Loading...
TR-2016-31b I�EPARTiVIENT OF'COlVI1VIiJNI'I'Y DEVE�.OPIVIENT .a.:a:�.i . � CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE � CUPERTINO,CA 95014-3255 ��������� (408)777-3308 a FAX(408)777-3333 a planning@cu�ertino.org August 4, 2016 Jon Rohde 20395 Pacifica Drive#108 Cupertino, CA 95014 SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—Applica�ion'�'IZ-20�.6-3� 'This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on August 4,2016 approving a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of one dead 12-ulch and one dead 14-inch European W11ite Birch(betula pendula) at an office park located af 20395 Pacifica Drive. Staf� has made the find°ang that the protected trees are dead. basecl on the defa�ation p�oviclecl in 14.1�.020 of the �it�'s ��otected'�'�ee �rdinance, poses a hazard to the safefi� of persons or property, ancl cannot be eox�tx�olled. ox�rexaied'aecl ���ough reasonabl� relocation or moclificat�on. �'he pr�posed �eplacemen�plan is consis�ent�vith fhe�'ro#ected'7Cree �rdia�ance �ince the applicaa�f Ys replacing the trees o�a s�te, and. t�e nu�ber of replaces�enfs is coa�sgstent with �he o�clg�ance. �'he finding i� � � � � � � necess��o gra�t the tree�eano�al perxrai�in accorclance�rith Section 14.1�.1�0 (A) (�) an� (4). � ` The application is approved with the followulg conditions: '1. APPROVED PROJECT This approval is based the arborist report prepared by Joe Nama (WE-3238A),froin Commercial Tree Care,consisting of three pages and a removal and a replacement site plan,except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENTS The required replacement trees are three(3)24-ulch box Chinese Pistaclle to be planted on tlle subJect property as defiailed on the replacement plan.T11e replacement tree shall be planted withul thirfy(30) days of fhe tree removal. The applicant shall provide the Department of Commw.lity Development adequate documentation, includulg but not Iimited to pllotographs, receipts or invoices, to verify that the replacement trees have been planted. 3. PROTECTED TREES The applicant understands that the replacement trees may not be removed without a Tree Removal Permit aild that they shall be responsible for ensurnlg tlle proper maintenance and care of the tree. The applicant sllall also disclose flle Iocation and species of all replaceinents trees on site upon sale of the property. Tree Removal Permit Action Letter Page 2 TR-2016-31 4. NOTICE OF FEES,DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements,reservation requirements, and other exactions.Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1),these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby notified fhat the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exaction,pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a),has begun.If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020,you will be legally barred from Iater challenging such exactions. Sincerely, �,�,�.� 1 isi � Haleigh King Assistant Planner (408) 777-3313 haleigl-ik@cupertino.org , � CC: Commercial Tree Care, ath1.:Joe Nama,P.O Box 549,Santa Clara, CA 95052 �' ;�. A,��`�, L ., �,� `� : _� �s.� i—tr^,,, z,.r.���--;.�-r,�,n `� �"�.�'.'��� ��r�� s�,� r �^<�.,rr�,,�� : � � . � c�_"`�i�'�"�,„ ,�, a .`�t.�� � ti y� � k i . � 3`: S fy� y `{a ,� � .,.�,- { � ..=v� "4 V'+' ic '. �'�N. i`M "�#�• �.. � � �. , �. � � w�; . � . .� �q� �7 ��� ,r �� � ar- ��,��.� �: s� � '��^�. .z ��° ��*�u� L"� , � ° ��� � ��,� ���� ���y � � ��� � ���� � � � ; � '�_ ��� e s., , � - . _„ . �ue..<, .� .�,�� � � `"� � �. ; �.����k� � � �' ; -,�w�s." ,r' �a "� z a �s'�a"�` � s. a� �„ �� s p - p+'S� . �:. � n . �, ,.ea2 we�� e+.�����,�°�n.�s � kw 4"' � ,. 42�^v� ' �M� � (1 q � ;��� � � � � �--e c �..s ' g aP„� �r.� �a.,. � �.��u ., F��iMq� h� Y �� � ' g� b' 4 ♦ .� � • �� r "^.^„^��,"R,. ,.s �ti.,.,.�.-. „,. . . 6 ..�,�,v s `� "�� :.�. � �.a::.......»s�.�`. a.�.a� � :"a�.a�. " �C �, � i � � �. �s�a,��.. � r,, �a., : �,K "0'e M. .r v�""`�"" � � � �z �„-r _ �` . -. ,. ; �} < i:�9 a t $`.� `v� '�. : F a C�� b•,< '3� :.-. g G '�.: .8 �. . ` r . ...y«�a �. �w a��y .,� ��. s i n e -� � � "^� '* 'a" S � -t*^*�a�+a9��;'�.'�' "a . �,�:,K ,� .�„�,. ..,h.._ "}^ .... � •:�^ �"�S - , ., �,,.., � . � * ', `� �•"'c-�, 3' z �'�-� F aM,,,a,�.+^i�`k R+r ,�:�.v� �k�`��}t �� � x.�^� �f�,��»,`��^u s ��� . a ��—,"^' � 4��a�,�,� �3F�,\�� ��� ;�"�" �°,`�"��`^,�d. �`�"��"�"�'„'�,e ?``�� °f< � � ' �..._ ,^�t � �., ��«.. yr-t �^. *r c .e�sR �'} .� t f '�.:...:� ��.� qr`y �`ar.h '.4-i C?t^^"°"'ai� ��'`����� ����- �`�-� .' ._.. ���S,��e� �� }�� „Y � `A; � ' � e �� �. �w � ",."k�,.�� � T� '. k,. o� s a� �r �. � a.4 .�p, ... '` s"' �� �c�;� � � ' e £{� ,r'�, t � `:u, ��,»+y� �... i"' ..Y"^a "o"� ,. „ �x�. ..a�{�aF x�f ° t t � y � "� i,*�„� � `»�� � _. � �'`'�.'�"v� r."-�' i����k �„�'�"',��`� ¢��Y�*� §�;�u � ��„,�,��� �"*�:...w �`� �'"�" ��E� -.. � �"�Z.•.; ��. � VV � � 4y § "� Fd��r. � v 1i �� S,� � � a� �t3, y . r�^M".2e 1 Yi C-^ �.: ��k G,a"'"«�`". �»b��� nA,.. - 4; r �.. k� ��:a �6 � � � � ��� ��' � � � ��+,tt.�.aa.�„*.^^rc"Ee"'"'A�,�k���^ ,�'�,��� �..a �� �� � ����' ����YY,, a ..i� �vb F �,k �"" ,"��,'��� °��t���c�..�:'�°��,a� ��e �'�."��c t"'* �a^ r�^' � � -�5;� ;�� `��e � t� x ?�. ��� r .__._._...�. � �- s. � m��� �"� "''�+� _�.. ,:'r t �m.c, a«�3.'l�,,?�.�,r.,.�;c� �?,�..c 1�S�aS.r.i::,m'� .Ay;;+ :za �r a }w � '� ��,�,� �7',� ,1",fi` a«x M +:;��,s, � �. .p— =.o �.y "�' ct�j i� �"; r a�n ��.�* R %.�� �"^�4�"''�„�'�i� '1 �` �' .. ' , �y} k A . � .. . . , .»p .,,A�:t,.��'..�.P_� '�. � t y; '� ��� s - .� 3 c--.�--�^'�; . L�� � ,•�. � �+,� y� � tc�s �,,,�;�' �> �� s�. �.� '� ��+�" ��� 4" �. � �� ���� a�.�.�` `�'� °�a� w �?`� �'�;'�i -t��; =e „�,,,,,,..„ ._ �.�„, ��t �#�: � �� .�s T �- � �' ra =% ��C� iH. �`�a`"' �� ;� � -�� �""s,""��"°� . � ,a � � "� � � �� * � '� �� � 9 ,y�..:e �3` ,. .,, _,� � �. .__._ ,_..._._i� �.. �., ; � . n..���. . ; '? .»i:-��� ;^t' ��Ys.Y t ��.yS'S" '. ..- l� �.�,� �0 ,���' P r. .��N a.. �����y''. y � � � ' �� . . . ,� � .,;�.s �",� �" ,�"wr."x"� �S"-� , .. .,..._ '�n '. � �, w:.z�""� r� ��'�s.�°.e3� = rf�,�re .� �,� �,:,e;�»�w a c��"��M�..;s,� t� ~�r ��*^ .�"�-'�. w.,...��� �� ,i � a � ^� � � � �w� �� t, � �, A �;,�s ���; ��'1�'��a �� �� � � a8v. " ,;t�` .. . . +�"'""r , §�tt.,���i�� '..' _ #�,� ,?';'� '�� "�. -:r '� r`„� '� -..,�,,.._.,:. ..:.....« �� 5 an.'� � '�..,� _ � � � .� � �, �"x cv ���a"`��k }�-�x +., �.,:. x `t. �. ., ..-�-�., � , . � a�+ .r t �"�j,�a��. ��.,�t�.+�e. G:,� :ys.�3 � �� ����� �' �a j � ,.�4 w� r� � -a'� � �'� �� � *"�: .�,�, ' �°"�'�G ��.��' . r, � � ��k' F' � � �v� x� ' �' a��,-�°^a _ �n;fe�''� � u E'� F �a a m�� F ���,'s x �t�� 3��� ' y ' i � \�,r,:. t � i�'r.e ��: i�;� � '�a r.�.,� .:�e�� '^'"° 4 $a���M'� � . 3T d F' f:x, a �. ..�, �a �. � . „ .. . � -�- . , . ,:�: .,�.�... �»K;. ,.. r c�. ; ' �..�:: r R . ��:�*'ra.`�� ;��'y �6 , ��.��,�., ""Y'"°,`x` y„�:� m^y <,�.x �,�� x !k£,_•, -., ��:.,�. .... . .�. ... ?rv; .,�n �,3 �. Y ..,,.a� +.,:r � _„ ` ., . , a ' �a',..�... . , . �..,. . .;..�.1k" 1M a,. .t. P . * � � ' F.�.; , ,....., . ..,r... .»^'^f.,:. � .� ...tw �,..���,�.� xi -� Y�p'�}� �'` � e �A�,.us;x p �;� t a°��k� ��'tr -�„ �-xc, .�.��. ..� �, 4 h: 't � o-•::,, .,,c'�rY,� �: t ..�s "?..,� ri�� ��:�•� �" ,�,.u�� ";c„c� ,�.;,.. ;� d� ,>;` '�1«�.� n.� ';:u i ".S ;4 +��,� a „?i ;��:;A x... t � �"�� �. , ,... . ., ;,,:- ;h z � �mH p,. ...:.:�„„ �` �. .,,,, ,r.. �-�� .� „�:�x���.' ,. . dn.'�r.�.�,., � "` x.�..�� `,;, ��,t"�i "�:+. , ..��� t�:�.�, ? t� -c. `"R ��,.. ._„-.�•;w,�„w a�'�F4 � '„s-���:.. , a""", .e� �^"`C�.:,,w, �r r:..�a ,7 .1«..: ,.;�.. 6;?�;�;-+wr ;� �,.�:_� m �'� ,..,, ;.�.: a �wr:,,; .:.°_ -.: , � ,g>., e. ...��: s..,,. ,.�,k .."' ; �.. . ,r�.���":� �',„,; . #�„'. .st;��' -s^ �.kS� � ..� `V e��"�::a� �v .;�.�.�,. .,.,.&,'�,a, '� 1 "K,e�a.a�.- ;t+w�, �� :7 ,e�„"�'�.v:�`..�f„n .°c�,�,.�s .a�» � _.`.�� ...�il,,,.w_o`s,."^.:� , ..:`« «. �: ^a,� ,.�r+y,,,,,,._.�:,.- � ..�w �. �. . y�i. �� k w.a. r � ��mY'�� � y�y;5'�#��"` �_..: �` ,� x � �� : ; ..�ax ` , ,. ....,..,,,., .....�.,.:. .. .,,.. � �...r. ,. ' , ,..��� . .. �,����,�, ,ne`�, s � �a ��`"���-°m. ';. ,v..'���r. e ;.'�`.� .::'� �,t a � �& ��' 4 �.�,�'�" - ZF' `�.,: �r �.v.. ....� ,„ . � �, ,,,��: : , .��. . , . . ', .,. �..: ..,. �t,,,,,-�-..J ,. ,� ... ?�.. Y -,..� 7�=�`.�� � :.`:,r�.. �rT�,� .� �x .,,-. . '- , ; ; . . .. .,r:. . . . .: . :, _t _'. .. .. .,: ...:„:; . . ��r� :�"^�', f t � ,��, �`w`t.. t �"`?i"�..t` , .. ,. ,:�. . ,- :;�., ';�,,.. .. .�.::; ...:.,� , :: .:u�. .. ....:.:> ....::, ..,.. k .,t_. "r a ,'.;� z� �q�.: 2° � �� : . �. . �:. .. - . � ;i3t .r ..�,._ :. �:��.! < �.... : � ,,.. ..,<r �:.. 3 -L, 'a. �ul �.E "�S'-�� h .;� -�^ *�'S � `��„J�'� ; �. . �, . . .:. .. :. ...'.:,.,�,x �� �.4� ,�.. .. ;.� , .� . . - , -� ,.. �� � z>" _. .„ i.� .�.: _ „ �^. �'�'.:- c �.� � *1�, .t `�.L Y.. sn� :+� �.d:?�.��� . , ., :... . . ..,": : 2 .,.. .. � �e:a ...�1�s.`�.i'""�;� r x �As��„ ��;: ..<.e� _,... : a�....,,ww "r�����:»�.�,w.�.i u��..�,w„�.,`we::,�,, � 'C � �a"a �,,- �.:,`��� ,u. �w,.,, s�a,�. ,�>,�,�e��„�,�,�'���cc t���'� ��� �.. . �a...�o-�"w'e:, ,,.,, .. .;,.. .�,�.- . ,�.,.: ..x '- a. �� .-� �n , .�.«s- v ��..��.�«,.�.z^5.�*r�;. r.. :�,�.�cs ;^�:'r,,,� �. �`�">'�'k�,�,, �i �... . ,. . "� t� , � ��� .�-.<N . �;, � ` ,, �'�' ,» <� y„>,..' � ..a.w,.k .. �:h ... .. ;R�...�N .>�.. P�e... ... .x.._. .s. ,.,�:�.uu. ...'. .. ..:z�. ...�.� �.,� ...,i: ..- � . :::. '�:��t r....'n3s�� �. F;� , t..��-^.. #�. .�e°�. ...�,. v..t ���.....a,et. ,,.., , t.., ..�`�.�i .�..,�'; , ..-., ,. �,.-, ,.. .�,.. :,,. ... � ._... � ..,., 't.. .. ,i., s� a t - � r%... �..., w.....�.,„ .„,r;�., .. ..+'�� � �s�.�.. .M ,.."+*��"�.M. �::r, .,_..,.,,. .,fi.._. .�.3 a. .kr..�s ^<�..,.Y. ri�"..�...,.�� �e G �...�.`C . ,. .�s.. �v ���4....€4 e?, .;..R..a ..f;... ,.:,mr ,..c:..;�� t,.,_. � �:3 .:: -.. ..-. z�.:�.� .x .>. .t...^� ..rt�' s�...� a .:��.v , ,�.';.:�., t_.#:,..�-��. �..,,. 7 �;, � .�.-3. ��. ..:,. ,, . P,. 3 .,,i � �� a�� �.�;�� �i� � �.v,>v_s,�,a�� `�.^a:�� �.ayYv� � �'��, `�.'� X.��.�,� .�,,�����`€i �� z:.: � - x i ... ,,.,-'_ .�._,e ; � u� V. a., ma........ e� � ,'��"' h- � : ... . "� � �;.�. . "�� �� � .� �� ��,��.� � �.. ��,�";"� � a.� � __.._...W ��...�_..� .�.� _:' �� ,.,. _�.:.� ..,_...._...... .,.. ,. .<. _.�:,:��-. � ',�s�a9 a �a�. .,a,..,,,. 7�,a��o.. a �...o..._ '�,�; s :,w<'� - . � ������J� �`c�,C1f1�i1 �r1�'tTf:' • � Dead Birch tree reamvals ��p������ Repl�tcernnets will be3-24" box Chinese Pistache In the approximate location , � � �, . , � _ ;.: ;� _�_ ��l� -�__� ,. , . , . . � _ '-��/� _ , . � . ,:�����.�,���: �-��.��� I � _ _ -, 4� __ � _ _ _ ._ t _ __ , , _ . _ Corn ercial Tr�e Care _ _ ". A Rhino Enterprises Company _ _ _ _ _ Crystal Springs Landscape _ _ _ 4261'erryniont Ave. _ _ _ _ San Jose, California 95125 _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ __ __ _ _ _ _ l�e: 20395 Pacifica Drive Cupertino : _ _ _ I�ear�rian, _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . 'I'hank you for providing Corrimercial Tree Care with the opportunity to preview the trees iocated at 20395 Pacifica I)rive. All inspections were visual and are for the purposes to obtain a tree removal __ _ _ : permit from the City of Cupertino. �'IlICIl�ll]CIl�S o - - - : - �IC��° � : _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ C��n�n�����n�e European White�irch _ _ _ _ I��h��n��ll���n�e �etula pendula _ _ _ _ CIl�°��u�����n�ee 12" _ _ _ __ _ ��n��nhe 25' : _ , ���n��y/�p�����< 12' _ _ _ __ _ _ �'�°��< � _ - _ _ _ ���n�nn��n m���a�o European White�irch : : �����nIl��ll���n�o �etula pendula _ '� . �n�°�uuIl�iF������e 14„ - -_ � _ _ ��ngl��o 25' . _ C�����/Sg�����ta 12' : I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ : ���, ��;,��,� ��-�/� ��-�� _ _ f ����d _ _ __ . . . .. .. . . . . .. . . .. .. . . . . . . . . � �. . d � f 9t�.'�.L�1,7[��.'ei����.°s S�a��� _ . . . . : :��.,:_...�..__'�_��'���.�__ _ _ � -----� - - � t,, �, _ _ � � .�,.._a�� � � � .�._ «�.� �v�����:�� �.�:� _. _ —� : - _ � .- :�:;:� _ _ _ P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara; CA. 95052 Office: (408) 985-TREE(8733) Fax: (408) 985-6536 _ _ _ _ _ _ www.commercialtree.com : _ _ _ _ _ _ info @ commercialtree.com 4 ' �s,,.,� ��� ��� �� � �r��� ���� Commercial Tree Care ' ,. 4 �t,--� : . � A Rhino Enterprises Company --::.:,� Page 2 F.,r.... ....... ... .. ......-, .. _.,«.�...� .., .�....,., . ._..... __..._ (� � t i � I � � E f 1 C . .. �.�� .. � i Tree A, B, completely dead ` � � ; `��,� i with zero signs of living tissue � � �` � � � � `r i E iK�: X z; Drought stress has been the leading � ` � , ��; �,<<� , , � � � �� cause of Birch die back in the Ba � ' . � y ,,. , ,; Area over the last few �ears. � � �`r � �_ �. -- i �� � ;r�� I � , ,.�:� ,,�= � € � ' � � � �� � 7 Y a r ' P�"����, ` �: f � 1 � � 1 ' ~�. �.: ' € ,` ; � �} ` � � .,E '� ,t � � .ii k {; I � r � � F � � l � } � ( �> > . l�� �� � 1 t .� a"q {i� t t �� F�3 ; ��f � 3{� �n�\� ^ f i d Y �+ 4 i (- A 'p, k` r 3`„r YS � �� �� r r � � i �� ����� 3. r + � ��'.� t F��!�t � { f � ���i ���r.�� a R� + }C/ � x � ; y f :� - Jr I ,! z�� ,��.�� r� �,� y� � z � � .: 'd:Fi� 2 I � . �� � j�,.l � � �{ r �. �' �' � � � �I I: � µ �. t f S t! � � �'1 F6 E r`.,� ������ �'; .�r:._ .�.� \ 4 {l� � �.E �� `� L � �. ��.; � '- -Y`v. Yt �� P � �L � � -j ��� � � ��, � � - � i� �.��. _ _ _. __..._...w ..... . . _ _ _�._.� _ v._.. .,._.,� . .. � ,�.._� P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara,CA. 95052 Office: (408) 985-TREE(8733)Fax: (408) 985-6536 www.commercialtree.com info @ commercialtree.com � n ���� � ��'�„ '`!` ��-� Commercial Tree Care ' ��� � �� A Rhino Enterprises Company �:� Page 3 _ _ - - , - - - - � � �; �� g �i. `'a i p k ] " � Close up of both trees, �; � � ` �' ;,;( t yf rE Once trees have been removed the will '� � � i; r << s� 2 , Y :r . , `�:�Y I . ,�E . 7f �(�� i':\� C 4 �E — N j S 1 l � d,. be re laced with P 24 box Chine e . s �, �. ,� t �F r P � � • > ,,, :; � Pistache � ° ° `�` ' "' .�� ,,' ' , ' ` 14 � .. __.. � '. . . . \ # t� b � t i �p �',(` C r "',{ # � i 'Y „ ,� A t � `t:E 4h ; a � ~' �� � J � N' � y't '`�t� ,� t � F �� tf 1 �.-'�:{ �y { E ' �k J.j ( t �fp,j�..�;� i N li�� i G f -',E i �� � t t✓,� Z .� �, i f d r `��� S � ' i : r }.. �d.B, a .. .�� 1 '"'t � ,:4 '�(�n �' 17 Y" S � � x � Y k q f � w.'� y S ,� yF 1 �J .�S�4 � �F. 'y� d i f r � �x� X '�{�e-Y. � . � ' 9�T'i Cc ii ..� T � Y �: l C .y���.,� �yh� 1P �:�� ( -�f N t��r���f�� 3� � k , �4 � ; 1` t �. y� .1 . . � i� f �,f �iR'Sµ }�,� r � Y i '�, 1; .,t.� 1 y r a` t�� f l�� i ' l f � i:_ �• V {/y�� .i: �f �< �t�' � El� �_ Zu .,^�L 1 l{) � �'� ( ���q � H re' ^ n; � � }i� a� ,� �Fr f .�.�� i 3 � f � � ��1 S { k �.� , Thank You,��� %���ma ; '; � ; ������j I.S.A. Certified Arborist � �'� ' � � ` � `�� ' ��� _ � �Q�; #WE-3238A � , �` ,, � ` r � ''�; � E - u ,, _, ;.. � � � , . ���, � ;, , ,rr � �* z r� i : g, t 4S �f "✓' . :� . �±.a�,�'���t�F y' W y, '{ :.� �t ;-���� `� ��a�--- ' ���" � ��,,,fi� ,7 t �a i,� i [H 1 � Y t ; ,�:� } � ��f r�.,:�����.��� �- s ~� r a �.i r S ?� y �( , t� .�. � � £riY��f� NA; !?�, �. ::1 P.O. Box 549 Santa Clara,CA. 95052 Office: (408) 985-TREE(8733) Fax: (408) 985-6536 www.commercialtree.com info @ commercialtree.com