birch borer)infestation. Adult beetles feeding on the leaves of trees cause little damage to overall tree health.However,the passageways under the bark tissue createdby the larvae cause signi�cant damage to trees.'Ihese passageways disrupt the transport of water and nutrients in infested trees.The initial symptom is often branch dieback at the top of the tree,as seen in other birch trees onsite.If 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFicE: (888)969-8733 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CIIY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM March 18, 2016 �,����:����:8,<��=x<.,.:a�„�,�R���;�,�,<v�g� the tree continues to decline,dieback extends down into major branches and eventually into the main stem,as is observed in Trees 18, 19,20 and 21. This condition elevates the safety risk of branch/whole tree failure. White birch are considered a tree with a short life expectancy,and appear to be at the end of their viable lifespan. They are also susceptible to pest infestations and not a regional climate-appropriate species. All of the Birch along the front of the building are an immediate hazard and should be removed right away. Replacements Due to the approaching winter storm season and the potential for very extreme weather events due to the El Nino phenomenon,we ask that the identifiedhazardous and/or dead trees be granted exemptionpursuant to Section 14.18 of the City of Cupertino's Municipal Code, and ask for your permission to proceed with the removals and replacements perthis document. In our site walk inNovember 2015 with assistantplanner,Erick Serrano,we received preliminary approval to move forward but ask for official permission. To mitigate the removals, we are planning to replace with thirty-six(36) 24-inch box Quercus spp. or equivalent (species determined by the Apple Arborist)per ordinance mitigation requirements in the same locationas the removals but evenly spaced formaturity.Replacement tree species will be selectedfor favorable characteristics whenever possible such as drought tolerance,long lifespan,structurally sound, deep-rooted, Cupertino climate-appropriate,onsite location-appropriate,shading value,pestresistance andoverall enhanced aesthetics.Newtrees will be selectedby an Apple arborist to ensure optimal structure,health,and reduce the risk of girdling roots,and then trained from an early age as needed to optimize branching structure which will extend the aesthetically and structurally sound lifespan of the trees. Conclusion Our concern is that the property is a commercial space that has an abundance of employees occupying the area at any given time,resulting in an elevated target value. Given the elevated probability of failure,the large size of the trees,and the increased risk of a tree damaging property or causing personal injury,we think these trees have a very high tree failure risk and should be removed and replaced immediately. Again, the trees listed above have been identified as candidates for immediate removal based on likelihood of failure,observable hazardous conditions,and close pro;cimity directly over parking stalls,parking lot drive aisles,pedestrian walkways,City street and sidewalk. Please review this information and contact me with any questions or concerns regarding the information provided in this letter. Sincerely, �--� � �_ Samuel Oakley ISA Certified Arborist,WE-9474A,TRAQ ASCA Registered Consulting Arborist#556 2337 AMERICAN AVE,NAYWARD,CA 945�5 OFFICE; (��8}g�9-�733 �993 EAST E3AYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW.ARBORVVEL�.COM APPROVAL __���-�� / f"'' � 3 -.�, ..�.i� � �_�n_��.. _5�� � ...n_� ._ �i ; _. _ ..��.,rbo'r ell. MarCil I�, 2��6 � _ �� per,>.'s5r2�nrxi treet man�a,yt:ment Exhibit 1.1—Site Map 1 of 2: The location ofthe dead/hazardous trees,shown with red dots. The replacementtrees are shown wiin green dots in ihe bottom image. =�-. .; * � .. -rs _ � 'ss.�'���� . v � - �i� �: � �c'-- - � . _ � i a �� �! .r13i���i ...�. - ^ . 1 ..�, ,. .- -- .- . , � .: Y. 1 ��� ,_ - ' �� � �v •!'Ir �3 � :, „ ` Yk � .3 � ...�� " . - . £, �.a 4 � � �� �,� M��Y �Kt „�.d .��i�+rl �' �:a.i':. ! � - '` � �i��. . e a� . , i �. . � � �u�? � ��...� �� -$�y` y"M1n � � �`rW,$„ �s .s ,.�: ,-i,.� ��g .# �,<.� � 4^;.:�� ?' #,��```�. r `�\. a ss . ��� '�' r' �� t,..,.... I., � , '' .'" ` � '' .��r"j �1'-`_i � �, -j 4 � ""� � ��F�;, �' .t � � fi$�R t ' ;�y�� �� �.\ �_�'� — . �i i. ;��%`.�}� �� .r�! �r � " � � ��Y a .;� ",�l �n r a�� 4 -�; 3 .�� � � � ,,a��r,�-� �_ ��,�� ' -� ,' °,` � �, ,�,�x<�:,� ��` � �; . _ � � � � `.`�.nu"�'.#�,.. �'� ,�`�"�� ��' �;. .� t r `".�#� n�`.> � �x t�:_. . �t.. t `�"i , '� �, ���` � _, � I _�c� �, ,�`���~ , : `. �. � _ � �a � �1 �� ;i ���, � •� �.�� � t _ . , « ` — x� .,.. ,:�5���,� t� ::•. � - " �� t.r �_ ��g ��F� �_ �- ; �ry� _.�.� �� ,;it i� � ..n�.� . !+;'�. �e:.��' : . _i1'T ,a"o' ...�. ���� � ',' n� '�. . ,�- � ,� — '''�� k k t� ,� �.�• +t+�.. '$l s., `�.g �, yy, � ..�,�.L ' � � �4r� y,_.� :g'a � � , A•t� �� Y r a `� • ' �� ,� �l � �� �'�� 'd, p.°-�.s: te +. ��� � .. p -w:::�wr t�_s.?k� i� y-� �7a�'a�'t�i '�� �,; � i. A � ;� �•� � „ ` ' �e ` f � €�° Y' "� s � ?i,�C� �"'�,d x° Y^t. € � 1 „�'. 7���—' � ,: �� ��'�+���,,. ;� a � i,�.. � � � �r,'- '�r%•� ��' `• 1�'��r---�. /i, � , � � `° ;, ���i � «�,, � � i i � �``�+.> ' t� -'�- �c�; � �@---�i e� `%k�'�r.�"'�,` r�... ,r,�' �- ' `_ 1'�t:•. : :}�' a:� ���` � <r.,:a!v.s >a �;�'� '. �,���� F . �, - ',����,t d,a fx!4�Pr*'t.:'��,a,.� .,,-:.�,`q ..s r i av ... � �� �.` � +�� �z ` .. s,`��,.` ,�,�,'�' r �` �� „1�y z . . $+d+...�. � 3s "��s�,A���. �v ,�...� -.`� � �s''� G iP�'�� �����` I �i I� 't"1� - ... . _.. ,�.-._ `' � .3 4'�1 ..,..� �� a � � �� !1 T� � .� .�"� � �;-: "'s� � t, f.t� �,w°�'i�Lj � .. ��� 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFicE: (888)969-8733 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM March 18, 2016 �;G��4;.�a���:�;���,��w x;�<��;.;���f,,,w�,�` Exhibit 1.2—Site Map 2 of 2: The location ofthe dead/hazardous trees,shown with red dots on the 10355 N.De Anza Boulevard property thatare included in the original 10431 N.De Anza Boulevard property's lease. The replacementtrees are shown with green dots in the bottom image. ,,. ,._. �:,-;.,;.�µ � , ��� � ���� .-. �.. � � . �. '_._. � 3 �''f 4 tr �{ .�� .,2 '. ^C^ t �..wr G � '2� „ ��t � �i -t,a�; � i t .�1�"s �r.. r y i F > _ _ _ . _ ..�............. ._.» . . ..:,_, _._....... �.._ . ._....... ._._......_ ,,.,_ . ...� ���:�_._-_"'. � , , r.= , a,..�.�.� ... . �;�;_; . . � . �. � ., -� ..'. .. = . �'�]Igt.`u r.7G'4�A+1J . . .. . . _� � � � � ��.1� -� � . .. � . _.— �_ -- .,,......... (I,... _ - T,,-..,,> _.. ��v -�} 'Y 1� . .. . �j f S 1 � � _- -, � j :�} .r'�' t tt4���s`la �,���,��,s �a kr��2'�Ny�:.s{f*��}�� � �.c'���r.�.. .- s t � E � t ��fj ( � ��'Y`� �3��'kJ) }�� ��-� {� ��.��-'r,3�t,,7� � 3�,iF r s�.r .1��`�f � j '� �. k ����,��r��j i a�, g(Y r' ,s�� { ''^ 4 h u Q,,,-- r � - � ra— , � ��n�rst ���s�;;� ; ,,,� �1 � -� qr. q � L,r""`7- !� f. �� . r5 ( � ` �� ��,i�?� �p�'i....' ��C ` �< < t I 1 �` � � i �I � �, I �. . :'�t'a,k O�y ���:�''�� `� �..'� , ! ;' . , �.: . { �,eyx�f "1 ���„� .� ,s:� +� ��`, �° �r,,.,-�: ���~ �� �i' y , ., ` �� '4 ��E y �� � i �� A � •4y'C. //�' ;` k � ' �,lf � ! t{ ii �{� i i ���' �� �,.�, �,� ��'1 �.1„ " . . . IE ���'�` i� n � � �i ��i r � ro �' f/� �` �1�,�,� .�, f �-{ ' r?�- i-� i� ''' �� i� � (` .�j ' �,,. �,„ � ' � � � �� � `� � ' �J t -�—'' ;: �.:� � ` ' '`' fl` b�, �,4�: . :C� t �1r�.1 � � � �� �� �,. �s�S ` �i� t -,,� �,��'1 . t: �-� , �, S '��J 4! !_k ��'i�} 3 i S r ! �( � � . " .. , �. { k � J V trr i iE� 1���.�./�[`�` 1� �'.�` � 7!I,II /�'1l.��''� �� jl Y1� �.= i,` ��� ,. ,�. �i "� �� �� � �c� � x - �,�--- � --��n"�• �---� .. � � " .l "t `rx:w `4 4 ... � - 1 ,7 t "y . . ._ . ... _,_..,...� , v...,._r�-.. ..� . <-.�.,._. .._.W_.�.,�.._._� .._...-_.:,e... � ....... � : , ,. ,,. _� .. , •� .. .. . .. . . ,-... ,."1;1�1�.� Yat�rJ���,'l�) .. �� ... .. `�"�-� _f T ....»..�«.» ,i 1 . . � �} j . ( G t y�.�. _} t _ � � ; r , • _ ,,�.' F l � '� p 1 � � G ^� . _.:, _.., . .:�.. _ �,i .. �a .. .. .; , , f. ., .:. � " ;. f� r rt= t � � �} � .lp�)_ i,; 1?� �' �t '' t .`i � i �S^. ' j j Y. .. '�� a+,S� �r,t�1 m `C' Lf�L� -� i_� "�� � r s�� � tf y�� �1 . , "1,�.a �% � �r , � � �`•.ti t F = � "i }�t i ��t� � J �,� ��� ,� �-�. C,,s: � �.� � ' ' �� �` r `� � '�' ` ',�'' � t�� � � ,.'� � '� ��i . �`� �L'�%+- ..� p� � ��t, r i a v a z.-t � "'�� q. �".i •"- ��� ��'z �. r�' � �� � j{ �'9 i q � �,'` �� `° � �, �( i�(: ,y i 3 � 6� . t ��'r 1 � i.:I l r �-r � ( i 3�: 1� 9 t:;i � � . _Y , _ x� Ft�� ��t�9 /1, t ` � ' !� d �� ��� E s i i r ,} � ' 3i r r ;�� �` ���� � � . . � �r ���[ �� �k 5 �� . �,�.+ - r.: �� '; �� '� .,�` - 3 . •� , . ;`. .:, . ,. . .' ';� �": `<. ... �� .. ..,• -o.- :� ��`i� � 9� �.� 1`' "`' �l�_ 1 ./. � � �I� �:� �;,, . ,.,�� . �. , � �.. , f ��� ��� � `��:� � , '��� `�� _� }- F � ��,�"�p _. ` �� ' � ����1 t � � ' r' �4 �:��'=syi��` : � £ i E � t P.r.xi�, 1. � f 3 ._.� t , '.� �. � V t'.;,� �;�t�, � (i ;s.� � �.�. � '�-1 � . ��r i �J ��; z tP- .{��_ �_ � � �� � i.��� r i .r J t �r � �'a��/:�'1 ` i �d/l/lL�`i (s ��—"S� �`�, �'� � �� � �' :,r 1 :3' c.q:,.,.�I �.�'�a' L a..,,.;1� l. I �"S` ...__f�',� r, 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,GA 94545 C�FFICE: ����}���-$7�� 1993 EAST BAYSHORE POAD,REDWOC}D CITY,CA 94063 CELL: ����J���$-�0�� V�iVVW.ARBQRWELL.C4M V� Arbo'r ell. March 18, 2016 f,��::�„�,<.,,z�i��Efa f„<,t,G,�,,.,,,,�r,� Exhibit 1.3-Supporting Image: An image ofTrees#1 and#2(from leftto right).These Ash have an abundance ofdeadwood,w�eak branch attachments, are in continuing decline,and pose an increased risk of failure into the City street and sidewalk. ,M.p ,� k�, ., :�; � �� /�. ��a° ��t� �� , , � , �. �� �: �'i�. ��4". -' � ,{�r �4� yy, � �� T...fi„r +7 z"`*� Y � _ ` -r�F ' « � �r�"��°. � ti." Y�'� ��d..X�: � t.n � ! �t'��Z����. i w.'� u, ��� ��"ii��k. ���, .;� ;�� � . � / nM p t. �� . ., � 7 �:� �� �' .�'r A;�.w i �� tl� `` °�* �d*r .,� � * �� . � �� �� � �� ° ..'�� 7+��,�'.,�° �.. a y �... � >�'"' ��'!'r'�. . . � ��F� .. ��1 t#` �� i � a. A . y. � .h �. w4�s „��v.A..� .'Q' 1"7����+. _ t�. � r i ,,.�_,�. YI <��� �.w i �� 1 I 1 _+f t ...,} �e+. .� �� ,'�!� J � � j�� v � . ,nm .e+ :�;' ' � f : P �e �. 1 �n.... y r . . , 9 x . r � �„. *� " , ,." - . , � �a*� . � �,x+.� � � . - � ; ,y.:_ . �s '�r ^ .,� '��m � . •� ��� � � �� � � � � "r' �.�. � �� �i ��� � �a, 5-y�� �, r '��f ,� �., ,� » « t,,:< ` ��w, ,,,��:..'S� t. r ... � � �`t. �T' s�. cg�, `.i. g � ^�i:, ,a9.Ar.:`1�.. ��- M►, 'el ri+ ,:�g`�'- "�.+`. � �� � ��� ;;„r'.<:. �:.�,.,. t I 0 ,,.._..;+ros� ..,,._�.a. � � �� � _ ,., ,1 � � � "� � ,� �,_.. 2337��-�E��c�N Av�,�;r,��•u��,h��,Ct�9�5�� �FFicE: (888)969-8733 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM March 18, 2016 ��r«s.�.a�:��E�3�=.�E.�w;,;<��,::�:.�;>�:;,,x:� Exhibit 1.4-Supporting image: An image ofTrees#3,#4,#5,and#6(clockwise from ihe top left corner).These Ash have an abundance ofdeadwood, weak branch attachments,are in continuing decline,and pose an increased risk offailure into the Ciiy street and sitlewalk. �°!f���"x'' � � �fit�r��1 ,.."±�i��Sns �ka�1 a E .?.� � �,.t i , � . . .. . . . z1 ry�'�.�y -. ,+t �A< �+ca d 1 y;� ������J� K��}� �� �; { � e . . � . �ry-4 _e 4„��t �: �r f \ .4 S i y : ' ( . y YN � n j � +�' � . ;+���•�' � 4b� l � '-� ' Mg4.�"��1 ,� :.,. -� H��� �:.��t����{-'a� . , . t S7��t� � °+.7� �r t � ' , �1' a ; ,� j � x- � �, a .- � � a mr�$�` rt�' �''ys ei ,t �e�� Z r-� �La�'��f� �� �„'� " �'. .'� I � r��,'a. r s�� '�,sS �+'' . ; . � � � > r�., §� � a�� ��" - r 3.: 3s ^�,�;s _ 6 �d` e � a� � ..- ' � y� �. : �, � = �d, �_. � ..a�� ��, , .�..I - u�'�`'�' r�, s ,� � �' �'s�'�''R1,`v�i z ��r 5�' r t� {�`�'���b"'� m�� ��'1� � � ,'����� z �1�3��!�.+N r � � � � r�.,, :.�� i°��' �'�Ztp� :.�T-�'.. k,�s,* o-� n �� t'r- `,�.. u � t�;� `s���� ���sw,v +.a,� �.� �x.... , . , i���'�� ,:�r�.�w:. ,.. .. „ .. > . . � ���� � . � . . , � . d . �. . �. � . d �� � 4 � t `�3 �1 � ry �� ,. �. �.r b j��L � z's,f� . F , � Y. F ' : a . '. � i , ,, . . �. c t P �,'�l.�.'�„'fR� � � `�, . g. � X�Y ���s }'. � p.y ��,�t{ J 1 ' ��Y q ;*i��� � ��''.�°����p+ � � ' ti �� K�4 �f ��, s <�'�{`i, .-�.L f-- ��` �"' �� 1j g f �'r��.�y�,•��� 'f � � �i � '�.��,."��£t ?�Y�'S`t�t��y+'ss�,g�� �� t` /` �YS �-�K�'�.� � � ��� F �� 4�, ��s� I � � � »r< S� 1 `�:,: � ..,.�.����': ° r i + r` � 1 e a � � - �� i- - �� +. ���"�.�,., �,z�� . ��a . 5 g 5: � `.� � � � g�'+���� c"i�� �3 _ � ,, � ._.r F'�,�,�..�, ,� ,b.� �� . , ��a. ��. �� �cy „ ��v t��''•�"�; .� '� �������,`������ � � ta�`` ��j"x�� `u �� � ���tr-� �wu�"'������:� ...a:z::`..�L..a�i,��ia! ��ru s��� ^€ �,'�a�«�`� .� ' �...�, .,»�-. , ... . . x_ .. ':�v��sv"as.�.;��:a`y.""r.`�,�'��is.�«��.,,.3i� � �r�d", . ' . . .. . ..... � . 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 945A5 QFFICE: (8$S}9��-$733 �993 EAST BAYSHt?RE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94�063 GELL: {����J7�-�0�� WWW.ARBORWE�L.COM `, Arbo'r ell. March 18, 2016 �«���,��<«�����=4�:z,,.�,,,�,�,<,�F�,<�r�r � Exhibit 1.5-Supporting Image: An image ofTrees#7(leftimage)and#36(rightimage;Tree#7 in the background).Tree#7 is stuntetl in growlh and full of deadwood. The rightimage illustrates the narrowness ofthe planting area while also illustr�ating Tree#36 lifting the sidewalk. Tree#36 has been identified for short-term preservation. 1` "�,.' �'��a �� y , , ����,,� '�'� �� e� �� , . � ��, x " � y,. �� 4�" . �` ",'��""'� ��� � � C �a..., r II/ o t . a._ ,� � . � . . , f C� � � "'°.,'� � .. �` �. _ �P+.��,�..aauNp�. � ��•.�4�"ti�:�. , �`+� �.`'�$E�rt �� , , �. .� �� � � ���., . ,� . �.� �'f � `` *"''� �" �"� * �►''`'� ,.�r., . . + ,.. , , � ,� � . a. ° � � �►� � ._ti" �.�a � y � w . - ,. � � � h> . ��` y�f � A� � . . m, • ��� t � ' , � , „y.v= _..w .< Y, !�� • ' "„ , •, ,�' � i.. :arr a a. a � ; t .� .. ������� � af"��"� '1� � .. !' � � 'wrw : . w � * x� x + .� �S���x�hf '��t .�4 R�� ��. ,.�, ��`:�« > . .�� 1��� � "�. SA0.#r�n`*•� rk � (�w. .J� w,.,. � �R,- , �� . , � ! . .� ��+�N.,. y f. . . �5 � ��� . . � �.,,..,, ��, . .. . .�„q�k ,� ; . ,� .,, .° -, . ; 2,.� ��"^�. ��.� ..m. , �.}�',�.h. . :�. .d" :. , ,. �e , ` , .,. 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFicE: (888)969-8733 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAO,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW.ARBORWELL.COM March 18, 2016 ���,��.��,A�:�,�:��R�.; a,:�;�,�,��F�,���` Exhibit 1.6—Supporting Image: Images ofTrees#8(top left image)and#9(top rightimage).These Ash have an abundance ofdeadwood,weak branch attachments,are in continuing decline,and pose an increasetl risk offailure into the parking lot. The bottom images correlate to the image ofthe tree above,and represents deficiencies exhibited by the respective fi ee:large bark split�ng in main trunk and limbs;sloughing bark on dead/decayed limbs,respectively. ���:�r ,�, .r. � � �� 7� x� , �� � �P.z��a�, "° , ��,�� �'S�i. � �. . S �� �, r `� t� t , � :� ` } �. ';. x � 3# � � ✓ a � e :,, lr y ' Y .��5 �.E h- "p's� �°,�''3"r'�.�s�`��. � { �. �t �- �d .t,�;, . F & {�-.�� ' '� � $' 1 Y` . t ,,��,"h � � ` � � ��° � �. �� r� �� `'��'F�� �, yr��C� 5 `�r,�����"'����'� r r,,$F��y��' aa�`ws�,�tgJ��"��s`#+ ��`*�,z,:.�:�.' >s�' '. �T.� ' ¢est �.: ��� �_` ` 'CFy "- ��c . :,5 �„ ' �. S�� e, .� . � #��2'' � � :. i�- � Y��Y�'� � s cs�? �� `4 o- �s L i�,.��'��. '- �aak, �'{r�,.� ,t ��k�, ���2 ��`'�;# �� JY S. � ) .;.�k,�vp . ' tr.t.t� �x��.'"r e "�`. . ��., � .,f,5-k { �� A�, .,�. t E � ,x 4 �..€.> 1 �� 3�,z.,:_ +w2,�.,�,rv^Y .:� r � �, � � .` ::. ..� " . • � ,,� � � '�����;��'`7 �r���� ;��� 1 a v«�c� �,,,' _ . �� � � 3..:_ � .�:w.� �. � �� - F ; � .+<tFi.,.''aL��.-..��� . �u`6� K& f � .,„ , , . , � .. . . : ��`��� � : `s�'��` �':� 7� � ����'�ff.'� «'� �� t�� �' � _ ,a r;" , � ��-��,' �' � ' . . ,:_:. � �,.w z , . ,. � ..a._ � ..> . � y * � �� � m i ' � �� ' � `r%�.� A ; '4� � ^ d (���� `{ . f ,��, ���. 4 1� �*',�, �� � �.� `5� � & �� � � � Sk� 4� �'.q A '�N' ls . "�'t� ��C.-���� � , .� ��a'a. ';..' � � �.F��,�t* . . § 'z} . w „.� �A ��}� �. .;5;. . ��' �.� � � � f � �a,�� � Y`"�'a � ''�,� b��'x �}�'�6n��i,� �9{��` 3 �� y s;, � � ��P �� + �" �+ .•,St� �5 `�"� � �'������ 9�� �+ Y&' "d'd„Y" b 1^t,,r,uV� �$ n �4: �*.� �h 5 4 yi n $�j � + �� � �m e '• a .. . �W .��3 �',,3H �,� ' .�C. t ��y� .. . :� �. � k� A � � P . i, �"; r�� ` . . . � �. �&4 �� i;� �5 �� +1d�".. ...�, �s . .�d ". , . ! � � ' . . , . '� . - �3 �� � s Y. � y � , i-. .%` '6` sq�� € z r i e , .. i y � ��. 4 }� .... . � .. �x>. � Z:: Mr➢"'^zu y "- �-� ���a. „,t. � 2337 RMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,G�A 9�545 �}FFICE: (���}��9—�73'� 1993 EAS7 BAYSHORE ROAQ,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 �ELL: ������'�$—�O�$ WWW.ARBORWELL.GOM �, Arbo'r ell� March 18, 2016 prcy9�rtist>.ari<t(tr�:e�ranaqemeni Exhibit 1.7—Supporting Image: Images ofTrees#10,#11,#12,and#13(clockwise irom the top leftcorner).These Ash have an abundance ofdeadwnoci, w�eak branch attachments,are in continuing decline,and pose an increased risk offailure into ihe parking lot The insetfor Tree#11 shows the major decay in the codominant leaders. � � �`, i � �, g't, �; � �, , , � ��,R ��.d.,� ,� � x� + �� °� � � �� � �s«. ,�' �. �+�d s'� " � z,� � .�o r�� � � �� d � '+ +� �� m�,�"`�t� �r,y"�' y h '� ,�4°.s^�`" `T .. r e r `�� �` � � � k�� "t , ♦'"� "�.,' "9 '�2y x ��- �it y� w� ,. p, "" "aa� r . e )b�A�,$ yew 'wB �, .! .n�� ,* k .� "��'� ...i�" *�w.,� �' a �� �' � � w'" �'� �; �` � r �» ����� � er , �� �' �� �a�:: ,�� :.�„ � �� � • �.- � �`����'� �''� .�" �� .�� ���' . "�� � a � �. �� � ti� � � � x ,.�, � � �� `�,� �` x`�' � �� �� � �� .. �.�°` � ' �, �"��i � � � ' � .�: �'�`, p� a ��`,., `4 '�a �; ��5�� � ,,,,� � � m "��. ��,' . .. °''{ _, �.i 4 -.i�' &,�`. ,�" '�°� '1� . R 8 ,, � P. , � � - ,py. � � � � �'p� �1 � . �� 8� � �� ' �'" �#�`. , � �.�� r , � � e }. � ; . � .� . �.��,�k -� s ,� ,� , , , ��. ,;, � ,�� ��'-', �`.} lT� �b �"` k � g� z ; R " �� ��~ �3 5�:,.' � +7�+b�� I +� �` ����� , � t,� s.9�, '� ��. �� ��fi�;, ��„ T � #, F�� �f��� ,c r �'�asw a������ � � � '`q � - 'a'* Y�. z�� s �� �'e .•��� ����� � �,�1 `��A ' �" . ( '�' � „ .' ,'�� 7�� �6p � !. � � �. Y ' � ��yc.�`� , � ..�•a-.,. .— ,.. e; , .".,�.*,� w ,� - �: � .��� � j��t s s�-- `�'�' �,� , _ . r=� a�°� p 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFicE: (888)969-8733 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW.ARBORWELL.GOM c�r,�f�w�s%�;€3a3�r«�;�r�%sr��ac��:rr3enin March 18, 2016 Exhibit 1.8—Supporting Image: An image ofTrees#14,#17,and#15(from leftto right). These Ash have an abundance ofdeadwootl,weak branch attachment�,are in continuing decline,and pose an increased risk of failure into the parking lot. The oak has a defective , rootsystem and is leaning,shown in the top left inset. Top rightinsetshows the girdled rootsystem. fi � $'° d A e � � z���� , " Y> aa, � � � �;'� �•�,�F �A �)vy, a ` w��4 `� 1 #' ,� �r� �k, � ��� � * ��`� � �` � ; '"�-' � g�;� ��� � ��' � s : r x � �i �,, ' . . '3:+a$�5"g �Y1i �1, , s° 'y, a'd x � -�y uf �'fl, f� � a r :,�� �� � t^ r �g.._ � � , ,c+��y� r ��"�. "� �� � ta� � "�"'"�'� r�'� �� �`��� `� �� �`�' ` � ��s: , r i����``' . �e:� �� � xi� ��i� � � ✓" � s,cy{$-� p�� � y; 1�4 .h � � • r°� '� P''j h� y ; � �Yt � °. „ ��v:��`w°�Y � 3- � I � � ' '�Y� f�r�;e/�. i � . `'9�»,•�.;v,.. ' ^ � . { � �'' � f �"_a�`�'` f` , �• �,�,� � c � k j rr"` � ' �"',.:w��i �,.�,�.a r � �;�f} 's `' � �' x.�'� � � �4�� ��� s � �4C+ x � > �� $�� z ��?'.� �� ` � s ��e�xX'�� "L ,,� ,.�..� � � � t" s,���S , `L � x��"��� � � �� ,;��� ��� � � � r � � , a �` �`.� r�s.` x � '`�'i,� - 'a � a � ��� 4'a -'� � y� 4 `w�i`; n� ����' � , � ��L,. � ' +.��+w � r+w z S .t�., ;� � �;�c .�a 'c�`&'',-'' �"`'r �s ce �'� �. � ���� �..� ) ��, � `�t.� � �� ������ �` �,Y .�� � � Yp,�.3�s � �� �` � � � .� .»�. �i ;- � � ��' s r: ¢ n��,�� � i. . '' � '�¢� -�,�r'�X,� c,y „�; ;r�'a '`�t b�� `�7�c'`�� ��s �,r�„r� '�F�-1L w ��`� f,�€`fir� g '.�"J.'�'� � :�Y'ua'���.` `�'`�;� � t d�' �sfi 4 6; - �� �` n: 3 �q �' t; ' �F „€,-�r � �� �"y �br.^�Z y �r`�r�.sf"�. �`��'^s-�`2k�� '.n�E-t'''a '��,��l1M'4���+zK- , �^r �o�',- ,,. �'a`a q.. F ^ 1 Y�'N�}t ��-'F � � � �� �y p � '9 � _ .. ' �,� s.- f c ♦ . t �„ � q t . 3 _ �. 4f � a �� . ,i l'. . �t �� aa� .. '� �' '��� � � :-� n�- . ' .'" J �� �.�; - ,,- �+. :�.�. ; . .�: � . � �� i� .t'� ��.. , 1 �1� �� � � �.. � �:^r� _ '4�� < ,e, _. �f.r' ;;. „ ��t t r �s .�; ��"� ; � � � ` � � � � � �z E 4 7.. f (1 � { K��'*p 1 T gr ( `w { ��.� � 3����� �� i . ���� f � . �Y �..y. - *l .c;..'�; � J � t �: -c5'�✓v. ��."z� ;4 .. 4 ; J ��i� Y 9 r' �'�, � � ».-3 t � *� •f`"W y jq,, p� � ,- `t � � �,.�--� er+� t` } `�' d � .'��� t t#' � �'� � i- � �' } �3 # � , �� ?i� `�9 t ' s � '� i � � � t z � �� � �� � ,_� .�,. � �. { � � ��� ` � ��`�� � . � ' � �,,.�-�� �a „�'" �s-..--.�- .,��i r �.�:. ,� � x � w ��. �,. a .e.'`, � "�,�.; `��,�,. ). u✓'k t*Md: v 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 {7FFICE: {8����6�-87�� 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94Q63 CELL: t�������-�OZ� WWW.ARBQRWEL�.GOM V� Arbo'r ell. March 18, 2016 �:r��+r,�.><,<<.,t r�t.�,,,,r,.,,,<,k�_,,,,,t Exhibit 1.9-Supporting Image: An image ofTree#16. This Ash is in decline.This 6�ee has a weak branch attachment.The insetshows the elongated top with little live foliage. � � _ �°��d�� �r . p .�k � �a ,� �y � " � � �" ,g �,, — � Y�� � a��"r, t �`�"'��q -��j ,� •,,� ��� ,F y�� *3- �@ � � �� �� �� � y�'� �P ,���p � �� � e��. � rn� T �M !.Yw. �� . � � .r p\ Y w / 4 � 'M�.di' �� ,`F�6". +j t W;� 4 �'e �' � . p .,6� � 'a'.. +y,*1' s.�4tW. ,,"!4, . k�i���' � y '�� j*1 � � .:�`� �r `"��� �� � � � ,�x q g 's, "�m'' a t k> J. e 4 ' � e �� 9" � yf.8 y� �° 1,y� 1 i� � b� ��tti * ��yy� � .�,..nu.���y�.� � �", �,.. ����� y d-, � r � `� ���N` .�� . „q �`��, .� ��y , �.. "5.'y"y'� '�'� .t� �'�° r " ^ i s��' � �� d �' "�'�. �, r � � ' � "� -�� ��`� `� �.g�. ° d � z�"� '. �e�, � �r j'""'�p^�° s�"C` „,.^� k�. „*,.�.� c '��5 �=� : y r ' � b3 '� �t 1.'�°d `' �[ � ,�,'�'� .R � A� � K R�7` t: ,�` k� p�' �F�`, T��'�*"�' �y°.. �� , ��� � �� «sd r�; � ��* v t,, �. �� �'. �^#� ,�t. M.r � , "s � Y �'z � P" ��, �yt i ' o.yt ' �. � " +� �a T � � +a �` X�� `I 'p � . �1-a� ' a k r� �. �� �. a ew' y ^^^"�- . .� � -�,4 �., �-.. a� ��x#R �,-��„� . �`�. ..��� "S� .,�y� ,� "x ��r�f � �°� :.�� �` d� � �� u" � ��.�, +�!Z °'� � � * � � :; $ � ., E+�v;,y ����'��� ��`�„� .� � �`�` . �� .� � � °� � `;,�S�t�.w, �f, �„�, � � „K ��� ; �� N ' � t �. �� �r q,�x���'�y g� �� � � � ;� :� ��"� �I �.G 'a� � <zm.` ..�c� _ `s. ;'ia 9�r"�;"< �.� . ,�, .i.��� q �� ' � � _ _'#.. �'�' � �� .�« �r � t'� �,. ��� � � i� ��9 ���'� � �� �� �����I� 1 � �s, �;� �� r o " � Y �: �' �� � � �y�"` � � � $ '�C' ° +�` � � � t ,�� , � ��,� P " � ��� � ; � r� _ �'`��� _ ��� � ; � :�# ��: <� � � � ^,�� ; �' ��A �.� 4-� � t '� � £ �(*� ( t'�". �. .".'?. 4 '.y � g `�� ; �� ' j �x� t�'$� '.� g 4 � 4 V� .. yx .. f � � �, � � € � 't �"���E. x � � � � �� s ,.,� ,� € e �i �� � � ' �a � � � �,,�,� ;��' ' � � � � � � �� st�� `�� !V ������ M�_ �,. .� � a �t_`�.�� +�� � . , � . ��� '�'���., ,. �.4 y,}, � �� � "s�i ���'yy�{�,ad � � �, ,.4���;:;*�,���,�'� � r� ��:'r• ` J �.. �• '�,` �,:� � y�' ,•� �� ..+��'.�� ' q h .,;� "�� "�!"�' � '��',i•?M �.;,' ,�-a`$": ,a� ,.�'��� ��`*' �,� a q �,� .a.� b4w ;.�„ „�..:? �.,�� 2337 AMERicArv Rv�,HAYWARD,CA 94�5 f�;F;;;�; (���;���j�_�jj�;j 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WW W,ARBORWE�L.COM 'l..l c,�rafca�„'>itar�si�r���as��*�;�s�:rr:��ra;, March 18, 2016 Exhibit 1.10-Supporting Image: Images ofTrees#18 through#24(clockwise from ihe top left corner).They are all dead. w..'y�," > 'i t "t Y?. �t-- 5' .` � rr "' , x� � 4 � r� .. "����V + :r � �i �� d'�V,� '`""• a �� �k� � c y �^ "�''� � �� k� � �3��' � '' ' ` �� s �� �," �� ' f .r l. ; r `.`` �"'. )��«pr ��� � y.' d `(�� C j .4 t r�„ � :rT � ` 'l t �'t� ;� � x ;4.. (.1 �� �� � �i , F�-:�2 -�� ' � j ' t 3� i i" t �'' l�f ' � � . . . i } x� � g � � � 'f � g +.� � ;>�5 � 1 � ` 1 ,�! t )� i A '` �'• . i�s . f .w � ``"�` � ,�, � , T � .-�^ ,Y�'` ���t����d�� ���� � �; • r, r �l t '� � � ° ���� J��`���"�, �����'�'�j � i _ j '�-�`� ! ,r�r; � -^'c�,,,�.�''"�`�L `t� '�^ �„-°�za�''+ s� j ' � � t [�, ,- `4 ,:��,f .�s� � r/'"���"��'':. £��,�y�r�..������"e � e=c" '�.. � k�. e ,f ��K ��,� � ��.' �,. t f- � �( �, �"�� r� r � t� f r [ �c� f ��� ���� � j�,,,�'^ Y ' � rf4 F����� � f,�.�� ��r`� ���.i��,:; n. �r�f! �'-:�. t s i 1� � � �' ��-"�`st+ i� { ; 1�' •i y ��}� . ✓ i4f � '' o-;��"1'-f .. � T�.� . ku� �"`1' �i �l �' ' Mk,� {.: ({ �ft{ }� �Y : r yj- . y�7�� J c �.�_ . a���e�°' . �( �� �J �f . I��f' '��'.�si` y/. � 5�,�p*A '� i�^3 � f:. �� � �s/ ,.p4„'°t �'�4`t� �,�.' �,{-3 r ,�t z t iys�"`, . $ � ^ .!i � � i✓`�i.i � � �z a� �� �� }e.� � /` �' i+" �' s�; i r±' t� . � ��''i . � �.:{ � . a . t�, 4 t R 4 '..E` %q k P�A r�,{ _ . 6 �$� 4 b k Sz7� 7 L p4'��" .. �` ��. . 3 f �" P C2 �i ( {y � ; ��� �.ti Y i v �.i� � y�b a,e f{ ,`, n �� a� t E:. a 2 i � �- s '.E � 1���� t � y �` �k z.s � i i'�„����� �� � ;S �, ' k +�y. � it� 4� „t„ � , t> . �_k�y-S �`�y' j �!4i - ��i`j z . ,� `� � � :GY .� ' „ �... 1 � � �� ���*��f�.�'� f ��, i . Lill I ..+' P . 6 � � I 1 � e; � �� "'1t d �,4�t I t��� { � zf � ,���' +'S �i a s,k �t :�� i . �^� ;�� ; " > ��. _ - i - , � � . _ �.".' _.. . � . _. ,_ ;. . -_ . - - „ � �I �: �r�ti � � .`t ' _ � - ��'x '��� �� k",.. � m � 'aY'`�1.F. � �g �` � µ i �-� ��e-0"r-:m:, 2337 RMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 {�FFICE: {�BS��6�-$73� 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CEL�: {������g-�0�8 WWW.ARBORWELL,CON1 \� Arbo'r ell March 18, 2016 �.rf�;z,��,�.,�ti�P���:, rr�.��,.,���,�,��,� Exhibit 1.11-Supporting Image: Images of Trees#25 through#35(clockwise from the top left corner).This parcel located at 10355 N.De Anza Boulevard was includetl in the original lease of 10431 N.De Anza Boulevard. All the birch shown are dead. , , - • ' • a. ��r �� ;�-��x� ,��r'�' r , ,���`.� � '.- ` %`.,x. ^' �� �?s y Kl �� 4 I'��mM` ����� " 8 �� �/��}/'����� V i ,^y1' �1! /. .�(ri_' �'�e� .,�. �y ""��r 1C- � � �+ .� e a.,«x p,.,m:�N #tl• � ( y � ' . ,�_,�yJe w y t �'L A.s #'� ` 9i y� � i . �_ n ., � : .�yy' ....' �' W, ��t ,�' •�'d r '' Y �j � ' . ,,: � x�4 f.,... , s" �*' •'�' . +�ri � ��� ..(LL�� J;� ¢ p ���s� ��� �'y, d �� . ' t� � .. �`y ! q �� d� W },y *, p_ �t �,� �k���. . . �": � . wd^r'�"�, . r,� � &r.. - � � _�pe . d� �. d� A� %' i'.f.}i �M,?t ��k ��''� j •;�,... ,�' C".�sf� k'j*� � �.;. �»+'+�� .�m�� � �-�., ��" � �r�,,�� �, ! -�x � �_4,� . 'k�._ ,f i'9sm�: '�A�, *�y _ r , s�' R�%1• �,�} ,� f ;�,, �� �, ' .,�s�� , +�ly`� ���..'.• i,; �"4�1r.Y, :'.` yr�� �'y�-�� ��`� � b ,.��� � �� �.. P 4'- �a.`._ . o.�.. ,.. "rr+F1 a , � '�a'� x.r "a#,. ' . i�. ;-n, i!�. ���� ���:" �: � � , ; �: � �" �� �, � �� "r, �}�` � � � ,, � - . � , :_���� � , ��p 5 . s t E � .. . �^� , 9 �., T ��y. �{'....«+ • , . . � '�, a�'� s � � r E . _ .�;_. . � . _��I ii � � � �._�, g �"w. � � " . — ti"`'.,,.,x ^. <: � = � _ .. . . . yw-, �*-. �• .e �.�.� .r.s '- _ •. .;-:". ;:. A�,�.w� � , : � , �� . ' . ,�Z - � _. `� . � �. ..w,o.. . �� a : ,�-, ,�. -.��✓� 4t,,,• q�...�'.�,'" � �� ,�.{_ . :' -�- �,�. , �� - ,... , .�� �a�•�`.� ` t �� � _ � � �� � + . � b � � . � ,� , ��, � -�• �.,� � �, r�`�` :�._ ,����r_. �,.�� - „ � � .�. °^'�`` :«' �; - .�"�'N :,: 2337 AMERICAN AVEs HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFicE: (888)969-8733 1993 EAST BAYSHORE ROAD,REDWOOD CITY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW.ARBORWELLCOM March 18, 2016 �Ed����t>�s������:<:;������r,-��:��f�-�r,��� Exhibit 1.12-Supporting Image: Images ofTrees#25 through#35 as a stand.This parcel was included in the original lease. The Birches on the left side (halfl of the grove are dead,whereas the Birches on the rightside(halfl of the grove were alive at the time of inspection. , , �� � � �.^�� :;� ��:� , �, ��: � n-�� � �� � � � � , � �� ���� , � � ���� �� : � _ � ��� � x � � �� � ��� � ' �;" t � �4�";,� � Z �a,'t� �` �, i: � � � ,��;. ��::^�-s� y.; � �i, mt � �` � `r ��M1 �� � E ? f� `- �� �:n �' ���� ; �a� �� k` � �� t � � � � ����� � �� ��'��� � ��,. `� ���..' _, � �'�' � ' �x �; � .� �. ���;'� � , �.< %�. a ���� � ��� � � � "``�' � � 4 y � � � �� .�� � ' � � �� ' ���` ��� � r � � �"��'�,r �� �'�' ��t *��� 'r- �x � ���� ����� �� �. ��� Y. �. z�.�� �. ��`' �� b� `, ,� ����.,`� .g Y� .�y�'�� 9 �¢� �,� �� ' � � ,� � � � �,,q� ;� : I a r z � � � � � '�� k..yy'' {��� f� �,�'' � �� �6��:£� ���� � �� � ..� "��4� � ,� o- C' �l t . i �� � � �9 � '�.� 2 • q � { � � � ,� � � �� � �� � ��. � ���" �� ��.. [�'v�. p� �' � � #.�.� ;,s�[ � ;7� ��*i�,„ ��� *✓��� 4" ���3�a�..p""�.� .�-�'� '�'"" �r,��-� �.�` �' .E.x.. � � � ,y,. a�r��': ,�" '�r' "z,�.�'. �" ...�'Z�-�. '� ,'� � t�,'�°"�. . � ��.�r��i �� ,tn� x ��M� � � �' �' �� �� �- � �� _ �� � � � �� �.�� � � �� � �� �'� � �_ �� Gr ;� , �� � s� ��.,�. � � . � �'" ���:� ��r�.., � ,�..�, 2337 A��ERicr�N kv�,t-3A�+N�R�,�Ia���� C)FFICE: {588���9-H7�'a �993 EAST BAYSHORE RQAD,REDWOOD CI7Y,CA 94063 �ELL: {����J7�-���� WWW.ARBORWEL�.GOM V, Arbo'r ell. March 18, 2016 professionai tTee menagement Exhibit 1.13—Supporting Image: Several m iscellaneous images of Bandley Drive.Ashes-all have sharply declinetl since initial inspection and pics when they w�ere in foliage. Clockwise from top left Decay pocke�large bark spli�ng in main trunk and limbs;sloughing bark on dead/decayetl limbs;majordecay in central leader. u �p� . .. � 4 � . "4#, � � � 1 �a k � �y h C � � A� � 1? 1 �'9 ' � �� � IR ' # , `�.' `��.. a W � �fi+ t Y� P � i g � f�b . ,Ir ' yk Q.�... � .ra r r e � � �' " .�� �,� .� � . � �. �:� a , �� �.. �, �� � i �� t F �,a� � � � W� it � ' .�� Y � �� ,: c. ♦ m s.+'�. ����� i,�.^� I^ •�+�,� +� ��: �, �� ��g ��, ; �: : ;�;� -�� ._ :�a, ��,.�:. ���. ,���-� '�i�+ry y � � � ! �`' t�. �•'k*'�4,t.1w,`�� ,y. .�' . � , ,�p�.. ".. '��� ��� ;�► .7� ,w,�� �"`' X x. �. � r' � � �� d � � � � _4 ���: � «.di �R ,�,,� ,�� � y � �, , �� �e � � . ,.- » r .�, ''���.r;�. , �.r� �$ �+���, � � ��.- _�r� .ic�w� y�,� � w x:����Y �" � A � AF �a j p'!�� �+ �� . , � � � ,` ,� t�� �� � �; . . . r . ' a •y'� � 1 '+ . '� F ��,r ,Y �ki.A ry�``A— / d� !:�.. ..�aly. xV h%! ,�'�S ,r�"� r' ../� � I >�"a^`� 'µ '�` -�" �'�. �"�»"���, ` + � � ; � _ �° i �� �. � � z -�r� a`,.>� � - � � : � , , ; *. � � ,,� � � =����„� r�x �� .��?�:�` � , ' � � �;� ��� :,���, . ,, , . � ��-= � ° . , � „� ,° .. �, , , , .. � . ,�.. � a�.. 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 94545 OFFicE: (888)969-8733 1993 EAST BAY5HORE ROAD,REDWOOD CIIY,CA 94063 CE��: (925)518-2028 WWW,ARBORWELL.COM March 18, 2016 ����>s�.��o�g,��gE���,���,;���ra,�.��" Exhibit 1.14-Supporting Image: An image of the preservation tree along Bandley Drive. This tree is very large,has a beautiful canopy,and is presen�y relativelyhealthy,making itavaluable antl established screen tree in the immediatefuture;however,ihistree is a candida� for removal and replacement in the near fuiure since it is beginning to I ift the sidewalk and outgrow its narrow planter. �� � � � � � � � � � �� ��� �� � � �� �� ��- �� � � � „r � � � � � � ��, �.. � � ��r. : � �� �� � � � �, � �-�� ���- ��; ��,�3; � � ` � , ' � r � � E , ' � r����� ��x : � �� � r� �� . � ��rr� �"� - s � ��r� � �°����� . � ��: �rf^,�,- � �� � � . . � . ��. �"�"� ..-� a � l� � �`� ��" x€ z y r s z�� ..�a �������z ��� a � �c�� � �� � � s.r r �� ,�� "��,�' �� ' h � ,� ��' � �` �.� � � � � � K � ��°�� �"" -��, �.�,w� -�'� ,.i � �� . ��'�� ?;; • � �� ��.�� *� �r 3 � s . �`r�°�� �� ���u������ ' '*xi,� Y�' � .a .�'��r! A/�e'��3 �� �� �' ��� j' �r-:?X � ,� �.d'r�"`�YZ a�' ������ � rx n. `��, , � � �� � ��x����� � �`� � � � #�� � �s�ss� �� � ?�� �,.� .et.s-.� �� c ��� ���� .. � '°"�=��� � � � � �S"" ,�;"a��`' s � '�w` �`r������^z- �� as. �� ..,.. ? : � rr �a �v " � +�` I ,�,��- . . . ��, ,�?, '` �' � �� � . e w ,�y" . � �El;�'�, e4� �s s�, � ,�. , � � _, �,�,,, , ��� � . � . .. . � � �Msxb .. .� . � "`'�� � .�� � ��%�'�b:��. 5�s ,�, '�.e���s. ;_. r^ . . .' „ . ,: � _� ;,. . .w . �t, ,,, d �i�;: � � ,� i. � I f,a�r�'��r��3���1�. �.h:+��t�..:� 2337 AMERICAN AVE,HAYWARD,CA 9�545 C.�FFICE: (88S}96�-87�'� 1993 EAST BAYSNORE ROAD,REDWOOD CIIY,CA 9�063 �ELL: ����J��J'�8-2��� WWW.ARBORWE�L.COM